Ranking Member Mary Gay Scanlon delivers opening remarks

House Committee of the Judiciary
69 followers
1 Video View·Feb 10, 2026
Hearing: Sharia-Free America: Why Political Islam & Sharia Law Are Incompatible with the U.S. Constitution
Thank you to our witnesses for being here today.
When the Chair began his remarks, with a concern about forces trying to undermine our Constitution,
I thought we might have some unintended agreement, but unfortunately, I don't think that's
the case.
I can't think of anything more un-American than for members of Congress to be stoking
fear and suspicion against fellow Americans or anyone else on the explicit basis of their
religious beliefs.
No matter what hysterical rhetoric we hear from our Republican colleagues, our Constitution
is clear.
In this country, people have the right to hold and express whatever religious beliefs
they choose, or none at all.
You don't have to agree with those beliefs, but no one can use the power of the government
to punish or discriminate against those who do.
There's nothing foreign or suspicious about that.
In fact, there's nothing more American.
Whether our colleagues actually believe the histrionic and unsupported statements they've
made about Muslims and Sharia law, I'm not sure.
But it does appear that today's hearing is the most recent expression of a cynical political
ploy driven by the Texas Republican primary, where early voting starts in a week, and federal,
state, and local candidates are trying to outdo one another with anti-Sharia, anti-Muslim
sentiment in order to score political points.
In the words of one Texas Republican political strategist, the Muslim community is the boogeyman
for this cycle.
It seems the pretext for all this bluster is a proposed real estate development in the
Dallas suburbs, led by the area's growing Muslim population, but there's no evidence
it has anything to do with imposing Sharia law on non-believers of Islam.
And there's no evidence it's a Sharia compound, as Texas Republicans have alleged.
The Trump Justice Department itself closed an investigation into the development, finding
no basis for any violation of fair housing laws.
As with so many things Republicans bring to this committee, there's just no there there.
But their view seems to be as long as they can scapegoat someone or something for political
gain, who cares, right?
And it's entirely clear they don't care at all whether fellow Americans or others end
up as collateral damage to the anti-Muslim hatred and fear that's being stoked.
In addition, this hearing appears designed to support unconstitutional legislation.
Last October, Chairman Roy introduced H.R. 5722, a bill that requires the government
to, among other things, deny any immigration benefit, visa, immigration relief, or admission
to the United States to any foreign national who adheres to Sharia law.
It similarly directs the government to remove any foreign national already here if the government
determines that the person is an adherent of Sharia law.
This kind of government discrimination, based purely on a person's religious beliefs, not
actions, is a blatant violation of the First Amendment's free exercise and free speech
guarantees.
And to the extent that this bill implicitly favors Christianity or another faith over
Islam by singling out Islam for government disfavor, it would violate both the spirit
and the letter of the establishment clause.
By banning an adherent of Sharia law from the country, the bill essentially targets
any observant Muslim for government discrimination.
Sharia is concerned with guiding individual personal religious observance, not shaping
national laws.
Just as other belief systems guide the adherence of those faiths, Sharia guides Muslims in
how to pray, dress, eat, or fast, and includes rules about marriage, divorce, and the raising
of children.
So to say that an adherent of Sharia law should be excluded or removed from the country is
to say that all Muslims should be excluded or removed from the country because of their
religious beliefs and observances.
It goes against everything that America stands for, and we need look no further for confirmation
of that than one of our founding fathers, Thomas Jefferson.
In his autobiography, Jefferson wrote about what he considered one of his proudest achievements,
the drafting of the Virginia Statute for Religious Freedom of 1786, a precursor to our First
Amendment.
He affirmed that religious freedom was meant to encompass, within the mantle of its protection,
people of every denomination.
In addition to expressing the fundamentally American belief in the right to freely practice
one's religion, and to prevent the government from favoring one religion over another, Jefferson's
writings specifically reference, among other faiths, believers in Islam, illustrating that
from our republic's earliest days, Muslims were intended to be included within the fabric
of American life.
The kind of demagoguery that this hearing represents is unbecoming of this subcommittee
as one that is dedicated to the Constitution and unbecoming of members of Congress.
Our attention should be focused on the Trump administration's repeated attacks on our constitutional
order and on Americans' rights, including the rights to free speech, a free press, to
peaceably assemble, to petition the government for redress of grievances.
We shouldn't be furthering ugly Islamophobia and justifying a blatantly unconstitutional
bill.
It's shameful and it's un-American.
I yield back.
