House & Senate Republican Media Availability | Jan. 20, 2026

Washington State House Republicans
23 followers
Jan 21, 2026
Washington state House and Senate Republican leaders are holding a live media availability to discuss the 2026 legislative session.
Good morning everyone. Welcome to today's joint Republican media availability.
I'm Kimberly Wertz, Communications Director for the Senate Republicans.
I'm joined today by Senate Republican Leader John Braun from the 20th Legislative District,
Senate Republican Caucus Chair Judy Warnick from the 13th District, House Republican Leader
Drew Stokesberry from the 31st District, and House Republican Floor Leader April Connors
from the 8th Legislative District. With that, I will invite Senator Braun to provide opening comments.
Well, thanks Kim. Thanks everyone for joining us here on the in the second week of session.
I think there's not a lot new to talk about that we didn't talk about last week.
Top issue with Washingtonians across, excuse me, across the state is still affordability,
affordability, affordability, and we're looking at every bill that comes across
at least our desks with a view towards what's it going to do to the ability of folks in
Washington to afford food, gas, housing, child care, health care, and many other things that
make life in Washington possible. And while that is going on, we're not hearing a whole
lot about the budget. We did hear, of course, the governor's budget a few days ago and heard a lot
of, got a lot of feedback on that. I think it's kind of a mixed bag. We have a lot to do to make
sure we live within our means. What is striking that in spite of the absolute disaster that our
budget is in as a result of overspending by the democratic majorities, there's very little talk
about it from members of the caucus or willingness to take it on. Instead they're talking about and
quietly introduced at least to the business community last night is a draft of an income tax
that is 100 percent, in my estimation, a small business income tax. This is a tax that goes
directly after small companies in the forms of LLCs and S-corps and will drive them out of the
state or just plain out of business. This is bad in every imaginable way and of course is opposed
to the long historic opposition by the people of the state of Washington and characterizing it as
something that only goes after a certain set of individuals does not make it any more so,
especially when the actual words say this will put a small business out of business across our state
or move them into other states across the country. Lots of other bad bills to talk about, a few good
bills to talk about, but I'll stop right there and turn it over to my colleague, Representative
Stokesberry on the other side of the rotunda. Yeah, thank you, Senator Braun. Good morning,
everybody. Thanks for joining us. Happy day nine of session. I don't have a lot to add. Senator
Braun's right. There hasn't been a ton of things going on since we talked to you all last week,
but I will point out, you know, we're now day nine of session. On her opening day speech to the
speaker, talked about affordability in his state of the state remarks. The governor spoke about
affordability. They tried to blame it on President Trump, sort of forgetting the fact that Washington
has been very unaffordable since Joe Biden was president. But more importantly, and more to the
point for this week, you know, nine days in a session and there still aren't any Democrat bills
moving that address the affordability crisis and there are lots of Republican bills that would
address the affordability crisis that Democrats are refusing to give hearings to. Perhaps the
most offensive in a darkly funny way. Bill is a bill by representative partially out of Olympia
that would impose a new tire fee to deal with mitigation of the impacts of a complicated and
difficult to pronounce chemical in tires. You know, so again, how are we helping affordability
by making drivers pay a new fee to the state for every tire they get? But more alarmingly,
the bill not only prohibits tire sellers from informing customers about that tax. The bill
says that it's illegal for the seller of tires to tell the customers that they're going to pay this
tax. So, you know, Democrats not only are making life more unaffordable, but now they're trying to
hide the ball and make it so consumers don't realize what Olympia politicians are doing to
make everyday essentials like tires more expensive. As Senator Brown pointed out, one of the things
going on behind the scenes right now is a draft of the Democrats' income tax bill is circulating.
And he's absolutely right. This would devastate small businesses. I also think devastate a lot
of other sectors of the state's economy. There's a really complicated, not that complicated,
but it sounds complicated, tax policy involving what's known as loss carry forwards. Basically
says if you lose money in one year, you get to apply that loss in a future year. Federal tax
policy recognizes these. The state income tax would disallow you to carry forward losses. That
might sound complicated or not a big deal, but what it means is any sort of capital intensive
business that has losses in the early years and profits in the later years would never get credit
for the losses they incur as they build up to the profits. What sector does this probably hit
the hardest? The housing sector. We're in the middle of a housing crisis, and Democrats want
to impose an income tax on the folks who are deploying capital to build the housing we
desperately need and to disincentivize their investment in those projects by prohibiting
loss carry forwards. Just an unbelievably adolescent view of tax policy and will do
absolutely more harm than good if we ever want to solve the state's housing crisis.
