Claude Monet the Gare Saint Lazare and the Painting of Modern Life Jones Gallery Lecture Series

Smarthistory
10 followers
218 Video Views·Feb 20, 2026
Jones Gallery curator and art historian Sarah Jones discusses Monet's paintings of the Gare Saint-Lazare.
Welcome to the Jones Gallery Lecture Series. I'm Sarah Jones, the curator at Jones Gallery.
We're a contemporary art gallery in St. John, New Brunswick, and our core mandate is to present
work by contemporary Canadian artists. But art education is also important to us, and we think
that art history should be accessible, understandable, and free. And that's why we hold public lectures
at the gallery and produce videos like these. To keep this series free and open, we rely on the
donations of our viewers. Today's video is brought to you by Michael, Olivia, Jean, and Tom. Thank you
for your generous support. If you would like to also support our efforts, please donate at
jonesgallery.ca slash arthistory, and the link is below in the video notes. Up today, I'd like to
talk to you about a series of paintings that Monet completed in 1877. There's about 12 of them,
and they're of the the Gare Saint-Lazare, and that's a very important train station in Paris.
It featured often in the work of the Impressionists that we know, so Courbet,
well I'm not really an Impressionist, but kind of part of the gang, so Courbet,
and Monet of course, Degas, Caillebotte. They were all drawn to this scene and this structure
for a number of reasons, but I'll be focusing on Monet today. And we know,
kind of in popular kind of consciousness or popular perception of Monet, and we all kind
of know that he was interested in the effects of light. And this is really what drew him to
the Gare Saint-Lazare, because it's kind of a glass and wrought iron structure building,
and the light kind of filters through the ceiling here. You can see this is
one of his paintings of the Gare Saint-Lazare, and then mixes with the smoke and the steam
from the engines. And these structures, I mean this looks obviously kind of
antique or quaint to us, the idea of these kind of wrought iron structures
and the trains as something from the 19th century. But to Monet and his
contemporaries, these were remarkable structures of modernity. And there was one
French writer, Gautier, who said that such structures were the new cathedrals of humanity
that were being built around Paris at this time. And I'll talk more about this particular
painting in a moment, but just to describe the kind of the atmosphere of this station
and stations like it, I'd like to draw on Emile Zola, because he had a wonderful description.
So he writes, opposite, under this dusting of light, the houses of the rude Rome, which
you can see in the distance here, grow blurred, then vanished as though swept away. To the left,
the covered markets opened up their smoke, opened up the smoke-stained panels, panes,
sorry, my dog is licking his nose and distracting me, the smoke-stained panes of their vast porticos.
Amid the ghostly passage of wagons and machinery cluttering the rails, a red signal strained in
the pale light, just remember that image because I'll show a few paintings where this is relevant,
a red signal strained in the pale light, an express locomotive with its two vast devouring
wheels stood alone while the thick black smoke of its smokestack rose slowly vertically into the
calm air. So it's, Zola isn't exactly describing this particular painting, but it's so reflective,
it's as if he's standing in front of Monet's painting and expressing this. And then just a
bit more from Zola, and he saw emerging from the bridge a whiteness profuse and swirling like a
bank of snow, taking flight through its array of iron girders. So that's Zola from Human Animals.
And this is again kind of a remarkable passage and pairs so well with with Monet's depictions
of the of the Gare Saint-Lazare because you can see that the interest that is driving both Zola
and Monet in these paintings, that is this mixture of light and and smoke and cloud and light
with these new cathedrals, with these kind of temples of modernity that are being
built at the time. So the story is that Monet rented an apartment on the first floor
relatively close to the Gare Saint-Lazare. He would have been very familiar with this station.
About 40 percent of the the rail traffic went through the Gare Saint-Lazare.
And this is the station where so many of the the impressionists would have been coming
and going because these were the trains to Normandy. This is the train that Monet would
have taken to Giverny, his garden. So this trains up to the northern coast of France.
So he rents an apartment in January 1877 on the Rue de la Mancy, which is close.
And it's rented under his friend Caillebotte, who's another impressionist and a friend of
Monet and the gang. So it looks like what we, from the records that we have, is that Caillebotte
rented the apartment and then Monet kind of would pay him back gradually. So they're all
kind of interconnected. Caillebotte was the only one who, one of the few who had money,
independent money. Monet was broke most of the time, so was Renoir. Until this, around this
period, started to be a bit of a changing turning point for Monet and his sales. But he's really
still kind of an impecunious artist at this time, relying on his friend Caillebotte. And he painted,
as I mentioned just a few minutes ago, a series of 12 paintings of the Gare Saint-Lazare. And I've
picked out a few to show you today. And some of them, not all 12, but some of them were exhibited
in the third Impressionist exhibition. And I talked about the first exhibition
in an earlier video on Monet, and you can find that on our YouTube channel.
