Workers in eighth century India climbed to the top of a cliff and carved a temple downward out of one piece of volcanic rock, cutting away around two hundred thousand tonnes by hand with nothing but iron chisels. In this one I go through how the Kailasa temple at Ellora was actually made, because there is not a single block or seam anywhere in it, the bridges, the elephants, the tower and the shrine are all the same stone. The part that gets me is that there was no undo button, so one slip took an elephant's trunk off forever, and they still fixed the whole design before the first trench was cut. I will be honest, the detail that gave me chills is on copper plates found three hundred kilometres away, where the architect himself said the work could never be achieved again and asked out loud how he had done it. Nobody has ever found where those two hundred thousand tonnes of rock went either, which for me is still the strangest unanswered question about the place. #archaeology#history
AI Generated·May contain errors
In the 8th century,
a team of workers climbed onto a cliff in western India.
They did not bring stone.
They brought hammers and chisels, and they began to cut downward.
This temple was never built. Not one block was ever laid.
It was carved from the roof down
out of a single piece of volcanic rock.
About 200,000 tons were cut away by hand.
What was left is a tower as tall as a 10-story building,
standing in a courtyard sunk 30 meters
into the cliff. If you pictured great temples rising stone by stone,
this one breaks the rule.
But the strangest clue is not at the temple at all.
It sits on sheets of copper found
hundreds of kilometers away.
They record the words of the man who carved this place,
and he could not explain how he had done it. Nobody fully can.
To understand how strange that is,
you first have to see where it happened.
Go back around 66 million years.
Long before any human walked the earth, the crust beneath
western India split open.
Lava poured out across the land. Not from one volcano,
but from great cracks in the ground.
Flood after flood over hundreds of thousands of years.
Each flow cooled into a layer of dark, hard rock called basalt.
Layer was stacked on layer
until whole landscapes were buried.
Geologists call it the Deccan Traps. It is one of the largest
volcanic outpourings in the history of the planet,
and it left behind exactly the kind
of rock a carver would dream of. Time and rain did the rest.
Rivers wore the plateau down into ridges and hills,
and on the western face of one of those ridges,
about 30 kilometers from the city long known as Aurangabad,
the basalt was left standing as a long, steep cliff.
Local people call the place Verul. In
old inscriptions, it appears as Ellapura.
Today, the world knows it as Ellora.
Walk along the foot of that cliff and you pass something remarkable.
Openings. Dozens of them.
Doorways and halls and pillared rooms cut straight into the rock,
strung out for more than a kilometre and a half.
Archaeologists number the main ones from 1 to 34,
and they were not made by one faith.
Caves 1 to 12 are Buddhist.
Monasteries and prayer halls where monks lived, slept, and worshipped.
Caves 13 to 29 are Hindu. Caves 30 to 34 are Jain.
Three religions carving into the same cliff across several centuries,
sometimes within sight of each other. Notice what that tells you.
This cliff was not chosen once by one king.
It was chosen again and again by different
communities over hundreds of years.
The rock was good. The skills were already here.
People knew how to turn a mountain
into a room long before the temple in this story was ever
imagined. And right in the middle of the row stands
the one everyone comes to see. Cave 16,
the Kailasa temple. Now before we walk inside,
it is worth clearing something out of the way,
because there is a story about this place you may have heard.
It goes like this.
For centuries, the caves lay forgotten, swallowed by jungle.
Then, in 1819, a British officer out hunting tigers stumbled
on them by accident and scratched
his name and the date into a pillar. It is a good story.
The officer was real. The tiger hunt was
real. The graffiti is still there today.
But it did not happen here. Hold on to that. It comes
It comes back at the very end,
because Ellora was never lost, not for a single century.
The record runs almost unbroken from the time the chisels stopped.
In the 10th century,
an Arab geographer named al-Masudi wrote about the caves.
He was writing less than two centuries after the temple was carved.
To him, it was already a wonder worth reporting to the wider world.
In 1352, a sultan of the Bahmani dynasty, Hasan Gangu, came to visit.
