Old school vs New School Burgers: Melbourne’s Evolution (5 Burger Joints)

Australian Cuisine
62 followers
G'day guys, welcome to another video. Today I want to check out the Melbourne burger scene,
but more so the history of it, the old school takeaway fish and chip shop style burgers and
some of the new style burgers like the smash burger. We're going to check out what's changed,
what are the new trends and how the old burgers compare to the new burgers.
Our first stop is Andrew's Hamburgers. Now they claim to be one of the first,
the oldest hamburger shop in Melbourne and possibly Australia. They've been around since
1939 and they still do the same style hamburger to this day. But before we get to that, being a
fish and chip shop style, I couldn't go past but not order a nice potato cake. Give that a try.
It's not that this potato cake is amazing. It's just that something that when you go
to a fish and chip shop, you want to order and it just reminds you of something really nice and
something homely. At the same time, I ordered something uniquely Australian, which is the
Australian dimmy, a nice fried dimmy. Oversalted, like I like it. That's how it should be.
It's very tasty. Took that down in two bites. Got myself some golden chippies.
I have to feed the cameraman. This is again an Australian style chip. It's not a french fry.
Hope you can hear the crunch. Nice golden, proper coloured, soft in the middle, extra salt.
But this is the hero, Andrew's Hamburgers. And I like how they do this little wrap here.
Now this is a heavy burger. That's how I like it. It is old school. It's been done like this
since 1939. That's the claim. Who am I to dispute that? Look at the first thing you see there.
It is really wide. I'm not sure if that comes out onto the camera,
but it is wide. It's not like that new style of burgers that you see
from everywhere. And you've got a big chunk of tomato. Look at the bacon in there. There's the
egg, the tomato sauce. Now there should be a beetroot somewhere. There's the lettuce.
I can't see the beetroot, but anyway, I'm going to get into this. Look at that. That's huge.
This is $19.50. But again, there's a lot of ingredients in here.
I need to take a second bite straight away. It's massive. And before I explain what I'm
tasting, you're probably expecting me to say something like it's smoky and charred,
blah, blah, blah. But you know what? I'm tasting nostalgia. One of the things growing up as a kid
in Melbourne was going to the fish and chip shop. So just like Andrew's Hamburgers,
there was fish and chip shops everywhere in every suburb doing burgers exactly like this.
And you had the option. You order your plain burger or you add your lettuce, your tomato,
your beetroot, your egg, and in some cases, pineapple. Yes. And I would order a pineapple,
but for today's video and doing the comparison, I just wanted to order it as is. So yeah,
one more bite. A ton of flavor. The meat is cooked like an old style type of meat,
not like the new style of burgers. It doesn't seem that there's too much in there.
It just feels like a clean piece of beef. The egg, the bacon, tomato, lettuce,
it all complements together with the tomato sauce. Look at that bacon. But yeah,
for me, this is nostalgia. This is Australia. This is what I grew up with. And this is why I
love this old school burger. So I'm going to get back into it and onto the next place.
Second burger joint we're going to try is Danny's Burgers established 1945. So we're still sticking
to the old school burgers. The reason I wanted to come to this place is one, I wanted to compare it
to Andrew's and two, it is a Melbourne institution. So I thought, why not? I've never, I've never
actually tried this one and lived here all my life. I thought better do it. So I've ordered
an old school burger. Now this is a double stack and that's what it looks like. And it's, as you
can see from the outside, it's got the bun. So it's almost like a McDonald's style and it's got
pickles, lettuce. What else has it got in there? No egg. Oh no, the egg is stuck to the bottom.
The egg is there. That's the egg. And it's like the works, the burger with the lot also comes
with the side of chips, which I'm going to try now. Nothing special, normal chips, nicely salted.
