The recent government shutdown standoff has reached an end but, in yet another stage of the war against immigration enforcement, only temporary funding for Homeland Security has been passed. Democrats now aim at sweeping ICE reforms, Republicans at pushing through the SAVE Act requiring national voter ID—and dropping the Senate filibuster ahead of the midterms. Meanwhile, a New York jury has awarded $2 million in damages to a detransitioner who went through Female-to-Male “gender affirming care” at 16. Digging at the roots of malpractice and overdiagnosis and with a surgeon and psychologist on the hook, could the case signal the beginning of the end of trans-mania? #claremontinstitute#transgender#voterid#icedetention#governmentshutdown#trump
------
Chapters 00:00 Introductions 00:33 A Mini-Bus Shutdown 25:17 An Unruly House 30:37 An End to Trans-mania? 45:02 Roundtable Podcast Updates 46:08 Cultural Recommendations 57:07 Closing Remarks
Welcome everyone once again to The Roundtable, your editors and publishers podcast here at the
American Mind at the Claremont Institute. I'm your host Ryan Williams, President of the Claremont
Institute and Publisher of the American Mind and the Claremont Review of Books. I'm joined by
Spencer Claven, our Publications Editor for both publications and Associate Editor of the Claremont
Review of Books, and our Managing Editor of the American Mind, Mike Sabo. Well gents, shutdown
has just concluded. The brief, I guess, four-day shutdown that we've run through the House has just
by the skin of their teeth passed funding that will fund the Departments of Treasury, State,
Labor, Transportation, HHS, Education, and some other quote-unquote independent agencies, the
bane of Claremont Institute's existence, or at least a part of our scholarship over the years.
But interestingly, the DHS funding, which has been the source of much controversy
led by Schumer and the Democrats in the Senate in light of what we've been talking about for a few
weeks, the ice crackdown in Minneapolis and the two shootings. So they've got 10 days to figure
out some other DHS compromise between the two houses and the two parties. But most of the
government is funded through the next fiscal year. So we have five, what they're calling a
minibus, that is five different appropriations bills for the major cabinet departments and some
of the bureaucracy. The vote was 217 to 214, with 21 Democrats voting for it, with Speaker Johnson
and the Republicans, and 21 Republicans voting against it. The controversy swirled around two
things. Well, really, yeah, two things. I mean, the Democrats, nearly unanimous opposition that
is just giving away 21 votes, as I said, to anything that seemed to endorse Republican
and the administration's crackdown on deportations and illegal immigrants over the last month or
so, with again, Minneapolis at its center. And then also some dissents from House Republicans
in the Freedom Caucus about really spending and the deficit. So some normal fault lines amongst
the two major parties. But floating off somewhere in the background, occasionally there were
Representative Luna from the Republicans was, and along with one of her colleagues, was trying to
persuade from the other House, the Senate Republicans to put the SAVE Act into this
package that would be to require national ID to vote and proof of citizenship, a thing that's
actually very popular with most Americans, Democrats and Republicans, something around
80% of the country thinks that you should be able to, or you should be required to show ID to vote.
That is not in this full package, but there is the notion that perhaps Senator Thune is open to
some filibuster reform. That is to say, the long practice of the Senate has been to maintain a
filibuster zombie style. The old way of doing filibusters is you had to talk and stay on the
and occupy it to prevent the vote from happening. That is to prevent time expiring and cloture
being finished, thus moving to just a majority vote in the Senate. That is 51 votes will get
you what you want instead of 60 plus. Nuking the filibuster is often confused with this,
but that's not actually what's on the table as a possible way of getting the SAVE Act
through the Congress. To nuke the filibuster would be to abolish it completely, something that only
Democrats have contemplated seriously over the last decade or so. Lots going on in the House
and the Senate. We are again reminded of the dysfunctional appropriations process in our
Congress. I will remind everyone we've said it before, but normal appropriating used to long,
long ago before the memory of any young staffer and before the memory of many of the current
members of the House and even some of the Senate. The old process was Congress had a lot more power
over controlling the federal bureaucracy especially and holding cabinets and cabinet heads to account
by bringing up individual appropriations for all these departments that I listed
individually and moving them forward and debating them and passing them one at a time.
These days we cram them all together at the last minute to avoid a shutdown and that's how we've
done normal government for many decades now. I don't know, what do you guys make of this?
One last thing is that the White House, rather than empower more deliberation and an extended
shutdown over the SAVE Act, which they would like, that is they would like the SAVE Act,
the White House would, or maybe accommodating some of the more fiscal hawks in the House Freedom
Caucus or continuing to deliberate. I think they feared another shutdown after the
quite long one last year and so the White House was pushing to get this done.
I think partly to put or to try to continue its pivot away from the headlines about Minneapolis
and ICE so they didn't want another story of Republican dysfunction. However true that
story might have been, they wanted to cut that narrative off at its root. So here we are.
Here we are. I'm going to resist dilating at length on why minibus is an etymologically
incomprehensible and illogical shortening of omnibus. Our listeners can thank me for
not spending time giving a lecture about that, although I do think it's a pretty funny name.