The approach roads were repaired for him,
and he is said to have stayed at the caves for a week.
In the 1660s, a French traveler named Jean de Thévenot walked through
and wrote down what he
saw. An Italian adventurer named Niccolao Manucci came too.
Marathi poets and saints mentioned the
caves in their writings.
Later, the local rulers, the Holkars, even began charging visitors an
An entrance fee.
Think about that.
People were paying to get in.
You do not charge admission to a place nobody can find,
so the temple was never hidden. Kings,
travelers, pilgrims,
and soldiers stood in its courtyard for more than a thousand years.
They saw much of what you would see today,
and almost every one of them was left asking
the same thing. How was this possible?
Because the more closely you look at cave 16,
the less it looks like a cave at all.
Every other opening in the cliff goes in.
Halls carved backward into the rock,
with a roof of living stone above your head.
Kailasa does not go in. It goes down.
There is no roof above you. There is open sky.
And standing beneath that sky,
in the middle of a pit cut into the hillside,
is a complete temple.
Tower, halls, bridges, and statues, freestanding on every side.
Most monuments ask how people lifted the stone up.
This one asks something stranger. How did they take the mountain away?
To see it clearly you have to walk in through the front.
From the road the first thing you
meet is a wall of rock with a gateway cut into it.
It is low, just two stories. Carved figures
stand guard on either side.
It feels like the entrance to a modest shrine. That is deliberate.
Step through the gateway
and the ground seems to open in front of you. You are standing in
Standing in a courtyard sunk into the hillside.
It runs about 82 meters long and 46 meters wide,
roughly the size of a football pitch.
On three sides, the cliff rises straight up around you,
about 30 meters high.
Picture a 10-story building. Now picture it made of solid rock,
wrapped around you on every side but one.
Cut into those cliff walls are long galleries,
rows of pillars stacked three stories high
with carved panels running behind them in the shade.
And in the middle of all that space,
rising out of the floor, is the temple itself.
It does not look carved. It looks built.
A great tower climbs in layers toward the sky,
its top about 32.5 meters above the courtyard floor.
Below the tower sits a pillared hall.
In front of the hall stands a smaller pavilion.
In front of that, the gateway you just came through.
The people who made this called it after a mountain, Kailasa.
In Hindu belief, it is the Himalayan peak where the god Shiva dwells.
The temple was designed as that mountain,
brought down to earth and set in the middle of a pit.
Now walk the courtyard slowly,
because every few steps something stops you.
The small pavilion in front of the main hall holds a statue of Nandi,
his sacred bull who,
in Hindu tradition, carries Shiva.
He kneels facing the shrine, as if waiting.
look up and you will see
the pieces joined together. stone bridges cross the air between the
buildings. a bridge from the gateway to the pavilion,
another from the pavilion to the hall.
walkways hanging above your head. on either side
of the pavilion stand two tall stone pillars,
square and carved from top to bottom. victory pillars. banners
of the king who paid for all this.
Beside them stand elephants, life-sized,
one on each side of the court, trunks raised,
though time and damage have taken parts of them.
Then look at the base of the main temple.
All the way around it runs a frieze of elephants and lions,
standing shoulder to shoulder,
facing outward. From the courtyard floor, the effect is uncanny.
The whole temple seems to rest on their backs,
as if the animals are carrying the mountain.
Walk around the side of the temple
and you find the scene that may have given the temple its name.
A carved panel of Ravana,
the many-armed demon king from the great Indian epics.
In the story, he is trapped beneath Mount Kailasa
and tries to heave it up.
The stone shows him straining, his arms braced.
Above him, the mountain trembles.
Many art historians rank it among the finest carvings in India.
Climb the stone steps into the main hall
and the light suddenly drops away.
Sixteen great pillars hold up the ceiling.
Beyond them, in a small dark chamber,
sits the inner shrine.
And that is the moment most visitors finally notice it.
Run your eyes along the walls. Look where the pillars meet the floor.
Look where the bridges meet the buildings.
