On December 18, 1912, scientists presented a skull and mandible, as well as other artifacts, to the British Geological Society. The fossil was in fact an orangutan jawbone paired with a 500 year old modern human braincase. In fact, "Deliberate malice" could hardly have been more successful than the hazards of deposition in so breaking the fossils as to give free scope to individual judgment in fitting the parts together. As a result no less than three restorations of the skull were made, while the canine tooth was assigned to both the right lower mandible and the left upper jaw. The estimates on the capacity of the braincase also ranged widely from 1,070 to 1,500 cubic centimeters, the American wrote.
CHAPTERS 0:00 A new Skull and Mandible from England 2:45 Paid Promotion - Incogni 4:15 A history of Deception 8:00 Who did it?
Impressed by the incontrovertible evidence in the form of a recently discovered ancient human skull,
one anthropologist of the British Museum fantasized on what the creature must have looked like,
and wrote, he was a man of low stature, very muscular, and had not yet attained that graceful
poise of the body which is so characteristic of the human race today. He knew how to make fire
and a hand axe. He gambled about the countryside as naked as a monkey, flashing an admirable pair
of canines, and his cranium could hold two pints of Carlsberg beer. As a result of the unique
combination of a primitive jawbone with a modern-looking brain case, the ancient human
was given the species name Eoanthropus dorsoni after its discoverer, Charles Dawson.
On December 18, 1912, scientists presented the skull and mandible, as well as other artifacts,
to the British Geological Society. The fossil was, in fact, an orangutan jawbone,
paired with a 500-year-old modern human brain case. This meeting was immortalized in a now
infamous painting, which has come to symbolize scientific fraud and forgery. As early as 1915,
one American anthropologist accused the British of outright fraud concerning this fossil. In fact,
deliberate malice could hardly have been more successful than the hazards of deposition
in so breaking the fossils as to give free scope to individual judgment in fitting the parts
together. As a result, no less than three restorations of the skull were made, while the
canine tooth was assigned to both the right lower mandible and the left upper jaw. The estimates on
the capacity of the brain case also ranged widely from 1,070 to 1,500 cubic centimeters, the American
wrote. Regarding the fractured condition of the mandible, Dr. Pyecraft of the British Museum wrote
that the wretched pickaxe added yet another obstacle to identification. It cut off the
forepart of the jaw, bearing the front cheek teeth, the eye teeth, or canines, and the cutting teeth.
However, according to other expert, the missing pieces of the jawbone had rotted away,
while still others thought that the pieces had been broken off naturally.
In The Lost World, published in the spring of 1912, Sir Arthur Conan Doyle made references
to a practical joker and to prehistoric bones, vamped for a forgery. If you are clever and know
your business, you can fake a bone as easily as you can a photograph, was the famous line from the
book. Conan Doyle lived near Charles Dawson and the site of the fossil discovery, so this is a
intriguing quote. Now, a message from our sponsor, Incogni. Did you know that commercial databases
and people search websites collect your personal information, including your social security
number, names, aliases, phone numbers, home addresses, passwords, and email addresses,
as well as your location and browser history? It's easy to see how these sites expose you to
a variety of risks, namely identity theft and fraud. In fact, the possibilities of your personal
information being leaked are real and increasing. According to the annual Data Breach Report by the
Identity Theft Resource Center, 2023 was a record-breaking year for data compromises,
with a 78% increase from 2022. However, it is nearly impossible for an individual to request
their information be removed or to pursue legal action. This is why Incogni is an indispensable
tool. They contact data brokers on your behalf to request that your personal data be removed.
Furthermore, because many data brokers continue to gather your personal information
even after you request removal, Incogni monitors these databases and ensures that your data remains
off the market by completing multiple removal requests, which is why an annual subscription
is so essential. Use the code HIGHLYCOMPELLING with the link in the video description to receive
an exclusive 60% off an Incogni yearly plan. It is not known exactly when this forgery was created,
but there was a presentation by Dr. Arthur Keith in London regarding human evolution in the spring
of 1912, and it is possible the this hoax was inspired by this presentation. Sometime in 1912,
Dr. Arthur S. Underwood, a dental surgeon who attended the presentation, was brought in to
write a report about the unusual jaw bone discovered in a field about 50 miles south of
London. His report was just four pages, with only two x-rays of the jaw bone which were taken from
the incorrect angle. Furthermore, it has now been determined that the two molars in the jaw bone
were removed, filed down, and then replaced. This is a stunning fact that has not been addressed
before. In fact, when questioned why the fossil teeth appeared to be worn so flat, Dr. Underwood
wrote that in fact he had seen orangutan teeth that were worn very flat, just as in the fossil
jaw bone. Only an expert in ape jaw bones and teeth could have created such a chimera such as
this jaw bone. How did Dr. Underwood miss this important fact? How did he fail to notice the
similarity with orangutan jaw bones, especially when he wrote about the orangutan skull and jaw
in a book only ten years prior? This evidence is shocking because Dr. Underwood has never been
suggested as possible suspect in the forgery. Moreover, important evidence that the jaw bone
came from an ape was dismissed as early as 1913. Sir Ray Lancaster, the former head of the Natural
History Museum and close friend of both Arthur Conan Doyle and Charles Dawson, also wrote about
the difference between orangutan and human teeth in a book he published in October 1912,
just two months before Eoanthropus dorsoni became public. The fact that both Dr. Underwood and Dr.
