The Time Team believes an 11th-century flour mill once stood on her land, near Stoke Trister in Somerset, and asks the Team to dig. There is reference to a mill in the parish in Domesday, and standing remains of a building depicted in a 1782 parish map. Multiple leat earthworks in the area indicate multiple mills over the centuries. The remains of the standing mill include parts of the last mill wheel, a 19th century overshot wheel.
It's like Netflix for history... Sign up to History Hit to start watching now https://bit.ly/45CPh5u
You can find more from us on:
/ timelinewh
/ timelinewh
This channel is part of the Little Dot Studios Network. Any queries, please contact [email protected] Time Team investigates a Somerset field, searching for an 11th-century flour mill mentioned in the Domesday Book. Evidence suggests
One of the great privileges of working at History Hit and making films
together with our team at Timeline is the access we get
to extraordinary historical locations like this one
Stonehenge. I'm right in the middle of the stone circle now. It is an absolutely
extraordinary place to visit. If you want to watch the
documentary like the one we're producing here
go to History Hit TV. It's like Netflix for history
and if you use the code TIMELINE when you check out
you'll get a special introductory offer. See you there.
A few years ago the new owner of this sleepy Somerset field
made a remarkable discovery. Buried away amongst the brambles and trees
she discovered this. Intrigued she did some research and she
discovered that these ruins had once been part of a
powerful industrial machine. A watermill which could well have been
putting bread on the tables of the people around here
since the doomsday book. But despite her best efforts
we still know very little about Buck Mill. So we've been invited here for the
next three days to reveal the secrets of this powerful
feat of engineering. Right, time to get our noses to the
grindstone. Sorry about that. Buck Mill lies near the
village of Stoke Trister in Somerset. We know that the ruins belong to a
watermill that went out of use 150 years ago
but its past remains a mystery. Although there is one exciting clue.
A doomsday reference that suggests beneath the ruins
we could find a mill that dates back to the Normans.
So by excavating Buck Mill we hope to learn just how this powerful mill
would have shaped the lives of people around here possibly for a thousand
years.
What have you managed to discover about it? The oldest
mention that I could find of a mill at Stoke Trister
goes back to doomsday and we've been to the records office where
we found some old maps like this one here. This is a 1782
map and you can see the mill there. There's a
little drawing of it. It's a little drawing but Mick
it's a pretty big mill. It's got a bit of a puzzle isn't it?
It is because this is not an arable area. This is not an area where people are
growing cereals. We're at the bottom end of what was the medieval forest of
Selwood. So you'd expect a lot of trees and
grazing and pastured animals but not people growing
cereals. So why would they need a big mill?
Helen I know you've hardly had a chance to look at the documents yet but have
you found any clues so far? Well no there's not a lot really. After
the doomsday reference where it's worth tenpence. Which is nothing at all is it?
It's not is it? And there's almost nothing after that until our 1782 map
so it's going to be a real detective task to find out what's going on.
So apart from one doomsday reference there's nothing else until the 1782 map
and we've no idea how that ties in with the standing archaeology.
This is concrete you don't expect me to be spending three days digging a sheet.
Because of the tough terrain our geophys team aren't able to survey the site
so we'll have to rely on our experts to tell us where to dig.
That must be the wheel pit. Martin down there.
We got the back wall there and one of the return walls I think of the water
wheel pit. I mean that ought to be where our first
trench is then. Yeah I think so yes. Get the wheel pit cleared and we'll
know a lot more about the size of the water wheel where the water came on
which would give us a good indication of the power how much work it could have
done. And as we go down through it what are we
likely to find in it? Well we may find some bits of water wheel some bits of
metalwork in particular I would think possibly
even some timber and maybe some scratch marks on the
stones where the water wheels fouled it in the past at some time which will give
us a few more clues about its size. But that
is actually a crucial part of the mill. I think so I think it's the it's the
heart of the mill really. But before we can go any further the
mill has to be stripped of a hundred years of brambles.
Phil's job will be to uncover the industrial end of the mill
by digging down into the wheel pit. While at the other end of the building
we're hoping to find what we think is the miller's house.
And the moment the brambles around the wheel pit are cleared we make our first
find. Well that's what he was hoping you'd
tell me. Some sort of metal casting look.
But I don't there's got a new break there look
and that's broken there but I don't think that I don't think that fits on
there does it? No that ain't it.
Oh hang on what's that one? Is it that? Ah that's it.
So what's that then? Any ideas? It seems a little bit lightweight for the mill
but I can't think what else it could be at this point.
I'm told identifying mill parts can be a bit of a brain teaser
because there were so many bits and bobs of machinery required
to get the power of the water to the millstones. But we do know our mill is
likely to be one of three common types of water wheel.