More broadly, if we want to continue Washington's economic powerhouse, we cannot be
messing with tax policy and doing things like prohibiting loss carry forwards. That will just
immediately dry up capital investment here in Washington. I should have mentioned at the outset,
we have also joining us from the House, Representative April Connors, our House
open it up to questions. Thank you. We will start with Jerry Cornfield from the Washington
State Standard. Jerry, do you have any questions today? Good morning. Thank you. Two questions
for Senator Braun and Representative Stokesberry. First, your meeting with Governor Ferguson later
today. It looks like it's one of the first formal meetings of the session. I guess I wonder what
questions do you have for the governor? What requests do you have of the governor? What do
you want to accomplish in this meeting? And then secondly, just because you mentioned
Representative Stokesberry, have either of you seen a draft that's circulating of the income tax bill?
Yeah, so I guess I'll jump in there. Yeah, first meeting of the session, I expect it'll
largely be just cordial and, and getting good things, you know, kind of get started meeting.
Although I plan to press on both budget issues. And I've had some discussion with the governor
and some provide some feedback on his proposed budget. And there's some one or two good things
and some things that I think do considerable harm. I will talk about that. Without I'm certain we'll
talk about the income tax. And I'm curious to hear from the governor how he explains it intends to
preside over a state that has folks fleeing left and right as a result of an income tax,
it's going to put put small business out, out of business. So I'm super curious to see how he came
to that conclusion. For a person who seems you know, claims to care about representing the people
and the democratic process to ignore repeated opposition to income tax and the undeniable
economic impact of this sort of a proposal. So the last thing I would say is he has said on a
couple occasions, he he will only do this if there's some tax relief for small businesses.
But we've yet to see anything that's really meaningful. Everything is just words and words
that you know, saying that we're going to protect small businesses is not the same as actually
protecting small businesses. So I think expect that will be the discussion. And yes, there was
a copy of the draft copy of the income tax bill that was released to the business community. It
wasn't actually sent to me at least maybe it was sent to represent Stokes Ferry. We did get a copy
and we have looked at it. I have looked at it. Yeah, I'll echo what Senator Braun said. I also
got a copy yesterday. It was not sent to me directly by the democrat leadership that's
circulating it but it was sent to me by another member of the democratic caucus. And so I've
looked at it as well. And that kind of informed my comments on among other things, the very
problematic issues with disallowing law security forwards. As for our meeting with the governor,
again, like Senator Braun said, I think we'll talk a lot about the budget. I introduced a bill
the other day, my first bill of this entire term, I didn't introduce any bills last session.
I've got my hands full with with caucus leadership obligations. But we found an ability to save the
about $10 million a biennium by consolidating the investment office at University of Washington
and having their endowment be invested through the state investment board,
which over the long term has achieved better investment returns for much lower fees. And so
by shifting that function away from U-Dub's dedicated endowment office and over to the state
investment board, we can save taxpayers about $10 million a year. Certainly won't solve the budget
crisis entirely. But every little bit helps. And it's absolutely something we should be looking at.
We've got a couple other budget savings ideas. Like Senator Braun said, I think we'll talk a lot
about the income tax, I want to understand what what has led his transformation over the last 365
days to, you know, oppose a wealth tax and give all the reasons why that would really hamstring
Washington's economy. And then less than a year later, decide that income tax is not a problem
at all. So I want to understand his logic there. And to the extent this is something that Democrats
are insistent on passing, we got to figure out how to make it the least impactful to Washington.
I don't know if that's possible, but we'll be talking about some of the details.
And then the last thing on my end, we've got a transportation crisis out in my district,
we've got a bridge that DOT didn't bother warning anybody about was about to fail for
decades. And now it's failed. And it's depriving all of Washington the ability to access one of
the state's crown jewels of Mount Rainier. And more importantly, it is just absolutely devastating
the local economies of a couple of towns, a couple of very small towns in East Pierce County. So we
need we need some relief there. So those are a couple of things we'll be talking about from my
end. Great, terrific. Jerry, was that it for you? Oh, yeah. Thank you. Great. Thank you. Okay, next
I'll turn to Carleen Johnson, from the center square. Carleen, go ahead with your question.
Good morning. Thanks, Kim. My question that might go to the hearing this afternoon on Senate Bill
5973. This is the one to, I guess, make the initiative process even a bigger challenge.
Any of you have thoughts on that bill? Obviously, we've heard that we're not going to get hearings
on either of the initiatives to the legislature that are currently sitting here, they're going to
hunt those to the ballot. What are your thoughts on this bill 5973?
Anti-democratic, it's a continued effort of the by the democratic majority to hide hide from the
public when it comes to actual policies that people care about when they get a beach day.