Also, Ryan, thank you for explaining the filibuster to me. I know I probably shouldn't
admit that I've always found this a bit perplexing myself, but I think a lot of Americans probably do
and the confusion between the two, as you suggested, does seem to be a kind of false
both sides-ism. Reform to the way that filibusters are enacted is not the same
thing as ditching the filibuster altogether. I can lapse into a sort of shrug about,
oh, the Democrats are just as bad as the Republicans. They toss these things back
and forth like a political football. There is a lot of that sort of thing that goes on,
but not everything is like that. So rather than talk, I guess, again for the millionth time
about how meaningless these budget fights are and how we're kicking this enormous can down the road
and waiting for the shoe to drop and all those metaphors, we can get into that and it probably
always bears repeating. To me, the ice of it all, which is hanging, as you say, in the background,
I don't know, like icicles from a rooftop. I'm so sorry, everybody. I can't help myself.
Anyway, the ice of it all really is kind of illuminating because we've spent some time over
the past few weeks criticizing the right, which is always merited. It's always right to do that
when it's merited. We are not simply a line towing podcast. We're here to talk about what's
good and we're here to give friendly criticism when we think that the administration needs to
adjust course and all of that. But it's important still, I think, to draw a distinction between
those internal disputes and the criticisms we may have of how the administration has been running
things and the other side of this equation, which is very easy to forget. The Biden years are more
than a year in the past now. Even last year, it was very quick how the memory of that stuff
faded, how the memory of 2020 and COVID and then subsequently all of Biden's real dereliction of
duty at the border and the dysfunction that that caused along with his sort of arbitrary
financial decisions and disregard for the constitution, that vanished like a kind of
vapor or a dream. Then we moved on to having these criticisms of Trump or discussing and
he's doing things right or wrong, et cetera, et cetera. Now that we're having this fight over
ice, it's like we remember that there is still a significant portion of the country and indeed
one of its two major political parties whose position basically seems to be it is not
righteous for America to exist. Was it the Emmys or the Grammys? It was the Emmys, right? Billie
Eilish? No, it must have been the Grammys because she's a singer. But anyway, she came up and she
said this now growing slogan, what is it? Nobody is illegal on stolen land. It's like leaving aside
for a second the just utter, the drooling mental deficiency of that logic and the fact that it's
on a completely fakakta and made up idea about laws and government and leaving aside the fact
that it's not even clear that there is such a thing as stolen land, unless some people are
illegal. Put all of that aside for a second. Just remember that this is what the Democrat party now
stands for. It's like abolish ice. If abolish ice is too radical a proposition for the general
public, for the masses, then just hoodwink them into saying you want something else and then
abolish ice after. That's lingering for me, at least in the background of all of this otherwise
minute disputing over budgetary constraints and over whether Trump's running things right.
The left really still does want to pick apart the country. It's not clear that they have any
way of moderating from that position as we've discussed at length. In a funny way, this
weird little technical interval has really reminded me of that and reframed the criticisms
that I've had of the right in the context of, but it's a good thing to be disputing over how
to preserve the country rather than trying to fight against a political party that wants to
literally unmake the country. I guess that's my takeaway from yet another budget cycle.
What about you guys? It's funny because my takeaway is actually,
you're focusing more on the left. I'm actually still focusing on the right. We actually ran
a piece today by Ryan Newhouse showing how, in his mind, and he makes a very strong argument
that the GOP needs to basically blow apart the filibuster right now because as soon as the
Democrats come back and that's what they're going to do, the idea of getting a super majority
anytime soon, he looks at 2026, the midterms, 2028, and just says, this is not going to happen
at all at any time soon. He basically makes the argument, look, we have to do this, but then he
actually really critiques the GOP and says, part doing this though means that there has to be an
agenda that they've really systematically made that actually makes sense, that follows on what
President Trump has outlined, why the American people elected him again in 2024, but that hasn't
been done yet. These two things do need to go in tandem. Really, I think the unsaid thing is,
until that happens, probably keeping the filibuster is probably a smart thing for now,
but there's just still so much GOP just not understanding what time it is.
Finally, PBS funding was cut. That's great, but where are some of the other low-hanging fruit?
Where is the healthcare bill? We've been waiting for that. How long now? Over a decade easily,
probably a decade and a half now. I think those are some problems. Those are some problems,
I think it points to some of the priorities that Trump has put up there. He's set on record he's
not going to take away entitlements. He's not interested in cutting Social Security,
basically doing anything that I think people do really start needing to look at, especially for
huge budget implications and just the huge funding problems that are really only a decade away or
less, that are going to be the problems of the time, and I think already are and already should
be. There's a case to be made, is the politics catching up with that now in a way? Maybe it
wasn't in 2016. I think so, there could be, but in any respect, I just still think this shows
fundamental issues with the Republican Party, the structural issues with the Senate. You have
something as good as the SAVE Act, where like Ryan said, it's an 80-20 issue. I think Rachel
Bovard, she wrote a great piece in The Federalist said, I think she cited 84% of Americans support
only 15 oppose. 36 states in most of the world's developed countries have it on the books.