The most basic and least efficient undershot wheel
or a middle of the range breast shot wheel
or the most complex design of all an overshot wheel.
The whole idea of a watermill must have been a very dramatic improvement anyway
because as technological breakthroughs go the
watermill was a big one it would have transformed the lives of
everyone around it. In a way they are the first machines
you know up until the time that water mills come in
the only power you've got is either human muscles or animal muscles
to suddenly harness something like a stream and then of course later on wind
power and then of course later on steam and coal
it's it's a it's a real breakthrough it's a complete change
so it had an enormous impact on people's thinking.
Is that gonna fit back on there? Back at the wheel pit
we now have another piece for our increasingly puzzling puzzle.
Oh wow look at that that's the bit. No then what the hell is it then?
Maybe that curve was to do with the actual circumference of the
water wheel.
With almost no records to go on we'll be relying on our army of diggers to
explain the mill's past. So now the brambles are cleared they can
get stuck in.
And as Phil and Martin work their way down into the wheel pit
something else has caught Phil's eye. Look there's
a cavity opened up in here. Look there's a piece of curving metal
That looks like part of the wheel Phil. You reckon that what that is?
I think we found a bit of a metal water wheel.
This really is a big discovery and the more of the wheel we find
the more it can tell us about the power and importance of this mill.
Ah there it is. That's fantastic that's part of one of the buckets of the water
wheel that's part of a metal bucket. That is the water wheel. It is part of
the water wheel part of the bottom of the wheel is still in there.
Can you date this design of construction? Well an all metal wheel like that
is going to be sort of middle of the 19th century
around about. If you can find me a bit more with a name on it and possibly a
date then we'll know. Middle of the 19th century that would
presumably mean that that is the last wheel that was in here when the
mill went out of use. It's one o'clock day one all the diggers
have gone to lunch except Phil who is of course a bit of a nutcase
and down here amongst all this rubble somewhere
we think we've got the mill wheel the very heart
of all the activity here. We couldn't have really dreamt of better in the whole
of the three days but the other thing that's really
impressing me is the size of this site now. We started
off with just a few crumbled bits of wall
and now we've got all this and if that wasn't enough take a look
down there. Helen what do you reckon that is?
Well at first sight that looks very much like an Anglo-Saxon comb.
Anglo-Saxon? This mill is starting to get rather weird.
It's just after lunch on day one and we've already found a wheel
from the remains of our water mill Buck Mill
the origins of which remain a mystery as all we've got to go on
is an 18th century map. So it seems that we've been incredibly
lucky to find our wheel as they were usually removed when a
mill went out of use. So Phil what have we got now? We've got
the other side of the wheel Martin. That's excellent. Here's the actual
circumference inner circumference of the wheel coming
around there and then we've got a bucket there and
looks like we've got a bucket coming in there
but the crucial thing is we've actually got part of the internal structure of
the wheel because we've got one of the spokes
in there and then we've got another one there look
and another one here and another one back there as well.
So they're all coming in to that main axle here.
But they've just been cut off have they? What they've done before they demolished
the mill was they looked at all this scrap
metal in the wheel thought we could make use of that
so what they've done is they've chopped the wheel off and then when they've
demolished the mill all the demolition rubber was gone in on the top of it
and the rest of the wheel's been taken away. All you've got to do is find this
name and date on it for me. You go away and I'll see what I can do.
The mill wheel would have needed a steady flow of water
and it should be Stuart's job to work out where that would have come from.
Stuart I would have thought by now you'd have been striding across the
landscape not mucking around in sand. Not exactly playing this time. I have been
doing a bit of looking at the landscape round about.
I thought it would be really sensible to trying to
understand how the water works in this landscape by making this sand model.
Now on your model you've got a blue line which is presumably a river and a white
one. Yeah I mean what we've got here is
basically a valley which comes down here and we've
got a stream which flows all down the valley.
If you want to turn a water wheel in an overshot or a breast shot wheel you've
got to get the water higher than the wheel to physically
turn it. You can't do that in that gentle valley there.
So what you have to do is to go up the valley until you're
on the stream at a point that will be higher than your water wheel
and basically cut an artificial channel to lead the water off from the stream
bring it along the contour so that eventually
it's higher than the water wheel you want to turn. Is that what Mick calls a
leet? That's right yeah this artificial channel along here.
And do you know that we've got that? Have you found a leet? Yes you can see this
going to way beyond the mill where they're
excavating at the moment. It's a deep channel going along the
contour. So we now know millers went to extraordinary lengths
to get water to the mill. But the 1782 map would suggest they
also put a lot of effort into their homes.
