What Makes A Mug Handle Comfortable?

Ceramic Art Studio
35 followers
4 Video Views·Feb 11, 2026
Is this the best handle design ever? No, probably not but I've been working on a blog post that
looks into handles and the components of them and over the course of this video I'll explain
how I arrived at this handle. Hopefully some of that will be useful for you and it is a very
comfortable handle. So I'm going to start with the basics. What I'll do is I'll time stamp the
whole video and I'll link to the blog below so if you don't want to watch the full thing or you
want to jump to the more complicated part then fine but I'm going to start with basic basics.
So there are a few different ways of making handles. The main ones are pulled handles,
extruded handles, slab built, hand built, slip cast or press molded and sometimes wheel thrown
but primarily I would say that pulled and extruded handles are the most common unless you're building
with slabs anyway in which case you might slab build them. I vaguely know how to pull handles.
I did a jokey video on Instagram a few weeks ago of me pulling them but I extrude mine and
this is the extruder I use. I've got a post, I've got various videos and a blog post about
how I use it so I won't go into it too much here. I'm not going to try and explain all of them.
There are links to people who know what they're talking about for each type
on the blog post but what I will do is I'm going to use the extruder now to make a few
handles to demonstrate the different shapes you can use. An extruder just presses out clay into
the shape of the die that you have. These are using my handle dies. This is the medium size
the standard one. I classed the types of handles in the blog post as a lug which is just anything
sticking out that doesn't loop around and they're generally only used on small things. You don't
tend to see them often but I think they do count as a handle and then I would say the C shape,
what I call question mark shape because I can't think of a better way to describe it,
D shape and full loop. So having a quick look at what those would actually be,
C shape would be one continuous curve which is easier done with wheel thrown or
pulled handles but you would have that sort of shape. I'm calling that C shape. Then
question mark shape would be a curve at the top and then bending in like that.
D shape would be a bend and a bend like that and then a full loop. Obviously you make a full loop
and attach that to the side of the handle. Those are the most common I would say and then in terms
of sizing obviously you can go on units of measurement but most handles are designed for
a number of fingers to go in them so it'll be a loop and either you'll get like that loop would
be a one finger handle and then in the C or D shape that would probably be a two and then you
could make a longer one that has three and a full hand where you've got all four fingers in and
holding it like that. Now that would be the size that you make the handle. Obviously it's up to
people to decide how they hold it so you could have a handle like that but someone would pick it up
like that. So far so simple. Different shapes lend themselves to different sizes
so if you're pulling a handle you get a nice continuous curve which means that you are most
likely to go for a question mark shape or a C shape so you would come out and bend smoothly
and then either just attach back in or curve down. Extruded handles are easy to get discrete
bends on so they tend to lend themselves to the D shape although obviously you can make any shape
with them. Slip cast handles you can do in any shape you want but the point is that you wouldn't
do a full loop in any more than one finger ideally just because obviously you've got a
complete circle to scale that up to the height to fit two fingers means you're scaling up to the
width of two fingers so you wouldn't make a complete circle that would hold three or four
fingers because it would be massive unless you're doing it stylistically. So you might choose to do
it aesthetically but practically it's not a solution that most people would reach for so the
loop ones tend to be fewer fingers which means they tend to be on smaller mugs and if you're
trying to get a whole hand in there you kind of want the D shape where you've got a discrete bend
and then a straight bit so it fits through the fingers of the hand. There are some combinations
that work better than others but as a general rule those are your main ways of making the main shapes
and the main sizes. Most mugs I would say are either one two or four fingers. A small mug would
aim to have a single finger holding it most mugs would probably have two inside and the third
finger on the outside and I'll get on to why I think that is in a moment and then on larger mugs
you'd have a big chunky handle and you'd hold it with a full fist. So the next thing I talk about
in the blog post is attaching handles. You would score and slip typically and the reason for that
is quite simple because you tend to be working with handles and mugs in some level of dryness
approaching leather hard if not leather hard and you might have burnished the surface or you'll
have at least made probably made the surface smoother. So clay really likes to stick to other
