Why Some Martial Arts Will Always Have a Bad Reputation

Martial arts originated from Japan
137 followers
I've seen it around online and even been asked once,
how can we restore the reputation of our art?
This question, of course, typically refers to some of the internet's favorite dead horses to beat,
Aikido, Wing Chun, a whole litany of Kung Fu styles,
sometimes things like Capoeira, and so on and so forth.
My answer to this is generally that this is a poor question,
and a more useful one to ask is something like this,
why isn't our art reaching an audience?
But this video isn't really about how to renovate a martial art,
or mark it better, or anything like that,
although it probably is good future content.
Here, I just wanted to discuss why certain martial arts just keep getting beaten down.
On a surface level, sure, they quote-unquote don't work,
mystery solved for a lot of people right there.
This has never been satisfying to me, for reasons I'll get into, though.
To bring anyone new up to speed,
it has been my position that a lot of the criticisms of, for example, Aikido,
are actually very legitimate, at least through a purely martial lens.
My push, however, is that just identifying something as lacking
is really only the start of a good conversation.
Noticing an issue is step one to finding a solution.
Yet, what most often we see is people saying,
This is fundamentally not constructive,
and this has always kind of been a pet fascination of mine.
I can't speak to other people's experiences,
but usually when I see a puzzle, I want to try and solve it.
So it's always been a bit alien to me when people look at a formula,
make some kind of ankle-deep comment about it,
and then just leave X perpetually unsolved.
I have to admit that a younger Tengu totally chalked all this up to people just being stupid.
Very edgy, I know.
As I've aged, and theoretically at least, matured, I no longer think this.
The fact of the matter is that every luxury,
every convenience, and every comfort we take for granted daily
is the product of human ingenuity and industry.
People may or may not be efficient or articulate or know how to apply their knowledge,
but I certainly don't believe most are outright dumb.
Instead, what I think is going on here is that people are motivated to point,
laugh, and leave when it comes to these martial arts, primarily because of comfort.
In my view, this comfort really has three components.
First, maintaining a status quo.
Second, avoiding difficulty, that is, problems that will take a lot of effort to solve,
and this is especially true when a potential solution wouldn't have a tangible benefit for someone.
And third, just feeling justified,
correct, and confident in their decisions and resource investments.
To break that down a bit,
the status quo thing doesn't really have a whole lot of bearing on our conversation here,
but I do think it's worth pointing out that a lot of the broader martial arts community
seems to find comfort in this idea that things are more or less, quote-unquote, solved.
Now, this is kind of ridiculous, even from a modern perspective.
Just look at how often MMA and BJJ see meta-shifts, and it happens pretty often.
But when you're living moment-to-moment, or you just are a hobbyist who jumps in from time-to-time
with no consideration of a larger timescale,
it always feels like you're living at the summit of all knowledge.
Our grandparents thought it, and so did their grandparents before them.
Of course, I mean that in terms of society as a whole, not just martial arts,
although it'd be very interesting if my grandparents' grandparents were martial artists.
Regarding the second point,
people typically don't want to drop five years of study into something
when they don't really have a horse in the race.
I see disciplines like Wing Chun or even something like HEMA take heat online,
and I'm very much a sympathizer,
but even I probably won't be leaping into those disciplines to try and push them forward.
Of course, the difference is that I'm also not in the crowd
that thinks those practices are utterly pointless, either.
Third, and most importantly to us,
I think people like taking the piss out of these arts
because it makes them feel certain in their own worldview,
in their own choice of martial arts training.
There is a certain comfort people seem to get from it,
that even if they are the trashiest BJJ guy or the worst MMA guy,
at least they aren't training Aikido.
I mean, can you imagine?
Which brings me full circle to why I think people like to point,
laugh, and leave rather than being constructive.
It brings me full circle to why some martial arts will always have a bad reputation.
For a lot of people, the point is that they are a dead horse to beat.
They get more value out of these martial arts appearing like failures
than they do in their potential successes.
At least, that is their perception.
Naturally, I think this is extremely misguided,
but I believe it's a better explanation than,
well, people are just stupid.
