Shark Business: Meet The Ocean’s Apex Predators

Echoes of the Wild
29 followers
2 Video Views·Jan 21, 2026
The same animals that strike terror in the hearts of swimmers generate excitement with many scuba
divers. In an ironic twist, divers deliberately seek face-to-face encounters with some of the
ocean's most dangerous predators, sharks. Whitter is a leading authority on shark behavior and a
passionate supporter of human and shark interaction. In the spring of 2002 he paid a very high price
for his beliefs. A severe attack nearly cost him his leg and his life. Sharks fuel a booming
ecotourism industry. From tropical seas to the cold waters of the Pacific Northwest, sharks are big
business. A shark feeding frenzy. A fascinating and frightening spectacle.
Dozens of predators slash and tear at their prey with razor-sharp teeth.
But this exciting display is not a random act in nature's grand design.
It's a carefully choreographed event staged for the benefit of scuba divers.
It's a fair assumption that most people would avoid intentional contact with sharks,
but many scuba divers and snorkelers line up to interact with the animals.
Believe it or not, shark encounters are becoming one of the most popular attractions in the sport.
Of all the sharks, one towers above the rest in our collective imaginations.
The great white. Human fatalities have decreased. The visceral horror of being eaten alive remains.
Since the dawn of time, people have been terrified of sharks. But in a deeply primitive sense,
we admire them. We're transfixed by predators that can kill us.
This fascination is the inspiration for the holy grail of shark dives.
The Cape of Good Hope. One of the most treacherous bodies of water on Earth.
Winter storms work their way north from Antarctica and pound a battered coastline.
Windswept shores provide refuge for tens of thousands of South African fur seals.
On land, they're clumsy and slow. Underwater, the nimble seals are eager to show off their
acrobatic skills. But these seas are not safe for even the most agile pinniped.
This is the hunting ground of the great white. In the South African fishing village of Hunzbai,
great whites fuel a burgeoning dive tourism industry. J.P. Bota and Andre Hartman operate
Marine Dynamics, one of the most successful shark diving companies in the country.
Both were formerly commercial fishermen, but with dwindling catches, they turned to eco-tourism,
specifically shark tourism. Their business plan is simple. Wait for good weather,
ferry visitors out to sea, and get them up close and personal with great whites.
The South African white shark diving business around Hunzbai started in the early 90s. In the
It grew to the eight operators we have at the moment. Initially, there was a sort of an emotional
outcry and people were really concerned that the number of shark attacks would increase due to the
commercial activity of attracting sharks. That fortunately has proved to be a false fear.
This activity does not necessarily lead to more shark attack. And of course, the statistics have
also been with us so that the number of shark attacks have actually not increased.
The local economy has benefited quite substantially by the shark tourism. The
industry employs about 40 to 50 people and these people spend their money in the local businesses.
So there's a lot of spinoffs emanating from the shark business.
At the sharks, Andre Hartman first chums the water with a pungent combination of blood
and fish remains. The scent of cow shark liver is a particular favorite of great whites.
Coaxing them to the stern, Andre demonstrates an unusual phenomenon.
Pushing aside the snout of a shark one day, he discovered that the animal became almost catatonic.
It rolled its eyelids down, rose out of the water, opened its mouth and snapped its jaws.
The strange behavior appears to be related to highly specialized sensory organs in their nose
and mouth. Touching them momentarily short circuits their senses. Most customers view
sharks from the safe confines of a boat or from a protected cage. But a few brave souls pay extra
for the privilege of venturing into the water without the security of steel bars.
At the surface, Andre Hartman acts as a safety diver
and occasionally shows off. Do not try this at home.
On the seafloor, a cautious Hartman sensed the water with fish blood. The diver's expectations
are exceeded. A 15-foot white shark appears like a ghostly apparition.