clay like you can get these two cup bits of clay and you can push them together and they
they do an all right job of sticking. As they dry out you get more of a skin and they don't want to
adhere and then once they're kind of burnished smooth you really don't get much of a join
and you have a very clear line for any stress to break along. So by scoring what you're doing is
giving a rougher surface on both sides what you're doing by slipping is making them both a little bit
wetter so the clay can squidge together more and you no longer have that clean break line because
you've scored the surface so there's a bit of texture for it to grip onto and the slip
rehydrates all of the thin bits that have been loosened up by the scoring. So you don't need
to do both I don't score when I do my drippy slip bits I just press it into the clay there's enough
slip there and it dries all together enough that that's not a problem but if you're burnishing a
leather heart pot and then trying to attach something to it you really want to score through
that. As I sort of did there if you press together lightly you can pull them apart if you push
together and work them together they stick. So you don't just want to score and slip you want to score
slip and then apply pressure support the mug from the inside apply pressure and give it a slight
twisting action or some movement you could either twist or slide sideways but as you
do that you kind of you intermesh them essentially because clay is made up of
platelets and what you don't want is all the platelets aligned as they would be if you
burnished it in two parallel sections that don't adhere to each other you want them intermeshed
like that. So that's the purpose of scoring and slipping and that's kind of standard practice so
no big deal. The next thing is why handles fall off the biggest problem that most people have with
handles is to do with drying and basically what it amounts to is that clay shrinks as it dries
so you start off with a clay object a certain size and by the end of the drying process
it will be depending on the clay depending on how wet it was but you're you're looking in the
high single figures smaller so you might have shrunk by six eight percent something like that
now obviously that's a really big deal if one thing has shrunk and the other thing hasn't
so if you get a dry mug body and you attach a very soft handle to it that's fine but then the
handle's going to want to shrink and that stress has to go somewhere so the solution to that is
really easy you just make sure they're the same dryness and that often means planning things and
having a system for controlling the dryness. I make my handles the day before so what I can do
is I can put them on a wooden board and let them firm up just a little they're covered and then
the next morning I can come in and I can see where they're at and if they're dry enough I cover them
more and if they're not dry enough I uncover them and you get an hour or two before you attach them
to balance the dryness so that would be two pieces being attached at different levels of dryness
which is a an almost unsolvable problem if you've done that you've created that stress it has to go
somewhere you can rehydrate them both to the point of being soft and then dry them together and you
might get away with it but you probably have already created a problem that's going to resolve
in the handle cracking and possibly falling off but even if you attach them at exactly the same
level of dryness the handle has quite an exposed surface area compared to a mug body so this is
going to want to dry or this will dry faster in an uncovered room and there's not a huge amount you
can do with that other than covering it so I suggest making damp boxes they are just plastic
storage boxes with a layer of plaster in the bottom the plaster can hold the water without
transferring it directly into a mug where if you have a plastic base any pooling of water will soak
into the mug the plaster holds it but releases it into the air so you get a box of humidity
essentially and it means the mug and handle can't dry past the humidity that the box is at
so you can pour some water onto the plaster put a mug in and then leave the lid cracked slightly
and the humidity will slowly drop taking the mug and handle at the same rate sounds a little bit
convoluted but really it's just getting the storage box and pouring plaster into the bottom
you can do the easy version of that by just covering them with plastic it gives you less
control it won't smooth the process for you quite so well if there are any larger gaps any bits that
are exposed in the plastic that bit will dry unevenly but all in all yeah that works I prefer
having big storage boxes with plaster in the bottom and I just dry my mugs over a few days
and that should avoid the problem this is where it gets fun so the first thing I would say is
there is a video by Pete Pinnell which I link in the blog post and I will link below where he talks
about his experience with giving students handles and seeing which handles they're drawn to and why
but also he talks about what purpose a handle serves going into this I had been thinking more
comfortable was universally better I wanted to see if I could figure out what would make a the