Then of course, since I went to Andrew's, I thought, well, they've got Dibs here. I'm going
to order one and I'm going to give it a try. So much lighter in colour. It feels like it was
steamed and then fried. Not sure that's a style, but not bad. Now the price for this was, I think,
18 or 18.50, something like that. And you've got the options there on the menu where you can have
a single, a double or a triple. And also you've got the layers as well. So it tells you whether
you want with the lot or you want certain things out like the egg, etc. So you're kind of customising
your own burger. Anyway, I've spoken enough. I like the fact that they cut it actually. It makes
it a little bit easier to hold. Now the bun, old school. It's not brioche or anything like that.
It just looks like a nice bakery style bun. And I noticed the patty is a little bit thinner than
at Andrew's. So probably ordering the double was a good choice. If you want to be a hero and go for
the triple, go for it. But I'll leave that up to you guys. Okay. I taste a little bit of like a
more like a homemade burger, this one. Less greasy than Andrew's, I would say. It just feels a little
bit cleaner. And the pickles in it are delicious with the egg, the meat, the sauce. It's really cool.
But my favourite part is the bread. I really do like the old school bread in this. It's my
favourite with burgers. I don't know if it's just because something I grew up with or the brioche
sort of phase put me off it because I'm not a big brioche fan. But the bread makes it. But yeah,
the meat is definitely cooked perfectly. And to me, it just feels like a nice homely homemade burger,
which I don't get that often. So yeah, it does taste cleaner. The meat doesn't look as fatty.
Yeah, like a home style burger. Very, very, very good. I highly recommend Danny's.
Fast forward to 2004 and Grilled popped up for the first time in the local suburb of Hawthorne.
And the reason Grilled popped up was to sort of challenge the not just your big corporations like
your Maccas and your Hungry Jacks, but also your burgers in general and having the healthy style
type of burger. So you might see things like gluten free, free range, grass fed, etc, etc, RSPCA
type used chicken and so on, which is a bit of a good marketing ploy. Also, it was one of the first
ones to sort of have that restaurant style and have a massive menu. So not just your beef burgers,
but different types of burgers, chicken, lamb, etc. Anyway, I decided to get the Mighty Melbourne.
Now I'll admit, I'm a bit of a burger connoisseur. I've done a lot of burgers, but I haven't had a
grilled in a long time. I've got the Mighty Melbourne, which as you can see there, you've
got the bacon, you've got the egg, cheese, a big chunky piece of meat, and so on. You get to choose
your own bun as well. I just chose the traditional. Again, I'm not going to get into the facts whether
this is a healthy burger or not, but it does certainly give you the impression that it's a
healthy burger. It is up to you to kind of do your own research on that. Generally speaking, it's a
pretty decent size and this costs $17.90. So okay, it doesn't feel too heavy, which again, that whole
healthy thing. Okay, I finally got some beetroot. First impression is that it is very light in taste.
It doesn't have that greasy taste. So I'm giving kudos for that. Having said that, this bread is
very, very dry. Like it is, I don't know, like it's like a day old bread. So I'm not liking that.
But overall, the burger's got lots of flavor with the sauce and the beetroot,
egg and the bacon. You can't go wrong. Now these guys are now up to about 170 stores and I think
they're starting to expand internationally. And also now they've done a halal store in Blackdown,
New South Wales. And I've heard recently that their meat is all halal provided, except for
bacon to all their stores. Having said that, some of their stores don't actually have their license,
so they can't advertise halal. But to challenge the status quo, I think they've done a good job.
Again, I don't know whether it's a healthy burger or not, but not a bad tasting burger. So I'll get
back into this before we go to the next place. Come 2010, Huckster Burger came on the scene.
Now they did have a small shop called Huck's Table and then they expanded a couple years later
to Huckster Burger. They wanted to challenge the status quo of burgers as we know it.
And they were the early pioneers of the burger culture as we know it in Melbourne.
Them, Easy's, you had Grand Trailer Park, you had Truckstop Deluxe, Lorry D's, I can name a hundred
of them. They were just popping up left, right and center. And the idea was for them to do $10
burgers and have a restaurant setting. But it was more like the American style restaurant setting.