We were underwater for about 40 minutes and of course the action all happens
near the end of the dive. We were starting to get cold. Water temperature there was about 52-53
degrees. You're looking through the small viewfinder and trying to keep it framed and
focused and this shark comes out of the gloom and simply just gets bigger and bigger and bigger and
fills the frame on this high-definition camera. It's pretty awe-inspiring. That shark swam right
around us a couple times, looked at us, examined us, then made a pass across the bottom and right
at the camera. Sharks don't have fingers and hands to test things with, so what they have to do is
bite something. Unfortunately, because of their enormous size and tremendous strength, when they
bite something, even though they're just sampling it and you really couldn't consider that a shark
attack, it doesn't make much difference to the person that's been sampled. It still hurts.
The shark showed recent signs of mating activity. Deep scars along her side indicated a bite from a
very large male. You can only speculate on the size of the animal that inflicted these wounds.
It seems like the more time I spend in the water with sharks, the more I realize that when you look
into their eyes as they swim by you, and eye contact is very important with wildlife, there's someone in
there. It's not just a stupid animal swimming by. Sharks are not maniacal or dangerous man-eating
machines that are swimming around looking for humans to eat. They're really not. In the Bahamas,
over a hundred sharks show up for a feeding, but how do you get out of the way of a frenzied mob?
At the northernmost tip of the Bahamas, 100 miles east of the Florida coast,
lies Walker's Cay. The island is a renowned sport fishing destination and hosts thousands of
visitors each year. Seizing on the availability of leftover fish parts, shark diving pioneer
Gary Atkison found a novel means of recycling normally discarded carcasses.
We're a premier fishing destination. Subsequently, as the fish would come into our fish cleaning room,
we save those carcasses. We recycle those fish heads and carcasses back into the environment.
One day, my staff came up to me and said, Gary, when we go down and dump the carcasses at the
end of the runway, the sharks hear the trucks coming and they gather. Well, I took a look at
this and was astounded by it. I thought, well, it'd be a natural progression then to relocate
it out to the reef. Subsequently, that's what we did. We started saving the carcasses, packing
them, created the chum sickle. Basically, with the chum sickle, it's carcass feeding, which is
very natural for this predator. So we wanted to present it to him in as natural a form as possible
that he would understand. And in no way then would it also connected to us as the diver that we were
we were going to be just viewed as another predator down there on the dive who showed up for
the same reason they did. And that's why we can do the dive as safely as we do it and why we've
had a single incident of agonistic display in 11 years. Probably 35,000 people have done this
experience, including children as young as four years old, having animals within just a few feet
of them. At the dive site, the captain revs the boat's engines. The noise is a cue for the sharks
that a feeding is about to begin. As the frozen block of bait sinks, only a few sharks appear to
be interested. Other fish are quick to take advantage of the free meal. Once thought to be
set off by a single drop of blood, the infamous feeding frenzy may instead be incited by several
different stimuli. The vibrations and head shaking of the first fish to feed, the scent trail, and
the visual commotion all combine to excite the sharks. As the bait ball wears down, it eventually
falls to the bottom. The sharks then fight for the remaining morsels of food.
A handful of well-publicized attacks in 2001 spawned the Summer of the Shark. Overnight,
shark bites and sightings became front page news. Lost in the hype was the fact that there were far
fewer attacks that year than the previous year. Worldwide, only four deaths were attributed to
sharks in 2001. The Summer of the Shark dramatically changed public perception,
taking it several steps backward to the old Jaws mentality of the 70s.
The past quarter century since that landmark film has not been kind to sharks. Virtually all species
have seen population declines of between 50 and 90 percent. The strain on their numbers comes
primarily from overfishing. Federal regulations restrict shark fishing in U.S. waters, but the
animals are targeted relentlessly in much of the world. Their cartilage is still considered a cancer
treatment, and Asian demand for shark fin soup supports a wasteful finning industry.
One of the main goals of diving operators such as Gary Atkison at Walker's Cay
is to increase awareness of the shark's plight through interaction with the animals in their
natural habitat. I think it's so vitally important that people learn as much as they can about an
animal that is really misunderstood. In doing this experience and trying to educate people
and hopefully stop the slaughter of these sharks, I feel that what we do is significant.