And our second trench is now going in over the end of the building
we believe is the miller's house. And within seconds Faye and Raksha hit a
rather posh stone floor. This little bit here. I just want to see
what's happening.
Yeah if we just go to that level and then we can hand dig the rest of this.
In the middle of the building Tracy is looking for the cockpit
which would have held the gears required to transfer power
from our 19th century mill wheel to the millstones.
Mick suspects the mill's history should go back much further.
But the big question is this is only what 18th 19th century
what's underneath it? Well yeah that's the problem you see we could end up with
a really good plan of an 18th or 19th century mill
for which there are hundreds still standing. They've all been turned into
tea shops haven't they? Yeah and posh restaurants the sort of place you go to
you know. What we really need to do is to go
through underneath this where there are holes
in the floor and see whether the 16th 17th century mill
with all the fittings and pottery and stuff going with it
is encased underneath somewhere. That's the only way we'll get the early stuff.
I don't go into tea shops. And in the cockpit
Tracy has uncovered what could be another important piece of the mill's
machinery. I mean we've got we've got the cog
hole here which would have attached to the wheel
the cockpit which would have been in here we haven't got it yet. Okay that's
good isn't it? Yeah but then behind me I think you're
gonna like this. Oh crikey. First millstone. Yeah yeah. Half a
millstone anyway. Half a what? Is that in situ there is it?
Well we don't know until we've cleaned around some more of the demolition
material but it does look very flat. It might form the back wheel
uh the back wall rather of the cockpit. But that should help
because the size of it the type of stone the patterning on this
will give us the date of it. Yeah and then we see it coming up down here where
James is working we've got the floor coming up.
Great. Yeah it's starting to really come together.
So across the site there's a strong picture of the building in the 1782 map
emerging. All we need now are some solid 18th
century finds to tie in with the ruins. But the only finds we've got so far are
pointing to a completely different era. It's all a little bit late for me
I mean just looking at this I mean to my
semi-untrained eye I mean that looks like an Art Deco bottle to me. Very much.
And you've got this you've got this beautiful blue glass ashtray again
looks Art Deco. I mean have you got the idea what date any of this? This bottle
here with its clear glass and a mould seam running through the lip is
is certainly post 1920 and possibly even later than that.
It's a technique that wasn't used until the 20s.
It looks to me like the locals have just basically been using this as a rubbish
pit when it's fallen out of use. I mean you've got
everything you can possibly imagine from a household of the period dumped in there
I think haven't you? From the 1920s 1930s.
The archaeology of Buck Mill isn't proving as straightforward as we first
thought. So can our 9th century Anglo-Saxon comb
help clear up the mill's past? It's got these lovely blue
green coloured rivets which are what would have held the whole comb together.
Then if you have a look at this inscription on the bottom you can see it
So my inference is that this was bought in the gift shop at West Stowe which is a
fantastic place to visit and was perhaps deposited on our site
by somebody who came along and saw that it looked like a very ancient place with
an ancient wall lovely tree growing at the top.
You know this was the right place for perhaps there so it could comb.
Or maybe it was planted by someone who knew we were coming.
Possibly. Whatever this is not the scene that I thought we were going to do.
Our rather convincing replica comb means we're still stuck in the 20th century.
In terms of dates this site's really not making any sense at all
and the only solid historical evidence that can take us any further back
are Stephanie's 1782 map and the reference in the
doomsday book to there being a mill somewhere in this parish in 1086.
Which for some reason two of our experts now seem to think
might be in a nearby field.
Is there another leak? Because in the cross country like this.
Well I mean as I walked I've had exactly the same thought
and I think I'm walking along a leak same as you do.
It's what it looks like and you carry on.
And does that make sense to you?
Absolutely as we walk all the way down.
That's the bottom of the valley isn't it?
That's where the stream should be where he's walking.
Doing that quite nicely.
What are you guys doing? Everyone else is about 300 yards over there.
We've looked at the earthworks and we think this is where the early mill is.
Here? Yeah.
But I thought you said that the early mill was underneath the later mill up there.
This might be another mill.
I mean everything points to be in a mill somewhere where we're standing here at the moment.
What sort of date?
11th century something like that.
Or earlier.
Or earlier yeah.
Are they common?
Less than half a dozen have been excavated so it's a real find.
What an extraordinary day this is turning out to be and it's only day one.
Who knows what else we'll find in this sleepy Somerset field.
Maybe we'll get a brush to go with our comb.
It's the start of day two in Somerset
where we're trying to get to the bottom of a water mill, Buck Mill.