You are searching for the joins,
the seams, the lines of mortar between the blocks. There are none.
There are no blocks. The bridges, the pillars,
the elephants, the lions, the tower, the hall, the bull,
the shrine, every one of them is part of the same piece of rock.
None of it was carried here. None
of it was put together.
Before the carvers arrived, all of it was the inside of a hill.
People often compare this place to Petra in Jordan,
the city with tombs carved into its cliffs.
But at Petra, the masons carved a front,
a beautiful face in the rock with rooms cut in behind.
Here, they carved the whole building,
front and back, inside and outside, roof and floor.
And somewhere in this story, there are those sheets of copper.
The ones where a voice from the past admits he could not explain it.
We are getting closer.
Because first, there is a problem every engineer
who stands here sees at once.
How do you carve a building that has
to be finished before you have started it?
Think about how a normal temple goes up.
You lay a foundation, you raise the walls,
you add the roof, and if a block cracks or a wall leans,
you pull it out and try again.
Kailasa works the other way around.
Everything is already here. The tower,
the hall, the bridges, the elephants,
they are all locked inside the hill.
The job is not to add.
The job is to take away everything that is not the temple.
So where do you begin? You begin at the top.
Stand on the hillside above Ellora today
and you can still read what happened.
The ground behind the temple is the original surface of the hill.
That is where the work
started. Standing on bare rock with open sky above them,
the workers marked out a huge rectangle.
Then they cut three deep trenches, one along the back,
one down each side, straight down into the basalt, deeper and deeper,
until they had sliced a giant block away from the rest of the cliff.
The front of the hill already sloped away toward the valley,
so it could be opened up as the work went on.
That block was the raw material, a mountain inside a mountain.
Somewhere inside it was a temple
and only the planners knew exactly where.
And here is the clever part.
Because they worked from the top down, the first thing they reached
was the top of the temple, the peak of the tower.
They carved that first, finished it,
and moved down. Then the upper story,
then the roof of the hall, then the floors below.
Picture what that means. No scaffolding, nothing to lift.
Every carver stood on solid
rock while he worked,
and the finished temple slowly grew downward beneath his feet.
Gravity was on their side. Every piece of waste rock only had to fall.
Now for the tools. No explosives, no machines.
Iron chisels, heavy hammers,
picks. That is all anyone has ever found evidence for.
And you can still see their
marks today. Thousands of small grooves running across
the walls of the trenches.
The rock helped them a little.
This basalt weathers in layers. The outer skin is softer and
peels away more easily. The fresh rock underneath is much harder.
So the crews could hack through
the rough outside quickly,
then slow right down as they reached the stone that would become the
finished surface. Historians believe two kinds
of workers move together through the hill.
Quarrymen cutting away the bulk
and behind them sculptors following close carving each elephant
and pillar as it emerged from the rock.
They had to stay in step. Once a level was cleared
and the quarrymen moved lower nobody could easily climb back up
to fix a mistake. And
that is the heart of it.
In a normal building a mistake costs you a block.
Here a mistake costs you forever.
Take off an elephant's trunk by accident and it is gone.
Cut a pillar too thin and it stays too thin.
There is no glue that can put a mountain back.
So how much did they take away?
The figure you hear most often is about 3 million cubic feet,
roughly 200,000 tons of rock.
That is more than half the weight of the Empire State Building,
chipped away by hand and carried out of a pit.
Now for honesty. Nobody weighed it. That number
number is an estimate,
worked out from the size of the courtyard and the temple.
Different researchers, measuring in different ways,
have come up with very different answers.
Some put it far lower than that.
Some put it twice as high. But whatever the true figure,
it was a staggering amount of stone.
And the moment you accept that, four questions arrive
one after another. They are the questions archaeologists
are still arguing about today.
Question 1. How did they plan it?
How do you design something this complex when every cut is final?
Question two, where did all that rock go?
Question three, how long did it take? Question four,
who actually began it? Keep those four questions in mind.
