The most important lumps of dry mud in history

Archaeological
18 followers
Feb 1, 2026 #archaeology #history
Before writing there was what?? According to our best understanding of archaeology before writing came clay tokens. These simple lumps of dry mud played an incredibly important role in human development. They may be responsible for large numbers, writing, administration, board games and everyone's favourite, powerful bureaucracies.
#archaeology #history
There's no two ways around it. This is a video about small pieces of clay and some pebbles.
That's just what the video is about. No doubt the algorithm will love this.
But honestly, honestly, I have come to believe that these are the most important pieces
of dry mud in all of human history. I don't think that's an exaggeration. Let me show you something.
This is one of the earliest tablets, earliest piece of writing we have. It's about 5,000 years
old from Iraq, and it's written in a very early form of cuneiform. It seemingly belonged to a
person called Qushim, who might just be the earliest name ever recorded, which is crazy.
The tablet records a transaction of 135,000 liters of barley to be delivered over 37 months.
It's pretty crazy, pretty incredible. How incredible is it to say the name of someone
who lived over 5,000 years ago? I absolutely love that. Now, although this tablet seems basic to us,
it's already pretty advanced. There were so many symbols for different things, and like,
this was written by a literate society. Something must have come first, something must have been
earlier. Those little lumps of mud, those little lumps of clay is what archaeology believes were
earlier. Not only were they probably responsible for writing, but they might have invented other
things that we've come to love, like board games and powerful bureaucracies that govern every aspect
of our lives. You know, the things we love. Let's see how these little lumps of mud changed the
world, because they really did. A place called... now I'm going to struggle with the pronunciation.
For some reason, my mouth doesn't like making this sound. Is it Tepegaura?
Yes, Tepegaura. It's one that Penn excavated, so yeah, I want to talk about it because it's
been a focus of my research in this kind of transitional period that I was talking about.
That's Dr. Brad Hafford. He's an expert in ancient trade and Mesopotamia,
all cool things. He actually has his own archaeology YouTube channel, I'll put the link
down below. We've made a companion video to this one all about the first standardized measurements.
It just scratches the archaeology brain in just the right way. Do go check it out, there's a link
below. Gowra is this big mound of earth here in this olive field. It's about 25 kilometers north
of the modern city of Mosul in Iraq, of course. It was first excavated by the University of
Pennsylvania in the 1920s and 30s. Tepegaura means great mound, great hill, but this isn't
naturally formed. Tepes or tels are just the piled up remains of ancient mud brick towns.
Basically, humans would just build on top of the ruins of old houses, and over thousands of years,
these hills would just form as people lived on top of their ancestors. It's incredible, really.
I kind of want to say they're like human termite mounds, but that's probably not
accurate in any way, shape, or form. Whilst I had the opportunity to talk to Brad, who really
studies and excavates these sites, I had an absolutely burning question. Did people in
the past realize that they were just living on top of the remains of their ancestors?
Did they know that that's what their town was? Yeah, I think they had to have been conscious
of it because anytime they are, like you say, digging foundations for a new building,
they're cutting down into an earlier level, and they're going to find artifacts and parts of the
houses. In fact, they'll often clear off where that building had been and use that as a sort
of foundation to make their walls stronger. So sometimes you'll get a building built directly
on top of an older building, and there's new floor levels in there, and you can see
where the break is, and you can find out more about by digging through their floor,
finding the older building below. Saying that at Orr, I was excavating, and I found,
and sort of in the deep portion of this one building in the foundation of the corner,
I found seven skulls, and they were all placed intentionally with the orbits, the eye sockets
down into the dirt. I think it's because when they were building that building, they did run
into old burials, and they decided that this would keep the spirits from haunting them or
something. They went ahead and put the skulls in this corner.