Spurred on by a doomsday reference we were hoping to find a much older mill beneath it.
But last night two of our experts had convinced themselves they'd found an early medieval mill,
possibly our doomsday mill, 300 meters to the west.
So with half our team now shifted to this new site,
Mick and Stuart's reputations are already on the line.
Where the leak comes through here there's a potential that
it's still wet down at the bottom of the mix.
It's certainly wet further up so it could get quite to the dark.
The only problem is Geophys can't see anything.
Emma's done the model now, the topography and it looks really nice.
Just looking at a little plan you can see the leak clearly coming through here.
She's got the turn as well has she?
Got the turn as well, the bank showing in red.
There's nothing here that suggests building to us but we wouldn't expect to see it.
That was going to be my question.
Would you expect to see a timber lotland door building that's got no occupation in it?
No.
Right.
They might not be able to see any remains of the mill
but Geophys helped them pick the most likely spot for it to be in.
So that's where we're putting our third trench.
We've got the cleanest clay there and there's almost you could say there's something there.
Well just looking at the Geophys the way you've got that arrow straight
leat and then the wiggly bit I mean that is classic mill.
If there's one here this is where it should be you know.
If they uncover a mill dating back to 1086 it'll be a major discovery
because of the 6,000 water mills recorded by the Normans in the doomsday book
only a handful have ever been traced.
What is it in the landscape that makes you think there might be an earlier mill up there?
Well there's a couple of things.
First of all this depression we're in is the original stream course
the meandering course of stream that comes down the valley.
See it rises up up here?
Yeah.
And where Mick's heading up here.
Up here look.
To that terrace he's walked from all the way up there he's walking along it.
That carries on up this side of the valley up into the hills up there
and what that leet should be doing is bringing water
doesn't mean like a mill
just about there.
Oh let's make it a bit more dramatic than that.
Let me explain that in a bit more detail.
What you find in the landscape is a big leet which starts high up there
comes in a nice gradient
this is the terrace that Mick was walking along just there
it comes all the way to here and then it turns a corner
and goes back into the stream.
It's the same sort of principle you've got at that mill
so ideally there should be a mill somewhere about there.
I've seen the geophys there is nothing there.
No but you wouldn't expect that you see because this is not a site that's lived in
it's not going to have hearths and fires ovens and so on.
You wouldn't expect it to show up if it's a timber building.
We're happy either way you know I mean if it's milk great
if it's not we'll have learned something.
How arrogant and wrong you are.
Compared to the industrialized buck mill
an early medieval mill would have used very basic technology
and would have looked something like this.
Built largely from timber all that's likely to remain of it
are fragments of wood or traces of post holes.
So Matt and his team are sifting the clay
for any possible fragments of mill they can date.
While Mick and Stuart's early medieval mill remains a rather wild theory
thankfully we do have a real mill that we're excavating.
Phil hasn't stopped digging into the wheel pit at Buck Mill
since he uncovered a section of water wheel.
Oh Martin come and have a look at this.
It's getting quite a lot of this wheel now.
You've got a lot more showing now than yesterday.
Well that's right you see I mean yesterday if you remember
we started to expose the wheel over there
but now we're away from the wall.
Look you've got a nice run of the metal wheel running right down in under my feet
and we're beginning to get these spokes going right through.
It's going to be fascinating.
You've exposed so much more of this now
that I can see that my initial thoughts weren't quite right.
In what way?
I was thinking that it was a brush shot wheel turning that way.
And now as you can see from the way the buckets are
it turned that way didn't it?
It's an overshot wheel.
The water must have come over the top.
They could only be filled on the downside.
Well you can actually see that here because of the curvature of this bucket here.
Forgive my ignorance but what difference does it make which way round the wheel goes?
Well in a way the direction doesn't matter too much.
It's where the water comes onto it.
The fact the water's coming on the top and it's an overshot wheel
means it's the best solution.
It's the most powerful.
It's the most efficient type of wheel you could have.
So is that really upping the status and power of this mill?
Yeah I think we're putting it up where I'd like to see it really.
It points to this being an older site with an overshot wheel.
So this final phase of Buck Mill is both older and grander than we first thought.
And Martin says he can tell us exactly how powerful it was
by crunching the numbers from its measurements.
Old money three foot six.
New money 1.07.
With no finds yet that tell us anything about the previous occupants of Buck Mill,
Helen has enlisted the help of its current owner Stephanie.
I've been doing quite a lot of digging about and I found
a couple of references I think are quite interesting.
This is a will of 1703 made by a chap called John Benjefield.
Now he describes himself as John Benjefield the elder of Buck Mill
in the parish of Stoke Trister, Miller.
