The watch that killed British watchmaking

Antique Clock
13 followers
15 Video Views·Jan 23, 2026
Hello watch lovers, today we have a Longines pocket watch on the bench, with a piece of technology inside it that led to the downfall of the mighty British watchmaking industry in the 18th and 19th century.
The British invented most of the technical solutions we are familiar with in today's watches, and British watches were the pinnacle of both timekeeping and quiet luxury. But they relied too much on perfecting old ways rather than use new technology and production processes.
In this video we look at one of the main reasons the Swiss won the battle for the watchmaking crown, exemplified in Radu's beautiful Longines pocket watch. Join me for a full breakdown and some tech lingo!
Hello watch lovers! Welcome back to the channel.
It's been a while. I hope you had a good start to the year.
My first video of the year will be on this watch.
The watch that ended the golden era of British watchmaking.
This is a 1911 Longines pocket watch in 14k gold case.
Very nice condition overall.
But, as always, there are a few issues with the watch.
We are going to look at those.
You can see already that that hour hand looks a bit funky.
And the dial does have some cracks that have filled with dirt.
So we're going to try to clean that up as well.
But the overall visual condition of the watch is very fine.
The watch belongs to Radu.
And we can see it has a pull-out lever for setting the time.
And then you wind the watch the, let's say, normal way.
The movement is the Longines 19.70.
But this is a later model.
So it seems it already incorporated some features from the 1970N.
In particular, the regulator with the swan neck and the snail.
Let's put the watch on the timegrapher.
Now, this watch doesn't run to 52 degrees.
So let's turn that to the more correct 45.
So we can already see that the watch runs very fast.
And it's got a pretty bad beat there.
So we are going to have to fix those things.
At this point, we're mostly interested in seeing straight lines.
As that indicates that the train is in good condition.
Before we can take the movement out of the case,
we need to take out the crown and the stem.
Those are actually separate parts in most pocket watches.
And then we can take off the bezel.
And then there are a couple of eccentric screws that hold the movement in the case.
So we're just going to rotate those.
And then we can get the movement out.
And here we can see the dial a little bit better.
You see those cracks on the right side.
So those cracks are probably not too deep.
But they do gather dirt in them.
So they look more pronounced than they actually are.
Let's get the hands off.
And as I said that our hand does not look original.
So we'll see what we can do about that.
Let's just first get the dial and the hands off.
Then we can store them in a safe place.
And by the way, there was a good reason I was absent for quite a while.
That's the reason I launched my own watch brand, Northern Watches.
You can go to northernwatches.com to have a look.
There's currently a promotion for a pre-order for the next batch coming in March-April.
So do check it out.
So with the dial off we are down to the movement.
It is not very complicated on the dial side as we might expect.
Since there are no calendar, that type of complications.
The only small difference perhaps from most watches one is used to seeing is this part here.
That is the lever for putting the watch into time setting mode.
Otherwise very simple.
Likewise on the train side there is one thing that is different.
And that is the key reason why this watch ended the golden era of British watchmaking.
We cannot yet see it, but it is of crucial importance.
Another key difference from the British watches of the time
is that each of the wheels have their own separate cock.
Before LePin introduced this, watches were basically made like clocks
with all the parts between two plates.
So the main benefit of the LePin layout was that the movement could be much thinner.
But it also improved the repairability,
as you could then more easily access one broken part for instance.
But even decades later the British would still make watches with a full plate
or a three-quarter plate covering all the wheels except the escape wheel.
So that the continental watches, so French, German, Swiss,
were thinner, were not the actual deal breaker for people buying watches.
The British watches were still better in a lot of ways.
And the reason for that we will get back to shortly.
Let's just first return to the watch.
We see it's very dirty.
Some of these parts are really sticking.
And there is some play as well in the barrel arbor.
So let's just get everything taken apart so we can clean it up.
And then we can talk a little bit more about
the real breakthrough that killed British watchmaking.
Now I'm sure quite a few of you are sitting there thinking
why on earth is this guy talking about British watchmaking?
I thought watchmaking was Swiss.
Nope.
Pretty much everything in the modern watch,
Swiss or not, is actually based on inventions by British watchmakers.
So basically they had it all and then they threw it all away.
And this is the real killer.
Geneva stopwork.
We'll pay quite some attention to that a little bit later on.
But that simple mechanism, also used in other mechanics by the way,
was the real killer.
It really took away the main weapon the Brits still had
for selling their watches, which was precision.
Anyway, we'll get back to that in a short while.
We're just going to take off the keyless works.
And then we're going to pre-clean the watch a little bit
and get everything into the watch cleaning machine.
And while doing that, we have a special guest.
Who's me?
Huh?
Can you come inside?