Galrah is an important place in their sort of search for what came before writing,
in the study of these tokens, because it was occupied for a long time, and a crucial time
as well. Between roughly 6,500 BCE down to about 1,500 BCE. Although there were a couple of points
where the town seemingly was burnt down to the ground. It's hard to live in peace for 5,000
years. It's hard to do that. Proper writing emerged around 3,500 BCE, 3,200 BCE. So Galrah
existed, you know, for a few thousand years before the emergence of writing,
and a few thousand years after the emergence of writing. Just the perfect place to study
this sort of thing. Close to the Tigris River and the foothills of the Zagros Mountains,
Galrah was the perfect place for traders to exchange goods that are harder to find further
south in Mesopotamia. Things like wood, precious stones, metals. They had access to all of these
things through these mountain passes, and also close enough to the river to get them down south.
Galrah's location helped it in other ways too. Being further north in Mesopotamia, it received
enough rainfall that you can dry farm. Basically you can farm without having to dig irrigation
channels, irrigation canals. So perhaps it was an easier place for urban life to begin,
complex life to begin a little bit further north. All of these things, generation after generation,
were creating bigger and bigger towns, bigger and bigger cities, and more complex economies
that probably needed to keep track of goods. So one of the most important things for people,
I think, is to know how much food we're going to have. And you've settled down into agricultural
towns or whatever. I need to survive the winter when I can't grow. So we all pool our grain
together and we put it into a storage thing, you know, they're often these silos or whatever they
are, so that we can dole them out and we can all eat during the period when we can't grow.
But how do we know there's that much there? The answer to that question is probably these
tokens, or at least archaeology thinks it's these tokens. Thousands have been found across
Mesopotamia, some made of clay, some little pebbles, little stones. The earliest tokens
may be as old as 11,000 years old. At Galrah, they predate writing by several thousand years.
Yeah, these are stone tokens and from Galrah in different shapes. So spheres and then that
thing that looks like an egg, I've always said egg-shaped, but they might be related to the
conical tokens. Denise seems to think that it could be a cone with like a jar with grain
on the top of it, you know, when they're in clay, it could represent a unit of grain,
but we're not sure. Yeah, the most common forms are spheres, discs, cones, and cylinders.
It's believed these different shaped tokens could have represented different goods.
Cones perhaps representing grain, round discs maybe representing flocks of animals. They're
simple goods traded and tracked by these early cities. You can even occasionally find tokens
enclosed in clay envelopes which is very cool. No doubt the receipt of an extremely ancient
transaction. Brad had wondered also if perhaps some of these tokens were small
weights for measuring valuable things. I measured a bunch of them because I'm really
interested in weights and I wanted to know are these following a system of weight and they're
not. One thing I really wanted to ask Brad though is like how can we really be sure these were used
for accounting, right? Seems like they could be used for almost anything, especially gaming pieces.
As with everything in archaeology, when you're looking thousands upon thousands of years in the
past, it's difficult to say 100% for sure what some things were being used for, but we have a
context basically. As with everything it comes down to context, the first clue comes from
linguistics. So to calculate is to move pebbles on a board and figure things out. I had actually
had no idea calculus meant little stone in Latin. I actually had no idea. I love it when we get a
linguistic clue to something going on in the past. I need to do way more linguistics on this channel.
The second clue comes from archaeology. Check this out. This is layer 11, a gaura. You can see right
into the center here this huge round building, really thick walls. Probably this was defensive
in nature. It seems like the layer before this had been burnt to the ground and the city had
maybe been abandoned for a few hundred years. So perhaps upon returning this huge defensive
structure was built. But there's a lot of interesting artifacts in that what we call the
round house and it does have very thick walls, but there's also good indication of grain storage
there. So there's like charred grains and there are many of these tokens in some of those rooms.