most comfortable handle I could and he talks about how that isn't necessarily the best solution in
all cases and he raises some really good points that you might well be drinking an expensive coffee
from a handmade mug the coffee isn't necessarily the most immediately gratifying drink you could
pick you're probably drinking a coffee that's a little bit complex and maybe has some bitter
notes and so on and so forth and you're savoring it and there's no reason that that shouldn't apply
to the mug as well the mug shouldn't necessarily be the easiest way to get the coffee into your
mouth it can be a larger part of the conversation than that and that might mean a handle that isn't
immediately comfortable I think if you're going to make that distinction you have to make a very
specific decision as to what you're doing and why I don't think it's that's an acceptable
justification for a bad handle that hasn't been well considered but it is a very good reason to
not necessarily make every single handle exactly the same and as comfortable as possible if you
have a specific purpose behind not he raises some really good points I highly recommend the video
because he explains it better than I just did and he gives examples of times that he's used mugs
that weren't the most comfortable and were really good as a result of it and changed his whole
experience of drinking that drink from that mug so watch that if you're curious but I set out
thinking I didn't really have much to say about mug handles and it all got a bit long-winded
so you've got a mug the mug has a center of gravity the center of gravity is essentially
somewhere near the middle part of the geometry slightly more towards the handle because obviously
the handle has got some mass off to this side and the base which might well be thicker but even if
it isn't obviously there's clay at the base inside the top so you've got a mug center of gravity
about centered a little further down a little towards the handle fine that pulls straight down
no problems there the mug has a mass this would be about 300 grams this will hold about 300 350
mil of liquid so you're looking about doubling the mass once it's full and it doesn't change
the center of gravity much for the large part I mean obviously as you tip it it moves but it's
still not going to move that much it's kind of within the body and it will pull the center of
gravity around a little bit but essentially we have a point in the center of the mug that's
pulling straight downwards towards the earth when you're holding the mug like that you've got a base
of support the center of gravity is within it's not going anywhere when you hold it from a point
to the side you have the center of gravity pulling straight down you have your finger pulling straight
up with an equal force but the offset creates torque around the finger so the mug wants to hang
like that to stop it from hanging like that you have to rotate it back and apply some force somewhere
to stop it from doing that so when we're holding a mug you would generally hold with one finger at
the top and then you would have something pushing inwards now typically you would pick another
finger if it's one finger you're holding like that if it's two fingers you'd be holding like that so
you've got an outer finger pushing inwards and your upper finger is pulling up and out the upwards
is just supporting the mass of the mug that doesn't change much the inwards and the outwards
are counteracting each other so pushing in and in order to stop the mug moving sideways it's
pulling out and the result of those two forces has to equal the torque around the finger or
you're rotating and that is essentially the distance between the center of gravity this
acting as a fulcrum and this one pushing in to counteract it now what that means is that
i just so happen to have one of these brackets lying around which is quite a handy way of
showing it you've essentially got a seesaw or a teeter-totter if you're in the states but rather
than having the mug on one side in fact i could dance like this so you could have the mug on one
side and you push down it's not strong enough you push down on that side and you've got leverage
and obviously it's easier if the mug's there there's less force i mean you can actually this
quite a demonstration if you put it there it's too flexible it might well break if i try to do
that leverage is literally just assuming you're in a stable system once we're balanced you are
multiplying the mass and then the distance from its central gravity to the fulcrum and then same
on this side so i'm putting less force down than the mug is because i'm further away if i push here
i have to push harder simple this same principle but 90 degrees so you've got if you put the mug
here i'm pushing with an equal force to the mug if you put the mug here i would have to push
with a force say four times the mug because the distance from the fulcrum to this finger
versus the distance from the fulcrum to this handle is approximately four times
now the interesting thing is that is true of that grip so what that means is this mug
has a mass of 300 grams but i will be applying about a kilo's worth of force i know newtons
would be the correct unit but i'm not i can't be bothered because of the relative distance
