How New York’s Most Powerful Boss Hid from the FBI in Plain Sight - Our History

Museum Mysteries
14 followers
Jan 28, 2026
By the mid-1980s, five mafia families run the city of New York.
Through their control over construction, transportation, and the labor unions,
they use extortion and violence to dominate the city's economy.
For years, the authorities have battled against them with limited success.
But now the U.S. government prepared to deliver what they hope will be a death blow.
The plan is bold, but simple.
To cut off the head of the mafia's snake by taking direct aim at the men who rule New York.
Men like the Colombo family boss, Carmine Persico.
Head of the Gambino crime family, Paul Castellano.
Lucchese godfather, Antonio Dux Carallo.
And Fat Tony Salerno, leader of the powerful Genovese family.
Together, they form the governing body for the entire U.S. mafia.
Known as the Commission.
The task of sending these men down falls to attorney Rudolph Giuliani,
the man who would one day become mayor of New York City.
Giuliani believes that taking out the bosses will effectively destroy organized crime in the city.
Giuliani indicted the heads of all five New York City crime families,
which was, you know, completely unprecedented and unheard of.
Giuliani and his team order the five mafia bosses to be brought in.
It's the boldest move ever taken against the U.S. mafia.
Once and for all, the government was saying that in New York City organized crime exists,
and these are the leaders of the five organized crime families.
So the prosecution was significant and garnered a lot of publicity and press at the time.
As they prepare for their courtroom showdown with the mob,
the government knows that the stakes couldn't be higher.
Until then, virtually most mob bosses were immune from prosecution.
The higher-ups didn't do any real acts.
They didn't pull a trigger.
They didn't stab anybody.
They didn't shake anybody down.
Giuliani's challenge now is to make sure he secures his convictions.
He has a powerful weapon on his side.
The 1972 Racketeer-Influenced and Corrupt Organizations Act, known as RICO.
RICO is key legislation designed to catch the big fish
that until now have always managed to wriggle free.
But the key to the RICO law was if you were a member of an enterprise
and a leader of an enterprise, you could be convicted and sentenced to 30 to 50 years.
By using the RICO Act,
the government no longer need to prove these top mobsters are guilty of a specific crime.
Just proving they are in charge of the mafia will be enough to send them down
as part of a mass criminal conspiracy.
Giuliani and his team use years of FBI surveillance
and witness testimony as evidence against the bosses.
And eventually their strategy pays off.
On November 19th, 1986, a jury finds the bosses guilty of mass criminal conspiracy.
This is a great day for law enforcement,
but this is a bad day, probably the worst for the mafia.
In a stunning victory for the government,
the bosses are each sentenced to 100 years behind bars.
They proved the effectiveness of the RICO law.
This was a big prosecution where everybody was going to do a big amount of jail time.
And the government scored a clean sweep.
With one bold move,
the authorities have taken out the entire leadership of the New York Mafia.
Or so they think.
Leading the celebrations are the squads of the FBI's Special Mafia Task Force.
These five squads have been on the front line in the war against organized crime.
One of its key agents is John Pritchard.
Each squad would go after a particular family.
The family that I was assigned to supervise the investigation of
was in fact the Genovese crime family.
The Genovese squad's target had been the star defendant in the commission trial,
Fat Tony Salerno.
Despite the apparent success of the FBI's Genovese squad,
Pritchard isn't in the mood to celebrate.
Something about the commission trial is troubling him.
He has long harbored doubts about Salerno's ability to head up the Genovese family.
Fat Tony Salerno was viewed and believed to be
the head of the Genovese crime family.
But you have to understand, at that point, it was just theory.
To Pritchard, the comical looking Salerno
never seemed to display any of the attributes of a top Mafia boss.
And he's starting to suspect that the Genovese squad
may have just sent down the wrong man.
It's a remarkable suspicion.
If Pritchard is right, that means the real Genovese boss is still at large.
As law enforcement continues to celebrate their victory over the Mafia,
intelligence comes in which adds to Pritchard's suspicion
that Fat Tony Salerno is the wrong guy.