And I think included in that is actually about 70% of Democrats actually want something like
that to happen. So that's kind of amazing that that, I think passed the House about a year ago
now, and that's been sitting in the Senate ever since. I mean, not being taken up at all in any
movement at all. So this just shows just some absolutely fundamental issues that need to be
resolved. I mean, Congress, we can't just have the executive doing kind of unilateral actions and the
court saving us every once in a while. I mean, I think if really there is a real true political
revolution, I mean, Congress has to have a big say in that. That's where the energy has to come
from. I don't know how that happens. How do we get from where we are to the Congress, say the
founders envisioned where there's debate, there's deliberation, there's accountability, but that's
certainly what needs to happen. We should state for the record as a kind of house position here
at the Claremont Institute, that neither of our major political parties is a very serious party.
If for different reasons, the Republicans seem allergic to governing forcefully. That's not,
does not seem to be a problem that the Democrats have. The Republicans also seem
slightly allergic to doing the normal patronage log rolling protection stuff that
parties have done since time immemorial as part of the legislative process.
So that gums up their calculations. And then hanging over, and then the Democrats are
unserious because they have a series of pet issues, many of which are quite minority issues
that they dress in the garb of civil rights protection. The SAVE Act being an interesting
example. I mean, I think in your polling numbers, Mike, I read that at least 65%, if not 70% of
I don't know about all, but at least certainly likely voters who are black Americans think,
well, yeah, of course you present an ID to vote. What's wrong with you?
The Democrats use the imminent, the threat or the claim of the imminent disenfranchisement of
lots of their minority coalition with, I think, American blacks at the center of it as
the reason why they're against something like voter ID. So you have a mix of ideology and
more ideology on the left driving a lot of this. And then I think it's more of a mixed bag
ideologically on the right. It has more to do with older notions of maybe a libertarian hangover
about using state power for anything, let alone anything good combined with concerns about the
deficit, which seems like I cite this thing, this essay by Chris DeMuth from 10 years ago,
maybe in the CRB pages, Trumpism, Nationalism, and Populism. I think that's what it's called.
I always mix them up, but go back and read it if you haven't. Many of our listeners will have
read it four or five times now because I keep repeating myself. Chris's point was-
I want you to assume they go back and reread it every time you recommend it,
Ryan. That's a true devotion. I have a lot of faith. Chris's point,
and it again shows the unseriousness of both parties and maybe an unseriousness about a large
portion of the voters on this issue of fiscal sanity, that nothing really will be done about
this until our hand is forced. That is the people's hand and their representatives' hands
by a real crisis because there seems to be no political constituency broad enough to command
a serious look at our spending problems. I wonder what we'll call that episode.
Maybe one way of combining what you're saying, Ryan, and what I was saying earlier is that
both parties are clown cars, but the Republican clown car pulls up and out tumbles like
Dingus McGee and some doofus that you got to entertain at your child's birthday party while
the house is burning down behind him. Then the Democrat clown car pulls up and out comes Penny
Wise from It by Stephen King. Two different forms of completely ludicrous dysfunction,
but with two very different consequences. Then there's the other interesting fact,
which we've mentioned before. If you talk to and even poll, especially elites, but I think
the two parties writ large, they have mirror views of one another, which is to say the Democrats think
that they're always too divided and never move in concert enough. The Republicans are ruthlessly
efficient and will run over their grandmother to get a partisan victory. Then it is true,
too. That's what Republicans think of Democrats. These are all anecdotes amounting to anecdota
of the reason for our current dysfunction. You pile on top of all of that.
The added reason that in the post-Cold War era, we haven't really had a true majority party
in any commanding sense at all. We kind of are trading power in the executive and in the
Congress, which is abnormal for American politics. Look, maybe it's our new status quo in our much
more deeply partisanly divided country and ideologically divided country. Realigning
election does not seem in the offing, although I suppose folks on the right hold out that hope for
2028. As we've mentioned here before, they may continue to be helped by the fact that
the most ideological extreme left wing of the Democratic Party seems to command
more respect and fear than they ought to, given national public opinion on some of these big
issues. Even just to back up what you said, too, on just how deep some of the realignment elections
have been in the past, I'll just go to 1964. LBJ won a landslide. The Democrats entered Congress
with 68 seats in the Senate and 295 in the House. Then that dominance followed the Civil Rights
Act of 1964, where the Democrats were really able to kind of totally reframe themselves in very
kind of insidious ways. You go to other elections, too, Nixon in 72, that comes up. Those were
clearly defining elections. Nixon's battles with the bureaucracy of the administrative state,
put that aside. But those were truly realigning elections. You look at Trump's bold wins,
especially 2016, very close. 2024, a little bit more of a margin, but still nothing close to some
of the realignment that we saw in the 20th century. And I think that that's something I
think Republicans and most people on the right have to keep in mind. I mean, there might have
been, I would say, more of an ideological revolution or realignment. But in terms of
electoral politics, that has just not come yet. Yeah. And in many ways, the Republicans have been
since 1964, 1965, in major ways on the Civil Rights Act. And it's, as we've covered before,
is perverted administrative and judicial progeny. And then the Immigration Act of 1965, which
was a major reworking of American immigration, which has demographically transformed the country.
So the ground, that big shift that Reagan tried to reverse and was maybe half successful
in shifting that ground back to the right somewhat, especially on taxes,
certainly on foreign policy, but maybe not so much on immigration and, quote unquote,
civil rights. And we're still having those fights. So I think that just emphasizes or
is wonderfully demonstrative of the importance of commanding majorities and realigning elections.