So he is not just living at Buck Mill, he's actually defining himself as a miller.
And he leaves all sorts of bequests.
He's obviously quite a wealthy man but he doesn't specifically leave the mill to anybody.
So I think it's being rolled up with the residue that's going to his wife Marjorie here.
Which is interesting isn't it?
So presumably he's leaving the business to her.
Yeah.
Which I think is lovely.
And it mentions here my said daughter Mary.
Yeah he's leaving her a hundred pounds here and I think elsewhere she gets another five.
And there's another Mary Benjefield that crops up a bit later.
Now this is a deed, dates to 1790.
Now if you look along this line it says,
late in the tenure or possession of the said Mary Benjefield.
So 1790, it can't be the same one I wouldn't have thought.
But it could be a granddaughter or great-granddaughter of John Benjefield.
So we're getting a few names, we're beginning to piece it together.
At the industrial end of Buck Mill, Martin is ready to reveal its vital statistics.
We've got the diameter and the width of the wheel, about 12 foot diameter,
three and a half feet wide, six horsepower.
Does that make it a big mill or a little mill?
Sort of average, average.
Gives plenty of power for driving a pair of millstones.
So even though we've got a very big building,
we've only got a middling sized mill which sort of makes more sense doesn't it?
Given the kind of area we're in.
Yes but given this type of area where you've got a lot of pasture land,
it just shows that if you did have a corn mill here, it was a very important building.
So our mediocre mill might have been an important building in the 1830s,
but the records tell us nothing about the millers who were running it at this time.
But further back, Helen has uncovered a little dynasty
who ran Buck Mill for at least three generations from the 17th century, the Benjefields.
And at last the diggers could have made some finds
that could tie the Benjefields to the remains of our miller's house.
We're getting quite a nice selection of pottery from under the floor now
and some of it's 17th century.
Which is that?
Things like this, it's the local Donya urban one.
Could this tie in with our Benjefield family?
Well John Benjefield, the miller who dies in 1703,
his children are born during the 1670s and 1680s.
So they could well have broken this pottery.
They could if they were badly behaved enough.
What else have you got?
Well some of this would actually date reasonably closely to that.
These fragments here, I could date those to about 1660 to about 1680 or thereabouts.
We're getting a little background scatter of earlier stuff.
That piece for instance is 16th century, so that's a little bit early.
Anything else that you can work out from the pottery scatter that you've got?
It's all more or less the sort of thing you'd expect in this part of the world.
The cup is quite nice, it's not fantastically high status,
but it's still a nice piece for the time.
Thanks to the Benjefields leaving some of their kitchenware behind,
we're in the exciting position of being able to connect them to this earlier phase of the mill.
I'm hoping this luck will have spread to our other site.
Where they've spent all day digging the lumps and bumps in the landscape,
Mick and Stuart are convinced contain an early medieval mill.
They've opened two more trenches up,
and as Mick and Stuart are discussing opening another,
it seems they might still be looking for it.
The mill's not going to be massively far that way,
because they use the water for the wheel,
and as soon as they finish with it, it's off back down to the stream.
Chuck it back in the stream.
That's what's going down there.
So it's really, if it's not in this section here,
we need to be sampling along this terrace here
for perhaps another 30 metres to see if it's in this,
because it really ought to be in the next 30 metres or so, I would suggest.
Or why don't we put a trench in that takes in the edge of the leet,
back along that 20 or 30 metres,
because there ought to be something coming off that,
and we'll see it on the edge of the leet if it's there.
And use the leet as a guide.
After half an hour of our two experts deliberating on where they should dig next,
our diggers are struggling to share their enthusiasm.
I can't believe that they've gone to all that trouble to bring the water for no reason.
You know, it doesn't make sense that there should be something
to use that water when they get it here, just otherwise it doesn't work.
So Matt and his merry band of diggers now have another trench to open.
OK, helmet's on.
Ian?
Yeah, you woken up yet?
Not yet.
I fell asleep halfway through, I've lost the will to live at this point.
It seems as though the doubt must be contagious,
because at the sight of Buck Mill, Phil has just thrown everything up in the air,
just when I thought it was all coming together.
So Mick is taking a break from his wild goose chase
to try and get to the bottom of Phil's woes.
Phil, last time I was here it was all covered in scrub,
and up 19th century we've done a hell of a lot of work.
We have, and now it's all complicated.
Is the house at the other end then still a house, is that still contemporary?
I think that's still residential, yes,
but we've still got to actually try and tie in the actual phases of building
with what we've got where Tracy is,
and then we've actually got to start building on from that
and trying to actually understand what's going on in the phasing over this side.