The reason we do what we do is it's a myth exploder. People suddenly realize that I'm
down here with a hundred animals and I'm safe and they could care less that I'm here,
and they walk away with a whole different rich experience than they ever thought they'd get when
they first arrived here. That's the seed you're planting out there because they're going to tell
other people sharks have a bad rap as it is anyway, and I feel like our job here is to let
people know that they're not the bad guy people have made them out to be. If sharks are not the
bad guys, why would they attack and nearly kill one of their staunchest supporters?
Dr. Eric Ritter is a leading authority on shark behavior and a forensic investigator of shark
attacks. Ritter has been instrumental in helping to change the popular perception of sharks
as terrors of the sea to a vital species which deserves protection.
Over the past two decades, Eric has introduced hundreds of students, photographers, and
biologists to sharks. With a keen passion for the animals and their plight, he is one of few
researchers who dares to freely swim with dangerous sharks. Ritter works exclusively
outside the protection of a cage. What I'm studying is the body language of sharks. I'm
interested in how sharks express their intentions when they approach humans. Shark-human interaction
is a very new field, but it's most likely the very field we need to understand these animals.
We cannot just observe them by sitting on boats, sitting in front of aquariums.
We have to interact with them. My main theory is that sharks are as predictable as dogs, parrots,
cats, animals that we are comfortable with, animals that we're used to. We're not used to
being with sharks. We have to just give them the chance to let them interact with us.
In a unique experiment at Walker's Cay, Gary Atkisson and Dr. Ritter attract a handful of
large sharks to shallow water. One of Eric's more controversial theories is that dangerous
animals like bull and lemon sharks are not inclined to attack humans, even when enticed
with bait. He believes attacks are caused by curiosity or mistaken identity and should be
referred to more appropriately as shark accidents. More than 80 percent of attack victims survive,
mainly because sharks realize their mistake and don't return for a second bite. Ritter simulates
common attack scenarios such as those on swimmers in shallow water and those on spear fishermen in
deeper seas. Throughout his experiments, fish carcasses are thrown into the surf very near
to where he stands or swims. The most often seen accident scenario we have is blue exploratory
behavior, meaning the animal sees us, not us as a human being, but us as an object.
Several factors come together, for example sound, smell, motion of the object.
Sharks per se are very curious animals. They have a very high level of hesitance, but if their
curiosity takes over at the end they may grab an object just to get a final idea of what the object
would be, because nothing they sense is conclusive. So that's why in very rare cases they still grab
the object. In the spring of 2002, after nearly two decades and over a thousand dives with dangerous
sharks, Eric's luck finally ran out. He was severely bitten on the leg by a bull shark.
A journalist accompanying Eric nervously paced and stirred up debris, reducing visibility. Quickly
the situation turned deadly. A large female bull shark was cornered between the two and lashed out
at Eric. What led to this bite that I had with a bull shark was one of a general situation we've
done hundreds and hundreds of times. The person next to me did not stand still as I told him to.
He walked back and forth and so by walking back and forth he stirred up a lot of sand and so we
so it was us who created the situation not the animals. The second I got bitten I lifted my leg
right away because I had to get out of her mouth and the problem is if you have a 400 pound animal
attached to you there's nearly nothing you can do. I mean you always hear well hit an animal do this
then that doesn't work. She let go I looked at my leg and I realized um first of all it's not
much left and second of all I knew I'm going to die within the next two or three hours because
I've seen many of these wounds and I knew how they're going to end if they do not get proper
treatment. Eric was fortunate a small plane and its pilot were on the island at the time of the
accident. Within 30 minutes of the bite he was on his way to West Palm Beach where a team of
doctors was waiting. He nearly died due to an enormous loss of blood. Once stabilized it appeared
that he would lose his leg but skilled surgeons miraculously managed to save it.