And the last really, really big one we had was really LBJ. Although Nixon's re-election was
even bigger. And it was for a variety of complicated reasons and having a lot to do
with the expanded bureaucracy. And then the older intelligence community and national security
bureaucracy and domestic law enforcement bureaucracy, which is, of course, older than
the big expansion of domestic administrative stuff in 65 and 64. So the possibility of him
under his own understanding and as some Claremont scholars like John Marini have argued for a long
time, was his intent in the second administration to finally try to get political control of the
bureaucracy at a point at which Nixon thought it was sort of existential. He thought if he didn't
do it in the early seventies, early to mid seventies, it was going to be too late forever.
And maybe Nixon will have been right about that. We hope not.
And if you want to hear more about this, listen to our other podcasts,
Close Read at CRB. I had a really good conversation actually with Nathan Pinkosky about
his article on this topic. He was, I mean, he's just, I think one of the smartest guys out there
right now when it comes to this stuff. And he has some really interesting reflections on
like Nixon leaving aside kind of the underlying facts of the case, the fact pattern, if you will,
the sort of prophecies, the sort of like the stated or the proffered reasons for his ouster
being, becoming a kind of national myth that, oh, we got the corruption out of the government.
It was in that guy, right? It was like localized in the big baddie. When in fact, the thing that
he was fighting against was perhaps far more structural and profound and is still with us
today, as you ably mentioned. Just a plug for Close Read.
Yeah. Everyone go check out the Close Read and it's Spencer's quarterly, well,
monthly in some form or fashion, more or less, interview with one of our CRB contributors. And
yeah, Nathan Pinkosky, who's a Lincoln alum of the Claremont Institute and is at the Center
for Renewing America, a great new-ish think tank on the right. Used to be run by Russ Vogt,
another Lincoln alum, who's now at OMB for the second time. And CRA, Center for Renewing
America, now run by Eric Tietzel, another Lincoln alum. So a think tank close to our,
familially close to the Claremont Institute. It's Politico's worst nightmare. Claremonster's
everywhere. We're just like all over the place. Yeah. Yeah. In government and out.
Well, any predictions for the next 10 days over DHS? You know, I mean, Johnson's difficulty is
he has now a four-seat majority in the House. And so whatever one thinks of Johnson's inability
to deliver on Trump's promises, if I can put it that way, I think he has probably one of the
tougher jobs in the world. And starting with Big Beautiful Bill and then avoiding this prolonged
shutdown is an effective guy in many ways. And so it'll be interesting to watch the next 10 days.
Yeah. I'm going to stick to my usual no predictions rule, which I've often broken
on this podcast, but I just don't know. Except I guess that my one prediction is,
Mike, you alluded to Trump's commitments that he won't touch the stuff you kind of have to touch
in order to do real reform. I think that's one promise he's going to keep. I don't think he
can afford to break that politically, especially now that his numbers on the economy are not as good.
So I'll say that much. Yeah. And within that four-seat majority, the larger
political reality is that Trump having won re-election or having won a second election
non-consecutively within spitting distance of his first and still being a major disruptive influence
and a reformer and remaker of the Republican Party, Johnson has to work within those
constraints as well. It really is Trump's party. And while he sits in the White House,
it's hard for Johnson to do much of anything effective, especially given his slim majority
without a lot of help from the White House. I think that majority is even smaller because I think
there was a Texas House special election that just happened that actually went to the Democrats.
So you have that. So I think the effective majority is actually only one when you look at
some of the vacancies, too. So it's yeah, I mean, it's a big problem. I mean, Johnson, you're right,
has a huge, huge job that is I don't even know how you do it under these circumstances,
how you cobble together. And that's a reason why we've gone through so many speakers,
why Paul Ryan didn't want it, didn't want it, finally got it, why no one really wants to be
these days. You've seen some of the issues even in the 90s where Newt Gingrich comes along and
tries to almost be a president of Congress instead against Bill Clinton. I mean, that
just really didn't fundamentally work out as a political revolution. I mean,
things don't work like that. So that wasn't successful. So yeah, I mean, he's certainly
an unenviable position. And, you know, we'll see with DHS funding. I really don't know. I mean,
I know, you know, obviously the administration is in a tough spot with that. So I'd be surprised
if it happened. But, you know, it's politics. I mean, anything can change, but I would be surprised.
For a big book on, it's now six or eight years old, but it's still quite relevant. And I bring
it up to tease this episode that Spencer and I are going to do at some point. It's going to
happen, I believe. Eventually, buddy. We'll be there. It's the longest PR tease ever for this
deep dive. It's going to be so worth it by the time people get to it. Yeah. The bureaucracy and
all that. Read our colleague. I say colleague because he teaches often in our summer fellowships,
he teaches at Hillsdale. Joseph Postel has this big book called Bureaucracy in America,
which is a great primer on the history of the rise of this large administrative state,
which is not that old. I mean, now about 70 years old in its current form, give or take change.
And it's somewhat independence from Congress or the president and what the founders would have
thought of it, how the founders approached administration. It's a big chunk of the first
of the book and how Congress might fix all of this. It remains a great tour of all this stuff.
If you want to check that out, there's that old, there's also the old obscure book,
which I keep mentioning, which is exorbitantly priced on Amazon because it's out of print.
