Put aside everything you thought you knew about being human. After years of rigorous scientific research, Evolutionary detective Danny Vendramini has developed a theory of human origins, that he believes is stunning in its simplicity, yet breathtaking in its scope and importance. Neanderthals, Denisovans, Homo Erectus, Homo Sapiens, all share a common ancestor, so we have similar behaviors.
Not only have we had the wrong impression of the nature and behavior of Neanderthals, he argues, but we have been fed sentimental, anthropomorphic images of them as well. Neanderthals, he says, were primitives and would have looked very primitive.
There is no reason to suppose they were clean-shaven and good-smelling. The Neanderthals, he expounds, came from the frozen north-they had large nocturnal eyes and were six times stronger than the average modern human.
His thesis is that many physical, social, and psychological characteristics now seen as uniquely human, are direct results of Neanderthal predation on our ancestors, and the theory will be sure to ignite controversy among any group of people genuinely interested in human evolution. Yes, I know Neanderthals are a type of "human".
CHAPTERS:
0:00 What is Neanderthal Predation Theory? 3:50 Theory Debunked - DON'T MISS THIS 7:30 Neanderthal Zoo-Archaeology 10:45 Neanderthal-Human Hybrids
Put aside everything you thought you knew about being human. After years of rigorous scientific
research, evolutionary detective Danny Vendramini has developed a theory of human origins that he
believes is stunning in its simplicity, yet breathtaking in its scope and importance.
Not only have we had the wrong impression of the nature and behavior of Neanderthals,
he argues, but we have been fed sentimental, anthropomorphic images of them as well.
Neanderthals, he says, were primitives and would have looked very primitive.
There is no reason to suppose they were clean-shaven and good-smelling.
The Neanderthals, he expounds, came from the frozen north, they had large nocturnal eyes
and were six times stronger than the average modern human. His thesis is that many physical,
social, and psychological characteristics now seen as uniquely human, are direct results of
Neanderthal predation on our ancestors, and the theory will be sure to ignite controversy among
any group of people genuinely interested in human evolution. However, many controversial theories
were once thought to be crazy. For example, Alfred Wegener's hypothesis of continental drift,
put forward in 1915. Wegener's hypothesis was scorned by many at the time and it was not until
the 1960s, with the understanding of plate tectonics, that an underlying mechanism to
support his hypothesis was provided. Also, Graham Hancock and other researchers propose
theories that were once thought to be crazy, such as comet impacts, and lost ancient civilizations.
This theory provides a similarly bold and controversial hypothesis about human origins.
But sometimes it takes an outsider to cut through the most intractable problems of science.
It is unquestionably the biggest shake-up in evolutionary theory since Darwin,
according to believers. This Neanderthal predation theory is the stuff of nightmares.
If true, every monster from every European myth, every horror novel, and every scary movie may be
derived from memories of the Neanderthal. After all, Neanderthals did have to compete with Homo
erectus and Homo heidelbergensis, who were likely their own ancestors in Europe, so they must have
been tough customers. Both of these archaic humans have been found to have killed and eaten other
human species, and even their own kind. I think that Homo erectus would have been an even more
formidable super-predator than Neanderthals. Groups of Homo erectus hunted large prey with
nothing but crude spears, so they must have been pretty fearless. Modern humans have been called
the third chimpanzee, but, Vendramani asks, why are we such a distinctively unique primate species,
anatomically, behaviorally, and why do we have these deep fears? His thesis that intensive
predation by Neanderthals forcing evolutionary changes offers insight into the human psyche.
He says that the trauma from Neanderthal predation generated the selective pressure,
which transformed a tiny survivor population of early humans into modern humans.
He cites archaeological and genetic evidence to show Neanderthals weren't friendly omnivores,
but savage, cannibalistic carnivores, super predators of the Stone Age.
The Neanderthal predation theory reveals that Neanderthals were apex predators,
who resided at the top of the food chain, and everything else, including humans, was their prey.
You can imagine them using their superior vision to raid Homo sapiens' villages under cover of
darkness. The theory may be one of those groundbreaking ideas that revolutionizes
scientific thinking. It represents a quantum leap in our understanding of human origins.