Across town, Vincent Caffaro, Tony Salerno's supposed right-hand man,
is facing a racketeering charge.
In an attempt to strike a deal with his interrogators,
Caffaro decides to reveal some remarkable information.
He dramatically confesses to investigators that Fat Tony Salerno
was never the boss of the Genovese family.
According to Caffaro, Salerno was never anything more than a stooge.
That was a ruse to throw us off the track of
ultimately who was in fact the leader of the family.
So just who is the real boss?
The person Caffaro now names takes the investigators completely by surprise.
It's someone they would never have suspected.
He told them that the real leader of the family
and had been the leader for years was Vincent Giganti.
But for years, the FBI had viewed Vincent Giganti as a bumbling madman.
He wandered around the city in his pajamas sometimes,
acting strangely and bizarrely.
He would do things like speak with the parking meters, urinate in public.
How could anyone think that this person
would be the head of the most powerful mobster family in America?
Agent Pritchard wonders whether Giganti could actually have hoaxed the entire bureau.
If true, the squad's biggest success against the Genovese family
in convicting Tony Salerno could now be their greatest humiliation.
If true, Giganti is now the most powerful mob boss in America.
Could this shuffling madman really have played them all for fools?
For Agent John Pritchard, one thing is clear.
If he's going to set the record straight, he has a massive task before him.
He's going to have to convince the entire city that this madman is,
in fact, a ruthless mob boss.
I believe that Giganti was far more powerful
necessarily than he had been given credit for.
Now, an insider claims that this bumbling madman
could have pulled off one of the greatest scams in criminal history.
To expose it, Agent Pritchard realizes he and his team
will have to start by re-examining every piece of intelligence the bureau holds on Giganti.
That historical information, you know, that was used as
to bring people up to speed in terms of who this guy really was.
Pritchard discovers that Giganti first came to the attention of the FBI in 1957.
Only in his 20s, he was given the contract to kill rival crime boss
Frank Costello, head of the Lucchese family.
But Giganti's assassination attempt failed.
You would think that that kind of high-profile failure would doom your career.
But in Giganti's case, it really didn't seem to have that effect.
Giganti quickly rose through the ranks of the new Genovese family.
And by the early 60s, had reached the rank of capo.
This was a senior position within the family, putting him in command of his own crew.
In the mid-60s, just as Giganti became a contender for a senior position in the family,
he mysteriously falls off the radar.
They had really no file on Giganti from like 66,
which is kind of crazy when you consider that even at that point, he was a well-known guy.
For some reason, the FBI's attention shifted to fat Tony Salerno.
Something dramatic had happened.
But what?
When Pritchard examines the FBI's earlier investigation into the Genovese mob,
he discovers a report that could explain everything.
Back in 1981, the FBI decided to use Giganti as the unwitting bait for a tactic called
tickling the wires.
Tickling means provoking the mob, and then listening out for chatter that might incriminate
them.
And one of the mobsters the squad targeted was Vincent Giganti.
They decide to issue him a subpoena to see how other members of the Genovese family react.
And when the agents turn up at Giganti's home, the investigation stops in its tracks.
The agents get inside, they go through the apartment,
and they go to the bathroom where they hear the shower running.
And they open the door and there's Vincent Giganti.
Nude, under the shower, holding an umbrella.
I mean, you know, that story went around the New York office quite a bit.
You know, it was very humorous.
It's suddenly clear to Agent Pritchard why Giganti dropped off the Bureau's radar.
For the most part, the concept or the theory the FBI had,
that he was a little bit of a daffy guy, but he was really not that important.
After the shower incident, the FBI stops pursuing Giganti.
Could the head of the Genovese family have been faking?
Agent Pritchard worries that Giganti may have been misdirecting the FBI for years.
Pritchard turns his attention to FBI surveillance reports,
and the unofficial Genovese HQ, the triangle social club in lower Manhattan.
The Genovese family would congregate there pretty much every day,
and play cards, and appear to be socializing.