center of gravity fulcrum fulcrum the point pushing inwards the leverage is very unfavorable
on this finger so i had a mass of 750 grams i could quite easily be putting three kilos worth
of force laterally with this finger and laterally in that direction with the top finger with no
resultant force this is the relevant thing this is all to keep it static if you have a handle
where you're pushing further down that's nice and easy if you design a handle where you have
to have two fingers close together you have unfavorable leverage and you are forced to apply
more force with those two fingers to hold it steady for no difference in outcome you're holding
the mug steady the amount of force these two apply that is strictly down to the relationship
between those points similarly if you extend the handle out to here most people don't but
i have seen stylistically extended handles so it was there you'd have doubled the force because
you've gone from there to there and then doubled it from there to there you've doubled the force
you now have to push twice as hard as you did before and that's already you know up to three
four times the mass of the mug so you might be applying six kilos with that finger handle design
makes a big difference in terms of the mechanics of it and how much force you have to apply there
is the question of what happens when you tip it to drink and what that does is you've still got
the center of gravity in the same place in the mug broadly speaking i mean if it's got liquid in it's
sloshed forward slightly but that's the idea but what happens is it's no longer pulling straight
down it is pulling straight down but not relative to the mug it's the equivalent of the force going
from straight down to coming out sideways and when you're holding mug sideways the resultant
force wants to spin it around the handle like that and what that means is that again you have the
leverage of how you hold it affects how much control you have to stop it twisting and you can
you've got your thumb involved here so that helps and you can put your thumb further out like that
gives you mechanical advantage that's another factor in how comfortable the handle is when you
tilt it to drink how much it wants to twist around the handle and how easy it is to resist that
round handles rely entirely on friction because what you're doing here is you're gripping the
cross section and when the cross section has some variation in geometry you can stop it rotating and
demonstrate that in that if i hold this it's not going to spin in my hands because it's it's very
thin it's very flat i get as it twists i'm applying force here and force here to resist the twist and
because of the distance between them i get some leverage and because of the cross section in order
to for it to twist it has to move my hand compare that to something around cross section it's free
to turn the only thing that stops it is friction handle cross section has an important role to play
in how comfortable a handle is when it comes to tilting the mug to drink and resisting that change
in the resultant vector of the force so essentially the mug weighs the same but rather than going
straight down and being in line with the handle and being easy to to support it that way you've
twisted it the force is now coming essentially out of the bottom of the mug at an angle because
gravity is pulling straight down and the mug is now twisted and the handle does a worse job
of resisting that force the less of a cross section it has the worse it will do the other thing is
obviously the surface area of the handle your fingers are a bone with flesh around them so it's
not as simple as the shape of the finger it's how much of the flesh is trapped between the bone
and the handle so a handle that's straight you're kind of squishing a portion of the finger against
a handle that curves with the finger you've got a lot more flesh the bone is putting a force out
in a kind of 90 degree angle and all of the tissue within that area is absorbing the pressure so
there's no focus it's not focused on one spot whereas if you did it the other way around if
if it was your outside finger applying the force to there it's two curves the contact point is
fairly minimal so it's a lot more focused pressure even for the same handle design it hurts a lot
more when the curve is against the finger rather than with it because it's not quite as simple as
how much of the finger does it contact it's how much of the finger does it contact and then how
much of that is it able to compress against the bone with obviously a smaller amount of flesh
being compressed means that it hurts more because it's applying that force and crushing a smaller
amount of tissue you know more pressure it hurts more now for most people it won't reach the
threshold of pain but if it's a big mug small handle or you've got any pre-existing condition
or injury that means that you're more susceptible to feeling it as pain it will be pain again back
to round handles you have a slight confounding thing of when you get two cylinders touching
bearing one bone you know approximately round round handle the actual contact point in the
middle of the two cylinders is minimal so round handles are even worse at this if you have a round