The theory reveals that Eurasian Neanderthals hunted and killed early humans for 50,000 years
in an area of the Middle East known as the Levant. However, is there any truth to the
Neanderthal super predator theory? It sounds rather absurd at first glance. Well, spoilers,
it is just as absurd as you were thinking. The author cites evidence to demonstrate that this
prolonged period of cannibalistic predation began about 100,000 years ago, and that by 50,000 years
ago, the human population in the Levant was reduced to as few as 50 individuals.
There is actually evidence from Israel of sapiens-Neanderthal hybrids from this time.
Around 100,000 years ago modern humans arrived in Europe and the Middle East.
They encountered the Neanderthals, who were a guerrilla-like super predator,
six times as strong as the average human, according to the book. These vicious and
territorial Neanderthals hunted humans almost to extinction, reducing our population to a tribe
of just 50. This forced us to adapt. Those 50 survivors salvaged humankind from annihilation
by transforming into aggressive and predatory human beings. Then spreading across the globe,
killing all Neanderthals and Denisovans in their path, until every other hominid became extinct.
The theory describes this global migration through Europe, Africa, Asia and Australia,
and the Americas, as a blitzkrieg. It did not end until these hyper-aggressive humans were
the only hominids left alive. It was the first instance of evolution by genocide.
The archaeological record confirms Neanderthal lives were anything but peaceful.
Neanderthalensis were skilled big-game hunters, using spears to take down deer, elk, bison,
even rhinos and mammoths. It defies belief to think they would have hesitated to use these
weapons if their families and lands were threatened. Archaeology suggests such conflicts
were commonplace. Prehistoric warfare leaves telltale signs. A club to the head is an efficient
way to kill, clubs are fast, powerful, precise weapons, so prehistoric Homo sapiens frequently
show trauma to the skull. And so do Neanderthals. This Neanderthal skull found in France suffered a
Indeed, a prehistoric skull could be the world's first murder mystery.
The 430,000-year-old skull seems to show the victim was bludgeoned to death.
Scientists pieced together the world's earliest murder mystery, showing that an ancient human
appears to have met their end after being bludgeoned to death and thrown down a cave shaft.
The skull, found in a cave in Spain, which has two holes above the left eye,
belonged to Homo heidelbergensis, an early human closely related to Neanderthals,
who lived around 430,000 years ago. The almost complete skull shows clear evidence of two
serious impacts. The apparent use of a murder weapon, even if it was only a stone, and the
apparent repeated blows to the head, hints that humans were turning their increasingly sophisticated
intellect towards violent ends, as well as towards cooperation and survival. There are big problems
with this theory, that seem to suggest that it is fundamentally flawed. First of all, modern human
had already sailed to Australia by 65,000 years ago, so this group of 50 could not have been the
only Homo sapiens on Earth 50,000 years ago. Neanderthals may have killed and even eaten
modern humans on occasion, and there is evidence that Neanderthals practiced cannibalism.
But the idea that Neanderthals drove the evolution of modern humans is not supported
by scientific or genetic evidence. But the Neanderthal predation theory brings to mind
several interesting studies. One of these studies was on the diet of Neanderthals,
providing zooarchaeological evidence for the idea. Neanderthals subsisted mainly on meat,
and a study provides molecular support for the theory of their carnivorous predilection.
It even postulates that Neanderthals were among the apex predators in their sphere,
even after anatomically modern humans began to arrive among them.
The earliest ancestors of archaic humans are believed to have subsisted on plants,
much like the greatest of apes today, the gorilla. However, the early vegetarians among
the hominins went extinct, while the meat-eaters carried on to this day.
Being an armivore seems to have become a trend by the time of the diminutive Australopithecines,
who lived three to four million years ago, and ate everything that moved, or didn't move.
Scavenging from dead animals, brought down by other predators,
seems to have been very much their practice. By the time of the much taller Homo erectus,
the taste for meat was firmly entrenched, though some scientists aren't sure these
early hominins cleverly trapped or stabbed their supper. But they did seem to create spears,
and were physiologically capable of throwing them, indicating they were probably hunters.
And they could also run very fast, which would have been a good skill for hunting.