Every one of them is about to be tested,
and one of them leads straight to those sheets
of copper, the ones with a man's
words of astonishment still written
on them more than 12 centuries later.
But before we get there it is worth dealing with something else.
Because whenever a place raises
questions this big and science cannot answer them fast enough,
other answers rush in to fill the gap.
Some of them say humans could never have done this at all.
Type the name of this temple into
the internet and you will not have to scroll far before you meet them.
The claim goes like this.
No people in the 8th century could have carved 200,000 tons
of basalt by hand.
So, someone else must have done it.
Some say visitors from another world.
Some say a lost, advanced civilization
with machines we have never found.
Some go further and say the rock was not cut at all,
but melted, sliced by some ancient beam of energy.
Others say the real secret is underground.
Beneath the temple, they claim, runs a hidden
network of tunnels and chambers,
sealed passages that once held the machines that did the work.
And a third group points to the sky.
The temple, they say, was aligned to stars or planets,
built to gather some kind of cosmic power.
It makes a thrilling story. So let us test it,
the way an archaeologist would, by looking at the stone.
Start with the melting.
Rock that has been melted does not look like this.
It turns glassy. It bubbles and slumps.
The walls at Kailasa show nothing of the kind.
What they show instead are tool marks.
Thousands of them. The steady bite of chisels and picks,
still visible on the trench walls
and in the corners where nobody bothered to smooth them.
And along the same cliff, several caves were simply abandoned,
half done. Rough walls. Pillars
blocked out but never shaped.
That is what a human workshop leaves behind. A machine from
another world does not run out of money or patience and down tools.
Now the tunnels.
There are rooms at Kailasa that visitors do not always find.
Galleries cut deep into the cliff
walls, a whole upper shrine reached by stairs,
side shrines cut behind pillars, but they are all
open. They have been measured, drawn,
and studied for more than two centuries.
No survey has ever confirmed a hidden network
of tunnels beneath the courtyard,
and the solid volcanic rock of this hill makes
a vast secret warren very hard to believe.
Then the stars. Most of the caves at Ellora face west.
So does Kailasa. That is not a message from
the heavens. It is simply the direction the cliff faces.
To carve a temple out of a hillside,
you face it the way the hillside opens.
Here is the bigger problem for all these theories.
The carvers of Kailasa did not appear out of nowhere.
Walk a few minutes along the same cliff
and you reach the Buddhist caves. Many of them are older than Kailasa.
Great halls cut back into the rock, with pillars and carved ceilings.
Generations of carvers had been learning
this basalt long before the temple was begun.
Look further across India, and the trail goes back much further still.
At Mamallapuram on the southeast coast, in the 7th century,
carvers had already cut small temples out of single outcrops,
top to bottom, freestanding. A century before Kailasa.
The same idea, just smaller.
So the skill was here. The tools were here.
The rock was here. What Kailasa shows is not a leap
from nothing. It is the moment a long tradition reached its peak.
None of it needs help from
beyond. There is one more story told about this temple,
and it is worth clearing up too.
You will often read that in 1682,
the Mughal emperor Aurangzeb ordered Kailasa destroyed.
that a thousand workers hammered at it for three years,
managed only to break a few statues, and gave up.
It is repeated on websites, in tour guides,
and in videos everywhere, but historians have struggled
to trace that exact account,
with its thousand men and three years, back to any record written
at the time. Some sculptures at Ellora certainly are damaged,
faces broken, arms missing,
But damage here built up over many centuries,
from many causes, including weather, water,
and simple time. Pinning every scar to one story
is not something the evidence allows.
What the legend does capture is true in a different way.
This rock is extraordinarily hard.
Carving it took an enormous effort, and so would undoing it.
So, set the aliens aside.
Set the beams of light and the secret machines aside.
what remains is ordinary people with iron
and patience and a plan achieving something very
few have ever matched that is not a smaller mystery it
is a far bigger one because the real
questions are still waiting
and the first of them is the most frightening one for any builder how
do you plan something you can never correct question one
the plan start with what is missing
No drawings of Kailasa survive.