These are very popular cross partisan line initiatives and their responses to not only
not hear them, but make it more difficult for the people to present initiatives to the legislature
in the future. 100% anti-democratic and, you know, at odds with the clear intent of the state's
constitution. Yeah, it's just such schizophrenic messaging from Democrats, you know, they say,
oh, you know, we're going to send these initiatives to the ballot and we're confident voters will
reject them. They were, you know, they were confident and albeit turned out to be correct
that voters were going to reject the three initiatives that made it to the ballot two
years ago. But at the same time, you know, they want to stack the deck, too. They want to change
the rules on how the ballot title is formulated. Now they want to make it harder to qualify
initiatives in the first place. Doesn't make a lot of sense. If you're confident the voters are with
you on policy, why do you need to make it harder for folks who disagree to put the question before
voters if you know voters are going to ultimately side with your idea? And I think it's also part
of a broader theme where Olympia politicians want to blame other people and disclaim their own fault
and their own role in the process. The same attitude that says we should make it really,
really difficult for citizens to put initiatives on the ballot is the exact same attitude driving
the House Bill 2421 I mentioned a second ago, where we're going to raise taxes on tires and
prohibit tire sellers from telling their customers that their taxes just got raised.
All part of the same theme, which I think is awfully chilling for democracy. And there's
an irony that the folks who cry loudest about chilling democracy are the ones in this state
chilling at the most. I just pipe in, Carlene. I don't have the testifying list for that bill
in front of me. I've been following mostly the House bills. But typically in the past,
even our secretary of state has been opposed to changes to the initiative. So I think
we'll take a look at that and get back to you on that. But I think that's important to note.
When we have our Secretary of State's office saying the process is working, it's okay.
We shouldn't be making these changes. We should be listening to our Democrat Secretary of State
on those items. Yeah, I believe Secretary Hobbs and former Secretary Reed testified together in
the Senate. I just wanted a quick follow up on that. I've heard some suggestions that I know
you get a longer timeframe to gather signatures if you go to the legislature first versus
gathering to just going straight to the ballot. But given the recent history of lawmakers here
just sort of undoing the will of the people, maybe all these initiatives should just go
directly to the people and then they're safe for two years anyway. Either of you have thoughts on
that or any of you? The Constitution provides both options. I think it depends on the situation. But
I'm certainly not opposed to them coming directly to the legislature. I'm just opposed to the way
that the Democratic majority leaders are dismissive of the will or the desires of the people.
Carlene, did you have a follow up question?
Any thoughts on the... I think there's only one bill alive yet. I think Senator Wellman's
bill is not going to get a hearing. I've been told, as far as making it more difficult to
access public records for DCYF providers. But I think Senator Wilson's bill is still
alive that would maybe water down the Oversight Board a bit certainly and change the name of the
Oversight Board to the Accountability Board because somebody was offended by the word oversight.
Any of you have any comments on that? I'm sort of indifferent on the name. They can name it
whatever they want. What I care about is that actually does something. And the reality is
we put this board in place, I think, in 2017, to provide some level of real
effort by legislature and others to hold the agency accountable. In spite of efforts by some
good people on that board, we failed. The agency is out of control across the board, whether it's
juvenile rehabilitation, which I've talked about a lot, or child protective services, or foster care,
or managing our child care system. They have failed, in many cases dramatically,
on virtually every front. So I don't think the name matters at all. What we need is a board that
really has some ability to move things in a good direction in that agency, or a governor that's
going to get really involved and take a hand in getting it back on the right track. And I'll just
add, in addition to the oversight responsibility that we've got, there's also an underlying
issue with the sort of substantive law and the standards for how DCYF is operating in these
situations. We've got to fix this imminent harm standard, which turns out to not really
be applied in a way that is actually saving kids' lives. Travis Couture has a bill, House Bill 1092,
that would actually effectively fix this issue. It was introduced last session. I mean, this is
just brutally sad, but had the legislature passed that bill last session, more than one child in
the state's care would be alive right now who isn't. And that's pretty inexcusable to play
partisan politics over this. So we've got to take action, not just on avoiding watering down our
oversight responsibility, but we've got to fix the underlying law too. And I don't think Republicans
care who gets credit for the bill, but I know that we've got a bill that would fix a lot of
the problems. And I think Democrats should take it seriously, and I hope they do. And I agree with
that. I was on that oversight board, but with added responsibility, I stepped off. But we need
to look at what's happening, especially with our foster kids or the kids that have been removed
from a home. When we find a nine-year-old boy living in a tent on the street in Seattle, and
it's the judge's prerogative to leave him there with drugs and other activities going on.
Something's wrong. Something's wrong with our system if that happens. Thank you.
Thank you very much, Carly. And next, we will go to Jonathan Martin. Jonathan, are you
prepared with a question today? Yeah, I wanted to ask you about the tort liability issue. I saw
DINGRA and Peterson dropped a bill to create basically a civil claims process for the bills.
I know, Senator Braun, you and I have talked about this issue. What are your plans, a session for
dealing with not just the deficit that is running, but the structural problem?
