Painting modern life: Monet's Gare Saint-Lazare

Smarthistory
10 followers
53 Video Views·Feb 1, 2026
Claude Monet, La Gare Saint-Lazare, 1877, oil on canvas, 75 x 104 cm (Musée d’Orsay, Paris). Speakers: Dr. Steven Zucker and Dr. Beth Harris
We're in the Musée d'Orsay, looking at Monet's canvas, Gare Saint-Lazare.
This is one of several large train stations in the city of Paris, and it's really interesting
that we're looking at it in the Musée d'Orsay, which is a renovated train station itself.
We think about train stations as just an ordinary part of urban life, but in the late 19th century
in Paris, large train stations carrying masses of people out to the suburbs, out to vacation
spots.
These were new kinds of structures.
They expressed their modernity not only through their function, but also through their architecture.
Trains at this point were powered by burning coal and creating steam, and that required
large open sheds, which were held aloft by iron, all of which spoke of modernity.
This was not the traditional architecture of wood or of stone.
This is a completely modern subject.
So this space looked modern, and it's not just the train shed, but the apartment buildings
that we see beyond it that looked new.
During the second half of the 19th century, Paris was rebuilt.
The old, winding, maze-like, congested streets were torn down, and wide boulevards were built
with apartment buildings, housing cafes and department stores, catering to a new middle
class and upper middle class that had cash to spend and the time and leisure to shop
and to enjoy themselves in Paris.
And in a subtler way, the idea of transportation itself, the idea of a place where people of
different classes mix, is also itself modern.
For so long, French society had been rigidly ranked, but that's unraveling in the modern
era, and perhaps nowhere more vividly expressed than in a public space like the train station.
We often think about Impressionist painting as being about leisure.
Renoir's Moulin de Galette, for example, where we see figures socializing and dancing.
This is a working space, but look at the surface of this canvas.
It's absolutely luscious.
It's so drenched with steam and light and smoke that it seems to almost dissolve before our eyes.
It's difficult in some places to make out the architecture of the train shed because
that steam hides it, especially on the left where those bluish lilac puffs of steam obscure
that iron framework.
Light is pouring through the opening at the top of the shed, creating this prism of color
that is playing across the steam within.
In fact, one critic humorously said, I can't really see the paintings for all the smoke
that's emanating from these six canvases that Monet exhibited together, each a play on the subject.
And it's not only the architectural structure that's disappearing, but the forms of the trains themselves.
I mean, these are big machines that dissolve into light and atmosphere.
Well, that's what Monet is interested in, pure color and pure light in the optical play before him,
rather than his empirical knowledge of the solidity of an iron engine.
We have to remember that the Impressionists were positioning themselves outside
of the academic establishment.
This painting and the group of other paintings of the Gare Saint-Lazare
were exhibited at an Impressionist exhibition, which was independent of the official exhibitions
called salons that were sponsored by the Royal Academy.
And so Monet is not giving us a painting that would be a view of the Gare Saint-Lazare
with a factual accounting of what was in this station and what one knows of it.
But you're right, this optical experience of light and atmosphere,
this very subjective experience.
And Monet was not the only person in his group that was interested in this subject.
Manet had painted this subject, although in a very different way.
And another important artist, Caillebotte, had painted a scene from the bridge
that we see just beyond the smokestack of the locomotive.
What fascinates me, too, is the degree to which Monet has reduced the figures themselves
to quick brushstrokes.
And we can't make out faces.
We can make out a little bit of gestures or postures.
But he's really reducing the human figure to these quick strokes of paint.
The human figure was the centerpiece of academic painting.
And yet here it becomes equal to the trains and to the architecture he's painting.
And subservient to the main subject of this painting, light and color.
Other Impressionist artists like Renoir will concern themselves
with the human figure within the light and atmosphere.
But for Monet, it is the landscape, and here an urban landscape,
that is most important to him.
And critics like Baudelaire had been calling for artists
to paint the beauty of modern life.
And I think with paintings like the Garcin-Lazarre,
Monet is taking up that challenge.
Artists didn't need to paint classical antiquity anymore.
They didn't need to paint biblical and history paintings.
They were creating a new beauty that was true to the new modern world
in which they lived.
But for all our talk about the sense of spontaneity, if you look at the surface,
this is a heavily worked canvas.
Monet seems to be weaving color across the surface.
You can see the paint has built up over time.
There's no atmospheric perspective.
The atmosphere is in the foreground as well as in the background, all of which
makes it impossible for us to forget that we're looking at paint on canvas.
Monet and the Impressionists are creating a new visual language
for a new modern world.
