Are The Kalash Descendants of Alexander the Greats Army?

Asian Mythology
12 followers
Tucked away in the rugged mountainous terrain of the Hindu Kush in Pakistan,
lies a tribe of people that are distinct from their neighbors.
A people that have light skin, many times blue eyes, looking more European than South Asian.
They follow a religion thousands of years old,
unrelated to the religions of the people around them.
These people, isolated in the mountains, have a history spanning thousands of years.
They are called the Kalash.
And according to many, they are descendants of Alexander the Great's expeditions into South Asia.
But is this true?
Who are the Kalash?
Where did they come from?
And are they descendants of European military campaigns?
Or is their history a little more complicated than that?
The Kalash people are native to northwestern Pakistan.
Majority of Kalash people are actually Muslim,
but a minority still practices their ancient traditional religion.
This religion consists of aspects of animism and ancestor worship,
and is mixed with elements of ancient Indo-Iranian practices and mythology,
showing many parallels to Vedic religion.
The Kalash are linguistically Indo-Aryan speakers.
Indo-Aryan languages are a part of the larger Indo-Iranian branch of the Indo-European language
family, with the other branches of the Indo-Iranian languages being the Nuristani languages,
and also the Iranian languages.
How these languages entered South Asia was from steppe migrations thousands of years ago,
and through these migrations came cultural practices and aspects of religion.
Because of this, we see many aspects of culture
that many people believe are directly from these ancient migrations.
Their religion is likely a mix of their beliefs prior to steppe migrations,
mixing with later influences by Indo-Iranian peoples.
Because of the fact that Vedic religion of South Asia
was also heavily impacted by steppe migrations, we see parallels.
Their religion and cultural practices are very unique.
If you want a more in-depth video about Indo-European religions,
and how they spread creating the ancient religions of Europe,
from the Romans, to Greeks, to Pagan religion, all the way to the religions of South Asia,
I made a video about that, you can check that out here.
Their religion and practices were very similar to their neighbors in Nuristan,
in Afghanistan, prior to their forced conversions in the late 1890s.
Nuristani culture would be quite closely related to Kalash culture,
as they do come from the same region.
The Kalash have a look that has been the source of many hypotheses of their origins.
Lighter hair, lighter skin color, lighter eye color,
quite different from other Pakistanis who tend to have browner skin tone,
and darker features on average.
They look quite different to most South Asian groups.
They actually look more closely related to their neighbors to the Southwest,
like Pashtuns or other Afghan ethnic groups,
sharing many features as well with Persians or Tajiks,
with the main difference being their eye color.
But they are actually genetically different from them,
so what does their ancestry actually say?
To understand how their ancestry is unique,
we first have to understand South Asian ancestry.
Most South Asians are actually a mix of three different groups,
the first being the AASI, aka the Ancient Ancestral South Indians,
who were the first Homo Sapien inhabitants of South Asia,
being found in the highest rates in some tribal South Indian groups,
some South Indian Dalit groups,
and also Munda ethnic groups of Northern India,
more specifically closer to the eastern parts of the Indian subcontinent.
But this ancestry of AASI is actually seen all throughout South Asia.
The second group to enter was the Iranian hunter-gatherers,
which is a DNA component we see with high rates as well all throughout South Asia.
And the final group of migrants were descendants of the western steppe herders,
and today we consider them the Indo-Aryans,
who entered South Asia about 3500 years ago.
And this DNA also is spread out throughout South Asia,
but having higher rates in the northwest,
and also being higher in upper caste groups.
If you want to know why caste impacts DNA, I have a video about that here.
But anyways, around 10,000 years ago,
Iranian hunter-gatherer groups migrated east to the northwest region of the Indian subcontinent,
where they mixed with the AASI and ended up developing farming there.
This ended up creating the Indus Valley Civilization thousands of years later,
and after the collapse of the civilization,
these people migrated deeper into the subcontinent with groups that went more south,
mixing even more with AASI groups that were already there.
And around 3500 years ago, Indo-Aryan migrations came from Central Asia,
and these people mixed with the people of South Asia, bringing many aspects of Vedic tradition.
Now that we understand the ancestry of South Asians, how does Kalash DNA differ?
From the information that we do have, we know that the Kalash were a very,
very isolated group, and because of this, their DNA is quite unique compared to most South Asians.
Genetically, the Kalash still follow the same three-part ancestry pattern
seen across South Asia, but the proportions are quite different.
First, like all South Asians, they do have ancestry from the ancient AASI populations,
the earliest humans in the subcontinent, but compared to most South Asians,
the Kalash have much less of this ancestry.