And this wall here, you see once we get up on the top here,
we've got a wall coming through here,
comes through underneath here,
and goes straight down through the wall pit.
Yeah.
This doesn't appear to come straight through here.
Look, we've got this one that comes across there.
Yeah, yeah.
So there's walls everywhere,
and until we actually look at the way each wall joins on
or butts up against every other wall,
we won't understand what's going on in this building.
It's going to be tricky, isn't it?
We can do it.
Somewhere in this area,
Mick and Stu are pretty sure that there's a Norman Mill.
In fact, they've staked their reputations on it.
Well, they've looked here and there isn't a Norman Mill here.
They've looked over there, no Norman Mill.
See a trench over there?
There's no Norman Mill in that.
But if you look here,
well, I'll leave you to decide what's here.
Oh, it's Mr Misery again.
Here he comes.
Do you know what that is?
Go on.
That is a line.
And see these?
These are your reputations and they're on it.
We don't care.
We're still confident this has to be the site of the mill.
We've got this leach.
We can see it in the ground.
We can see it in the side of the trench.
We can see it in that trench over there.
Everything focuses into this area in the corner in here.
I love the way they keep rediscovering the leach.
We've known about the leach for 24 hours.
Never mind the leach.
Give us the mill.
Give us the time.
So with only one day left,
we still have an entire early medieval mill to find
and a lot of detective work to do.
In spite of this, the team feel they've earned a treat
or as they prefer to call it, some experiential archaeology.
We're rewarding them with some genuine medieval bread
and some cheese.
And because this is Somerset,
they've got some genuine Somerset cider as well.
This is a good version of what the medieval peasant diet
would have been like in Somerset, you know.
We know they had lots of cheese.
They drank cider and we know they ground corn to make bread.
And the upper class people ate the white bread,
which isn't very good for you.
And the peasants ate the brown bread full of bran and stuff,
which is really good for you.
There's a good history lesson for you at the end of the day.
So what are we going to do tomorrow?
Well, I mean, the story is really, really complicated.
The thing we've really got to try and get our head around
is the relationship of all those wars
because it's a very, very complicated story.
I suppose in the end of the day,
we should be sorting the wheat from the chaff.
Actually, when you come to think of it,
there are a lot of phrases in everyday use that come from milling.
Grist of the mill.
Yes, yes.
The site is a total millstone.
Stop now.
This is a serious archaeology program.
No more of these run-of-the-mill jokes.
Cheers, everybody.
To day three.
Beginning of day three here in Somerset.
And yesterday evening, everything seemed to be going swimmingly.
We've got our lovely mill, Buck Mill.
We knew what date it was, what it was for,
how it worked, all that kind of thing.
That was until the archaeologists started drinking that cider.
After three glasses, they began to have doubts.
After four glasses, they were wracked with doubt.
They no longer think that all that is all this.
But why don't they think so?
And if it isn't that, then what is it?
Vic, what's the problem?
I think the problem is we've got so many walls.
We don't know what phase is what at the moment.
So this isn't all part of one mill?
Oh, no, clearly not.
So is it fair to say that this isn't this?
Well, in a way.
But what they've done there is they've put a facade
on a whole mishmash of buildings that were there before
that have gradually developed
to make it look as if it's one new build.
So how are we going to tell the story of the mill
or the mills on this site?
We need to look at the junction and the change of direction
of every piece of wall across the site.
So that if that bit going across to where Phil is,
is contemporary, he's obviously happy about something there.
He's obviously sorted that, right.
Got another phase in here.
Another one.
So there's another phase.
I thought it was good news.
It's bad news, really, isn't it?
You've got a lot of work to do and not much time to do it.
We have, we have.
We've got a lot of junctions to look at all over the place.
Yesterday, we were beginning to get a clear picture
of the Benjafields,
who lived here from the 17th to late 18th century.
But the archaeology of the mill is giving our diggers a headache
to go with their hangovers
because the walls seem to suggest 40 different phases.
When Stephanie invited us to dig her mysterious mill,
we thought explaining its past would be easy.
Any news?
I wish it was.
I mean, first thing this morning,
everything went very, very well
and we established that, in fact,
we've got two phases of building up on the top there.
We've got the early phase,
which is that main block of wall over there,
and then this later wall here,
which has been tagged on,
probably when they put the metal wheel in.
Now, we think we can see that this stone
that belongs to this wall here
is actually later than this wall.
So that is not likely to be part of the original mill.
What it might be is a wall that was put in
when they put a narrower wheel in.
So the current theory is,
is this wall part of the original mill?
Was there a much wider wheel pit in here?