No plans, no notes, no list of measurements scratched onto a wall.
The temple has no inscription telling us who designed it or how.
Whatever guided those first
trenches, it has vanished.
So how do you carve a building with no undo button? The best clue
is not at Ellora at all. It stands hundreds
of kilometers to the south in the village of Patadakal.
In the early 700s,
that region was ruled by a dynasty called the Chalukyas.
Around the year 745, a Chalukya queen built
a temple there to celebrate her husband's victory
over a rival southern kingdom, the Pallavas.
It is called the Virupaksha temple. And the Pallavas
themselves had built a great temple at their capital,
Kanchi, which the Virupaksha seems
to have been modeled on. Now watch what happens next.
Within about a decade, the Chalukyas were
were overthrown.
The new power in the region was the family
that ruled from the hills around Ellora,
the Rashtrakutas.
Put the Virupaksha temple beside Kailasa and the likeness is striking.
The layout matches, the tower rises in the same stepped style,
the hall, the porch, the pavilion
for the sacred bull all sit in the same order.
Kailasa is far bigger but it is clearly the same design
The Indian archaeologist Madhukar Dhavalikar spent years studying
this temple. His argument goes
like this. After defeating the Chalukyas,
the Rashtrakuta king saw the Virupaksha temple
standing in his newly won territory.
He was impressed, and he did what conquering rulers
often did. He brought its sculptors and architects north,
including craftsmen trained in the Pallava
tradition, and set them to work on his own cliff.
Think about what that would mean.
The planners of Kailasa would not have
been designing from nothing. They would have had
a finished temple to study.
Real proportions, real dimensions, a building they could walk around,
measure, and copy. The hardest part of the plan already existed.
It simply had to be scaled up
and turned inside out. And Dhavalikar noticed something else.
When he looked at the whole
complex, no major part of the main temple seemed to be an afterthought.
The parts fit together too well.
The bridges meet exactly where they should.
In his view, the whole design
was fixed before the first trench was cut.
That still leaves a staggering challenge.
Copying a temple you can see is one thing.
Finding that same temple inside a solid block of rock is another.
But the mystery is no longer a miracle.
It is a team of masters with a model and a method.
Question one was cracking.
Question two is even harder. Where did the rock go?
Remember the number. Around 200,000 tons.
Every scrap of it had to leave the pit.
And here's the strange part. Walk around Ellora today and you
do not find it. There is no great mountain
of waste stone beside the temple, no hill of chippings,
no obvious dump. Researchers
who have studied the site openly admit the puzzle remains.
Where did all those tons of stone go?
There are some sensible ideas.
Remember that the front of the hill sloped down toward the valley.
Scholars suggest that the work crews broke the rock into boulders
and simply rolled them down the hillside out of the way.
Over the centuries, rain, rivers,
and floods could have carried the smaller pieces far off.
Others point out that good cut stone is valuable.
1200 years is a very long time.
Some of it may have been carted away and used in walls,
roads, and buildings across the region.
A temple that gives away its own rubble,
one cartload at a time, would leave no heap behind.
Now for honesty. Nobody has proved any of this.
No study has yet traced where the stone of Kailasa ended up.
Some may have been rolled,
some may have been reused,
some may lie buried under soil in the valley below.
Until someone goes looking,
it remains one of the most basic questions about the site,
and one of the hardest to answer.
Question two stays open, and that is frustrating,
because somewhere in all this, one person knew exactly how it was done.
The man in charge of the cutting,
the one who held the plan in his head for years.
He did leave us something, not a drawing,
not a diagram, just one line recorded on copper.
But before we read it, there is another question
that keeps archaeologists up at night.
How long did all this take?
Question 3. How long did it take?
There is an old answer to that, and it is astonishing.
One week.
It comes from a legend written down
in a Marathi text called Bhikkata Kalpataru,
composed by a writer named Krishna Yajnavalki around the year 1500,
roughly seven centuries after the carving.
In the story, a local king falls gravely ill. His queen,
Manikavati, prays to Shiva for his recovery.