handle that bends outwards like that and then you push it against your skin it's focusing it on a
very small amount of tissue cross-section again plays a role in how the force is distributed
through the finger one other thing that is quite important the angles of the handle
when viewed from the perspective of the force that's applied to them so i kind of demonstrated
earlier that the the mug wants to dangle with the finger in that corner well that's important
i haven't quite got it clear in my head exactly what the limitations of this concept are so i'm
not sure i'm thinking about this in the right way but the way i'm currently thinking about it is
each part of the handle will have a force applied to it from a certain direction and you want that
part of the handle to be rounded with the shape of the finger forming a low point where you want
basically what i mean by that is it wants to hang from that point now if i had a c-shaped handle
there was a continuous curve like that and that was attached to the side of the mug then what you
would have is when you should have prepared one of these i know what you do now the point is that
you might want to have your finger there but as the mug as the mug hangs it will slide around as
the mug wants to pivot your hand will slide the only thing stopping your hand sliding is friction
again so friction is kind of important for a few mug variations i feel like you want to avoid
relying on friction as much as possible firstly that limits the usability of a mug for someone
with limited grip strength but also if you've got your hands are wet while you're washing up say
or you put moisturizer on as i always have to do because the clay is currently drying out my hands
and it's going to start splitting in a second when you hold the mug there you're holding it
as you would you know perfectly comfortable it's a good comfortable grip i like d-shaped handles
except that the mug wants to spin around like that and it will do that and so you have to hold it
tighter whereas when you've got a d-shaped handle you don't you can actually relax your hand because
that finger that top finger the force that it's applying it's applying to that handle up and from
the perspective of that force the finger is in a low point the finger doesn't want to go anywhere
else that's where it wants to be when you have a hand like that there's no low point the hand
the finger will quite comfortably be anywhere on that handle so the mass of the mug the force the
rotational force it provides it will just slide your hand through the handle if you're not holding
it tightly the last thing i'm not going to try and tell you all the numbers i will put up on screen
these are the approximate hand sized numbers that i have found for different ranges within which
hands are commonly found these numbers were taken from multiple sources i didn't find a single
outstanding source of data a lot of the studies look at very specific populations for a very
specific reason and then the broader ones don't give you that much depth like glove sizes for
example you can see the numbers i ended up at they're not from a single source they are from
a variety of sources kind of mashed together and adjusted to try and make them robust for the data
sets that i had it's not ideal i wish i'd found a single better source but i couldn't find anything
quite as universal so these are my numbers the main thing is that there isn't a huge overlap
between the numbers that you get for men's hands and women's hands obviously you know this is a
gendered way of looking at it that the researchers use the point really is that large hands and small
hands cover a range and there isn't necessarily a size that would do both of them if you're doing
anything where size is specifically important having the ability to have the person who's
buying the mug specify the size might be a good idea or you have to specify who it's for
because there's no universal size however 20 mil seems like a pretty good universal number
for a finger so if you're making a three finger mug 60 mil would be good the two fingers would
be 40 except that obviously on the two finger mug one finger has to go on the outside you still want
that to be a little bit longer than 40 but that's the kind of concept so how do i go from all of
that to this handle design i didn't invent it i've never used a handle with this design before
so it isn't new to me in that sense my logic behind this handle is that you've got one finger
there that you know is going to be supporting the weight and applying force up and out and you know
that the third finger is going to be down here applying force inwards you want to distribute
the force for both of them around a curve so it's as comfortable for those fingers as possible
you know approximately that when you have your hand like that there is not a complete overlap
between them they're not they don't line up and they don't completely step in so you want
a step to accommodate the distance that the third finger is going to be out it's a strap handle
that's quite thin and wide so you get better rotation and also so the fingers can be closer
together and you essentially end up with a nice surface area for the top finger to apply pressure
a specific surface area for the third finger to apply pressure which means that it can actually