One of the first things they were trying to do is identify
the people in the Genovese family and who was who.
Over the years, the squad employed a variety of methods
to put pressure on the Genovese mobsters to break cover.
Agents openly patrolled outside the triangle club,
writing down the license plates of every car,
and in full view of the mobsters, put the bar under constant surveillance.
And they would just have someone there with a camera,
taking pictures of who came in and out.
And by doing that, they could figure out who the hierarchy was,
and throughout the FBI surveillance,
Agent Pritchard discovers that Vincent Giganti stuck to the same routine.
If you're doing FBI surveillance,
you're going to see every day on Sullivan Street,
Vincent Giganti going from his apartment to the social club.
Once he gets there, you're going to see a procession of the family's
top capos coming in and going out back and forth.
And although the so-called lunatic was frequently observed
wandering the streets around the club with high-ranking mobsters,
despite their best efforts, the FBI failed to record any conversations.
The Genovese guys, they're a very close-knit and closed-mouth group,
and they didn't have a lot of success.
The squad's surveillance teams concluded that Giganti was harmless,
a relic from a previous era, tolerated by the real bosses.
Everything Pritchard reads suggests the FBI ignored Giganti,
believing he was little more than an ex-mobster with dementia.
For all intents and purposes, he appears to be mentally ill,
incapable of crossing the road, let alone running a million-dollar criminal empire.
But Pritchard can't let go of his hunch.
What if Giganti is the proverbial wolf in sheep's clothing?
The very fact that he continued to move in mob circles was surely suspicious.
There's no question about it. I mean, if you're in the mafia and you're crazy,
really crazy, you're not going to last in the mafia, not at all.
Agent Pritchard decides to go back to square one.
It's time to start surveillance of his own.
For decades, Giganti has been thought of as a bit player,
but now Pritchard decides to give him the attention he deserves.
They were very intent on doing what had not been done in a long time,
which was to get Vince Giganti indicted in a courtroom.
This time, the squad keeps their presence discreet,
secretly setting up round-the-clock surveillance of the Triangle Club.
It isn't long before Agent Pritchard sees evidence that his hunch about Giganti is right.
I was participating in a surveillance one night
and saw him with the usual ratty bathrobe that he wore.
And all of a sudden, he had taken off the bathrobe
and he had a very well-tailored sharkskin suit on.
It just further cemented for him that they were after the right guy.
Because it just showed me or convinced me that whole thing was an act.
It's the moment Pritchard has been waiting for.
Now he presses the button on a new investigation into Giganti.
He had this great fear of going to jail, of being prosecuted.
But Pritchard needs more than a hunch.
He has to prove Giganti's mental illness is a deception.
He returns to the case files.
He eventually comes across a report from 1970.
It reveals the very moment that Giganti came up with the idea for his perfect cover.
He was accused of bribing, it sounds crazy,
but bribing the entire police force of a New Jersey town that he lived in,
which he didn't consider to be anything more than kind of a gesture of goodwill.
But local prosecutors decide to make a case against him.
And trapped in a corner, Giganti tries something extraordinary.
He checks himself into a hospital and convinces psychiatrists he is schizophrenic.
His lawyer came to court and said,
my client is mentally unwell and he's actually in a mental hospital.
This is 1969, 1970.
The idea of an insanity defense really hadn't been broached anywhere.
He was cunning and he saw a dodge that he took,
or attempted to take, to get out from under the thumb.
Giganti's strategy works.
At trial, he's acquitted of all charges.
And over the next decade, Giganti meticulously embellishes his role,
building a convincing picture of a mentally disturbed man,
a tactic that was paying dividends.
There's a developing sense that, hey, this is not a bad way to approach these things.
And he decided to go big with it.
Every couple of months, he would go in for what was known as a tune-up.
He would actually check into a mental clinic.
It became almost like a vacation, like if I would go to Disney World,
he would go to the St. Vincent's Mental Hospital.
The orchestrated visits give Giganti virtual immunity from prosecution.