Our friend and colleague, John Marini is the politics of budget control,
which is a nice snapshot of all the things that led up to Nixon's troubles with the budget process
and the bureaucracy and all of that, with some Hegel and Tocqueville thrown in for those of you
who are gluttons for political philosophy. Gluttons for what exactly? I mean, if you
liked our last episode, and I hear many people did, that sounds like the book to read.
And then on the Nixon question too, I think there's at least one video and there's certainly
text. If you just Google John Marini, Hillsdale, Nixon, you'll find at least a couple of speeches
he's given over the decades at Hillsdale. I think the most important and relevant one,
probably given in the last 10 years or so, worth your time if you want to do a deeper dive.
We also had this other development this week, really yesterday. Yeah, yesterday, I think,
of the first malpractice award for transgender surgery, trauma, et cetera. It was a case out
of White Plains, New York, about a teenager, a girl who was the product of a broken family
and seriously unwell in her teens, estranged from her father, her father sort of estranged
from the family. I'm rendering no judgment on whose fault it was in that divorce. That's
not relevant for us, what we're doing today. But the suit was against her surgeon,
who gave her a double mastectomy, and then the psychologist who was at the center
of arranging that or talking her into it. It emerged in the case that her mother
felt browbeaten by this psychologist. And it's an interesting case because it's the first real
$2 million worth of damages were awarded, 70% of it being borne by the psychologist,
because he was deemed much more culpable in this malpractice. I think they had asked for
something more like $14 million, so maybe a small victory, but the first of its kind.
So the question now is, will this open the floodgates to cases like this? In fact, there's
another case going on or set to go on soon in Nebraska, and many more will follow. A lot of
our friends on the right have argued that you're really not going to begin to get a handle on this
problem of what has now become a huge and lucrative industry for mental health professionals
and for surgeons and plastic surgeons, especially around quote unquote, trans care.
And the argument has been one way to reform it. Of course, there's all the state level bans,
which have spread across quite a few states now, a few dozen at last count, I think 30-ish,
34-ish states have banned it in some form or another. But also just going after the
monetary and reputational side, which is to say if these doctors come to regard the recommendation
of these procedures and the diagnosing of them, both in the psychologists and psychiatric
armchair, so to speak, as well as at the operating table, if people, doctors who've
been benefiting from the rise of this transmedia begin to see it as a possible liability for them
financially and reputationally, you will get much less of the practice. It seems to be,
at least it was demonstrated to the jury and led to this award, that they judged that the
psychologist abandoned best accepted practices. He did not have thorough enough notes about the
child's stability of their gender dysmorphia or dysphoria, I should say, body dysmorphia.
Yeah, they didn't have gender, there's a distinction between gender dysphoria and
body dysmorphia. I mean, this gets a bit more into the weeds than we might want to, but
they didn't even have clear evidence of or testimony of gender dysmorphia or gender dysphoria,
sorry, which is supposed to be the cause of this kind of surgery.
Interestingly, a piece of the case turned on the fact that she had been referred to this
LGBTQ counseling center by the psychologist and in those two sessions, which was, I guess,
a couple hours from where they lived, so they had to drive a long way, so they only went twice,
documented by that activist group and counseling group that the subject in question, the patient
in question, had many doubts about what exactly was troubling her and what the solution would be.
This did not make it into the psychologist's notes, which then went to the plastic surgeon.
Anyway, these are just some of the details of the case that led that jury to conclude
that malpractice had actually been done. I'd say this is a positive development
in this very troubling area, troubling and fairly new area of, quote-unquote,
doctoring. It's one to watch and I suspect, I mean, I can't see how this wouldn't
maybe not open the floodgates, but let the sluice doors down maybe halfway and get us closer and
to a return to sanity on, quote-unquote, gender-affirming care.
These people should be thanking their lucky stars that there's no true justice in the world,
because if there were any true justice in the world, the penalty for this kind of thing would
be a lot steeper than two million dollars. I mean, not to put too fine a point on it,
but these people are possessed by demons. I mean, you read this piece and again, it's just
a reminder of the derangement that we were under about this stuff for so long and it's not over,
like that stuff hasn't gone away. It's very much in retreat and these cases will help, as you say,
Ryan, to push it back even further. But I mean, just the testimonial, detransition testimony
has always been powerfully affecting and very, very painful to read. I mean, we've done something,
as a society, we've done something completely unforgivable to these children and it's, I think,
a major reason why we've rolled some of this back is that they've had the courage to describe their
experience and to speak out. I just want to read one short paragraph, set of paragraphs,
shame and cognitive dissonance, Varian testified, this is the detransitioner,
kept her from openly confessing her remorse until three years following the mastectomy.
At 19, she finally stopped identifying and presenting as male and has since considered
herself a woman, but an incomplete one. I mean, it breaks your heart. It's so hard to face that
you are disfigured for life, she says. The physical toll, she testified, includes scarring,
lack of sensation in her nipples and nerve pain where her breasts once were.
She will never be able to nurse him. No amount of reconstruction, she said,
is ever going to bring back what I lost. I'm sorry to get graphic here, but I just think
it's important to listen to these people. We've been publishing stuff about this at
the American Mind for a long time, ever since I've been there and before as well.