So, I haven't studied that bill. I'm familiar with the idea. I'm not necessarily, what I know
of it, I'm not necessarily opposed to simplifying and perhaps reducing the cost of some of these
claims. That's not the underlying issue. The underlying issue is we have repeatedly seen a
state fail with people, specifically children, in their care over many years. And some of these
claims go back many years or even decades. But a lot of them are happening more recently. And I
can tell you, just based on my experience with juvenile rehabilitation, there's a whole host of
claims that have occurred that probably haven't even been filed yet based on activities at Green
Hill in particular in the last couple of years. So, I mean, I think Republicans have been talking
about some type of tort reform for a long, long time. It's hard to believe. I mean, without knowing
exactly the details, it's hard to believe we would be opposed. But the underlying issue is the state
is failing in an enormous and tragic way when it comes to caring for people that we're responsible
for. And we got to do better there. We can't just fix the cost. We should fix the real problem
underneath. That's where the true problem is. And, as I've said before, it's often tragic and
often involves small children. Yeah, I agree with that. I mean, I pointed this out of the AP
pre-session media thing. I think part of the problem is structural. You've got the same
political party who's been responsible for all the senior appointments in government since literally
the day I was born. Forty years of single-party rule means that you're not going to have new
ideas. You're not going to have old ideas challenged. You're not going to have accountability.
And I think that's been a huge structural problem and part of why we've been failing
so much in our responsibility in terms of the folks under our care. I mentioned a second ago
in the context of Colleen's question, one of the areas where the state has failed the most recently
is DCYF. I noted that there's a Travis Couture bill that I think would get at some
of those underlying issues and allow us to do a better job of getting kids out of harmful
situations before they become tragic and before the state incurs liability. So, in addition
to actually avoiding liability in the first place, which I think has to do with management,
the other thing I'll point out, Senator Bryant's talked about this too, we've got to focus our
hiring and staffing efforts on frontline workers. We've not really grown our frontline workers in
many agencies, but we really have grown our middle management ranks. It ought to be the
opposite. We ought to have as few middle managers as possible and as many frontline workers as
possible and I think that would help the problem. So, you know, other than avoiding the incurring
liability in the front end, the other big structural issue is we've got a very generous
system of joint and several liability in Washington State where the state can be liable for, you know,
up to 100% of damages when we're only 1% at fault. There's a fundamental unfairness to the state and
taxpayers in that regard. I hope that someday we can get in a position where we talk about
reforming that. In the meantime, I think the smallest baby step we can take this session
realistically is House Bill 2255, which is actually a Democrat bill sponsored by Amy Wallen,
although our caucus's representative Jim Walsh is a co-sponsor. That would at least require,
it wouldn't change joint and several liability, but would at least require disclosure of who's
financing litigation efforts and I think that might be a very tiny baby step towards
a little bit more fairness in our tort system. Thank you. Jonathan, do you have a follow-up call
or I'm sorry? Yeah, you have one other follow-up. Yeah, related to the 340B issue, the drug pricing
issue, wondering where your caucuses are at on that issue? Well, this is a complicated issue and
I think we're just starting the conversation and it has both a potential short-term and long-term
impact. The hospitals who we've supported very strongly in the past have concerns about the
340B program or FQHCs around the state. Certainly the one in my district or one of the ones in my
district is very concerned about what it will do for their ability to afford uncovered care in the
future. At the same time, there is some evidence of misuse of the 340B program, meaning contracting
with pharmacies across the country when there's not a clear connection between the medical care
these hospitals, FQHCs are providing and the pharmacy and thereby just using that as a way
to extract more money out of a program. And you have to understand when they do that,
that cost doesn't really come from the pharmaceutical companies, it comes from
private payers, it comes from missed rebates for Medicaid. So this is a very, very complicated
issue. It's an issue that I am very concerned if we don't handle it correctly. Ultimately,
this discussion will be taken to the federal level and the 340B program will be reconfigured
in ways that are bad for hospitals and FQHCs and ultimately bad for our citizens. So,
very complicated. I think we'd like to see hospitals in better financial shape. I'm not sure
the bill in front of us is the right bill to address the fundamental issue.
Yeah, Jonathan, thanks for asking about this. I mean, it's complicated and I can't imagine
there's a lot of regular people sitting at home that are like casting their vote or things like
that based on 340B. But like Senator Brunson said, it's going to affect regular people and it's
important the legislature gets it right. And so I appreciate you taking an interest in it. And I
hope it's something you talk about because I think it's something where everybody ought to weigh
in and the public ought to understand how challenging some of these issues are. As Senator
Brown pointed out, hospitals have been just absolutely hammered the last couple of years.