Lancaster wrote about the difference between human and orangutan molars and jaws is a remarkable
coincidence. As a matter of fact, the dentist Dr. Underwood and the zoologist Dr. Lancaster
would have been the only ones with the knowledge to be able to effectively mutilate the orangutan
jaw bone and file down the teeth in this manner. How could both of these experts have missed the
jaw bone as being from an orangutan? It defies comprehension that these men, on whose expert
opinions Dr. Smith-Woodward and others depended, observed nothing unusual about the fossils.
Smith-Woodward was the leader of the scientific team reporting on the discovery,
but he seems to have been duped by Dawson, Lancaster, and Underwood. Meanwhile, Lancaster
and his apprentice, Dr. Pyecraft of the British Museum, authored numerous pieces for newspapers
to influence the public. They also released books and scientific papers debunking other scientists
who argued that Eoanthropus was not a true new species. They spread disinformation regarding
the fossil to influence scientific and public opinion. The forgery worked for a variety of
reasons. To begin with, the forgers were well aware of what they were doing. The forgery itself
comprised a plethora of plausible confirmatory evidence. Second, the concept of human evolution
from ape-like predecessors was relatively fresh, with new ideas sprouting and expanding quickly.
Indeed, Charles Darwin had died only thirty years before. Most crucially, the forgery emerged from
a perfect storm of scientific and non-scientific events. Notably, the period coincided with
significant paleo-anthropological finds in Germany, France, Indonesia, and elsewhere
throughout the world, which included the famous Neanderthal man and Java man fossils.
But now let us turn to the British Museum's ill-fated first construction
of the ancient skull, created by Dr. Smith Woodward, an expert in prehistoric fish.
Owing to his imperfect knowledge of human anatomy, also shared by Dr. Pyecraft, an expert in birds,
he made a grave error over the reconstruction. The incompetence at the museum at South Kensington
is understandable, for clearly the department did not know what the fossil was about.
In fact, anatomist Dr. Arthur Keith of London argued that the owner of the skull,
as reconstructed by the Natural History Museum, would be unable to eat or breathe.
Remarkably, the British Museum's first reconstruction of the skull went against
everything that was known regarding human anatomy. Though human evolution was not his
area of expertise, Dr. Smith Woodward waded into the subject, hypothesizing that both the skull
and the mandible must be ancient, in which case it appeared probable that they came from the
same individual. If that was the case, he was arguing the existence of a creature with a brain
the size of a modern human, but a jaw and teeth somewhere between human and ape. Nevertheless,
Dr. Smith Woodward was criticized for his lack of leadership, and some scientists were
genuinely perplexed at his dogmatic views of the fossil and unwillingness to listen to scientists
outside of his small circle. Dr. Lancaster was a strong supporter of this hypothesis,
and he wrote about it multiple times, notably in a book published in 1915 that explored
Eoanthropus dorsonii, whom he referred to as the all-important missing link. As a point of fact,
Dr. Lancaster wrote that he believed there could be the bones of a dozen of these ancient humans
at the discovery site. Lancaster also wrote in his 1915 book that the Eoanthropus was one of
the most important fossil discoveries of all time, and that its significance was actually
underappreciated. It is obvious from his books and letters that the scientists at the British
Natural History Museum were in lockstep with Dr. Lancaster's views. What's more, there is still
a pervasive myth that scientists back in 1913 did not have the expertise and the technology
to prove that Eoanthropus was a fraud, but this is untrue. In fact, there were many experts who
realized that the jaw and the skull did not belong together, and the only technology one
needed to prove this was a microscope and a simple chemical test. But scientists that were
not part of the Natural History Museum were never allowed to conduct their own tests,
and in most cases they only had access to a replica of the fossil, not the real thing.
Indeed, obvious evidence of forgery was so neglected by Dr. Smith Woodward and his assistant
Dr. Pycroft, he truly may not have been aware of it, or at least he wasn't thinking about it
as he examined the newly excavated mandible, the skull, the flint tools, and the mammal
bones that were truly ancient which had been found with the human fossil. The British Museum
truly believed they had found the so-called missing link and were eager to show the fossil to the
world, so eager that the institution failed to undertake key tests that were fully within
Dr. Smith Woodward's capabilities. For example, he should have analyzed the skull and mandible
for organic and chemical remnants, such as analyzing the nitrogen concentration.
Were these tests purposely avoided, or were the tests conducted,
but the results were never made public? This test would not have disclosed the bones' exact age,
but it would have demonstrated that they were not hundreds of thousands of years old,
thus revealing the fraud. Smith Woodward or Dr. Underwood could also have examined the teeth
using a magnifying glass, which would have revealed that they had been filed. Therefore,
by avoiding such testing, the Museum was effectively dismissing the possibility
that bones of a human and an ape from different time periods had ended up in the same gravel pit,
either accidentally or on purpose. Did Charles Dawson have any expertise in human anatomy?
His previous forgeries are known to have involved dinosaur bones and petrified fish,
and were nowhere near as elaborate. Whomever the mastermind behind the forgery, he knew that
recruiting an expert in human teeth would be needed to convince other scientists of the validity of
the fossil. Dr. Underwood was publicly criticized for his inadequate report on the fossil jawbone
just before he died of a heart attack in December 1916, a few days before the four-year anniversary
of the unveiling of the new human species, Eoanthropus dorsoni. Dr. Underwood was sixty-two
and died of a heart failure only four months after Charles Dawson died of a mystery illness
at age fifty-two in August 1916. This fact adds to the need to find out who was involved in the
conspiracy, and whether it could have involved something more sinister than only fake bones.
And with that tantalizing statement, we leave you to ponder the mysteries of our shared human
history. Please share, comment, and check out the other videos on our channel. Thank you and take care.