Months of rehabilitation and a determined will spurred an amazing recovery. Additional
reconstructive surgeries and skin grafts helped to restore use of his leg. The first time I jumped
back in the water was about four months after my bite. The wound healed so far that I could be in
water 15-20 minutes. So the first opportunity I had I jumped right back in at the very spot where
I got bitten. I want that everybody sees these animals the way I see them. I want them to see
the animal through my eyes. I see it even more clear what we have to do. We have to destroy the
myth the bad rep of these animals portray them the way they really are. They're fascinating,
incredibly intelligent, curious. So I'm back in the water. I interact with sharks more than ever.
So I'd say I do this for the rest of my life. What is the fastest growing and most popular
attraction for scuba diving tourists? Another Bahamian island is the epicenter of the shark
diving industry. At New Providence half a dozen scuba operations rely on sharks as a main attraction
for diving tourists. As for the sharks, what we don't want you guys doing is swimming with your
hands, okay? These sharks are attracted to movement more than the blood in the water.
Unlike the bait ball style of feeding at Walker's Cay, sharks here are fed by hand or with a steel
pole. Shark wranglers utilize a chainmail suit which helps prevent injury, but a crushing bite
can still hurt. The difficult part initially is to keep the ravenous animals away from the bait.
Like pigs at the trough, they jostle for position. After using a pole, the wrangler moves towards
the divers and feeds by hand. For the customers, this close-up action is a thrilling introduction
to sharks. It was pretty comfortable down there until the sharks got real close to you. I mean,
I got pretty nervous. I've always thought they were pretty aggressive, but being down there today
while they were feeding them and everything, they looked like gentle giants down there.
This dive was really, really good. I've never been so close to sharks. Other divers have seen
them in the blue in the distance, but never so close up. It was almost like he was roughhousing
dogs. Whenever a couple of sharks would come up to him and he would just push their snoot away or
whatnot, he'd grab a hold of them and roughhouse them and pet them, so it was pretty neat.
The first thing this morning, we never would have known that we were going to be shark diving today,
that's for sure. We just happened to run across it and it sounded like a cool thing to do,
so we said, let's go shark diving. It was just a fantastic experience.
From an economic standpoint, shark feeding, I'm very much in favor of. Some people don't
approve of shark feeding. They feel that we've changed the behavior of sharks. Yes,
to a certain degree we have. Take in this area, we've probably changed the behavior of about 100
sharks. Slacky, but they're still in their own environment. They generate a lot of income for
the Bahamas, and those same sharks generate revenue year in, year out. Shark feeding is
definitely becoming more popular, and it definitely does contribute towards conservation
of sharks. These people who would have otherwise viewed them as dangerous man-eaters and not cared
about them, once they've been on a feed, they've seen them feeding, they're seeing they're not
these vicious creatures. They're far more inclined to support conservation issues.
Most shark encounters occur in the warm tropics, but what animals lurk in the cold deep sea?
Shark diving is not confined to the tropics or to shallow, temperate waters.
In the dark, frigid realm of the deep sea lives a mysterious giant, the six-gill shark.
Ancient hunters, unchanged since dinosaurs roamed the earth,
they inhabit great depths. These living fossils can attain a length of over 20 feet.
There are only a handful of places where six-gill sharks are frequently encountered
in shallow water. Washington State's Puget Sound and the Pacific Coast of Canada.
One of the best places to photograph and study the sharks at scuba diving depths
is British Columbia's Hornby Island. Rob Zielinski and Amanda Heath operate a busy scuba diving
business on Hornby Island and six-gills are their number one attraction. Despite the cold seas and
sometimes challenging diving conditions, the animals generate enormous interest.
The main reason that people come to Hornby is to see the six-gill sharks. They're a real draw here
in the summer. We cater to about 500 diving tourists in the course of May to September
and all of those people come with the intent of seeing the six-gills if they're lucky enough to do
so. Hornby Island is a unique location in that it's one of the few places in the world where
we can observe six-gills in water shallow enough to scuba dive in.