So you go there, you're not just ordering your burgers. They had obviously chicken burgers and
other types of burgers. And then they also had waffle fries, french fries. They had the curly
fries. Things that I never even was aware of until I actually went to America a few years later.
First time I tried waffle fries was in one of these burger joints. Thick shakes, milkshakes,
desserts, donuts, you name it. They were trying to do it and obviously they can't just sell burgers.
They had to, you know, if you're going to open up a big restaurant, had to have an expanding menu where
you were going there. Things like popcorn chicken, chicken tenders and chicken sides. Again, let's not
carry on. Now I got myself a normal Huxta burger. So the menu is actually inspired by the Bill
Cosby show and obviously the Huxtables. So, you know, you've got different names based on the
characters for the burgers. However, the actual name of the restaurant is not based on that. It's
named after Aldous Huxley, which is a philosopher and it was to do with a brave new world. So these
guys were going into a brave new world and that's how they're sort of derived to the name. The
Huxta and the burger put it together. I'm not exactly sure, but there's a bit of a misconception
there. Anyway, the burger I got was the Huxta burger, which is just a normal beef patty, tomato,
mayo, lettuce, cheese on a brioche style bun. This was, I think, $13, $95, $14 bucks. Something
like that. And it's not overly big, but you can obviously option it up. Now let's give this a go.
It's got some pickles on the bottom. Oh, mustard, tomato sauce. It's really tasty. Really good.
I like how they've put the tomato sauce and the mustard on the bottom and the mayo on the top.
The other thing to remember during this time, social media was alive. Facebook was
really on the scene. And this is how some of these guys actually made their name.
Like I remember myself going with friends every week because of the latest burger craze on
Facebook. And not only that, I'm not sure if some of you remember, but you had the stack challenge,
like how many stacks of meat you can put on it. You had three, four, five, six, you know, ridiculous
amounts. Then you had even something more, I think is ridiculous, but a lot of people were getting
into it. You had the beef and chicken in one on top of each other, which was a bit of a phase.
And I guess it all looked good on Facebook and then Instagram later on. And obviously social
media drove that. And I think the other thing I remember, it forced McDonald's to come out with
the build your own burger menu. I think they were actually worried about all these restaurants
popping up because there were a lot popping up. Now, not all of them survived, but I do remember
that build your own menu, which was, I reckon because of these guys and maybe I'm wrong, but
let me know in the comments if there's any difference. Anyway, I'm going to get back to
enjoying this burger. Like I said, these guys were the pioneers and this is a really tasty burger.
I recommend checking it out if you haven't already. In late 2014, early 2015, St. Berg's came onto
the scene and they introduced the smash burger. Number one, I didn't know there was such a thing.
Number two, they didn't actually advertise there was a smash burger. They were just doing normal
burgers. However, having said that, as you can see the meat there, it's nicely smashed all the way
down. And the key to it is that the edges have to be burnt on the outside, but in the middle,
it still has to be nice and juicy and a little bit thicker, obviously. So without further ado,
I'm going to try the Double D burger from St. Berg's, which was roughly around, I think it was
18 bucks. And this is the last of our burgers in our series of old school versus new school.
Looks saucy and juicy. Immediately you get that crunch from the sides, like I explained what a
smash burger should be. But as you can see, there still has to be enough meat in the middle
to make it tasty. The bun is brioche, there's cheese, tomato, barbecue sauce, etc.
It's a really good burger. But more so, I just wanted to bring to attention that this is the
latest craze in Melbourne that's been going on for the last how many years, and these guys were
the first to bring it to us. There you go, Melbourne. We tried a small selection of all
different styles of burgers across history of time, obviously from the 1939 Andrews burgers,
which is that greasy fish and chips style burger. Danny's nice, clean, homely made.
Then we had Grill, the healthy burger. Huckster burger, which was the normal burger craze,
American style and the smash patty. I want to know one thing, old school or new school? What
do you like? What's your favorite burger in Melbourne? And what will you try next?
You know what to do. Like, share and subscribe.