And I think that is part of the impetus for this bill. They've been hammered in this state by the
policies passed by Democrats. The Peb and Seb price cap bill, Peb and Seb being the state's
public sector health insurance plans. By capping what the state would reimburse those that cost
hospitals to the tune of like $180 million a year. There is a B&O surcharge that hits several
hospitals that is going to cost hospitals $60 million a year. The cut to Medicaid MCOs is going
to result in Medicaid MCOs, increasing prices on hospitals to the tune of like $40 million a year.
There is a B&O rate increase specific to providers that $15 million a year, a variety of sales taxes
on services that that hospitals use is going to cost hospitals $15 to $20 million a year. I mean,
all told the policies the Democrats passed last session are going to cost hospitals over $300
million a year. And this is after they've already been struggling immensely due to some of the
COVID related policies that affected how their finances operated. So they've been struggling
for years and got hit with $300 million in lower revenue and added costs just last session because
of house democratic policies. So I think part of part of what's going on here is is how hospitals
are looking for a way to stem the bleeding. And I think the majority party is the ones responsible
for that bleeding. You know, but but it cuts both ways. I think the pharmaceutical companies are
rightly concerned that, you know, they are they participate in this program voluntarily when it
started in the 1990s. It was at the impetus of the pharmaceutical companies themselves. But I think
they want some assurances that when they're selling these drugs at very steep discounts,
oftentimes for pennies, that benefit is accruing to the patients themselves and not just padding
hospitals bottom lines. You know, so it's difficult. I hope we get it right. It's complicated
because there's this huge overlap with federal policy. If we were to do this entirely on our
own as a state, we might come up with entirely different rules. But because there's this federal
overlay, we're very limited on what we can do. It's possible we might not be able to do anything.
Hospitals point to a couple court cases that show the state has got a limited ability to regulate
here. But pharmaceutical companies point to another set of court cases that showed no states really
can't regulate anything here. So we'll see what's happening. But but Senator bronze, right? I mean,
we want to ultimately make sure that this this this works in a way that doesn't increase
health care prices for anyone and provides the most benefit possible to those who need it the
most. We also want to make sure that we're not destroying hospitals finances anymore than have
already been destroyed by the majority party. And we also want to make sure that we're not
punishing pharmaceutical companies and making it difficult for them to invest their revenue
to innovate and create new drugs that are going to save and improve lives. Thank you.
Thank you, Jonathan. And next we will go to Shauna Sowersby with the Seattle Times.
Shauna, do you have a question for us today?
I do have a couple of questions. Good morning, everybody. I yesterday there was a bill that
was heard in the Senate that would eliminate interest on medical debt. And I'm wondering
where each of your caucuses stand whether you support that or not.
I'm sorry, Sean, I've not I've not yet seen the bill, I need to look at it. You know, like I said
a second ago to Jonathan, I mean, we want to make sure that folks have access to affordable health
care. But I need to look at the bill. As I said, in the setup to Jonathan's question,
health care policy is complicated. There's several legs of the stool. And I mean, just just as an
example, when the legislature passes a mandate to say a certain kind of drug needs to be covered,
or a certain kind of service needs to be covered, that can be great, because a lot of people really
need that service. But that comes with a cost. And that means that health care is going to be
more costly for the people that are paying for the coverage. It's a really, really delicate
balancing act, appreciate the effort to want to make sure that it's not unaffordable for folks,
you know, and obviously, eliminating medical, medical interest on medical debt would,
would would do that. But you don't need to look at the bill and understand what sort of second
and third order effects it would have on the entire system, you know, in terms of not just
affordability to the patient, but affordability to everybody else who you know, has to pay into
the system, how it impacts access how it impacts coverage. But without having seen the bill yet,
I don't know if I can opine much more extensively than that. So apologize.
I'll jump in a little bit on this. I haven't read the bill either. But from what I hear from my
small hospitals, who are struggling to to exist when self pay folks don't pay, they either have
to file for charity care, or ask for payments. And sometimes it goes to a collection agency. And I
believe that medical debt, or the interest on medical debt would be either through a collector
or through judgment. But when I hear that my local hospital is losing millions a year,
through either charity care or bad debt write off, I understand the need for good healthcare.
But if they can't afford it, if we have to cut services, then that's, that's not going to be
good for anybody. I think it's important to point out that, you know, that it's only at the very
end of the process of their medical debt, or interest on medical debt exists in our state
already. If you certainly if you pay your bill on time, and even if you protest it,
or if you arrange payment terms with most hospitals, it's all debt for you know,
interest free. And without any sort of incentive to work to find a way to pay it off,
I fear that we're you're going to end up with just a huge increase in unpaid
medical debt because there's no consequences. So difficult situation, one where you want to
balance the needs of the citizens with the need to keep our healthcare organizations healthy,
including financially healthy.
Did you have a follow up question, Shauna?