In many cases they're found at depths of several thousand feet which is
unreachable by people under most circumstances. Sport diver tourists come here as well as
scientists, film crews, still photographers, etc. who are interested in an opportunity to see the
six-gill in its natural habitat. Researcher Dr. Robert Dunbrack of Newfoundland's Memorial
University searches for clues to the behavior and biology of these enigmatic sharks. Each summer
aboard his research vessel, the Stalvik, Dunbrack travels to tiny Flora Islet off the coast of
Hornby Island. Six-gills and their unusual habits pose many intriguing questions but simply finding
the elusive animals is the first of many challenges. It was much more difficult than
we originally thought it might be to work on the six-gills. We thought we could just
do a bit of diving and the six-gills would be there and we could make behavioral observations
in a way that we might do on let's say polar bears or some sort of terrestrial mammal.
The study site that we settled on was on Flora Islets off Hornby Island.
We spent a few days there on our research vessel looking for sharks and didn't see anything and we
were prepared then to leave and go and find another site but on the our last dive we saw
eight sharks in one dive so that as soon as we saw that we decided this was a place to do the work.
The unanswered question about these sharks of course is why are they coming into shallow water?
They're deep water sharks. They're known virtually throughout all the oceans of the world but only
from deep waters. A natural thing to conclude is that they're coming in to feed because this is
what animals have to do most of the time is look for food but we have no evidence that they are
feeding. It's not known whether they feed at night and maybe come onto the reef during the day for
some other reason. Dunbrack quickly realized that direct observation of the animals was very
difficult. Depth and time constraints, cold water and currents and finally locating the sharks on
the deep reef made research a daunting task. To aid in his studies he devised two ingenious yet
simple methods of observing and recording sick skills and their behavior. We have built a time
lapse video system that allows us to put a video camera down it takes pictures four frames every
10 seconds or so. On a single film we're able to get two to three to four weeks depending on the
time of year it's just a daylight system. We also have set up a stereo system which consists of two
video cameras that are cabled directly to the surface. They look over the same area they're
facing down off the reef wall and so the sharks will swim underneath these two cameras and based
on the geometry of the cameras we can actually get measurements direct measurements of the size
of the sharks as they pass underneath and also their swimming speed which we can use for metabolic
studies. Early in the summer field season Dunbrack made a curious discovery. Harbor seals and stellar
sea lions prey for other large sharks were interacting with the six gills. Video monitors
and time lapse cameras revealed the startling behavior. Now what was that being that's interesting
that's a seal right chasing him
I don't believe this wow it's amazing seals directly underneath the shark sort of coming
underneath them is sort of buzzing them. Six gills sharks are not known to feed on seals or sea lions
it appears that the playful mammals are simply curious about their large visitors from the deep.
In recent years fossil remains of prehistoric relatives of six gills sharks have been
discovered on Hornby Island. Over 25 species of mostly deep water sharks from the Cretaceous
period have been identified from fossilized remains. Fossil shark teeth are very common
but they're usually attributed to shallow water species. These puzzling clues appear to suggest
that six gills and many other deep water sharks frequently ventured into shallow seas.
Within a stone's throw of the site where we were watching these sharks swim around there
are fossils of the sharks that have been there over 65 million years ago and looking at the
teeth of those species they're virtually indistinguishable from the teeth of the fish
that we were looking at. Within the last 100 million years or so they probably haven't changed
much at all. With the collapse of many traditional commercial fish stocks six gills were briefly
considered a viable new fishery but with little knowledge of their population reproductive and
growth rates this ill-conceived plan was put on hold. Trying to run a fishery on a species like
the six gill is very problematic it's a large fish it's certainly long-lived and has very low
rates of reproduction so the sustainable exploitation rates would be very low.
