Something Terrible Is Happening in China _ VisualEconomik EN

Global Finance News
11 followers
China has a big problem. And no, this time we're not talking about the real estate market,
local government debt, deflation or low domestic consumption. These are all complex problems,
with many nuances, positives and negatives. The problem we're talking about today is much
simpler to understand but no less important. China's high-stakes struggle to defy demographic
disaster. China's over 60 population sits at 297 million, or 21% of the total. By 2050,
those figures are expected to reach 520 million and 38%.
As you know, on Visual Economic we love to talk about demographics,
and with good reason. We're facing one of the world's major economic challenges,
and not just in developed countries. This isn't only about paying pensions. An ageing population
is also a much less innovative population, not to mention that fewer heads simply means
fewer ideas. When it comes down to it, demographic winter is a pincer attack. On the one hand,
it increases the share of the population that doesn't work but still needs to be supported.
And on the other hand, it slows down the rate at which the productive part of the population
is able to increase its productivity. Believe me, the magnitude of this problem cannot be
underestimated, especially in China. In 1950, Chinese women had an average of
six children each. Today, only one. By 2010? And so it's estimated that their population
could drop by up to 55%, becoming a country of just 650 million inhabitants, many of whom
will be grey-haired. As a result, the Chinese will go from representing 20% of the world's
population to only six. Or to put it another way, by 2050, China is expected to spend 30%
less on education, because there will be no children to educate, while spending 30% more
on healthcare. You can already see it on screen, the demographic pyramid will become a lollipop.
For many analysts, demographics are one of the main drivers of Chinese policy.
From the huge investment it has made in capital when its working age population was enormous,
to its increased aggression towards Taiwan. The idea, of course, is to make a move now,
that China is in a strong position, and not when it has half the population.
But hold on a minute, because the situation is not as simple as it seems at first glance.
For this very reason, we at Visual Economic have taken a deep dive into this issue,
and today we're going to answer the following questions.
How will demographic winter affect China's economy?
Can the disaster of the one-child policy be reversed?
And does the Asian giant really face a much bigger challenge than the rest of the world?
In this video, we're going to tell you all about it, so let's get started.
It's January, and while most people are planning new goals,
the smart ones are already focusing on AI. Because at this pace,
2026 could be a turning point. That's why I want to tell you about Outskill,
the first ever AI-focused educational platform to accelerate AI learning for regular people,
not only engineers. This weekend, they're hosting a two-day live AI mastermind training
running Saturday and Sunday from 10am to 7pm EST. And it's the perfect moment to join,
because you can get in absolutely free as part of their New Year Upskilling Fest.
This 16-hour AI training has already built 10 million plus AI-first professionals worldwide,
and is rated 4.9 out of 5 on Trustpilot. Without skill, you'll learn how to build AI
agents that plan, write, execute, and report for you. Automate workflows that keep running
even when you're offline. Connect tools like Sheets, Notion, CRMs, and email into smart systems.
Use AI to save hours every week and gain a real advantage at work. Not just that,
you'll also learn how to profit from these skills. People who've taken this training
have used what they've learned to build AI-powered services that now bring in
roughly $2,000 to $3,000 a week. You also get premium lifetime bonuses like the AI Prompt
Bible, the AI Profit Roadmap, your personalized AI Toolkit Builder, only if you attend both days.
And another great bonus, when you sign up, you'll get access to the 2026 AI Survival Hackbook,
outlining what's coming next in the world of AI and how to prepare. Seats are limited,
so check the link in the description to secure yours, and join the WhatsApp community to stay
updated. The decline in China's birth rate has been brutal, but as you all know, this didn't
happen on its own. At the time, this was precisely the goal of the Chinese Communist Party,
to have fewer children. You all know about the One Child Policy and the terrible human tragedy
it caused, a human tragedy that now threatens to become an economic disaster. What you may
not have known is that this policy was not the Chinese government's first antinatalist measure.
Ten years earlier, one of Mao Zedong's last policies before his death was the LLF campaign,
which stood for Later, Longer, and Fewer. In other words, it encouraged women to have
children later, to have fewer children, and thus devote more resources to each child,
so that their lives would be longer. And as you can see in this graph,
its impact on the birth rate was immediate. The number of children per woman had already
fallen by almost 20% before the One Child Policy. You already know how the rest of the story goes,
but pay attention because something needs to be clarified. The idea that the policy
encouraged women to have fewer children is a simple euphemism.
In reality, the Chinese Communist Party used every means at its disposal to ensure
that this was the case. Forced abortions, sterilizations, and even food rationing.
And then came the One Child Policy, which added fuel to the fire.
Fortunately, this policy was gradually relaxed, although it was not officially
abolished until, wait for it, 2015. The limit was then raised to two children,
then to three, and finally, in 2021, the cap was removed once and for all.