I do. And this one is specifically for Senator Warnock. So last year, you sponsored the bill
that would have stopped the state from collecting disability and survivor benefits from foster
youth. This year, you're sponsoring another version of that bill to my understanding.
It's not as far reaching as the one last year. Can you talk a little bit about the differences
and then also talk about whether or not you would like to maybe see this bill go further in the
future?
Absolutely. And we did have a good hearing on that bill. That's 5911, I believe.
And it has narrowed it down to foster youth that are 18 to 21, I believe. So a smaller amount,
but we need to help those foster youth who are entitled to federal benefits. We need to help them
plan for their future once they get out of the foster program. And I know we last year,
realized that we just couldn't afford it as a state because of the budget. But in my opinion,
we should not be using foster youth benefits to balance our budgets either. We don't charge other
foster youth when they're in the systems. And in this regard, we're charging foster youth. So
I would like to see it go further. I'm really working hard to see it get passed this year.
And we need to be helping those most vulnerable foster youth that are there not through any fault
of their own. And so this is a bill that I'm absolutely passionate about. So thank you for
bringing that up. Thank you. Thank you very much, Shauna. Next, I will go to, let's see,
Bill Lucia with the Washington State Standard. Bill, did you have a question today?
Sure. Yeah, I have one. So there's kind of a handful of bills this session that focus on
various aspects of protecting kids online. One around social media safeguards we covered
yesterday. There's also the bill that the governor is supporting around AI chatbots,
separate legislation to set age restrictions for, sorry, the age permission requirements,
parental permission requirements for kids to use social media. It might be tough to talk about
these all in a batch, but just in general, where is your caucus at in terms of, you know,
believing that it's time for some stricter regulation on, you know, how kids are using
social media and accessing other stuff online, particularly with AI? I would say at least in
the Senate Republican caucus, there's philosophically, there's a support for the
idea that we have to provide additional protections for children online. There is concern. I know we
had this, the bill, I forget the number, Senator Frame's bill from last year, that many of us
support the idea, but we really got tripped up in the details. If we're going to do this,
we have to do it in a way that doesn't get tied up in court with First Amendment suits from the
social media companies or from others. So I think the broad answer is support the idea,
support the philosophy, certainly want to prevent harm to children, but want to do it in the right
way so that it's effective and will stand up to court challenge. Yeah, it's the same, I think,
for House Republicans. Directionally, I agree. We want to do what we can to protect the kids.
I think we're also hypercognizant of the First Amendment, and for better or worse, it protects
speech, whether you like that speech or not. So we need to be careful that we're not passing
something that's going to get struck down. And like Senator Bryant said, a lot of the devil
is in the details. The definitions are really important. AI has just rocketed to the forefront
of public consciousness. I think mostly because of things like chat GPT, where there's this really
easy-to-use user interface where folks can operate AI really, really quickly and easily. Businesses
have been using AI under the hood, so to speak, for a couple of decades. And so I think we need
to be cognizant in our effort to rein in some of the technology that the public might think about
the most. We need to also not, though, catch up technology that nobody has a problem with,
that we just don't realize is operating behind the scenes because none of us have a very deep
technical understanding. I think one of the priorities for House Republicans in most of
these technology bills is not wanting to stifle innovation. So part of that has to do with getting
the definitions right. Part of it also has to do with we don't want to open this up to private
right of actions and allow every lawyer with an ad on a bus or a billboard to file a lawsuit
against a large company and constrain their ability to innovate. We also want the rules
to be fair so that if a company inadvertently does something against the law, they ought to
have the opportunity to fix that rather than sort of immediately facing multimillion-dollar judgments.
So we want a fair structure that protects kids but also promotes innovation. I think that's really
important in this state. So while we're directionally and philosophically aligned with
the concept of protecting kids, we want to make sure we do it right. The one other thing I'll add
on top of that, it's a related bill you didn't mention, but it has to do with cell phones in
schools. I think the evidence is increasingly clear that kids learn a lot better when cell
phones are put away. Obviously, we want to defer to local districts' ability to figure out the
rules that are best for themselves, but day after day, evidence grows that those phones should be
put away. I've talked about this before. I mean, Washington state's test scores are plummeting.
We've got one of the lowest college-going rates in the country. We need to improve the results of
our education system, especially given how much money we're funneling into it. There is a bill
by Stephanie McClintock that would require school districts to adopt a cell phone policy that
doesn't necessarily require they outright prohibit them, but at least make them confront that
question proactively. I think that would be a great, great tool to recognize the science that
we've seen, follow in the lead of red and blue states that have already done this, and get
cell phones out of the classrooms. Unfortunately, Democrat leadership and committee chairs are
sitting on that bill and refusing to move it, even though I think the vast majority of Republicans
and Democrats would support that bill if it came to the floor. I agree with Rep. Stooksbury on that
in particular because OSPI actually has sent information out to all of our school districts
asking them to look at having some type of cell phone policy. So it's my understanding quite a
few school districts have already done it, including some in my region, and they're seeing
a lot better test scores. The amount of notifications that they get every single
minute on their phones is distracting them, and so we want our kids also to be able to be
safe in schools. This bill actually just lets the school districts decide what their policy
is going to be. It's not saying that the kids can't have them in their classrooms for safety.