So he takes the idea further.
Taking the charade out onto the streets, it takes him out of the FBI's firing line.
Giganti plays the harmless old man among a family of killers.
And for decades, the shuffling old man act appears to dupe the FBI.
But now, Agent John Pritchard has to find a way to expose Giganti
as the fraud he suspects he is.
First, he has to blow the crazy act wide open.
And then prove he's the real boss of the murderous Genovese family.
Pritchard pours more resources into his investigation.
He increases surveillance on Giganti and targets his known associates.
It only needs one conversation to reveal him as the real boss,
and he immediately becomes responsible for every crime carried out by his organization.
We were going after people that we felt could draw Giganti into a conspiracy involving
a RICO case. And in fact, that was the emphasis.
We knew that eventually, if we kept after him, that we would be able to show
that he, in fact, was the leadership of the family.
The squad now has growing evidence that behind his act,
Giganti is sane.
But lacking anything concrete, the team are in danger of losing momentum.
But if you ever need a convincing,
Pritchard discovers just how important his investigation was.
In January 1986, two of his detectives, Anthony Vendetti and Kathy Burke,
were on a routine surveillance operation.
They're watching one of Giganti's mobsters.
A fellow by the name of Fritzi Giannovelli.
Fritzi was a capo that answered to Giganti.
It was a routine surveillance, and it wasn't one that,
you know, you would think would be particularly dangerous.
When their shift ends, the detectives head home.
But they've been spotted by their mark.
And unknown to them, they're now being followed.
The detectives decide to stop for a coffee.
Vendetti heads into the diner while Burke waits for him in the car.
Giannovelli and his crew decide to strike.
Burke spots the danger and tries to stop them.
But she's not quick enough.
The mobsters shoot her.
Then Vendetti.
Burke is seriously wounded.
And tragically, Tony Vendetti lies dead.
It was emotional for me because I had lost a friend,
a detective that worked for me on the squad.
Agent Pritchard's investigation just got personal.
And he decides it's time to enter the lion's den.
Knowing that Giganti was the head of the family,
he took on far more importance because of their shooting.
Myself and another agent went to interview him at the Triangle Club.
Giganti is ordered to step outside.
And according to Pritchard,
when confronted about the shooting, completely drops his act.
He saw that we were serious and he was very lucid.
There was no doubt in my mind having this conversation with him.
That he was as sane as I am.
Back at the squad's HQ, Pritchard gathers his team.
The shooting means bringing Giganti to justice is more urgent than ever.
It's now clear their target isn't just sane.
He's dangerous.
So far, though, the squad has failed to get any tangible evidence against Giganti.
And now he's been inside the Triangle Club.
Pritchard knows why.
I'm probably one of the few agents that have been inside the Triangle Social Club.
There was a sign up on the wall over the payphone that this location is bugged.
You know, don't say anything in here that's criminal.
They actually had that written on the wall.
It's clear that wherever Giganti is doing his business, it isn't at the Triangle Club.
The boss must have another secret HQ.
The squad decide to escalate their surveillance.
And eventually, they get a break.
As the FBI increased its surveillance of the Chin,
they came to realize that Sullivan Street was not the be-all and end-all
of kind of his existence as they initially thought.
Every evening at the same time,
Giganti is picked up by a driver from his mother's apartment building on Sullivan Street.
And he doesn't reappear until the next morning.
So where does he go?
Pritchard's team focus their efforts on following Giganti's car.
Tailing him is easier said than done.
Because wherever he's going, he doesn't want to be followed.
For weeks, Giganti's drivers expertly navigate the city's streets,
shaking off any FBI tails.
The squad don't give up.
And eventually, they discover where Giganti has been hiding.
They finally traced him to a home on the east side.
We realized that it was being used as a place for him to hang his hat, if you will.
The apartment belongs to Giganti's mistress, Olympia Esposito.
It's a well-chosen location,
making a clear line of sight for Pritchard's surveillance teams difficult.
But they find a safe position on the roof of a local school.
