In this episode of Leadership Insider, Paul explores emotional autonomy — an often unseen leadership skill that shapes clarity, confidence, trust, and momentum inside organisations.
At its core, emotional autonomy is the ability to know what you think, feel, and believe without needing external validation — and to hold that position even when others disagree.
Paul unpacks how a lack of emotional autonomy quietly shows up in leadership through hesitation, over-collaboration, reassurance-seeking, and decision paralysis — creating instability for teams who are looking for clarity and direction.
In this episode, Paul explores: Why confidence that collapses under disagreement creates confusion How over-collaboration often hides a lack of inner authority The difference between healthy alignment and self-erasure Why reassurance-seeking slows decisions and drains momentum How leaders can listen well without outsourcing their leadership
Stay connected, share your thoughts, and subscribe @paulscanlonuk
AI Generated·May contain errors
Hey everyone, welcome to this week's episode of Leadership Insider. Thanks for being here
with me in this space for a while. I want to speak to you today about, it's a strange subject I
suppose you're going to think when I announce the title of this idea that I've been thinking about
for the last few weeks and having conversation with various leaders and their teams about this
I suppose invisible leadership problem is how I want to frame it for you guys today.
I want to speak to you about emotional autonomy. As a leadership skill no one taught us
emotional autonomy. I don't know what you think of when you hear that term
or whether you immediately see an irrelevance of that thought to your life or your leadership
because emotional autonomy is of course in my opinion a huge invisible problem
in human beings generally but I bring it into a leadership space because we're here on Leadership
Insider and my observations in recent months of mentoring leaders in all walks of life around
the world. I think this has become a common thread in various ways as it comes up and I've come down
to this as a conversation with them and I thought it'd be good to pass on to you in the podcast
today. Let me start by saying one of the strangest moments I think in adult life is realizing you
don't actually know how you are feeling about something until you check with someone else
how they are feeling about something that you're feeling. In other words,
leaders who look for external validation because they're internally outsourcing themselves to
other people's thinking, other people's opinions. Decisions that feel solid and reliable only after
consensus has been sought is again a symptom of what I'm calling emotional autonomy or lack thereof.
Confidence about something that then collapses under disagreement is again evidence of a lack
of emotional autonomy. Does any of this strike a chord with you? Any of these things I'm saying
so far bringing into this space with me and the instant I think well yeah I recognize that in me
or I recognize traits of that in people I have worked for or currently am, I'm calling all of
that to get on the same page with me quickly, I'm calling all of that emotional autonomy or a lack
thereof as I said in the way I'm trying to frame this for you guys today. I think it's an invisible
leadership problem because we often don't know what it is that's going on, we don't know how to
explain the fallout of it because that's often how it first presents, that we thought we had clarity
and then the leadership shifts, the conversation changes, it becomes less stable because unknown
to us in the room the leadership that was in the room kind of wasn't clear and wasn't confident
and the lack of emotional autonomy made them want to go and ask someone else that perhaps wasn't in
the room for opinions on it and whatever this person said changed what they said in the room
is so frustrating when that's gone on especially when you don't know what is happening behind the
scenes and it's some version of what I'm talking to you guys about today. It's emotional autonomy,
let me just say this as well at the beginning in case some of you're thinking this is the pushback
you're getting in your voice in your head or you're thinking others would say this about this
topic, it's not about being tough or unhelpfully wrongly independent, it's not about
it's not about not being open to other people's thinking or opinions or wisdom, it's not that at
all, it's about not outsourcing I think your inner authority is what I wanted to talk to you about
because it produces in business some kind of decision paralysis that sets in that then
everybody is affected by and when it becomes a pattern because the personality of the leader
that's making the decisions is to outsource their own internal sense of knowing something
their own internal sense of I know this is right but and they outsource it when that's a personality
type then decision paralysis becomes common and it feels like we are ready set ready set ready set
but never go we're not pressing go on anything because of the leadership's sense of outsourcing
what they're thinking to others that then change the algorithm change what was agreed
and kind of we're all waiting or wondering what's coming next and it creates some sense of
instability this decision paralysis does it's over collaborating a lack of emotional autonomy
presents in the form of over collaboration over seeking other people's opinions after we've been
there done that talked it to death a continual over collaborative energy that's way beyond
necessary is another evidence and brings another kind of cost to businesses that behave this way
it's a culture of reassurance seeking that drives you crazy when you kind of think well this is what
we need to be doing and we knew this two weeks ago and then it's this feel that we're looking
for now more reassurance and there's this hesitancy let's look at but let's look at this