I've seen in our district alone where I've been in a classroom where the teacher just requires
the kids to have their phone in their backpack in the front of the room so that they're not
distracting them while they're actually learning during the day. So I think great legislation,
helping our kids, trying to keep them safe at school, keep them offline.
Just a quick follow-up. On the chatbot bill specifically, the AI companion chatbot bill
that the governor's supporting, I mean, that as written, do you know enough about it to say
if it will get any, you know, does it have support from either your caucuses?
I might be alighting some of these bills, but my recollection is this was one where
I think a lot of folks liked the content of the bill but were concerned about the private right
of action and the right to cure. So I think if you fix some of those technical details,
I suspect a lot of Republicans would support it. If you don't fix those technical details,
you're going to have a lot of folks, you know, weighing a list of some pros and a list of some
cons, and I'm not totally sure if it's not changed how folks would come down on it.
Great. Thank you very much. And while that's it for the reporters who are on the call today,
we have two questions from reporters who had to attend a committee meeting,
so I'm going to share those. The first is from Drew Mickelson from King 5. His question is,
Senator Peterson suggested some taxes could be increased to help balance the budget. He mentioned
raising the cigarette tax, for example. What fear tax increases are you hearing may be proposed,
and would there be any increases that your members would support?
Well, I'll start with the last one first. I don't see any tax increases that our members
would support. Our state, I want to remind everybody here, we are not in a recession.
Our revenue is growing, at least for the time being. But every time we lay one more tax at
the feet of the business community to absorb, not only does that make it harder for them to
be successful, it also passes a lot of cost on to our constituents. And we've talked a lot about
affordability. That's the wrong direction for affordability. And we could have, you know,
specific discussions about specific taxes, if desired. I made some comments earlier about the
proposed income tax. I think it's highly destructive for our state's economy. The
people of the state of Washington will be poorly served long term. With regard to the cigarette
tax, I don't think, first, I don't think they're going to really raise a lot of money from it.
The real driver on that has always been health related. And I just think the advocates
misunderstand what will become of this. We already have the highest cigarette tax in the country.
Adding to that is not going to change people's minds. Research shows not going to make a big
difference on whether people continue to smoke cigarettes or not. And I'm not a big fan of
smoking. But we're not going to change people who are addicted to cigarettes, just by making
the price higher. What we're going to do is we're going to hit the poor in our state the hardest,
the most regressive tax in our state's inventory is the cigarette tax. And the idea that they want
to preach about progressivity, and then try to raise the cigarette tax. You know, it's just
wrong, I guess I would put that in will simply drive more costs are the poorest among us,
or driving them to buy those cigarettes in illegal markets with with the associated health risks.
Yeah, I've yet to hear of a tax proposal that I think Republicans would support.
There's been a lot of taxes proposed. You mentioned the cigarette tax. You know,
Senator Brown alluded to that. He made a couple points I want to reiterate. One is,
it's extremely regressive. When you look at the rankings that show Washington, you know,
number 49, or number 50, in terms of the regressivity of the state's tax codes. One of
the main drivers of that is our quote, unquote, sin taxes. So the reason why we have among the
most regressive taxes overall, is because we have an extremely regressive set of taxes on things
like cigarettes, why you would raise that and make that even more regressive at a time you're
claiming to want to make your tax code more progressive is beyond me. It's also just an
incredibly schizophrenic approach to taxation of tobacco. In the first place. You know,
Senator Brown alluded to the fact that maybe the reason you'd want to tax some of this activity
is for health reasons. But if you look at the types of tobacco from from from cigarettes to
vaping to pouches, there is sort of the I think they exist along a spectrum with perhaps more
or less harm depending on where on the spectrum those things are. A lot of these devices can
really service smoking cessation tools and allow smokers to progressively adapt to less harmful
uses of tobacco. But our tax code is so schizophrenic, we are taxing the less harmful
activity more than we're taxing the more harmful activity. It doesn't make a lot of sense to layer
more cigarette tax on top of that doesn't make a lot of sense. One of the bills floating around
in the Senate would specifically increase taxes on menthol cigarettes more than regular cigarettes,
which is, again, confusing. And I think some folks would find have some has some racial
undertones given the demographics of of who smokes menthol cigarettes. So again, very,
very confusing tax policy there. There, like I said, though, there's a long list of taxes
Democrats want to raise. I mentioned the new tax on tires and House Bill 2421. A second ago,
there's a property tax increase. Back on the docket this session, another read increase
another B&O tax increase, a wireless device tax that that Senator Gregerson keeps pushing
a cell phone line tax, Airbnb tax, authorization of a new county B&O tax, animal control tax,
a new tax on your utilities to fund a wildfire mitigation fund. Democrats have not run out of
ideas of taxes to raise but none of those are going to make Washington more affordable for
the people that are struggling most to afford to live in Washington. Thank you very much.