Second, they have quite a large amount of ancestry related to ancient Iranian
hunter-gatherer groups. These were the people that moved east thousands of years ago,
mixed with AASI populations, and helped form early farming societies in the region.
This ancestry later became a major part of the Indus Valley civilization.
The Kalash carry a strong amount of this Iranian-related ancestry,
similar to populations from Afghanistan, Iran, and parts of Central Asia.
Third, the Kalash have higher levels of steppe ancestry than most South Asian groups.
These steppe populations came from Central Asia around 3,500 years ago to about 4,000 years ago,
and are associated with the Indo-Aryan languages, Vedic traditions, and Indo-European mythology.
This steppe ancestry itself already contained lighter features in some individuals,
and it mixed into the northwest of South Asia more heavily than elsewhere.
Because the Kalash live in the northwest, and because they remained isolated for thousands of
years, this steppe ancestry stayed more concentrated in their population. In most of South Asia,
steppe ancestry was later diluted through mixing with larger populations.
But among the Kalash, it was preserved. This combination of steppe ancestry,
strong Iranian-related ancestry, and lower AASI ancestry helps explain why the Kalash
often look different from other South Asians. Their features overlap more with neighboring
groups, like Pashtuns or Persians or Tajiks, rather than populations further east or south
in the subcontinent. But one major reason for their looks that many people leave out
is sexual selection. Sexual selection plays a large role in how a population develops their
phenotype. If they keep selecting for traits like lighter eye color or hair color, over many
generations this becomes the norm, even if their DNA doesn't change. So if the ancestors of the
Kalash kept selecting for blue or lighter eyes, they will have a high rate of this trait.
There are also some other theories on why the Kalash look the way they do.
The Kalash are quite genetically similar to their neighbors like the Pashtuns,
but we see lighter features on average. Besides sexual selection, it is possible that the reason
for this is higher rates of certain ancestral components. Many believe that the Kalash have
higher rates of CHG ancestry or Caucasus hunter-gatherer ancestry, which would have already
been a part of their steppe DNA. And the Caucasus hunter-gatherers were very closely related to the
Iranian hunter-gatherers. But some would make the claim that the Kalash have higher rates of
additional Caucasus hunter-gatherer related DNA, possibly from migration south from Bemak. Or they
might even have higher ANE DNA compared to their neighbors. Ancient North Eurasian DNA or ANE DNA
is a significant portion of both EHG, eastern hunter-gatherer, and CHG DNA, so it would be
harder to quantify how much ANE DNA Kalash really have if they have an extra percentage of this DNA.
It is possible, however, that they have some slight higher genetic influence from
groups like the CHG or ANE, and that might be one of the reasons for their phenotype,
likely from migrations of Bemak residents. But what does this say about the belief that
Well, actually, although they aren't descendants of ancient Greeks per se,
the western steppe herders who the Kalash get a huge portion of their ancestry from
do have an origin in this part of the world, the Pontic-Caspian steppe. This is the region where
the ancestors of the western steppe herders came together and mixed, these ancient groups being
the eastern hunter-gatherers of eastern Europe and the Caucasus hunter-gatherers. This region
is considered Europe, so does a significant portion of their ancestry come from what is now
Europe? Sure, you can say that, but does that make them white? Well, not really. Besides the fact
that whiteness itself is quite a new concept developing over the last 400 years or so,
most Europeans are a mix of western steppe herders, western hunter-gatherers,
and Anatolian Neolithic farmers. Northern Europeans tend to have the highest rates of
western steppe herder DNA. So yes, technically they do share common ancestry, but in the same
way a Levantine person or a Moroccan will share similar ancestry with Italians or Albanians.
They would still be racially defined differently in our society.
So when you take all of this into account, the story of the Kalash becomes much clearer.
They are not descendants of Alexander the Great or a lost Greek army hidden in the mountains.
There is no unique Greek genetic signal separating them from the rest of the region. Instead,
their ancestry fits into the same ancient population movements that shaped much of
Central and South Asia. What makes the Kalash stand out is not a sudden European origin,
but a combination of ancient steppe ancestry, strong Iranian-related ancestry, and lower AASI
ancestry, and long-term isolation. Living high in the Hindu Kush allowed them to preserve
both their genetic makeup and their religious traditions in a way that most surrounding
populations could not. Their appearance, their language, and their religion are not anomalies.
They are living remnants of older layers of South Asian and Indo-Iranian history,
layers that were once widespread across the region but later disappeared due to migration,
conversion, and cultural change. In that sense, the Kalash are not outsiders to South Asia. They
are a people shaped by deep history, standing at the crossroads of Central Asia, South Asia,
and the ancient Indo-European world.