I'll come in a few minutes, okay?
I still need to finish some work.
I need to finish some work.
What is it?
Every time you say a few minutes, it takes forever!
I'm going to come in a few minutes and then it's
when I'm going to go to football at six o'clock, you know?
Can you give me a candy from football?
So no candy now.
Have some fruit with me.
Oh, the disappointment in her voice, man.
No candy now, just bloody fruit.
Anyway, here we have the Geneva stopwork.
We are going to take it off for now, clean everything.
And then we're going to run through why it matters afterwards.
What we also see is that the mainspring is an old one
of the old spiral type.
That is the type of mainspring that the Geneva stopwork was made for.
I'm going to see that in a short while.
Let's just finish pre-cleaning some of these parts
and then we're going to get everything into the watch cleaning machine.
While putting the parts into the baskets,
I just want to thank all my members, both on YouTube and Patreon.
Thanks a lot for being patient.
It's been a couple of months even since I last posted a video.
So I really appreciate your support.
As a member, you get unique member videos.
We also have a really nice Discord server
where we help each other out and share experiences and so forth.
You can check it out by clicking the Join button below.
Don't worry, it's not going to take your money right away.
You get to choose a tier and see if you like it.
Or you can go to patreon.com at this URL.
With that, we're going to let the watch cleaning machine do its magic.
In the meantime, let's then turn to why the technology in this watch
was so detrimental to the British watch industry.
So from the illustration before,
we saw that pretty much all innovations in watchmaking were made in England.
So we already discussed that the Lapin layout, as we see here,
really made the bulkiness of English watches a bit less attractive.
Their ace up the sleeve was precision.
A big reason for the lack of precision in old watches
was the power curve of spiral mainsprings.
Fully wound, there's a lot of power.
And then it fades very quickly into a middle section that is somewhat flat.
And then towards the unwinding, there's very little power.
Of course, for a timekeeping device,
you would ideally have constant power from start to end.
The best solution to that would be to have some sort of device
that equaled out the overpowered beginning and the underpowered end.
Enter the Fusée.
The Fusée is a very elegant solution to the problem.
The Fusée is on the right side of this drawing.
On the left side, you have the barrel with the mainspring inside.
Note that the barrel does not have any teeth.
So the Fusée is what actually drives the train of the watch.
So the idea is that the power of the mainspring is then
equaled out by the torque of the Fusée.
So when you have max power in the mainspring wound up on top,
it acts on the smallest diameter of the Fusée and thus the least torque,
which will provide the less power to the train and vice versa when the power is low.
And the English made fantastic watches with Fusée movements.
Real pieces of art.
Very high precision.
Very high quality.
But also very complicated.
The chain itself is very fragile.
If it breaks while the watch is running,
you can imagine the whipping action of that wreaking havoc on the movement.
Also, it's much more difficult to set up, of course,
than modern watches with going barrels.
And lastly, while spiral mainsprings were still common until only 100 years ago,
the escapement in watches improved dramatically over the years.
So while the Fusée was a revolution for precision in old verge escapement watches,
it had much less of an impact in more modern watches with cylinder or lever escapements.
Which brings us back to this curve.
And I promise, this is the last of the technological talk for now, okay?
So if you're still with me, just hang in there for a little bit longer.
So if the main issue in the watch is that
with the spiral mainspring you have this very uneven power development,
what if you simply use the best, most even part of this graph?
And that's where the Geneva stopwork comes in.
It simply stops the watch from being able to use the upper or lower parts of the curve,
and thus provides much more even power development.
Exactly how it does it, we're going to have a look at in a few minutes.
But for now, let's do some actual work on this watch.
We're going to take the balance off so that we can take off the endstones and lubricate them.
Speaking of improvements in watches, this is one of the main hassles of old watches,
that you cannot easily take the endstones or shock settings nowadays out.
You have to more or less dismantle the balance first.
So we're going to clean everything.
It was cleaned mostly already in the cleaning machine,
but I also use a little bit extra cleaning afterwards here, as you saw.
And then we're going to immerse the escapement parts in this Fixodrop solution
that helps lubrication stay in place a little bit better.
As you probably saw, I did try to put the escapement into that little plastic basket,
but it's actually too tall, so I'm going to have to do that manually afterwards.
After the immersion, I'm basically stabbing the pivots of the escape wheel and the pad fork
into some pith wood to remove any residue on the pivots.
And then we can commence with lubricating the endstones.
Note that these are not shock settings, they are just endstones,
just to allow for less friction.
But it would not in any way reduce the risk of breaking the pivot if the watch is dropped,
for instance.
And then we can screw the endstone back in place.
One thing that's nice with these pocket watches is that the screws are all so big, man.