And it wasn't just eliminated. Xi Jinping has made a 180 degree turn.
Whereas before his party did everything possible to prevent women from having more than one child,
it has now approved gigantic birth subsidies, particularly subsidies focused on having three
or more children. One example is the national subsidy for children under three, which amounts
to $500 per year. Not bad, considering that despite the skyscrapers and neon lights,
30% of workers earn less than $300 per month. Yes, we are taking into account that the shopping
basket does not cost the same in China as it does in the US. We are also taking into account
public subsidies and non-monetary sources of income. However, this is just one small example.
Most provinces and other local governments have their own aid schemes. For example,
in Hubei, there is a subsidy for the third child of up to $22,000 over the child's lifetime.
Although other governments are taking a slightly different approach.
China to tax condoms for the first time in 30 years as demographic crisis deepens
Clearly, you can't say they're not trying. Will all these measures work to reverse the
demographic winter? Well, it's too early to say. But the truth is that even the central
government is not very optimistic. The fact is that the consequences of
anti-natalist policies are more profound than they appear at first glance. Remember the campaign we
mentioned a few minutes ago? Well, this campaign did not affect all Chinese people equally,
only the dominant ethnic group, the Hun. However, the other ethnic groups who were
not affected by this policy also still had fewer children. Specifically, up to 0.65 fewer children
for each standard deviation of proximity to the Hun ethnic group. Or in less technical terms,
an absolute outrage. This happened for two reasons. The first is easy to understand.
Simple cultural imitation. If your neighbors have fewer children, you will probably have
fewer children. But there's a second reason that also makes it difficult to reverse the damage
caused by these policies. You see, because the Hun had fewer children, they invested more
in each child's education. And with more education, these children had a better chance of getting the
best jobs. How did the rest react? Well, the wealthier ethnic groups, those with socio-economic
status similar to that of the Hun, also voluntarily cut back on the number of births so they could
invest more in their children and thus ensure that their families did not fall off the elite ladder.
Do you understand now why it's so difficult to boost the birth rate? A race has been created
in which no one wins. But if you drop out, you lose.
So no, if other developed countries haven't managed to slow down demographic winter with
birth subsidies, it's very unlikely that China will succeed. And that's why we read news stories
like this. China raises retirement age for first time since 1950s. The top legislative
body on Friday approved proposals to raise the statutory retirement age from 50 to 55
for women in blue collar jobs and from 55 to 58 for females in white collar jobs.
Men will see an increase from 60 to 63.
Yes, yes, I know that the retirement age in China is still very,
very low and they're raising it very gradually. But don't be fooled by this,
the demographic problem is enormous. While in the 1970s there were up to 10 young people
between the ages of 35 to 65 for every retiree, by 2050 there will be fewer than two and,
according to some estimates, closer to one. What's more, the retirement age in China has a catch.
The Chinese retire early, yes, but they also work many more hours during their working lives,
between 10 to 15 hours per week more than in wealthier countries. And although they
begin to reduce their working hours five years earlier than in other countries, 65-year-olds,
even though in theory could retire, still work more hours than most workers in developed countries
who are not yet officially retired at that age. Furthermore, as a matter of interest,
in China there's practically no difference in the number of hours worked between men and women,
despite the fact that women retire much earlier. Meanwhile, in the West,
women over 50 tend to work about 10 hours less than men even before they retire. So,
could Chinese people over the age of 45 extend their working hours to compensate for the aging
population? Technically, yes, but that would mean working twice as many hours as their counterparts
in rich countries. And even then, it wouldn't be enough. Simply to offset the hours lost due
to the aging population in 2050, all young people between the ages of 20 and 49 would have to work
between 8 and 9 extra hours per week. Of course, instead of working longer hours, another alternative
is to make each hour worked more productive. Now, this is not so crazy. You all know that China is
killing it with technology. In fact, it's the number one country in the world that is adding
the most industrial robots to its economy, and not just in absolute terms. There are already
factories producing complex products such as cars that operate in the dark because they're 100%
automated, without the need for any workers. They also have drones that clean solar panels,
maintain their huge high-speed network, and even clean the streets completely automatically.
Seen in this light, the demographic challenge doesn't seem so daunting, does it? Well,
unfortunately, it's not that simple. Despite the Asian giant's technological boom,
the truth is that the productivity of its economy is declining. This is completely normal,
it happens to everyone, but now what matters is that China is not managing to break this trend.
To achieve a 4.9% growth target, China would need to grow its productivity by 5.5% a year.