next week when we sit down that the week's gone by and while businesses are doing that your
competitors aren't they are pressing go they are getting on with it they are agreeing and moving
forward it doesn't mean that they don't have some doubt in it all but it means they've learned not
to outsource that doubt to others to settle it before they do something so this culture of
reassurance seeking is killing the business the organization the morale of the team it's leaders
also i think who confuse alignment with self-erasion that the leaders call it i'm looking
a few days ago it's looking for alignment but really it's not alignment that you're looking
for or that you need what you are doing is you are erasing your own voice you're erasing your own
self-confidence and outsourcing that to others thoughts and opinions and when that's all coming
it leaves you again unstable unsure in decision paralysis over collaborating and on that pattern
go these are not bad people these are good people people you respect and like and it's good to work
with them but this is why i called it kind of an invisible thing this nagging thing of for crying
out loud can we just get on with it we made a decision we talked it and then there's this
hesitancy as this outsourcing thing begins to happen the paralysis sets in and this reassurance
seeking is going on and you're thinking what and again i want to say to you guys that the best
people you need in your business will not stay if they see this pattern they want to be on leaders
that lead and i don't mean leaders that lead are people who don't take on board other people's
advice i'm not saying that at all i hope you understand that you know anything about my
teaching um over the years you know that's not what i'm saying but i'm saying that we want you
to lead in a way that gives us a confidence in your leadership that when we've all had a voice
into what we're going to do next in a direction we're taking a product we're launching an idea
and an opportunity and so on a hiring or a firing or whatever it may be can we please stop overthinking
it can we please stop this sense of reassurance seeking this paralysis because what it is is it's
erasing our own sense of knowing what we need to do um in case there's something we missed or in
case so-and-so wants an opinion and on it goes it destroys friendships it destroys romantic
relationships it destroys the relationship with leaders and their teams and followers
and so on um emotional autonomy what it is and isn't let me just say that a little bit so i can
drill down into the definition of this a little bit more for you emotional autonomy is the capacity
to know what you feel think want and need without external validation and then to hold that
knowledge even when others disagree that's what it is how are you on all of that definition
um again let me say it's not selfishness it's not emotional coldness it's not i don't care what
anyone else thinks it's not that it's this nagging sense of um i need something else
to kind of push this over the edge in me to dream light it which is that paralysis this could go on
by the way for years in someone's life and in the business and we kind of put up with it and
skirt around it because these leaders have other good qualities that's why i call it an invisible
problem because it can hide inside a nice personality otherwise and it can hide behind
other good leadership qualities but when i bring this out and isolate it and describe it to you in
the way that i am and it's you now thinking wow i see that in me or i see that in people at work
suddenly when you do that about it that you realize how prevalent it is what a big deal it is
and what i've always found with these things in life and in leadership is that the more able we
are to language these things the better we can talk about it if you don't have language for it
like if you don't have a term emotional autonomy now you have that term you could drop it into a
meeting let's say i've been listening to a podcast this guy was talking about emotional autonomy
um there are several points that this guy raised that i think would be helpful for us to table here
in our executive level meeting or whatever the setting is you're in or a one-on-one conversation
once you have a language you have leverage once you have clarity and definition at least we know
the parameters of the conversation because you've done your homework and now once it's languaged
and said watch how what happens next what happens next is you begin to see it everywhere when you
don't know what to call a thing it hides in plain sight you just know irritating i don't like that
that drives me crazy stop doing that but you don't know what that is so you don't know what
to call it so we we live in these cycles of frustration with people's behavior and how they
are but we don't know what the frustration is caused by we haven't named it so something like
emotional autonomy that we have or we don't have and its symptoms uh means that the conversation
now can be clearly had around these things that are the symptoms of it they are not the root
problem they're the symptoms of all this stuff i'm talking about here the hesitancy the outsourcing
the reassurance seeking the alignment that we think is that but really it's self-erasure
self-abandonment all of those become the symptoms of the deeper problem the deeper problem is a lack
of emotional autonomy so it's the ability to say
i hear you and i still know where i stand on something it's the ability to
take on board an opinion listen to someone but then come back with i hear you but i'm still
convinced that what i'm saying is the right thing to do and i still know where i stand on this it's
kind of that um i was having dinner somewhere a while back with a group of sports leaders
and someone said to this guy in the room what do you want to eat and he said i don't know what do
you want to eat and i noted that and watched throughout the evening how at various points