Well, I mean, it depends on what you're used to, of course.
When you're used to 0.2mm screws, then everything else looks huge, obviously.
And that's not to say that watchmakers are used to small things.
I mean, you know, we do lift metal all day, so...
Anyway, we can then put the balance cock back on.
I'm rocking the movement lever back and forth, just to make sure that it isn't trapped,
so that we're not breaking the pivot.
It should be safe from that anyway, since we're now putting in the bottom endstone.
But if there's anything life as a married man has taught me,
it's that you're better safe than sorry.
Anyway, let's see if the balance oscillates freely.
And that looks nice, so we can proceed with the rest of the assembly.
I mentioned before that this movement is the 19.70.
That's what's stamped on the main plate here.
But it might actually be a 1970N, because when I look it up in this tome of a book
I got in the Longines Museum in Saint-Emier,
it definitely looks much more like a 1970N than a 1970.
But it might be that this movement was a very late version of the 19.70,
and just in the transition to 19.70N, or nouveau, new,
because we see the dial side is a little bit different in the N version.
But the train side looks more or less identical to our watch here, or Radu's watch rather.
So that's a little bit of an interesting peculiarity with this specific watch.
Anyway, back in the day they weren't as obsessed with having everything within the parameters.
So there are quite a few watches, movements and so on,
that do not entirely conform to the standards they should.
That's fine.
We're going to put a new mainspring in.
This mainspring is obviously not spiral.
Modern S-shaped mainsprings have largely solved this whole issue of
the non-uniform power distribution.
So the whole curve is much flatter.
So it really isn't any point having Geneva stopwork on this watch,
now that we're putting in a new mainspring.
But we are of course still going to do that,
because it is part of the history of the watch.
This mainspring has a T-end,
so it has two little prongs that have to fit into corresponding holes in the lid and the drum.
With the mainspring in the barrel, let's have a closer look at the Geneva stopwork.
So this barrel is designed for a mainspring that has a total wind of six revolutions of the crown.
The reason we can see that is that there are four arms on this Maltese cross that can be turned,
and then there's a fifth one that blocks the barrel from moving any further.
It blocks it in both directions, meaning that it cuts off the top and the bottom revolution.
So that leaves us with the four full turns of the barrel,
and the much more uniform power distribution curve, and thus better timekeeping.
Now here's a question for you.
What is the trade-off?
What are we losing with this solution?
Let me know in the comments below.
So what this resulted in was a watch that was competitive in terms of timekeeping.
Still not as good as a Fusee watch,
but it was much cheaper both to buy and to repair, and much less fragile.
All right, time to bring out the watchmaker's sledgehammer.
This bad boy is going to wreak some serious havoc on the barrel bridge.
We've seen that there's a little bit too much play in the barrel arbor bearing in the barrel bridge.
I'm going to close that hole with a couple of stakes,
and some violent hammering.
So cover your ears.
And after that mayhem of hammering, we're testing it a couple of times,
and I'm using a smoothing broach to make sure that it's a good fit,
but that the barrel still moves freely.
So with that, let's move on to a different problem.
So the third wheel, the ruby, is cracked,
and that makes the watch not run so well, especially in the vertical positions.
So I took the jewel out.
It just comes out in pieces, of course.
Now there are a couple of issues here.
First of all, the old jewel was rubbed in,
meaning that there's a little piece of brass on top and under it that keeps it in place.
But nowadays it is very difficult to find jewels of the same sizes.
They simply do not make them anymore.
So the only jewel I found with the correct pivot hole size was actually so big
that instead of being able to rub it in,
I would have to open the hole up and then press fit the jewel.
So that's what I've been doing here.
I first open the hole up with the staking tools,
and then I use the smoothing broach to get a uniform round surface.
And then I was gonna press the jewel in until I messed things up.
So I'm not entirely sure what happened,
but I think it was a moment of lack of attention.
So I managed to mark the cock.
Now this might not have been such an issue if the finishing of the cock was somewhat different.
But this also gave me an excuse to find the proper pair of hands for the watch.
So I got this old movement.
Still possible to find.
So I could then cannibalize it and take the cock as needed.
And I then also took the hands.
We're gonna get back to those in a little while.
Let's now finish reassembling the watch.
Most of the reassembly is pretty straightforward.
It is, after all, a very simple watch.
No complications.
It also has small seconds, which is then directly driven by the fourth wheel.
So very simple in that way.
We did notice that the Keyless Works is a little bit different
because you have this separate lever to pull the sliding pinion into time setting position.
But it's, again, not complicated.
I wasn't entirely sure of the best order to reassemble it, however.
So you will see parts magically disappear and reappear.
So I mentioned the Longines Museum.
So the Longines factory is actually still in the same place.
