The U S Housing Market Is Broken And Policymakers Are Out of Options w Melody Wright

Living In America Homes
9 followers
1 Video View·Feb 2, 2026
In this episode of Milk Road Macro, Melody Wright explains why falling mortgage rates won’t restore affordability, why policymakers are effectively out of tools, and why today’s housing market is stuck in a dangerous limbo with no real price discovery. Despite government intervention, subsidies, and creative policy proposals, buyers remain locked out, sellers won’t capitulate, and inventory continues to build.
Note: This clip is taken from a longer episode published earlier. To catch the full conversation and all the context, head over to the complete interview on our channel.
We've painted this picture of widespread grift, we've got a huge amount of unutilized inventory
that no one can afford to get into, and we have a lot of people who own these properties who are
looking at their valuations dropping. Trump, as you alluded to before, mentioned in an address,
and he's made several comments offhand to the press and the Oval Office about this,
wanting to keep home prices high but bring mortgage rates down.
And this sounds like pulling a rabbit out of a hat. He keeps making allusions that he's going
to figure this out. The administration is, in good faith, trying to work on solutions here,
obviously, because it's an important thing. But what does this mean when the rubber hits the road?
What policy path might we see from the Trump administration, and what likelihood do you
think there is of being some success there? Yeah, so rates won't do it. I mean, I'm so sorry.
I mean, we'd have to get down to something absolutely bananas low, even lower than what
we saw during the COVID boom, to really make it affordable for everybody. And they're already
trying. I mean, they're really trying. What they've done is they've told Fannie and Freddie
to buy mortgage-backed securities, because the Fed can't do that. Everybody knows. It is crazy
how you can just walk up to somebody on the street and say, why are home prices so high?
And they say, the Fed was buying mortgage-backed securities. You're like, whoa. How do you know
that? But it's just people realize that's what happened, and so the Fed can't do that.
They'll get in trouble, because they know that looks inflationary. And so they've told Fannie
and Freddie to do it, which is terrible, because that has a whole range of implications. But my
point is that they're kind of out of options. They've done everything. And so I think we're
at the stage now where it's pure kayfabe, meaning that I think they know that lower rates aren't
going to do it. I mean, you can just look at, we've seen rates come down with Fannie and Freddie
buying that mortgage MBS, because that reduces the spread between the 10-year and mortgage rates.
That's a whole other conversation. But they're affecting a lower mortgage rate,
and that's done nothing to sales. Nothing. And I want sales to increase, because then we'll get
actual price discovery. And so I think what they're doing, John, is they're performing.
And they're performing, and they're saying, we're trying, we're doing everything. But they realize
they're kind of out of options. And unfortunately, who's going to be impacted the most are our
boomers. And people think that all of our boomers are rich. They're not at all. Like 50% of them
can't really even afford to live. And they're the biggest increase to our homeless. That cohort is
who's adding so much to our homeless population. And so they're going to get hurt. And I can tell
you, when I was down in Pembroke Pines in Florida, where they stormed this condo office building
because their HOA fees went up because of insurance, these people cannot afford. It's a
fixed income, fixed. I mean, they can't afford these increases that came out of nowhere.
And so I just think that they have to make a show. And there's two bills right now in committee
that I'm sure will get passed, which is just more like subsidies, more of this grift that I'm
telling you about where this nonprofit is going to buy the block. Well, you have this program in
Rochester, New York right now called Buy the Block. And it's hedge funds. And they put lipstick
on a pig and they're not actually rehabbing these homes. And so you're going to get a lot more of
that. And I think you're also going to get a bailout of the builders, which will probably
lead to some sort of, we'll give you a swap line where we'll finance you for these homes if you
price them at a certain percentage of the household median income in that area or something like that.
So I kind of see those types of things happening, but it will not. It will not save us from what's
coming because supply is and it's hard for people to understand because they've been
lied to for three years. But supply is going to be a tsunami onto the it's coming fast and furious.
ETFs provide investors with a structured, disciplined and diversified approach to crypto,
which is cool, but the world is moving on chain. We need a crypto native equivalent.