push upwards as well so now this top finger doesn't have to bear the whole weight which it
does when you're doing that because that third finger isn't contributing any vertical force
here it can you can actually hold the weight on the third finger and just pull inwards with that
finger so now you've got the weight shared between the two fingers you've got a small-ish
gap out so you've minimized that leverage and maximized that leverage while still using a
strong finger for the support your rotational support everything's held away from the mug
far enough that you don't burn your hand you're just going on the fact that you know where you
want the first and third finger and you want to cushion them so any handle that has that
approximate shape will be fine and that means that the question mark shape of handle is the
runner up that doesn't give you such a big bend there and such a specific place to rest that third
finger but otherwise it works in a very similar way but having a bend here that fits tightly around
the finger having a bend here that fits tightly around the finger give you a very comfortable
holding experience if you hold the mug the way i do and if your hands are the size mine are if you
were making this for someone else you would have to know what size their hands were didn't tailor
this to my hand i just went with the kind of more generic the 20 mil per finger figure i'd imagine
this will work for most people i've offered it to a few that have held it and found it comfortable
with different hand sizes but not the broadest of ranges so you might need to adjust it for
the different groups and then obviously different people will want to hold it differently anyway
and it doesn't really allow for you holding it any other way that was the logic behind this handle
and i hadn't really stopped and thought about the forces and how they interacted before i made this
this whole blog and video has been a very interesting thought experiment for me and i've
learned a lot from it and i'm thinking about handles a lot more than i was before before i
kind of had an idea what i thought was comfortable based on handles i'd used before but now i'm kind
of thinking about why i find them comfortable so hopefully those thoughts will be useful for you
when it comes to you thinking about what type of handles you like and why and the factors that go
into it a final note is designing for kind of inclusivity so designing handles that don't
limit the number of people that can use them specifically people with wrist or grip or
mobility issues and what you can do to make a handle comfortable essentially the the problem
with a handle is the torque around the wrist and for a lot of people that's what makes it
uncomfortable as i said even with a good handle you are adding a lot of force between your two
fingers just to to keep the mug stable and that's only because the handle's offset if you hold it
from underneath or above you don't have that offset you don't have that torque but you also
don't have that torque if you have two handles so handle on either side you essentially put the base
i don't know what the correct term is but once you're holding from either side
there's no torque because the center of gravity is within your grip so it can't it's not trying
to spin you're just literally holding half the weight with one hand or half the weight with the
other which makes it far easier to hold another thing is obviously some people hold it in their
hand now the problem with that with a mug is that they conduct the heat too well for that to be
comfortable with boiling liquid inside i did a test going back a few years but freshly boiled
water within a few seconds the outside of the mug was at 70c so that's too hot to hold you could
get around that by doing a double wall or a rubber sleeve or something like that designing in such a
way that it has no handle can be more comfortable or designing with two handles is probably better
and i'm not sure but i i would have thought a chunkier handle would be better because obviously
the smaller it is the more you've got to grip it where a if you've got grip issues having a larger
handle would probably be more comfortable but i tried to to research this i thought it would
again i thought there would be like a central database of recommendations for designing for
people with grip issues and there isn't really and there aren't many product design blogs that
i found that even mention it most of the ones that come up seem to just want to sell you
a second handle to attach to a mug that obviously is the popular solution if you've got any thoughts
on that please comment below if you've got to be honest if you've got any thoughts on any of it
comment below i will put all the links in the description if there's anything that didn't make
sense it's probably covered better in the blog post but yeah hopefully this was as interesting
to hear about as it has been for me to to work through logically and it turned into a much
deeper dive than i was expecting i initially rejected the idea of doing even an infographic
on handles because i didn't think i had anything to say and here i am about an hour later still
talking so i'm going to call it quits there let me know what you think