It certainly could be true that some of these tokens were maybe a gaming piece left behind by
a board administrator. Could be true. Could certainly be true. And maybe some were used for
other things, right? But it is quite likely that in the giant grain storage building some of these
tokens were used for the administration of grain for the administration of the city. That has to
be a big possibility. Huge possibility. Although these clay artifacts are so humble, I think they
do genuinely represent a huge moment and maybe even a revolution in human thought. The ever-increasing
size of these towns had created a challenge, a problem that prior to this time period we had
never dealt with. One thing I find really fascinating about these tokens is not just that
like our people had developed this new method to count, but like the numbers literally themselves
had to be invented. Thousands of years before this time in the Paleolithic, hunter-gatherers didn't
need to know they were like 135,000 deer or whatever. They would just have a few numbers,
however many that they needed practically, and then they would just have a term for like many
or lots. Almost certainly they didn't have like such advanced mathematics. I really wonder how
these like conversations went down, you know. How were these people like literally creating these
numbers, these terms, out of out of nothing? No one had ever done it before. It's so interesting. So so
interesting. These tokens really are like the archaeological trace of a real huge cognitive
revolution, societal revolution. Do you get what I'm trying to say? These tokens, these aren't just
like abstract numbers. These could allow people to really concretely count things, really know how
much stuff they had, project those numbers into the future, plan ahead, you know, know how much to
plant and harvest and keep for bad times and all these things. This is like, it's a big moment,
it's a big deal. I don't know. It's a real revolution. Why do you think these tokens end up
in graves? Well, with the evidence at Gowra at least, they appear in the level 11. We start to
get different graves. This is why 11 and 10 are important to me, I think. Where they're built up,
they're more, they've got chambers in a way, right, of mud brick and then of stone in level 10.
Levels 10 and 11 correspond to roughly 4,000 to 3,800 years BCE, about 500 years before the
writing. And it's not just that graves start to get more built up, for the first time we see
really obvious luxury goods too. You know, beautiful golden artifacts, really delicate
pieces of jewelry, clearly a sign of some sort of class distinction emerging, really obviously,
a ruling class emerging. One grave in particular kind of stands out, it's grave 181. You can see
it here on the map of Gowra, level 10. It's got tokens, it's got jewelry, all the signs of wealth,
a company, presumably a wealthy administrator. But interestingly, it's a child's grave.
So what does this mean? You know, okay, first of all, they said, ah, of course,
they're gaming pieces. Games are for children. But I don't think it's quite that simple,
because there is also this differentiation in wealth or social status. Normally that happens
when you have shown yourself to be important, right? You probably can't do that when you're
really young, you need time to whatever, do something great that they're rewarded. But
this implies inherited status. I was born into a family that already had status. So I've got
luxury items. And maybe that's because I use the tokens or I was being trained, I was going to
become one of these people that uses tokens. So they put the tokens as a symbol of profession
or intended profession. The reason that I'm wealthy is that I know how to use these things.
And I think that's the counting element and the ability to administer.
It's not hard to imagine the people keeping track of grain at Gaura becoming some sort of elite,
even if they didn't have more grain than anyone else, which they probably did if they're the
ones keeping track, let's be honest. But even if they didn't, people are asking you how much grain
there is. You're the one deciding how it gets distributed. You're in the position of power.
Maybe the first kings of these early urban societies were not like the strongest warrior,
the most most ruthless leader, you know, some Genghis Khan figure. Maybe they were simply the
accountants, the bureaucrats. And it was knowledge of these clay balls and the and the mathematics
behind them probably put them in that position. They were so important that these things were
included in people's graves. With this power with these positions, no doubt came a desire to
share your name, share your title, very important things like that.
Check these out. I absolutely love these artifacts. They're little clay tokens,
only tiny things, just like three centimeters across, but with little pictures on them. It's
like a little sitting deer here. Very cool. This one is 6,000 years old from Gaura. Really
interesting geometric pattern. Some of these tokens are very simple, but some are really
extravagant. I really love this one. This this sitting woman here, press it into clay and it
this this interesting signature, this series of dots. I have no idea what it means, but this is
another beautiful example of fish. But on one side is two deer and and some kind of rock ball dot.
I don't know. I don't know. They're beautiful, though.
So when we get this heavy use of tokens, we also find a lot of clay ceilings. You find some seals,
but a lot more of the impressions in the clay that they were pushed into. It's kind of like a
lock. It's an indication of private property. You know, we talked about whatever public storage of
grain and maybe we all get it, but we start to protect some of that by sealing them off.