One of the agents on the squad really did a Herculean job in terms of,
at night, all sorts of weather, crawling out on this ledge
to observe what was going on within Giganti's residence.
Over the next four months,
the agent painstakingly records Giganti's behavior inside the apartment.
And at last, they have visual evidence that Giganti isn't mad.
They could see how well-dressed he was,
how he acted normally, how people came, he had conferences.
He actually had people there for meetings.
We saw him in conversation at the table.
We observed him, you know, counting money and things like that.
What the FBI saw confirmed everything that they had believed.
That this was a mob boss, he was not a mental patient.
To prove Giganti is the Genovese boss in a courtroom, they need him on tape.
So far, the mobster has no idea the squad are onto him.
Pritchard now knows just how paranoid Giganti is.
Any mistake they make could blow the entire investigation,
and months of work will go down the drain.
To reduce the risk of discovery, Pritchard decides to use some expert help.
It was a really rare opportunity for the FBI to have recordings of this guy.
And they brought in a FBI specialist who had this special drill,
and it was supposed to go just so far into the wall,
and then it would sense where the other side was and stop.
Unfortunately, the installation of the device didn't go particularly well.
And in fact, it was discovered.
We tried things that were unique, and sometimes they worked, and sometimes they didn't.
The botched attempt to install the bug tips off Giganti.
He immediately resorts to his tried and tested fallback plan.
And books himself into a mental institution.
With Giganti's deception successfully resurrected, the Oddfather believes he is safe.
But Pritchard's investigation will yet come back to haunt the Great Illusionist.
A lot of stuff that was developed over the years just doesn't die.
It sits there as evidence.
So eventually, some prosecutor or some agent down the road
is going to be able to use that earlier evidence.
Two years later, lawyer Greg O'Connell picks up where Pritchard left off.
His challenge is to prove on the record that Giganti is sane and in charge.
But O'Connell has found a way to succeed where Pritchard's squad had failed.
He's managed to get a Genovese associate to cooperate with his investigation.
The investigation into Vincent Giganti grew out of a
federal organized crime narcotics investigation,
where we placed the wiretaps on a couple of significant organized crime players.
O'Connell's investigation quickly exposes a major drugs ring
trafficking heroin and cocaine in the heart of the city.
Armed with damning evidence,
the authorities quickly shut down the narcotics operation, arresting its members.
They're big players in the New York mafia.
And O'Connell discovers that one of them might be able to give him something
which has eluded the FBI for decades.
Direct access into Giganti's inner circle.
Bobby Faranga is a Genovese family associate.
But facing life imprisonment, he's also the ideal candidate for O'Connell to turn informer.
So his investigators now turn on the pressure.
He decided to cooperate.
And he opened our eyes to a world well beyond
the narcotics investigation that we were conducting.
Investigators discover that Faranga's involvement in a major narcotics ring
didn't end there.
He's also carried out far more sinister tasks on behalf of the Genovese mob,
helping get rid of their competition.
Some of his buddies were knocking off,
these were mob wannabes or low-level mob guys.
They were committing murders and they needed a place to dispose of the bodies.
Faranga knew where the remains of several homicide victims were.
And that evidence enabled us to actually conduct digs, exhume remains,
verify the identities of the victims.
All these victims have been disposed of
on business premises and warehouses belonging to the Genovese.
And Faranga reveals that all these locations are all owned by the same person.
It's a lead which blows the case wide open.
It turned out that he was a guy who was on record directly with Vincent Gigante.
It's a huge break in the case.
Faced with Faranga's statement,
O'Connell's latest suspect also decides to cooperate with the investigation
and testify that Vincent Gigante is the Genovese boss.
His informer's name is Peter Savino.
I would look at that as the milestone event.
Peter Savino worked directly on record with Vincent Gigante.
He had met with Gigante on dozens and dozens of occasions.
So Savino was absolutely critical to our investigation.
We had him wired up against numerous organized crime figures in New York for a year and a half.