It's always been in a small village up in the Jura Mountains called Saint-Imier,
in an area that the locals called Longines.
So the long meadows or long flats along the river there in the little valley bottom.
Longines has contributed a lot to watchmaking.
It is one of the oldest companies and, in my view, a bit, yeah, unappreciated today.
It is absolutely one of my favorite brands for watches.
I think what Longines did in the days before the quartz crisis were just really, really good.
But nowadays they are a bit relegated to at least second place behind Omega.
So, yeah.
Anyway, let's turn to the train side.
The click spring is in the underside of the barrel bridge.
So we need to remember that.
And then we can put in the wheels and the windbreaks.
So one question I do get quite frequently is what type of watch is good for beginners to work on.
And what I always say is that you should start working on watches
that are already in the running condition.
Because if you try to start working on watches that do not run,
you're going to run into a whole lot of frustration
trying to figure out what's wrong and so forth.
And of course, if you do get across a pocket watch like this,
and it is running, then you probably won't have to try to find spare parts.
So you don't have to go through that frustration.
And of course, everything is big.
So it's much easier to work on with the big screws, big parts, solid parts.
Much less chance of destroying things.
So old pocket watches are really good candidates for that.
After that, I would say watches from the Soviet Union are good.
They are cheap, sturdy, and also old Cycos are brilliant for learning watchmaking.
What I'm doing here is just to make sure that all the wheels
have their pivots in the jewel holes before screwing anything down.
That way we don't risk breaking the pivots that would necessitate a search for wheels and so forth.
And with everything running, we can then put the pallet fork in.
And then we're going to take the movement over to the microscope
and then lubricate the pallet stones.
Now, I have seen people lubricating pallet stones without the microscope.
And I think younger people probably would manage.
But personally, I just turned 57 and have more than one foot in the grave, I think.
So microscope it is.
I'm putting the lubrication on the exit pallet stone.
And then basically turning the movement a little bit
so that all the teeth and escape gets a little bit of lubrication.
And we're also going to lubricate the rest of the train and put in the balance.
So there are still a couple of issues.
First of all, we of course have to adjust the watch.
And if you remember, the beat error was quite high.
And in this old type of watch, we have to actually turn the collet on the balance staff.
To find out which way we have to turn it, we have to look at where the pallet fork ends up.
When the power is off, we can see the pallet comes to rest
quite a bit closer to the right banking pin.
So then I'm trying to see how much I need to adjust the collet.
Or move the collet to get to the right beat error.
And I have to try this a few times, but ultimately we get to a decent rate.
There is, however, a different problem.
We can see the watch still runs much too fast.
And if we look at the regulator, it's actually at its slowest.
So when adjusting the watch, you would turn that snail.
And that would then move the index a little bit back and forth.
And thus change the timekeeping.
But when it's at its lowest, then we need to look at the balance instead.
The balance has these four timing screws.
And by turning those a little bit outwards, we slow the balance down a little bit.
So with that done, we see that the beat rate is good.
And the timekeeping is also good.
So we can then finish the watch up.
Let's get the dial and the hands back on.
And case the watch.
Off camera, I did clean the case in Gold Solution.
So that's already done and waiting for us.
But the dial, we also need to clean.
So you might remember that it had these cracks with some greenish color on it.
I'm not sure where that color comes from.
But we will try to remove most of it.
And the way we do that is simply by using denture cleaning tablets.
That does a really good job of cleaning the dirt out of those cracks on the dial.
There will be slight remnants, of course.
We are not removing the cracks.
But they will be much less visible with the dirt most removed.
With the dial back on, we can then turn to the hands.
This bottom hand here is this replacement hour hand.
Away you go.
So the hands that we got from their spare movement are the correct ones.
I cleaned them a little bit off camera.
And now the hour and minute hands actually look like they belong together.
Slightly different color.
But that is to be expected of an old watch like this.
Of course, when they are from different watches.
So with that we can case the movement.
This would be classified as a hunter type watch.
Because it has the crown at the three o'clock position.
And also because the dial is completely covered.
The last thing to do then is to get the bezel back on.
And then the watch is pretty much ready.
Before seeing it, not on the wrist,
I just want to remind everyone that at vintagewatchservices.eu
you will always find more than 100 beautiful vintage watches.
And as a YouTube subscriber you can use this coupon code for 10% off.
And there we have it.
Brado's beautiful old Longines pocket watch.
Longines is absolutely one of my favorite brands.
And this watch carries a lot of history with it.
I hope you enjoyed this video.
Let me know in the comments if you thought it was too much theory.
Or if you think that was good.
Also, if you liked the video, feel free to click like and subscribe.
I'll be back with another video shortly.
Until then, ta ta.