And I put a mark on it so that if you break the clay and try to steal grain or get into the room
because it's also on a door, you know, there are door ceilings. Then I know you've broken in. It
doesn't stop you from breaking in, but you can't cheat by putting new clay on there and putting
a seal unless you've got that specific image. A lot of the times we don't necessarily find
the stamp, but we find the clay, the clay seal. This one here, this symbol on this piece of clay,
it's signified someone's name or family or title, some identifier that has been lost to time.
These are signatures. It's an early form of authentication, two factor authentication,
6,000 year old two factor authentication. And obviously another step on the road to writing.
Obviously, if you're allocating resources based on these tokens to different people,
it's a perfectly logical step to start writing a name on some of them, to start putting someone's
name or identifier on these tokens. And eventually they become cylinder seals where you roll it
across the clay. These though are the earlier ones, stamp seals. And that was in a grave that
also had tokens. So again, it implies control. I have my seal and I can indicate that I have
protected this material. And then I'm the only one who might be able to, or my office,
whatever this is, to be able to open it up and dole it out to who might need it.
I'm not saying the entire concept of private property was created by these tokens, but
I bet it facilitated it. I bet it expanded it. One idea is these signs may have evolved out of
amulets, identifying amulets. Many of them are amulets. You can see this one here, a cow,
little hole at the top or bottom on the back, these intricate dots. There's another really
interesting amulet found at Gowra with a checkerboard pattern of some kind on it.
Was that connected to accounting? Who knows? Maybe someday someone was wearing their badge
for whatever reason, needed a token with their symbol on it. And why not use the symbols on my
badge? Why can't this be my identifier on clay too? And now your private property isn't just like
what you physically have available to you, you know, in your house or whatever, but your private
property is anything with your name on it. It's kind of groundbreaking, guys. It's kind of
groundbreaking. These little pieces of clay are kind of groundbreaking, man. Everyone in society
would have said, hey, this is Fish Deer's Grain. Okay, don't mess with Fish Deer's Beer. I wonder
their name actually was. Now, one thing I am worried that I'm doing here is presenting a
really simple story, a very straightforward story about the development of writing and
the importance of these tokens. There are lots of challenges still. One of the things I learned
from Brad is that we don't actually have any of the boards that these tokens move across,
it seems. I don't think we have any of them. And presumably that's because they just rotted away.
When we finally get writing, we do have the word for abacus, really. And it's got the
determinative gish before it. Gish means wood. So they were usually made of wood. Sometimes it's
got tug, which means cloth. So you might make it on a piece of cloth, and neither of those are
going to preserve. We do have one clue about what they might have looked like, though. Cuneiform,
at least in its early stages, was a picture of the thing it was describing. So in this tablet
here, for example, you have a head, meaning a person, a bowl, meaning a ration. These get
further and further abstracted as time gets on, but at least a lot of cuneiform symbols
originally were just a picture of the thing they're trying to describe. So what was the
symbol for administrator? Well, one more very interesting thing is that there's a sign for an
early temple administrator. It's a priestly title, Sangha. And the symbol for Sangha is partly this
abacus symbol. You can see it here in this really cool tablet. This little grid here in the bottom
represents the word Sangha, administrator. It kind of looks like a grid you would move tokens
across. One idea is that the little sort of box to the side is maybe where they kept the tokens
before they were moving across. You can kind of see something similar on that Kashim tablet I
showed at the beginning. We don't know what this symbol means, but it looks like a grid,
an abacus. How big is this? 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7 by 1, 2, 3, 4. Then one big box, 4 times 7. What's that?
28 grid. Does that mean anything? Is that significant to anyone who knows anything about
maths? I don't know. This symbol for Sangha really reminds me of something else though,
and I'm sure people have been screaming about it in the comments already. This right here is a 4,500
year old board game called the Royal Game of Ur. It was found by Sir Leonard Woolley in Ur, of course.