And that when they actually put in the narrower wheel,
they backfilled the cavity with a lot of rubbish,
which is why there's so much instability
and we've got all these cavities.
But...
But? There's always a but.
There is a but.
If we've got a wider wheel,
we should expect to have a wider hole up there
for the water to come in.
Absolutely.
And at the moment, we haven't got it.
So, it was going very well first thing,
now it's not going quite so well.
With the inner walls of this building
still a jumble of confusion,
Fay and Raksha are investigating the outer walls
in the hope they'll give us the bigger picture.
We're looking for the corner of this house,
so we're hoping it's going to be
about where Raksha's standing.
You might have to get rid of some of this, though.
Some of our vegetation's all this way.
Because we might have to go a little bit that way.
At the site of our possible early medieval mill,
Matt and his diggers have spent a day and a half
sifting through clay
but have yet to make a single find.
And if you thought life couldn't get
any more miserable for them,
it's started to rain.
The only person who seems unfazed
by the many phases of Buck Mill is Helen.
Yesterday's finds are telling her
there was once a flourishing family business here.
Well, we've got a will of the miller
who died in 1703, John Benjafield,
and he leaves a big estate.
It's worth something like £300
and it includes land as well.
Now, I don't think he should have been
making that money from the mill.
Did it come from the land?
Maybe.
This object that I'm just halfway through cleaning
really illustrates that
because it's a clothing clasp.
It's got very detailed, very well-cast decoration
and you can probably see in the sunlight
that it's got a little bit of silver coating on it.
So when new, it would have looked like silver.
This would have looked really smart.
And there's also a tantalising glimpse
of another much earlier miller.
We've got another clue here.
This dates to the first few decades of the 16th century
so it's nearly 200 years older than the 17th century items.
It's a purse hanger.
So it would have had a fabric purse
hung from this little bar here
and the loop would have been tied with strings to the belt.
So it would have had coins or something like that in there.
And so it's the kind of thing that you wouldn't have
unless you had a bit of money.
Very much a kind of middle-class item
and that was also found in the 18th century mill.
So one wonders if the people associated with the mill
were always a bit more middle-class than you might expect.
The scale of the millhouse that John Benjafield lived in
late in the 17th century
also points to our millers being surprisingly posh.
That is the corner coming through.
Perfect.
So we've got the corner of the house
and I actually think what I am
is the front wall of our house.
Yeah, if you actually look just here
it's perfectly aligned with that front doorstep.
And in front of you is our side wall of the house.
Yep.
And in there should be our nice floor.
There should be a nice flat surface, yeah.
Brilliant, perfect.
Revealing the corner of the millhouse
has given us a sizable chunk of solid archaeology.
It's just a shame the same can't be said
for our early medieval mill.
Well, you two have given Matt a great couple of days, haven't you?
He's happy in his hole.
What you got, Matt?
Well, we've put this section through the leak area here
and you can see this kind of brown silk fill there
and then we've got these clay bands,
the blue clay and the yellow clay bands.
But I mean, that's about it really.
I mean, I'm no mill expert, but I don't see much.
You may not be a mill expert,
but is there anything down there
that looks remotely, even vaguely, like a mill?
Like, what I'm prepared to say is
there was a water course coming through here.
There'd be no finds and there's no evidence of any structure
or anything like that.
We're stuffed, aren't we?
I don't know.
I've got to admit, there's always going to be a long shot this time.
Don't be like that.
This is always going to be a long shot.
We've only got, what, a metre and a half wide.
It could be under here.
It could be down there.
It's going to be a very ephemeral structure.
What do we do now?
I think we stop.
We haven't got time to chase it any further.
Somebody else might come back and look further,
but there's nothing more we can do.
Yeah, I might give you a hand.
Clearly, they're going to keep on saying there's a mill here
and with over 70 years experience between them,
who am I to argue with them?
While our early medieval mill is condemned to the clay,
at the cockpit of Buck Mill,
Tracy has had what can only be described as an archaeological epiphany.
Yeah, I had a real Agatha Christie moment earlier on.
Come on, give us your moment.
Well, we have the strange tale of the broken clasp,
the smashed teacup and the careless smoker.
Recount the story to me.
Well, we got down to the bottom of the cockpit yesterday.
Yeah.
And we've got a really well rammed in stone floor down there.
Underneath the floor, just at the point where it was being laid,
we found this.
It's mid 17th century and would have been some sort of dress fastening.
So somebody's been standing up here.
This is broken off and fallen down.
They haven't found it.
They've carried on laying the floor.
So that gives us a really nice date for the laying of the floor.
Then straight away when the floor has been laid
before anything's built up, no silting or anything like that,
we have a chappy.