That's exactly what reserves decentralized token folios DTFs bring to the table. Reserve DTFs are
rule-based baskets of crypto assets packaged into a single token, like CoinMarketCMC20,
crypto's version of the S&P 500. Go to milkroad.com slash reserve to find out what's on offer.
Okay, so we got a tsunami of supply. You're saying you expect some sort of subsidies for
homebuilders. I think there's a few other policy ideas that have been floated and I'd like to hear
you just address some of these things. The 50-year mortgage has been talked about a lot. I think
that's a nothing burger. If you'd like to explain why, go right ahead. But I think another thing
that Bill Pulte and others have talked about has been this idea of transferable or assumable
mortgages to sort of make it say, if you can take your mortgage with you, if it's already working
for you. But I think your opinion is that won't really fix things either. But I think a lot of
audience would like to hear, will these policies be effective? So could you kind of explain what
the impacts of those things would be? Will they help? Will they not help? And just kind of walk
us through some of that. Yes. So there's two different things. The assumable mortgage, right
now you can do that with FHA and VA. And what that means is that you would be able, they would
underwrite you, but you would be able to assume someone's low rate. Okay. That's not a big deal
because it's the actual, it's still the same property. Okay. And that'll become important.
And I'll tell you that in a minute. But the servicers aren't set up to do this. They're
just not. And it couldn't be done at a hundred percent. It could be done. I don't see us having
the political will to do it because it is a massive re-engineering of just service
operations. And they would want a heck of a lot more money to do it, John. And so I talked to
people that do this right now. They have whole companies and they are getting pushback from
every single servicer. They're having to file complaints with their AGs and things like that,
because the servicers just don't, it's a very thin margin business. They don't have the money.
They don't have, they're not getting paid because when you realize that our entire housing market
that's in mortgage is backed by the government, you realize like, just think how, you know,
how you think about the government. They're not paying the servicers to do this. If they
incentivize the government, I mean the servicers to do assumable loans, they would do them.
But they're not. And it's just, it's like these regulations just, it just takes forever for
change. Okay. That's the assumable. The portable is a non-starter because, and the portable is
the idea, you know, that you're just, so let me, let me stop and talk about securitizations. Okay.
Our entire housing market, the entire liquidity in the housing market are from securitizations.
If you watch the big short, right. What are those securities backed by? The actual collateral,
the house. Okay. So you can't, they would break our entire securitization machine.
And you would have a mortgage market where your credit unions are probably the only ones lending.
And they're only lending at like a 15% interest rate. And they're only lending if you have like
an 800 credit score. Because the only way we have the securitization engine that works today
is because of this government involvement. So you would, you would break that engine by doing
the portable. So that's a non-starter. And, you know, I think they have something like that in
Canada, but no one in the world, John, does housing like we do. And they don't have the
security. They've tried. They've tried our securitization, the way that we do it. And
they haven't been able to do it successfully. It is such a complicated machine.
And I'm sure I confused everybody. I'm sorry, but go ahead.
Well, you know, I think it's, it's an inherently confusing machine, right? Like you said. And I
think that that's something that a lot of people are trying to get their heads around because
there's a lot of these quick fix ideas that are tossed out. It's like, oh, this will help. This
will help. But there's, there's a lot more machinery behind some of these things like
assumable or transferable mortgages that people don't understand. And I think, you know, just
explaining a little bit of how that works and how it doesn't, it's helpful for people.
So, you know, I want to kind of get to something I've heard you say, which I think is a drastic
change. And I want to kind of understand the thesis here and how this could work. But you've
said that you think that the United States government, the federal government is going
to be forced to start buying houses and not just buying MBSs, but buying houses. Why do you think
they're going to be forced into this position? And what does that actually look like once that
starts to happen? Want insights on what's really moving markets and how we're trading each event?
Subscribe to our channel, then join the Milk Road Macro and Macro Pro newsletters.
This show is for educational purposes only. Nothing we say is financial advice.
Investing is risky. Never invest more than you can afford to lose.