It's very fun to say Ur. It's a beautiful wooden board, you know, inlaid with shells and precious
stones. Beautiful thing, beautiful artifacts. Can't believe it survived four and a half thousand years
in the ground. We actually know roughly how this game was played because the the rule book was
preserved in a clay tablet, which is absolutely remarkable find. Irving Finkel did a great video
on this with Tom Scott yonks ago. Do check it out. You can actually see how it's played. When I look
at this board and I look at the symbol for Sangha, I can't help but think that this is the kind of
thing that maybe those ancient accountant kings were moving their tokens across when they had
to calculate the amount of grain or silver or copper to give someone. It really looks like
that symbol for Sangha. And chatting to Brad, I learned that it could be that this ancient
Mesopotamian accounting inspired the entire idea of board games. Irving Finkel has done a lot with
games and he even says that he finds some of these game boards, their grids drawn on bricks,
for instance, and he finds them in association with what looks to be schooling, teaching, you
know, and the tablets that talk about them. He thinks that maybe they were exercises to help you
conceptualize maybe numbers and thinking of things. So, they may have taught games in school
in a way because they may have developed out of counting. If an abacus is just a grid and you move
these calculi, the little tokens, stone, whatever, along them, then you might start to think,
oh, well, that could also be a game.
I can totally see that. You know, two kids learning their maths at school. For whatever
reason, one kid's token jumps another kid's. They give them a bleh. And now all of a sudden,
it's a game. By 3500 BCE, right on the cusp of writing being developed, these urban centers
were just ever increasing in scale and sophistication. More goods are being traded
and it seems like these symbol tokens are no longer enough to keep track of the
economy. More and more tokens are needed in ever more complex shapes and their relationship to
writing becomes more obvious, I think. So, 3500 or so, we start to get some of these tokens,
and actually some of these are earlier. This is one of the problems. It doesn't just happen all
of a sudden. But some of these cones or whatever will start to have little incisions on them
or decorated in a different way. And do they mean something new? So, those croissants actually
looks a lot like Q3 in the early cuneiform, which is, well, it's silver, basically, of the metal.
And yeah, shining metal is Qbabar, and that's silver. So, maybe it does, but there are a few
that look a lot like the earliest cuneiform signs, but most of them don't. It might seem like a
stretch to go from the croissant-shaped token to the cuneiform symbol for silver. But I mean,
why not? It's so logical. First, you have the token, then tokens for specific goods,
and tokens for specific people. But what happens if one day you forget your token and you still
need to send a message, deliver a message, do some accounting? Why not just stamp the shape of the
token into a piece of clay? It seems so logical. This might have been the case with numbers, too.
If you look at that Kashim tablet one more time, the impressions of the numbers kind of looks like
the shape of the token. Impress it on its side to mean one number, and then just point it straight
down into the clay to represent another number. You can see it in other tablets, too. This is
another one found in Susa, which I believe is in Iran. It's so obvious. They're sort of turning
the tokens on one side for one number and jabbing them straight down into the clay to represent
another number. It's pretty incredible. Before chatting to Brad, I had no idea that we had all
this information about what came before writing. It really blows my mind. It's like you can see
the cogs of generations of people turning as they're slowly creating this library of symbols
and numbers and shapes that everyone understands. It's mind-blowing, man. To me. To me. Anyway, it's
mind-blowing. I don't know. What am I trying to say? It's interesting how much the human brain
can extrapolate from a couple of disks moving around. That really says a lot about our ability
to imagine and conceive of complex topics. Maybe all of complex urban life had its roots in just
some clay tokens being shuffled across a grid. I might be exaggerating there, but it doesn't
feel like a massive exaggeration. There is something there that has stretched across
all these millennia, and it's one of the things I like about archaeology is connecting with and
knowing that people in the past were very clever and trying to figure out what they were doing.
I want to believe that people started writing because they had such powerful stories and poems
that they had to relate, you know? But it's much more mundane, really. They just had to
write receipts, I guess, you know?