The RICO Act means O'Connell doesn't need direct evidence to put Gigante away.
He only needs to link him to a conspiracy.
And thanks to Savino, he thinks he's found a way.
Throughout the 1980s, the five Mafia families formed a cartel
to muscle in on one of New York's biggest maintenance contracts.
Replacing windows in the city's housing projects generates over $170 million for the Mafia.
And the man chosen by Gigante to represent the Genovese family's interests is Peter Savino.
Peter Savino was a major earner for the crime family.
He was a guy that knew how to make money.
But because Savino was the Genovese crime family representative in the window
replacement business, that gave us a focus for our extortion charges.
Savino agrees to testify that Gigante is a key member of the windows cartel,
proving beyond doubt that Gigante is capable of running a complicated criminal scam.
O'Connell feels this case is solid enough to put Gigante in front of a jury.
On May the 30th, 1990, the authorities make their move.
Gigante is arrested.
As he's led into court, prosecutors know he will play the insanity card for everything it's worth.
But stalling the trial is something O'Connell and his team can't afford.
The real key to it was Peter Savino.
And Savino, by this time, was dying of cancer.
If Savino dies before he has a chance to testify, the case against Gigante crumbles.
Gigante kept up his usual ruse, muttering to himself,
sometimes looking with his head down as a hang dog,
looking around, paying no attention to what was going on.
Gigante tries to convince the court that he's schizophrenic and unfit to stand trial.
It works.
The case is on the verge of collapse.
But this time, they're prepared.
They've got a second witness to testify to Gigante's sanity.
And now they play their trump card.
A secret star witness, Sammy the Bull Gravano.
As former underboss of the Gambino family, Gravano had meetings with Gigante.
And in March 1996, he testifies that on those occasions,
the Genovese crime boss had been perfectly lucid.
He was able to describe in a very meaningful and impactful way
the role that Gigante played in his own organized crime life.
Gigante is declared competent to stand trial by the judge.
And O'Connell and his team have the green light to present their case.
It includes more than 250 exhibits,
including much of the evidence from Pritchard's investigation.
Having an FBI agent sit on the witness stand and testify in great detail
about the normal nature of his second life was really crippling to the defense.
It's now time for Peter Savino to put the nail in the coffin for the prosecution.
Terminally ill with cancer, Savino is unable to attend the trial in person.
So he testifies via CCTV from his secret location on the witness protection program.
It's a devastating blow for Gigante's lawyers.
If a defense attorney could pick the most difficult person to challenge in terms of
credibility, it would be somebody dying of cancer from testifying from his deathbed.
Despite his pain, Savino makes it through the cross-examination.
And on July 25th, 1997, Gigante is found guilty on eight counts of racketeering and conspiracy.
And being godfather of the Genovese family.
Gigante would have died in his own bed if it hadn't been for Peter Savino.
His evidence was devastating.
Sentenced to 15 years behind bars, Gigante's health starts to decline.
This time for real.
With the writing on the wall, he finally drops his guard.
He decided to lighten up.
And he was chit-chatting with the nurses, acting normally, and looking to enjoy his
remaining days.
And when news of this came out, that he had shed his act, the Eastern District U.S.
Attorney's Office decided to indict him again on obstruction of justice.
On December the 19th, 2005, Vincent Gigante dies, age 77.
For over two decades, his cat-and-mouse game with the authorities kept him one step ahead
of justice.
Allowing him to retain absolute power over the New York Mafia.
And govern his criminal empire with impunity.
Inside the Mafia, the most respected, feared, cunning, and tyrannical leader was Vincent
Chin Gigante.
No question about it.
Gigante's elaborate charade failed to last.
And thanks to the stubborn pursuit of investigators like John Pritchard, the odd father of organized
crime is finally taken down.
There are two decades of efforts by some of the best FBI agents that we had that ultimately
succeeded in taking him down off his throne.
He engendered so much fear in people.
Because if you made a mistake, that would be enough for him to eliminate you.
I feel personally good that we were able to take Gigante and take him down.