This goes way beyond like, oh, Democrats are bad, also Republicans are bad. It goes way beyond
budgetary disputes. This is like a civilizational madness that emerges out of the materialism,
the scientistic era when it meets with the nihilism of radical gender politics.
But it has come down hard on these innocents, on these kids. And the penalty for that,
there isn't a strong enough one in law and in the human world. I'm sorry, but there is just
something deeply evil about this. It's the sign of a sick, sick society. It's a thing that we
are hopefully recovering from. And I think that the mention that you make, Ryan, of money and
financial incentives is really important. This is a major industry. And unfortunately, the only thing
that is strong enough to counteract the power of the dollar is the power of more dollars.
So once trial lawyers get their sights on the money that can be made from pushing back against
this stuff, then maybe we can right the ship a little bit. But it's also cultural. It's also
shaming people who even speak a word in defense of this stuff. And to me, it's just a reminder.
The disputes that we may have politically within the scope of the Republican Party or on the right
have to be set against the backdrop of a functionally mad and demonic philosophy that
is really the actual enemy of all good and true Americans. This is just something that
every sane person should be able to look at in horror and reject.
This case is interesting because it really doesn't get at that larger question, Spencer.
It's clear that the courtroom strategy was probably the right one given
maybe the limitations of the case or the prospect of winning the case with
dueling expert testimony or whatever. But it was interesting to me that the strategy of the
plaintiffs in the case, that is the girl and her lawyers, was to bring in some of the leading
transgender care people in the country, including plastic surgeons and others, and to get them to
say that best practices were not followed. Yeah, you didn't do child mutilation right.
It was not correctly followed, which is you're absolutely right. That's a major problem. And
it's something that our friend Hadley Arcus writes about a lot in other contexts, that
you can win temporary and intermediate battles with logic that does not strike at the heart
of what's going on. That's part of it. Right, because current malpractice law has been shaped by
this trend in modern medicine towards, at best, palliative, if that's the right word,
and at worst, more drastic measures to address this affliction and or social contagion,
social psychological contagion that afflicts a small portion of American youth. Yeah, and Hadley
wrote a great piece for us actually back in December just about the Supreme Court's take on
this, what's coming. They really have to get at the principle of this and not kind of dance around
this procedure, that procedure. And I'm with you guys. I totally understand in this specific case
why that specific strategy was probably taken. It was the first one of its kind, not knowing
what the jury, what the judge, what people may think. I think the jury deliberated for about
five hours, so really probably not that much time. But I think it helped that there was the,
I think, the president of the World Professional Association for Transgender Health. He is a
gender, quote, affirmation surgery, a surgeon at Rush University Medical Center in Chicago.
So, and I mean, the World Professional Association for Transgender Health is basically about as
radical as what you can think. I mean, they are pushing so much. And even that doctor,
the president said, yeah, the right steps weren't taken in this. So that shows you, I mean, this was
certainly an egregious case, but you look at, I mean, how it was described, how this woman talked
about it. I mean, this is happening time and time and time again. This is far from the only case.
And that in the middle of all this trans madness, you just kind of thought, look,
once lawsuits are going to be filed, I mean, you're going to have hospitals possibly going
out of business. There's cases right now kind of where I am, Cincinnati Children's Hospital,
where this is happening. And this is a huge, huge problem. But there are, I think, upwards now of
30 known civil suits filed by detransitioners to date. The first was filed in 2022.
Some have faced dismissals, but most of them will be appealed. So through the court system,
hopefully some measure of justice can be done. And I think at the end of the day that that's
where you rest on, is that God is just, and that these people will face the consequences,
hopefully in this life, and certainly the next one as well, because, I mean, what they've done
is just horrific, demonic, totally destroyed any idea of the Hippocratic oath, do no harm. I mean,
that's just totally thrown out the window. Yeah, these people really need to face the consequences.
Well, like this has been coming for a long time, right? We've talked before on this podcast and
people who, you know, people of goodwill who have noticed and spoken about this problem before it
was cool, before it was socially acceptable as it now is to be frank and forthright about these
things have been waiting for these cases to make their way through the courts. And, you know,
there've been some high profile ones in the UK that have also helped, I think, tip the scales.
And obviously they're, they call it a turf island over there. You are, if you travel among kind of
anti-trans feminists, you know, these are women who usually aren't on the right or are,
you know, if they're, if they are, they're a very unorthodox kind of right wingery,
but who on grounds, on feminist grounds, just oppose this idea that a man can kind of put on a
dress and walk into a lady's restroom. Anyway, that over in turf island, they've kind of been
leading the way on this. And we have, I think now we're starting to catch up. But when, yeah, when,
you know, the head of the child mutilation society, Dr. Mr. Child Mutilator looks at your
practices and says, I'm appalled. I'm appalled at the rashness of this, of this guy's activity.
Like that's when you know, you are really a bad guy, you know? So hopefully my hope is that,
yes, the logic of these cases is not ideal. It's kind of like cobbled together based on
the way the law currently works and they're, they're kind of picking the low hanging fruit
first. My hope is that that will gradually lead to more kind of robust attacks on this whole
rotten edifice. But we'll, I guess, have to see. Yeah.