He's smoking his pipe.
This is the careless smoker?
This is the careless smoker.
And he's smoking his pipe and he's dropped it and he's smashed it.
Why is he careless?
Well, you can't have a naked flame in the flour mill
because the flour will just combust and bang goes your milk.
So the only time he could have been smoking
was when they were building the walls.
Then unfortunately, the same poor chap,
he's had his cup of tea and he smashed his teacup.
And what sort of date is this?
The cup date is 1660 to about 1680.
So that ties in really nicely with the clasp
and gives us a good dating for the construction
of the first phase of this part of the mill.
So very possibly thanks to John Benjafield and his butterfingers,
we now know that the earlier phase of the mill
was built between 1660 and 1680.
But just how he became so wealthy remains a bit of a puzzle.
Because the mill was only average in size and power,
we don't know how he came to have such a big house.
Unless perhaps he had his fingers in other pies.
Although they've run out of time,
it seems Mick and Stuart haven't entirely given up
on their early medieval mill.
Let's say 1200 in round figures, yeah.
And that leat is another one like that one, like that.
It's a leat to bring water to.
Oh no.
No!
You said it.
A third mill.
Yeah, a third mill.
That's exactly what...
Which ought to be there by 1200.
And our two top experts have cooked up a theory
stretching back a thousand years
as to how this landscape could have supported three mills.
What that points to is a sequence of events
in that we've got one system coming down here on this side,
which is very low technology, low gradient to mix mill down here.
We've got one system coming down here,
leading to another mill just here.
These two are fairly inefficient, low technology.
It's replaced by buckmill up here,
implying a sequence of three mills.
It's a fantastic story.
And we're just going to have to leave these two mills vivid in the sand
because unfortunately we haven't got the time to dig them.
No, no, but I think, you know,
if we came back, we'd know exactly where to go now.
Yeah, sure.
Phil has finally solved the problem that's been giving him a headache.
How the water was brought to the mill wheel
during the 17th and 18th centuries,
when a much wider water wheel was in use.
It's been a real archaeologist's trench.
It's been really challenging.
It's been wonderful.
What was the challenge?
Well, what we really wanted to try and do
was try and establish whether or not
there had been a wide water wheel in here
before the narrow metal one.
Now, to put that metal wheel in,
you have to block off this wide opening.
And so what he really needed to do
was actually find the proof.
And the proof is in here.
We started at the top
and we began to realise
that this was actually part of this big blocking.
And originally we thought it came to here.
We thought this was going to be a major stone wall.
But the crucial bit of the jigsaw
was taking off all the limescale
that covered this part of the wall.
And you can see here,
actually now I've got rid of the limescale,
that there's a joint running up through here.
This is part of this major wall that runs down here.
All of this is blocking
that was put in when they put the metal wheel in.
So what does that tell us
about the history of the wheel in the wheel pit?
Well, it seems that we had a wide wheel
working off a lesser head of water.
And later on in the quest for more power,
more productivity in the mill,
they put in a bigger water wheel,
an overshot wheel.
And that way, by raising the head of water,
by embanking the pond
and getting a bit better head of water
coming into the wheel pit,
they could put in a narrower water wheel.
So it was more powerful
because the water was coming from higher?
Absolutely right.
With an overshot wheel,
you've got the best arrangement.
And because of our archaeologists' detective work,
we now have a pretty good idea
of what Buck Mill would have looked like
right back to the 17th century.
This earliest phase of mill
could have been built by John Benjefield
between 1660 and 1680,
at which point the mill
would have had a much wider water wheel.
In the 18th century,
another pair of millstones were added.
Around the 1830s,
the more primitive wooden wheel
would have been removed
and replaced by the cast iron overshot wheel,
which required fundamental changes
to the water supply and wheel pit.
Buck Mill had a leet
bringing water from the stream
over a mile up the valley.
So it would have been a remarkable feat of engineering
that supported not only
generation after generation of miller,
but the entire community around them.
And only this morning,
we thought we'd be leaving Stephanie
with a more confused picture of her mill's history
than when we arrived.
Pleased we came?
No, it's all been a terrible inconvenience.
Look at the mess.
Of course I'm pleased you came.
This has been a brilliant three days.
In fact, I'm really sad you're going.
What have we learned?
Oh, enormous amount.
I mean, not only about the building
that you asked us to come and look at,
which is all these phases of development
and reflects mill development generally,
but also the whole valley.
I know you don't like it,
but we think we've got two medieval mills
down there as well.
That's a real bonus, that is.
If ever you or your horses
stumble on a medieval mill
in one of your fields...
I'll let him know.
Yeah, because he's getting a bit desperate.