She makes a vow. If her husband lives,
she will build a temple,
and she will not eat until she can see its tower with her own eyes.
The king recovers. Now the queen is starving,
and the royal architects bring bad news. A proper
temple with a tower will take many months.
She will never last that long. Then one master craftsman
steps forward. His name is Gokasa.
He promises the queen will see her tower within a week, and he
does something none of the others thought of.
He climbs the rock and starts carving from the top.
Within seven days, the tower stands clear of the stone.
The queen ends her fast. The temple is
named after her. It is a beautiful story.
It is not history. But notice what it remembers. The
legend gets the method exactly right. Start at the top.
Finish the tower first. Seven centuries later,
people still knew how this temple had been made,
even if they had forgotten how long it took.
So what do the archaeologists say?
Madhukar Dhavalikar tried to work it out with simple
arithmetic. He assumed one worker could cut
away about four cubic feet of rock a day.
With 250 laborers,
and with the plan already copied from the Virupaksha temple,
he calculated the main excavation could have
been finished in about five and a half years.
Other researchers think that is far too fast.
The finer carving, the sculpture,
The structure and the finishing would have taken much longer.
Many estimates stretch to around two decades,
and some parts of the complex were clearly added
long after the main temple was done.
Five years, twenty years, a hundred years for everything?
Question three is still being argued. Which brings us to question four.
Who began it? You would expect a king to sign his masterpiece.
Kailasa has no dedicatory inscription.
Not one line on the temple says who ordered it.
For an answer, we have to leave Ellora entirely
and travel more than 300 kilometers northwest
to the city of Baroda in Gujarat.
There, in the early 1800s, a set of copper plates was
dug out of the ground. Local scholars could not read them.
In 1839, they were finally deciphered
and presented to the Asiatic Society.
They turned out to be a royal land grant issued in the year
year 812 by a ruler named Karkarajah.
Like many grants, it opens by praising his ancestors.
One of them is a king called Krishna,
the first Rashtrakuta king of that name.
The plates say that on the hill at Ellapura,
Krishna made a wondrous temple.
So wondrous that gods flying overhead stopped and stared,
wondering whether it had made itself. Then comes the line.
The architect who built it, the plates say, was himself astonished.
He said such a work could never be achieved again,
however hard anyone tried, and he asked,
aloud, how it had been achieved by him. Read that slowly.
The man who carved it did not understand
how he had done it.
In the 1880s, the Indian scholar Ramakrishna Bandarkar argued this
praise could only describe one place, the Kailasa temple.
Most scholars since have agreed.
So, the temple was probably the work of Krishna the first,
who ruled from around 756 to 773.
Now for honesty.
The plates were found far away,
they are not physically connected to the cave, they never
use the name Kailasa,
and later grants from Krishna's own successors do not mention the
temple at all.
The art historian Hermann Goetz went further.
Next door to Kailasa is another cave
with an inscription of Krishna's nephew and predecessor
Danti Durga.
Götz argued the work actually began under Danti Durga
and that his role was quietly written out.
Others argue the famous Ravana panel was added generations later.
So question four is partly answered.
A king of this family. Perhaps more than one.
But the most human answer is the architect's.
Twelve centuries ago he stood in this courtyard
and could not explain his own work.
We are still standing there with him.
And there is one more thing he would have seen that we cannot.
What he saw was white.
The whole temple was once coated in lime plaster and painted,
so the carved mountain would shine like
the snowy peak it was named after.
Traces still cling to the upper tower.
So here is where the four questions stand.
The plan has a likely answer.
The builder has a probable name.
How long it took is still argued.
And the missing rock has never been found.
Now remember that story about the British officer in 1819?
It was real. He was hunting tigers about a hundred kilometers away
when a local boy pointed him to a cave hidden by jungle.
Inside, he scratched his name onto a painted pillar.
Those caves really were lost. They are called Ajanta.
That is the next video. If you could ask the architect one question,
would it be how he planned it or where the rock went?