But as I mentioned in that video, they had kind of been panned by a critic named Louis Loire
as kind of just painting impressions, that it was kind of a term of derision.
And they've actually kind of assumed that mantle of, they've taken that word or kind of
reappropriated that word to define themselves. And so they've actually started calling themselves
Impressionists and calling their exhibitions Impressionist exhibitions.
And so like I said, he exhibited a portion of these, and I'll tell you more what happened
with that in a moment. But first I'd like to talk about this particular painting.
This is probably his most famous painting that he did in this series of the Gare Saint-Lazare.
And you can see there are a few trains coming into the station here. You can see the tracks
at the bottom center, and then the platforms to the right with a few people.
There are, you can identify those Parisian streets and buildings in the distance,
but you can see that they almost disappear into the smoke. And we don't know if it's steam
or clouds or smoke. It's all kind of intermingling. And then it slowly kind of
wafts up towards the ceiling of wrought iron and glass. And there are moments where we don't
know if we're looking through the glass, if the clouds are on the inside or the outside,
but it's all kind of blending together. Here's a detail of the upper left.
And you can see that building here in the bottom of the frame just kind of disappearing into the
bluish, whitish haze. You can also see Monet's, what's called an impasto technique, so very,
very thick strokes of paint here on the canvas. Monet's work is such a joy to see in person
because it's really hard, unless you have a very high resolution image, to get a sense of the depth
of the paint strokes and how the canvas is built up and up and up. You can get a bit of that here
from this image. And here's a detail of the center. So very, it's, he's interested in this
particular piece, how the light is filtering through the glass, how it filters through cloud,
how it filters through steam, and then how certain elements of the scene are picked up
or dispersed by that effect. And this is a detail of the lower right.
Look how the people are reduced to sometimes just two strokes of paint. There's a bit of red,
a bit of black, a little bit of kind of peachy color, a few strokes of green. It's reduced to
most basic elements. So the people are not the focal point here.
They're kind of enveloped by the light and by the steam. And also look at the hazy
outline to the left here, the hazy outline of that steam engine. So it also is being enveloped
by the steam and the smoke. It's kind of blue steam, which is obviously, the color is changing
because of the light filtration. And what is, what is so interesting about this series of
paintings, and I talked about this also in the previous video about Monet, is what marks the
impressionist is not so much the technique. So the technique varied from artist to artist. I
mentioned earlier Caillebotte. Caillebotte had a very realistic approach. Monet and Renoir
had much more kind of loose, loose strokes, heavy, heavy application of the paint.
You're probably familiar with Degas. His approach is different again. So they weren't necessarily
united by their, by their painting technique, but as really as they were by their, their interest
in certain subject matter. And for Monet, and I think others, and why they were drawn to the
Saint-Lazare is because they wanted to show the Paris or the world that was, that was around them.
They weren't interested in painting history scenes. They're not interested in painting figures from,
from kind of mythology or from religion. They wanted to, to paint the contemporary life,
paint the modern life. And that idea is what really binds them together. And, and in this
case with Monet is that he is, he's adopting a radically new painting approach with this,
with this kind of loose, loose, thick brushwork, hasty kind of almost an unfinished looking
brushwork. He's applying a modern painting technique to, to kind of modern industrial
forces. And there's this marriage of the two of them that renders these, these paintings
still so, so impactful and kind of what makes them really important in, in terms of the
Impressionist movement. This is another, another painting. Remember Zola talked about the,
the red signal kind of peering through the, peering through the smoke. And, and I love this scene.
See that red signal in the center. And then the, the individual brushstrokes here of the white
and orange and purple clouds. And I love how hastily the, the, do I have a detail? Oh, I do.
Look at that. Okay. Look how hastily the paint has been applied and the details obscured. I'm
going to pull back again. The details obscured of that locomotive on the left. And it does
convey a sense of, of movement that I don't think could have been conveyed if it was painted in a
more realistic style. So we, we, he's, he's evoking the, it's the overall feeling of the scene rather than
the individual details. So the details are sacrificed to the, to the kind of the atmosphere,
the essence of the scene here. That red signal, I think that's, that's, it stands out so well against,
against the, the, the oranges and the, and the, I was going to say greens, purple, that is purple.
That red kind of straining through this, through this hazy light. Here's another,
La Tranchée des Patineaux from the same year. So this is more of the train yard, not the station
itself, but we can see the same effect here. So the, the application, look, look how thick that
paint is of the clouds kind of moving off diagonally to the right. I love this one.
