Uthman, Ali & The First Civil War | 644CE - 661CE | The Birth of Islam Episode 05

Indian Ancestors
19 followers
16 Video Views·Nov 15, 2025
At the time of Umar's assassination in 644CE, his empire stretched from Tunisia to parts of
modern-day Pakistan. The people he ruled were of different ethnicities, languages and religion.
The empire needed a strong leader if it was to keep them in check.
Before his death, Umar had chosen six people to form a committee to appoint his successor.
Eventually, out of those six, it came down to two.
Uthman ibn Affan and Ali ibn Abi Talib, Muhammad's heir.
According to some historians, the final question that determined the next caliph was,
Uthman said yes, Ali said no. Hence, Uthman was elected the third caliph.
Uthman had no earlier experience of leadership or military.
He was margined by trade and the business had been very kind to him.
He was very rich even during Muhammad's lifetime.
Due to the lack of governing experience, he allowed his army a lot of autonomy.
His governors were allowed to invade foreign lands as they saw fit.
Uthman's experience in trade actually benefited the empire a lot.
He made reforms to allow for more efficient trade as he controlled a significant portion of the Silk Road now.
Under him, expansions continued to happen and some new areas were conquered.
Islam's first naval engagement also happened during his reign.
Muawiyah ibn Abi Sufyan, who was a cousin of Uthman, was appointed governor of Syria by Umar.
During Uthman's reign, his governors got autonomy.
Muawiyah built a naval fleet and engaged the Byzantines in the Mediterranean.
This resulted in the Battle of the Masts.
Muawiyah even unsuccessfully tried to lay siege to Constantinople.
Some areas revolted during Uthman's reign but were quickly put down.
But looking at it objectively, Uthman failed to govern the Tawas Empire.
He was accused of nepotism, living in excess, corruption even.
Although, personally, I don't think all of that was really the source of his dissent.
I think since he made governors autonomous, they forgot who the caliph was and they wanted more power
and so started to sow dissent in the public against the caliph.
Finally, a rebellion broke out in Egypt.
The governor was ousted and the new governor sent a thousand men to Medina with orders to kill Uthman.
Just a thousand men to kill the ruler of an empire that stretched over 6.5 million square kilometers.
Uthman didn't have anyone to defend him.
He didn't have a standing army or any personal guards
because all of his power was divided amongst his governors.
He was little more than just a title.
He didn't have any power to enforce anything.
Eventually, after a siege, Uthman was assassinated in his home in 656 CE after 12 years as caliph.
Death was Uthman's redemption.
He is now revered as a remartyr in Islam and forever remembered as the third of the Rashidun, the rightly guided ones.
I would like to add here that during the siege, Ali's sons, Hassan and Husayn, guarded Uthman's home.
It just shows how great and big Ali and his sons were to protect the caliph who held the title that Ali should've held.
Uthman's successor was none other than Ali ibn Abi Talib.
He was reluctant to accept at first mostly because most of his staunch supporters were rebels
but he was eventually convinced by the people of Medina.
On June 18, 656, Ali became the fourth khalifa.
He reigned for around 5 years and his time was the most turbulent yet due to the first fitna.
First of all, Ali moved his capital to Kufa in Mesopotamia.
Secondly, he had some problems with the Banu Umayya, especially Muawiyah, the governor of Syria.
Uthman was also a member of Banu Umayya and if there was anything this family taught their kids,
it was to stick together and boy did they stick together.
Muawiyah demanded that the rebels, each and every one of them, be killed.
But a lot of those people who rebelled were Ali's supporters.
Ali couldn't do that.
The disagreement blew up into a full-scale civil war between Ali and Muawiyah.
The two main battles of the civil war were the Battle of Camel and the Battle of Siffin.
Both of these battles are highly controversial and debated and I couldn't find any accounts
of them that I found logical enough to discuss.
So, let me just give you an overview of the civil war.
First battle, in 656 CE, the Battle of Camel was fought between Aisha,
Muhammad's widow and Ali, Muhammad's heir, cousin and son-in-law.
It was fought due to some confusion during negotiations.
Aisha demanded justice for Uthman and well, it blew up into a battle.
Ali won the battle and decided to forgive everyone and move on.
Second battle was the Battle of Siffin.
It was fought between Muawiyah and Ali in 657 CE.
The loss of life was heavy and out of fear for further war, negotiation was started.
It was clear then that there was gonna be no more fighting because it was
unbearable to think that Muslims were killing Muslims.
Out of Ali's supporters, the former rebels who assassinated Uthman,
a group emerged who were called the Khawarij.
This was an extremist group who believed in their own interpretation of the Quran.
The Khawarij declared that since Ali decided to negotiate with Muawiyah
rather than punish him, Ali was no longer fit to be caliph.
They revolted.
Ali spent some time trying to finish off this rebellion.
Ali fought the Battle of Naharwan against the Khawarij in 659 CE.
Even though he won the battle, the Khawarij didn't stop being a problem.
They went as far as to kill anyone who wasn't them.
It was a you're either with us or against us kind of situation.
They considered anyone who wasn't on their interpretation of the Quran to be infidel.
Sounds familiar, no?
Meanwhile, the peace talks broke down.
Muawiyah started raiding, even took Egypt from Ali.
Ali had two problems now.
Muawiyah and the Khawarij.
Unfortunately, he didn't live long enough to solve any of them.
On 27th January, 661 CE, Ali was attacked by a Khawarij assassin during prayer in the Great
Mosque of Kufa.
Ali died two days after.
He declared that if he lives, he forgives his assassin.
But if he dies, the assassin will be delivered only one equal hit as to what he had received,
regardless of whether or not the assassin dies from that hit.
Ali is revered in all of Islam.
Shias consider him the first Imam while the Sunnis consider him Muhammad's kin
and love him equally.
Both consider him the fourth rightly guided Caliph.
I personally believe that he was treated very unfairly by the Muslims around him and the
circumstances of his Caliphate were very unfortunate.
Had it not been for the troublesome empire he inherited, he could have made a great,
kind and just ruler.
His son, Hassan ibn Ali eventually gave the Caliphate to Muawiyah in 661 CE, the same
year as Ali's assassination.
Thus, Hassan ended the five-year turbulent period of the first fitna.
Muawiyah ascended to the throne of the Caliphate and yes, I do mean throne,
in a ceremony in Jerusalem.
He established the Umayyad dynasty that ruled the empire through their corruption,
intrigue and plotting for 90 years.
Now, I glossed over a lot of this period, mostly because there's contradictory stories
about the civil war.
Shias and Sunnis have their own versions of them and I found both of them illogical to
be honest and so, I decided to skip over it.
Maybe someday, I'll make a video about both Shia and Sunni versions of the war.
Personally, I believe that none of the parties involved in the war were evil.
Neither Muawiyah nor Ali wanted to shed blood but as wars often do, it went too far.
No one could control what would happen.
Confusion and lack of communication didn't help.
I apologize if I said something wrong in this video and if you send me the correction and
reference for it, I'll upload it.
Thank you and see you next time.