So a large shark that might be 60 to 100 years old might fetch just a few dollars whereas we
do know for a fact that this species probably brings in several million dollars a year just
to the dive tourism ministry as a living resource. The more people that interact with the sharks
in a passive manner as divers and get a positive experience the better it is really going to be
for the shark. Despite many unanswered questions and an uncertain future six gill sharks inspire
tremendous respect from both scientists and scuba divers. Rob and I consider ourselves to be very
lucky in that we're members of a very small select group that have seen a live six gill
swimming in its natural habitat it's something that many people can never dream of doing.
It's an exciting thing to see this shark moving in its environment.
It's really hard to describe the feelings that you have when you first encounter them.
To put it in terrestrial terms it would be similar to going through a hike in the west
coast and running into the elephants and the giant sloths that used to live there 12,000 years ago.
It seems like a throwback to times when animals were bigger and more plentiful on these reefs
and it's a very stirring experience. There's virtually nothing that we know about this
species so anything that we get is going to be useful and there's so much to know it's something
that could keep us going for many many many years. Many of us don't scuba dive or even snorkel.
What better way to satiate our curiosity than to view sharks through six inches of glass.
Shark encounters are not the exclusive domain of scuba divers and marine biologists.
The animals are also top attractions in zoos and aquariums.
The public fascination with sharks is deeply rooted. People of all ages are mesmerized by the
sleek and powerful fish. At the Atlantis Resort on Paradise Island in the Bahamas, sharks are a
crowd favorite. You can even rock it down a water slide or river raft through the middle of their
shark tank. I think the reason why people are so fascinated by sharks is because a lot of people
don't know about sharks. They have a lot of misconceptions about sharks. They think sharks
are these big scary animals that as soon as you get into the water they're going to attack you.
Economically, live sharks are much more valuable than dead sharks because they bring guests here.
They want to see sharks and it also adds an educational value because it's much easier to
teach somebody about sharks and how valuable they are if they can actually see something that's
living. I think people appreciate that much more than they would see in a specimen or just a
photograph in a book. A rash of shark attacks in Florida and Hawaii led state authorities there to
ban the practice of baiting sharks. But instead of decreasing attacks, the bans have proven to be
ineffective. The same number of people were bitten in the past few years as there were before the
bans were implemented. Although shark diving does attract and perhaps alter the behavior of a few
animals, feedings usually take place in deeper water, a long way from beaches and swimmers.
Dr. Eric Ritter and others believe that shark baiting and chumming is a potential
factor in attacks, but not because of scuba divers. I would say about 80 to 90 percent are
caused by sport fishing. What they create is a very hazardous situation around themselves.
By chumming the water, by hooking fish, sharks pick it up. You have people in the water frolicking
until we find a way to reduce some of the sport fishing habits.
We will always have the same number of shark bites on a yearly basis here in Florida.
If the ban really would have done what they predicted, meaning no accidents anymore,
then at least we'll be safer, but we still have the same accident rate each year. I definitely
feel that organized shark feeding done properly is safe, and it definitely raises awareness of
this animal's plight and raises awareness of the animal's fragility, and it's a myth destroyer.
As an animal that's been on this planet for close to half a billion years, that has been brought to
the verge of extinction in the past 20 years, and he's being wiped out at such a tremendous rate.
You remove the shark, you suddenly turn our oceans in a very, very short period of time
into a septic system. Our oceans are in trouble. If we don't protect this animal,
then all of us lose. Everybody. And what a sad thing. I want my kids to see what I saw today.
Despite their strength and predatory skill, sharks are remarkably fragile creatures.
Conservation efforts have traditionally had little support or enforcement.
They aren't as cute and cuddly as dolphins or as majestic as whales. After all, on rare occasions,
they do kill people. We are slowly coming to realize that sharks are integral members of the
ocean food chain. We're learning that while a dead shark may bring a few dollars to a fisherman
one time, a live shark may generate thousands of dollars in annual tourist revenue.
And best of all, the shark is allowed to live. Perhaps scuba divers and other ecotourists
can ultimately play a key role in preserving these vital species.