And our final question comes from Simone Carter from McClatchy. Senate Bill 6002 is receiving a
hearing this morning. It's a bipartisan bill that would restrict the retention of automatic license
plate readers or a LPRs data by police departments. Senator Holy is a co sponsor on the bill, but it
has also received criticism from law enforcement officials. I'm curious what your caucuses think
of this proposal. No, I haven't seen the bill. But I do have concerns. I mean, law enforcement
uses some one of the many tools law enforcement uses to try to enforce the laws that we pass
through the legislative process. If we don't like the law, we should change the law. But the idea
that we want to restrict their ability to enforce the law seems counterintuitive to me. And one that
gives me pause in supporting the bill. That said, I haven't read the bill. I think it's fair to have
a hearing and see what the advocates and the distractors have to say before make a final
decision. But on the face of it, the concerns by law enforcement officers, police in my district
raised concerns with me. Yeah, echo Senator Braun haven't had a chance to read the bill yet. So
not an expert on the nuances, but in broad strokes, as we talked about before, Washington has among
the highest crime rates in the country. In a variety of categories, our crime rates are
increasing faster than the than the national average. In nearly every category, every category
we have done, we're doing worse than we were, say, five years ago. There are to fix that we need to
do a variety of things. We've talked a lot about the need to hire more police officers. The
legislature tried to do that a little bit. I think the way we did it was was pretty stilted. And you
haven't really seen that bill manifests itself in any outcomes for communities yet. But but we'll
stay tuned. We need to have more public defenders so that the time to trial isn't as long as it is.
We need county prosecutors willing to actually prosecute crime and not just send folks on their
merry way. All those are part of the solution. But among the things we need to give law enforcement
the tools they need to solve these crimes and technology has given us a tremendous ability
to solve crimes that you know, decades ago were unsolvable. You know, DNA evidence wasn't
something we used until somewhat recently. Now it is a very common tool to solve crimes.
Same thing with this camera data. You know, we certainly understand the need to respect folks
privacy, but that also needs to be weighed against community safety. And we we need to give law
enforcement officers the tools to solve these crimes. I think you talk to these agencies,
talk to sheriffs and police chiefs, they will tell you story after story of how these cameras have
enabled them to solve crimes. And these cameras were the only evidence that provided the links
necessary to solve those things. So I think we ought to be awfully careful about rolling back
some of these tools that have proven to be an effective way to help lower Washington crimes
rates. So I've got some concerns, but we'll keep looking at it. And on a personal note,
just in the Tri-Cities alone, our sheriffs and police chiefs have been saying that these
cameras are really helping in our districts. They recently solved a hit and run accident. They also
solved a robbery in Prosser, Washington. And so right now, you know, listening to our law
enforcement agents and how this is really helping is has been an important voice in my district.
Terrific. Anybody else have any comment on this question? No. All right, well, then we will wrap
up for today. Thank you, everybody for joining us. And I will turn it to Senator Braun and
Representative Stokesberry for final comments. All right, well, thank you, everybody for being
here. Only second week of the session. A lot of work to do, but your attendance and interest in
the issues that we're considering here in Olympia is much appreciated. I'll just remind everyone,
our priorities remain affordability, affordability, affordability, and you can't make Washington more
affordable by adding all the new taxes that our Democratic colleagues continue to propose. You
can only balance the budget in a sustainable way by actually getting in and doing the work to
control the cost growth and living within our means and not get ourselves stuck into a
downward spiral where we solve a deficit with taxes, have less revenue, more taxes, bigger
deficit, and it just spirals into less economic opportunity for everyone in our state. That said,
have a great day. Thanks for being here. Yeah, I will. I agree with all that. House Republicans
are also laser focused on making Washington more affordable. So appreciate you all attending
today. Appreciate your coverage. And I hope as you continue your coverage for the next 50 days or
so, you cover these affordability issues. When there are bills that would make Washington more
affordable, that aren't getting hearings, I hope you talk about that and ask why. And when there
are bills that are going to make Washington more affordable, raise taxes, impose regulations that
raise prices. I hope you talk about hope you talk about those as well. Public deserves to be
informed and appreciate your role in that. Thanks. Terrific. Thank you, everyone. And we will see you next week.