We have some cultural recommendations as usual, but first I wanted to announce
we're going to switch up the format a little bit in the coming weeks. We're going to do our normal
round table for probably more like 40 minutes and then have a more deep dive segment for 25
that will be paywalled. We've been slowly building up a paywall system for exclusive CRB and now some
American Mind content. That 40 minute normal round table segment will be recorded earlier on
Tuesdays and probably out by Wednesday so we can stay on top of the news cycle a little more by
the time you hear it. I guarantee you this is not some ploy for us to fund half of the Claremont
Institute by paywalling stuff. It's rather, if only, if only, to shift a little bit to a hybrid
model with some perks for more dedicated and modestly paying superfans. It's what everyone's
doing or a lot of our competitors are doing, so we're experimenting with it. We appreciate your
patience with it. I'll start. We joke that we have at least a few, especially on Twitter,
haters of our cultural recommendations, maybe especially mine, which is fine. I think it's
amusing. We're in competition, Ryan, you and I. I think the general complaint is that we're
too uncritical consumers of normie slop on television or whatever. I will just put in a
plug, although I plug with an asterisk and I'll explain why in a minute. For this HBO show,
The Gilded Age, it's another Julian Fellowes creation who did, what the hell was that British
show called? Downton Abbey. Downton Abbey. And also, I think even the better movie,
was it called Upstairs, Downstairs? There's a pre-Downton Abbey murder mystery.
Right. Upstairs, Downstairs was, yeah, the OG one about aristocratic life in the UK,
and a series originally. This has been a genre for a long time, but this one takes the view
from New York of the Gilded Age. I forget precisely when it's set, probably right around
the 1880s, the rise of railroads. One of the central families is a new money family whose
patriarch is a railroad baron. Of course, like all these shows, it's really a look at the social
and class structure of the time, marriages, scheming, and all that sort of stuff. I'd say
its virtues are that Fellowes knows how to pace a drama like this very well. It has a certain,
wait till you see what happens next episode. It is cultural popcorn. I won't defend it as
deep or philosophical. It can't help but take some, I think, somewhat silly and anachronistic
license with maybe what the characters were thinking about race and gender at the time.
Although even that stuff has a kernel of truth, of course. Committed and learned right-wingers,
especially those familiar with the history, institutional, financial, and social of the
time will scoff a bit at the artifices that are used. But it's a well-acted show. The
costumes are beautiful. It's a wonderful job of recreating on some set somewhere what life
on 61st Street and Park Avenue might have been like in the 1880s. In some ways, it gives maybe
one and a half or even two cheers to trying to understand the importance of these small-c
conservative social mores of the time. In that way, it serves as a somewhat reflective
treatment of our current woes, depending on what you read into their difficulties then
and the pluses and minuses of their social, intellectual, and class structure in Gilded
Age America. Also, it's a lot of, I said the costumes, but also it's a lot of architecture
and interior decorating pornography. Well, first of all, Ryan, you earned your
curmudgeon card back by sniffing at that show about James Garfield. I forget what it was called.
You had plenty of disapproval for modern tomfoolery in that, so you're allowed to like
Gilded Age. Nobody, however, will accuse me of being normie in my cultural recommendations this
week. Actually, neither one is really a recommendation. I have first a correction
and then more of a cultural report observation. First of all, last week, I said I announced that
I was about to go teach a class on Plato's Republic, and then I promptly spoke somewhat
loosely about Plato's Republic. Luckily, I caught myself before I went to teach
class in this mistake, but I said that Socrates says in Book Four that it's not worthwhile to
dictate to gentlemen that laws among gentlemen will kind of come about naturally through respect
and intuition, et cetera. It's actually Adamantus who says that, and I mention this because I'm
always telling my students to pay close attention to who says what. Socrates does agree with him,
at least provisionally. He says, yes, my friend, provided, that is, a god grants them the
preservation of the laws of God. If you have the right sort of framing context, the kind of
first principles or ultimate ideas, then it's not worthwhile to dictate to gentlemen. Socrates
agrees with Adamantus, but I just wanted to make that note since I made it for my students. I will
my report. I rode in a Waymo for the first time two weekends ago. This is an autonomous,
I won't say driverless because somebody's driving it, just not in the car, an autonomous vehicle
that basically functions like a ride share, like a Lyft or an Uber. In fact, it's run through Uber.
So here in Austin, they've completed their training circuit. In Nashville, they're still
training these little vehicles by driving them around, human drivers drive, drive them around
the city. They kind of map out the street. You see them like drive past your house three or four
times and they, they have a, you know, I guess it's a camera on top or something and all around
just like mapping stuff out and then they let them loose and they go on their own. So here in Austin,
but you can't go on the Waymo app and ask for a Waymo. So we're already like meeting out via some
obscure process, the privilege of riding in these vehicles. So it's already a little bit dystopian,
but you have to go through Uber and not request a Waymo. You can't do that. You have to instead
tell Uber, yes, pick me. I would like a Waymo whenever one becomes available. And then they
will sort of deign at some point to bestow a Waymo upon you. It takes quite some time. It
took me, I don't know, maybe three weeks of ordering Ubers fairly regularly to get one.
And first of all, my friends, I must tell you the notification that you get on the Uber app
when a Waymo comes is worthy in itself of a close reading. It's like you pull up your phone,
you order the Uber, and then this little light goes off and shines across your entire screen.