It is pretty clear that after a couple of million years, the ancestral hominin to Neanderthals and
modern humans had become an armivore with a craving for meat, so it would follow that both
of us would continue that habit. For instance, bones of butchered animals were found in Neanderthal
domains. The study postulated that the Neanderthal developed a thickened thorax,
compared with us gracile Homo sapiens, to accommodate their enlarged livers and kidneys,
because of their protein-heavy diet. Weapons the Neanderthal used, presumably to hunt dinner,
rather than hunt each other or stab carrots, have also been identified. A recent study even
suggests they might have developed spears they could throw from afar, as opposed to just sticking
the spear into their prey from up close. But the latest, crucial evidence comes from molecular
analysis of nitrogen isotopes found in collagen, a protein, which in turn was found in two
Neanderthal sites in France. That isn't much of a sample size, statistics-wise, but the results
match nicely with the other evidence. Isotopes are variants of an atom that have different weights
because they have different numbers of nutrients. For instance, proteins, which contain nitrogen,
can have nitrogen-14 and nitrogen-15. The study showed the ratios of nitrogen-14 and nitrogen-15
in Neanderthal bones were found to be similar to those of today's big carnivores, such as wolves.
That strongly suggests that the Neanderthal ate mainly meat, with a little vegetable on the side.
So, what animals were the Neanderthals eating, based on the isotopes? In short, scientists don't
know what exactly they ate. But it does reinforce the position that the Neanderthals were not
vegetarians, and they wolfed down a lot of meat, as much as 80% of their diet. So this lends
credibility to the idea that Neanderthals were apex predators. In another study, the human and
Neanderthal love affair was traced back to Israel, 55,000 years ago, where remains of a hybrid
Neanderthal-sapien skeleton were found in a cave. Also, archaeologists digging in a cave in northern
Israel uncovered teeth, dating to at most 38,000 years ago, that display a mix of Neanderthal and
Homo sapiens features. Neanderthals are thought to have been long extinct in Israel by then,
though some may have survived in isolated pockets. The teeth, therefore, likely belonged
to humans who had interbred with our evolutionary cousins. The researchers conducted CT scans and
3D analysis on four of the teeth, comparing multiple features in their morphology, to a
sample of dozens of prehistoric human teeth from other sites across the world. Unlike bones, teeth
are preserved well, as they are made of enamel, which is the substance in the human body most
resistant to the effects of time. Scientists were able to use the external and internal shape of
the teeth, found in the cave, to associate them with the two hominin groups, Neanderthal and Homo
sapiens. All four teeth, which belonged to four different individuals, displayed a mix of
Neanderthal and Homo sapiens features. This usually happens in cases of interbreeding.
Therefore, this was a Homo sapiens population, but with a strong Neanderthal genetic component.
Scientists discovered the 55,000-year-old modern human skull in a cave in western Galilee.
According to the study, the first interbreeding between humans and Neanderthals may have taken
place in what is now Israel. The researchers think that the hybrid, who they think might be female,
though it's hard to tell with the brow ridge missing, may have been part of the first wave
of humans who moved on from Africa to colonize Europe and Asia. In another study, an ancient
Eastern European man was shown to have had a Neanderthal great-great-grandfather. Analysis of
the jawbone of a man, who lived about 40,000 years ago, reveals the closest direct descendant of a
Neanderthal, who mated with a modern human. A modern human who lived in what is now Romania
between 37,000 and 42,000 years ago had at least one Neanderthal ancestor as little as four
generations back, which is to say, a great-great-grandparent. The specimen consists only
of a male jawbone, and from the moment it was discovered, its shape suggested that it might
belong to a hybrid between Homo sapiens and Neanderthal. Those claims have remained controversial,
but the new analysis lays the controversy to rest. The genome scientists sequenced from the samples
was incomplete, but it was enough for them to conclude that between 6 and 9% of the genome is
Neanderthal in origin. People living today have 2 to 4% Neanderthal DNA, at most. That difference
is more significant than it might seem. Scientists found seven huge pieces of chromosomes that seem
to be purely of Neanderthal origin. That means pieces had to come from a relatively recent
ancestor, since they hadn't yet been broken up by the reshuffling that happens in each generation,
as chromosomes combine. Now that the intermingling is all the more certain,
there are some exciting questions to answer. What was the cultural exchange between these
two species like? What was life like for the hybrid child of a modern human and a Neanderthal?
The Neanderthal predation theory suggests that modern man violently expunged the Neanderthal
from the planet. But if humans and Neanderthals had centuries to get to know each other,
then the story of our success and their failure becomes much more interesting and nuanced.