this guy did versions of that not just over dinner but other things what do you want to do at the
do and it was this sense of before he said what he wanted he wanted to know what they wanted
which evidenced to me a lack of emotional autonomy it's looking for what do you think before i tell
you what i think because if what you think is different to what i think i'm going to switch
to lean towards your opinion and so when that becomes a pattern in leadership it's awful to
be around is that you when people say what do you want to watch on tv and you know what you
want to watch do you say well i don't know what do you fancy watching because honestly if if you
can't be clear about what you want to eat for dinner then you're going to be so unclear about
bigger decisions in your work life where people looking to you for clarity and strength and
direction but you keep deferring and hesitating and what that's called is a lack of emotional
autonomy you can't feel emotionally settled in a decision until other people have ticked certain
boxes and it's an affliction honestly it is an affliction in life and i'm not not judgment here
we were all raised to not be emotionally autonomous from childhood by non-emotionally
autonomous parents or caregivers we were all raised to outsource our internals
certainties emotionally we were all raised to be subject to other people's opinions and ideas about
small things and if you add into that a tendency then that's built into us to be people pleasers
to hate being disliked to hate being unpopular to hate being the one with a different opinion
in the room and that gets built into our dna if you like then we grow up into an adult life
and workspace and leadership opportunity perhaps where we carry traits of that with us and it
becomes so embedded in our personality it's always been how we are other great things about us that
and that's why it's an invisible thing because it's kind of who we are what i'm trying to do
today is separate out these bits of who you are and ask you is that who you are or is it who you
were conditioned to be if it's who you were conditioned to be and that's now your autopilot
personality and mo then the truth is you can come off autopilot take manual control of your life
and its direction and pay attention to these kinds of ideas that i'm sharing with you today
on the podcast most leaders are rewarded for reading the rooms that they are in or managing
other people's emotions or suppressing their own sense of uncertainty all of that works until it
doesn't work and when it doesn't work it shouts that it's not working so to be rewarded for
reading a room and so you suppress your own sense of what needs to be said because you're too busy
reading the room who's in the room and their body language their facial expressions what
they said five minutes ago you read in the room and normally that's a good thing to do
but it's not if you don't have emotional autonomy because they read in the room
is behaving like a thermometer instead of a thermostat emotionally you are reflecting the
climate that others are bringing to the room and responding to that rather than coming in
with an internal thermostatic set climate that you know and are convinced is right and the best
way to go that's not it doesn't mean it's not open for conversation but you've got this general
sense of this internal sense of this is the way we should be going but you're unable to sustain
that climate control because you have let go of the thermostatic dial if you like internally
you're outsourcing now the climate to incoming weather conditions and so you're in the room
as a leader but behave like a thermometer going up and down with what climate and weather conditions
people bring to the table that day rather than we can rely on you to be emotionally
autonomously stable in your leadership towards us and so while you're rewarded for these things
managing other people's emotions that's a great skill to have not if it's coming from
a lack of emotional autonomy in us when you're not managing that emotions that emotions are
managing you and dialing and dumbing you down from being the kind of person we so want you to be
in your leadership role and this isn't a perfect exact science you're going to get it wrong
you're going to overstep you're going to miss something you're going to have not listened
you're going to think well i wish i'd listened all of that's part of the an algorithm of life
and relationships and leadership so i'm allowing for all of that and you should too but what we
don't want what i don't want for you guys is that you are in these important rooms and you are in
perhaps pivotal transitional moments in your business where leadership really needs to step
up in those moments and we are all struggling because yet again we're witnessing this lack
of emotional autonomy in you where you are outsourcing and you are hesitating and you
are looking for reassurance and overthinking and over collaborating with things for crying out loud
please we have some leadership in here all right i'm going to stop there and come back to this on
the next episode let me know what your thoughts are so far on this topic and i'm going to unpack
this over the next few episodes about emotional autonomy thanks for being here guys uh please
would you be kind enough to hit subscribe i know it helps the boosting of the attention
in the algorithms out there of the podcast in the podcast universe and i'm a new voice in
this space or i've recently revived my voice i started podcasting uh way back i think in like
2013 or 14 before anybody was past podcasting then i had a break for a while i'm back so it
will help me to boost the ratings if you will follow me to follow and subscribe whatever those
things are that we do to help me uh with the ratings for the podcast all right let me know
what you think in the comments and the feedback and i will speak to you in the next episode
where we continue in this idea of emotional autonomy cheers