Subcommittee Ranking Member Scanlon's Statement at Hearing on Republican War on Kids

House Committee of the Judiciary
69 followers
1 Video View·Mar 18, 2026
TW: @HouseJudiciary | FB: HouseJudDems | IG: HouseJudDems | M: /HouseJudiciary
AI Generated·May contain errors
Thank you, Mr. Chairman. 50 years ago, Texas passed a law seeking to ban children who were
not legally admitted to the country from our public schools and to defund their education.
The state argued that this ban was necessary to preserve its resources for educating its
lawful residents and argued that these children were not persons under our Constitution. The
Supreme Court disagreed. In 1982, the Court struck down the Texas statute in Plyler v.
Doe, rejecting the argument that children did not count as persons entitled to equal
protection under the 14th Amendment. The Court also found Texas's economic arguments to be
unconvincing and the exclusion of undocumented children from public schools an unlikely and
ineffective way to achieve the true underlying objective of addressing and ultimately repelling
an influx of undocumented immigrants. Even Conservative Chief Justice Berger, while
rejecting the majority's reasoning, wrote, quote, it is senseless for an enlightened society to
deprive any children, including illegal aliens, of an elementary education, end quote, and agreed that,
quote, it would be folly and wrong to tolerate creation of a segment of society made up of
illiterate persons. He also noted that, quote, the long-range cost of excluding any children from
our public schools may well outweigh the costs of educating them, end quote. For a generation,
the issue was deemed settled, but bigotry and bad ideas die hard. Now, at the urging of the Trump
White House, the authors of Project 2025, and their allies, Texas and a few other states seek
once again to enshrine bigotry and bad ideas into law. To do so, they've mounted a coordinated effort
to overturn Plyler v. Doe, making the same arguments that the Court previously rejected.
But if anything, the intervening years have put to rest the argument that the public education of
undocumented children imposes a net economic burden upon the states, or somehow harms public
education and services offered to lawful residents. In fact, the overwhelming majority of
credible studies from both conservative and mainstream entities, including the Congressional
Budget Office, have consistently found that the net economic impact of immigration is overwhelmingly
positive. Most recently, the Congressional Budget Office issued a finding that immigrants, including
undocumented immigrants, generated a $14.5 trillion, that's trillion with a T, fiscal surplus
over the last 20 years. When one compares the tax contributions of those immigrants to the limited,
very limited public benefits that they consume, even in Texas, the purported subject of this
hearing, the net fiscal impact of immigration during the 40-year Plyler period, including the
cost of public education, has a net of $93 billion to the benefit of the state. In addition, we now
have decades of data showing the public health, developmental, civic, humanitarian, and social
impact of providing public education to immigrant children, regardless of their legal status.
No matter the rhetoric coming from the other side of the aisle, the fact is that our Republican
colleagues have brought us here today to advocate for kicking kids out of school.
Reversing Plyler versus Doe would mean that children as young as kindergarten and through
high school would be denied a basic education, left out of society, and held back from reaching
their potential and meaningfully contributing to America. This isn't just terrible education policy.
It's extremely harmful to vulnerable children. It's also bad for our country's health,
workforce, and economy. The Supreme Court's decision in Plyler versus Doe guaranteed
equal access to free public K-12 education for all children living in the United States,
regardless of their immigration status. The Court recognized in Plyler that education provides the
basic tools by which individuals might lead economically productive lives to the benefit
of us all. And in the 44 years since, the children who've benefited from these protections,
including some who have since become citizens and legal permanent residents,
have grown up to contribute immensely to our country. A report by FWD.us found that Plyler
beneficiaries have driven economic growth by paying over $633 billion more in state and local taxes
than their public education costs, preventing over 700,000 U.S. citizen children from falling
into poverty, increasing GDP by $2.71 trillion over their lifetimes. These are, again,
the accomplishments of the Plyler beneficiaries. They've strengthened the workforce with over 1
million people filling U.S. jobs, and they've reduced health care costs by at least $28 billion
since 1982. Additionally, other students have found that having immigrant children in K-12
classrooms improved the academic outcomes for their U.S.-born classmates, lifting up entire
communities. Public schools are a crucial part of our social fabric. They're places where kids can
learn, make friends, dream about their futures, and develop the skills they need to contribute
to those futures and our society. Robbing some children of that foundation would wind up hurting
all children and America as a whole. It's a cruel attempt to senselessly punish undocumented
children for their parents' decisions, choices they had no role in, and it's all based on a
false assertion that giving undocumented children a public education is a burden on taxpayers.
It bears dangerous similarity to other attempts to exclude children, including children with
disabilities, from public education. According to a June 2025 analysis from Niskanen Center,
the tax revenue from undocumented workers alone covers the annual cost of educating
undocumented children. Of course, the effort is part of an ill-conceived effort to end
immigration to this country, a country that is famously one formed by immigrants, but it's also
part of a larger war on children being prosecuted by this White House. A right-wing effort to kick
kids out of school is just another facet in the ongoing war that is being waged against American
children, particularly the effort to undermine public education. President Trump and congressional
Republicans' one big ugly bill ripped health care and food away from millions of kids when
enacting the biggest cuts to Medicaid, CHIP, and SNAP in our history. This administration is
attempting to undermine and erode vaccine science at a time when measles and other preventable
infectious disease outbreaks have killed American children, and Republicans have made callous cuts
to childhood cancer research, denying families the hope of a cure. This administration has
decimated the Department of Education, gone after funding for early childhood education programs
like Head Start, frozen access to billions of dollars in funding for child care and family
assistance, and cut funding for community violence prevention. ICE is now targeting schools, previously
protected areas, in its cruel, chaotic mass deportation efforts, leading to plummeting
attendance and fear among entire school communities. Children have been detained in traumatizing
conditions and used as bait by immigration enforcement agents to lure their parents.
Some of us may remember growing up and learning about when in the Bible Jesus said,
suffer the little children to come to me, rejecting the efforts of his disciples to punish their
parents' efforts. But right now, instead of caring for the little children, our country and its
leaders are shamefully turning their backs on those little children. We must firmly reject a worldview
that only certain classes of children, those whose parents can afford to pay,
are entitled to the blessings of liberty and the hope of a better future. Our kids are our future,
and I want to do all we can to make sure that that future is a bright one for everyone's sake.
So this is not the direction that we need to go back here. It's fundamentally flawed. I yield back.