This is the exterior of the Gare Saint-Lazare. The signal, again, the red light peering through the,
through the clouds. And, and look at the, the, the brush strokes. So the, those kind of cream color
strokes here that are uniting the, the clouds and the steam together. And then how, how stark
these signals, these kind of black and gray signals then stand out against that.
So it's that kind of juxtaposition of the, the haziness of the light
and the roundness of those strokes compared to the, the harshness of the, of the, the railway
structures. And, and as I said, this, some of these, these paintings, you know, six or eight
of them were shown in the third Impressionist exhibition. Sales were okay. We did have some,
some, some notes that he, he, he did indeed make some sales with this. And I think
this, this artist typically didn't exhibit works in a series. So at the, at this time,
this is one of the first times that we have kind of on record of a, of an artist choosing a
particular subject matter and then showing a number of paintings dedicated to that subject.
So typically an artist like Monet, he might do a couple of seascapes. He might do a portrait.
Then he might do a garden scene and then, you know, something else kind of thrown in together.
So, so thematically they weren't necessarily linked until this third Impressionist exhibition
where he showed these paintings of the Gare Saint-Lazare. And sales were, were not too bad
for the, for the first time. Monet hadn't, like I said, hadn't had great sales up until this point.
And I think there is this kind of a balancing that, that, or an attempt to balance
kind of commercial realities and, and the kind of genuine interest in, in painting the changing
effects of light on a particular subject. Because then after the Gare Saint-Lazare series,
he starts to move into his, his very famous series paintings, like of the poplars or the grain stacks
or the cathedral at Rouen. And sales for those just go off the charts. And, and it turned out
that clients liked to buy paintings that were part of a series. And I think Monet just starts
to glimpse that here in 1877. But despite, despite the, the sales being, being decent,
the majority of the reviews were, were quite hostile. The inspector of fine arts hated the
exhibition. He hated Cezanne especially, but he kind of lumped Cezanne and Monet together. And he
yeah, they, they, they didn't like this. So here's, here's another, here's another
critic in the Figaro. Monet has attempted to give us the disagreeable impression of
several locomotives whistling all at once. And of course, that's exactly what he's,
he's doing here. And that's why, that's why it works. But these critics, one, did not like,
they thought that modernity was, or kind of the industrial, the industry of modern life
was, was too loud and, and too dirty and kind of imposing on, on kind of the French
idyll. So they didn't like that. But then they also didn't like Monet's
mode of, of painting. So they're, they're panning the work for, for exactly now what we,
what we admire about it. And here's another, another critic in the Monet's Art Universelle.
The artist has sought to impart the impression produced on travelers by the noise of the engine
on arrival and departure. And that's supposed to be a criticism. We read it now. It's like,
yeah, exactly. That, that's, that's what's happening. But, but they, but they, they,
they, they didn't like that. And so, so yes, kind of that, the, the noisiness and the movement
that I was telling you about in this scene is, is what really set the critics, critics on edge,
as well as the unfinished nature they thought of the, of the canvases.
And they, why this caused such a consternation among the critics is, is because Monet was doing
something radically new. So as I mentioned a few minutes ago, these paintings are important
because they're tackling a modern subject with a modern technique or modern approach.
And what the audience and what critics would have been familiar with is a much more finished and
a detailed approach to, to the surface of the painting. So here, this is a, this is a caricature
by, by Daumier. And, and these, these two figures here are kind of leaning in to closely inspect a
painting and they're saying, you can, you have to get in close so that you can, you can tell if the,
the color's good. And that's what they expected to do. And, and of course, when you, when you
really lean into a Monet, if we, if we get closer and closer and closer, it kind of descends into a,
into a chaos of, of, of, of paint and brushstrokes thickly, thickly applied. Whereas a painting like
this by Jean-Jérôme, The Death of Caesar, if we lean in, the details all stay intact. And this is
what was traditionally accepted by the French Academy and the French state. So that, that
inspector of fine arts, this is what he really wanted to see at the time. Jérôme was a contemporary of
the Impressionists. And so in technique, they wanted the painting surface to be very finished,
highly refined and detailed. They also wanted the subject matter. They didn't want to see
their, their own world reflected back at them. They wanted to see historical subjects. So,
so paintings of, in this case of Caesar, this is The Death of Caesar. So ancient Rome,
that was good. Ancient Greece, even better. Or some kind of religious, religious topic. Napoleon,
you could paint Napoleon, that's fine. But not the train station where you take the train every day.
So, so Monet here is defying, defying both of the, the central rules of the French Academy.
Look at that difference in the surface. Jérôme, finished. Monet. Critics went nuts.
Thank you very much for watching. And how you can support the lecture series, as I said,
you can donate at jonesgallery.ca. Technical support, as always, is by Caleb Jones.
And we'll talk to you soon.