And it goes, the future is coming. It's your turn. You've matched with a Waymo. It's a combination.
Somebody swiped right on a dating app that you wanted to date and also dystopian horror
assimilation into the board, like all at once. And then you wait for like 10 minutes. It takes
a long time and it shows up. And it was pretty eerie. The car does these things because it's
using AI. It'll do things like it sort of seems to consider, oh, maybe I'm going to shift lanes
at this light. No, the light's changing already. So I'm going to get back into this main lane and
go. They're doing pretty well from what I understand. And all of us are going to have
to confront what we think about these things. So my recommendation, I guess, is if you live in an
area where there are Waymos, take one. Find a way to get in one. Not because I think this is the
wave of the future and we must all acquiesce to our great robot overlords, but to know what's
going on in the world and to have a clear picture of what we're going to be deliberating about
in the future, you should get in one of these things and sort of experience what it's like.
The little light on the top has your initials when it pulls up. It's a very weird,
Blade Runner-y experience. And again, just get a feel for one because I'm sure we'll
have episodes of this podcast where we're talking about whether this is a good thing or not. So
try a Waymo. Well, I certainly can't match that. But yeah, so I think I'm going to go a little
bit probably lower brow. I mean, I listen to jazz. I listen to classical. I was just listening to
Giuseppe Torelli, who's a great Baroque composer. If you've never heard him before,
got tons of stuff on YouTube. I'm sure Spotify, I use YouTube. I'm a YouTube fanatic. But I'm also
a fan of thrash metal, heavy metal. And the last Megadeth album just was released. So Megadeth is
kind of known as like one of the big four thrash bands of the 80s. Dave Mustaine, the founder,
he was actually in Metallica, famously got kicked out. Some Kind of Monster, which is a great
documentary. I think it came out in 2003 about Metallica. And Dave was part of that as well.
They infamously had not so great relationship. But I think it was actually in 2011, 2012. They
actually it was all the big four bands, Megadeth, Metallica, Anthrax, Slayer. They actually all
toured together. And I think that was the first time that it happened. And so I think the
relationship is somewhat better. Although it's interesting on this album, Dave actually without
you know, asking actually does record a Metallica song that actually came out on the Ride the
Lightning track, the title track, actually. So be interesting to see if Metallica responds in any way
to that or they just kind of laugh it off. But yeah, the new album is fantastic. It was really
surprising to me. I mean, it's typically bands kind of, you know, right into the sunset and,
you know, maybe their last few albums are kind of forgettable. One that also sticks out in my
that was very good was Rush's last album. Actually, I came out Clockwork Angels. I think that was
2012. But anyway, this last Megadeth album is great. It just includes kind of every era from
their more, you know, just heavy thrash and more even their pop in the 90s. It's really, really
well done. So it's great to go out on an album like that. And yeah, it was would highly, highly
recommend it, even if you're not, you know, in the thrash, that kind of stuff, you know.
Yeah, thanks, Mike. We were talking about this ahead of time, and it prompted me to
tell Mike and Spencer that I saw Megadeth at San Diego State University at one of their
smaller outdoor amphitheaters, as I recall, in 1998, when I was a I must have been a junior
in high school. And Danzig opened for them. So there's your millennial dating of Ryan anecdote.
Thanks, dad. A fun time. And memorable. As concerts are, as, as you know, interesting
concerts are when you're in your teens, I suppose. I was not really a junkie of concerts. So
I can I can remember most of them because I was not at them frequently. But that was memorable.
All right. Well, I think that's all the time we have for today. So again, thank you all for
listening to the roundtable. And thank you for putting up with our slight modification to come.
We hope to deliver you good entertaining content despite tweaking it a little bit. And it'll be
good to be slightly more on top of the news cycle. Because after all, first and foremost,
this has always been a chance for friends to talk about the news and talk to other friends
and like minded folks. So we appreciate you all very much. And if you want to learn more about
our work, as we say every week, go to Claremont.org. If you'd like to support our work,
Claremont.org slash donate. Please check out the latest at the American Mind at AmericanMind.org.
And then the latest from the Claremont Review Books at ClaremontReviewBooks.com.
And for the latest from our DC operation, the Center for the American Way of Life, go to
dc.claremont.org. I want I'll just for those interested, one of our projects and centers is
our Center for Constitutional Jurisprudence. And we filed this week or maybe late last week,
our brief in the birthright citizenship case. So if you go to the Supreme Court's website,
they have all the briefs listed. And you can look up, you can just do Ctrl F and look for
Claremont or Center. And you'll find our brief in the birthright case. Our briefs like old good
court opinions are not that long. So it's like a 15 page read and narrow format margin. So if you
want to get a quick sense of where we're at on this issue, it's not that hard to read, I recommend
it to you. And with that, I will thank our production and engineering crew, the brothers
Gannon, Ryan and Jake. Although these days, I should say, it's mostly Ryan doing the legwork on
all this video editing. And he'll have even more compressed work to do with our new format. So
thanks, Ryan, for all your efforts, including this studio shift that we have in here.
Our longtime viewers, which can't be that long, because we've only done vidcast for a few months,
may notice that we shifted in here a little bit. So we're always tweaking and trying to make it
more attractive and more engaging. So thank you all for joining us. And we will talk to you next week.