While Chinese annual productivity growth over the past quarter-century has been impressive,
above 8% it has slowed down more recently. Since the pandemic and through 2023,
Chinese productivity grew by 5.2% annually. That's right, just to offset the demographic
impact, Chinese productivity would have to grow at 5.5%, but these days it's already increasing
below that rate. And with a downward trend. But the bad news doesn't end there. According to some
studies, Chinese productivity is not only slowing down a little, over the next few years, it could
come to a screeching halt. And you don't need an ultra-complex, abstract model to make this
prediction. In fact, these are the conclusions of an extremely simple model. Yes, I know what
you're thinking. If it's so simple, can it really predict something so complex? Economists can't
even predict a brutal economic crisis when it's just around the corner. Well, of course, they
could be wrong. But there are reasons to think that perhaps they're not so far off the mark.
Here you can see the evolution of Chinese productivity in relation to US productivity.
The red line shows the actual data, what has already happened. And the blue line
shows the model's predictions according to a study by economist Jesús Fernández-Villaverde.
But that's not all. If this were the only evidence, what can I say? It would be a very
weak argument. Even so, take note. We don't know if the model's predictions will come true for
China. But what we do know is that the same model perfectly predicts what has happened in
other countries such as South Korea. And although we aren't showing it on screen,
we could also give you the examples of Japan, Hong Kong or Taiwan. The same pattern holds true
in all of them. Of course, this is only a prediction. But is China really doing
exceptionally better than South Korea, Japan or Taiwan in their respective golden ages?
Probably not. So don't be surprised if Chinese productivity starts to stagnate around 2040.
And in case anyone is curious if the predictions of this model are correct,
China's GDP per capita in 2100 will be something like 45% of that of the United States at that
time. Now, that's not bad at all, but it's certainly a long way from what Xi Jinping
would like. So does all this mean it's game over for China? Well, let's not get ahead of ourselves.
China's problems will begin around 2050, more or less. Until then,
the Asian giant will enjoy enviable demographics. Until 2030, there will be 2.2 adults for every
Chinese person of non-working age, that is, children and retirees. That's what Japan achieved
in its golden age. And in China, the figure will decline more slowly. In other words,
China still has demographic muscle for a while. But there's more.
Highly qualified professionals in China, the great engineers behind the success of Huawei or BYD,
are very, very young. Keep in mind that until just 15 years ago, China placed very little
importance on university education. These days, however, it's a priority. And it's estimated that
by 2040, 40% of the workforce will have gone to university. That's about 400 million university
students. In absolute terms. What's more, the urbanization rate in China is between 60 and 65%,
so there's still room to bring people out of the countryside, which could help maintain
economic momentum. Of course, let's not forget that half of all poverty reduction in China is
explained by improvements within rural areas, not by the exodus to urban areas. Clearly,
this comes up against a major problem, the hukou. The hukou is a system, or rather,
a tangle of systems, that basically discriminates against rural Chinese compared to those in cities.
Basically, if you have a rural hukou, it's really difficult to migrate to the city with
your family without losing your rural property and rights to government services,
such as comprehensive health care. The reason why this exists is enough for an entire video.
But let's just say that it was not in the interest of Chinese politicians to encourage
domestic immigration. So they tied many Chinese people to the place of their birth.
Xi Jinping is doing everything he can to undo this system, but there are parts of it that
still remain and are very difficult to combat, because they have created a very unstable
political balance. Which creates an additional problem. As many of you already know, China has
currency controls in the style of Peronist Argentina. In practice, this means that most
Chinese people cannot invest in the S&P 500 or any similar financial instrument. So where do
they invest their life savings? In housing. Particularly in cities. What will happen to
the price of this housing? The pension plan for several generations, when China's population is
halved. Especially if there continue to be barriers to migrating from the countryside to the city.
I suppose there's no need to explain. In short, demographic winter threatens everyone.
China is no exception. Quite the contrary. It is one of the most concerning cases.
Economic stagnation is terrible, but it's not the same when you're rich,
as when many people still live in poverty. Take Japan, for instance. Its economy has not
grown for decades. But hey, Tokyo is still a great place to live. In the case of Japan,
the ratio of workers to pensioners began to fall significantly when its GDP per capita was $40,000
per person. China, on the other hand, started when its GDP per capita was just a quarter of that.
There are still a few decades to go before these bad omens become real problems. But take note,
because when those problems arrive, they're going to be very, very serious.
Let's hope that both China and the rest of the world find a way to ride the wave.
In any case, now it's your turn. Did you know how far the impact of
communist China's anti-birth policies reached? Is the economic challenge really greater than
in developed countries? Do you think the Asian giant will achieve the productivity
boom that neither Japan, South Korea nor Taiwan have achieved? You can leave your
comments below. And don't forget that here on Visual Economic we release new videos every week
so subscribe if you haven't already to make sure you don't miss any of our upcoming episodes.
If you liked this video, hit like. I'll see you in the next one, take care, see you next time.