One of the social themes I was studying, albeit in a pre-modern Japanese context,
during my thesis days was the concept of the other.
If I had to condense this down into a catchphrase,
it would be something like,
every village needs a witch.
I've always been interested in creatures and things like that.
Halloween is predictably my favorite holiday.
What that interest led me to eventually was studying and realizing that
every culture has this kind of narrative trope,
be it in the west where some witch is living on the edge of town in a rickety old house,
or here in Japan where a tengu is out in the mountains on the fringes of civilization
teaching wayward warriors heterodox ideologies and countercultural curriculums.
And yes, that is the namesake of this channel,
so there's your meta tengu channel deep lore for the day.
What is interesting about this, though,
is that the mainstream culture rarely just gets rid of the witches.
Sure, the Salem witch trials,
but a core feature of that hysteria was that there was always another witch.
Why?
Because the mainstream needs an opposite.
Witches exist because they unite a mainstream culture
and help define it against undesirable traits.
Every culture develops this tactic.
While the use of monsters and creatures has fallen out of favor,
the trend even continues today.
The US, for example, becomes awfully united very quickly
when it finds a convincing enough boogeyman.
Sometimes those boogeymen are real.
Sometimes they are mostly a combination of fear, propaganda, and misunderstandings.
I'm sure politicians would tell you that real or perceived, however,
they are equally useful.
I'm laying it on thick here, so you might have guessed it already.
Yes, these martial arts with a bad reputation are,
indeed, the witches of the martial arts community.
In the next part of this video,
I want to explore how the valid martial criticisms
quickly devolve into very, very poor martial analyses.
Because, again, the most important function of a witch
is that they exist to be exiled.
Engaging with them or otherwise trying to incorporate them
into the larger culture is usually, more times than not, pure theater.
The examples I'm going to use here are far from exhaustive,
but just serve to illustrate my point.
One of my absolute favorite derpy martial arts takes
is when one of the dead horse arts actually spars and does well.
The overwhelming response almost always seems to either be
A. The other guys must have sucked,
or B. I didn't see them use any of X art.
This is always funny to me,
because the first response is classic goalpost moving.
People come to these videos with the loaded cultural knowledge
that the dead horse art is somehow dysfunctional.
Usually, I very much agree with this sentiment.
But why, then, would people, even in their wildest dreams,
expect such a dysfunctional art to win against a super high-level guy?
Of course the other party is low-level.
The part that people miss is that this is how growth starts.
Most new martial arts don't look very good,
and while these aren't new martial arts typically,
they are new to sparring.
A great example of this is Taito.
I've recently been trying to dig up old Taito film,
and sparring from the 90s looks really rough,
especially compared to more modern film.
Now, this isn't to say that I think Taito has become more practical in that time span.
I largely believe Taito has just gotten better at beating Taito at Taito things,
but it's undeniably true that the art has gotten far more refined in the last 30 or 40 years.
So yes, low-level sparring is exactly where I'd expect to see growth begin for these arts.
It's what I'd expect to see in sparring sessions.
But I think the critics are probably aware of this on some level.
Again, I think people are far more invested in seeing a dead horse get beat again
than see improvement.
I genuinely think some of these comments almost come from a place of disappointment
that Aikido or whatever else didn't get whooped.
The second criticism here,
that the martial art on display doesn't look the way it's supposed to according to the observer,
is super amusing to me.
I cannot begin to count the number of times I've seen the modern martial artist
talk about functionality over everything.
Meanwhile, I am strained to remember the last time I've been in a BJJ or MMA or Muay Thai thread
and people were concerned with aesthetics of all things.
No one looks at a BJJ style and goes,
man, that style looks weird.
That doesn't count as BJJ.
In fact, it's usually the opposite.
These weird things are often applauded as innovative and as pushing the sport forward.
Of course, this isn't limited to BJJ,
but really any of the so-called modern martial arts.
Yet, when it's time for the dead horse traditional art to spar
and the art is adapted to sparring
and they do things that don't look very like their non-sparring training,
we suddenly are awfully focused on aesthetics, aren't we?
I've seen this a lot on YouTube,
specifically where the comments section will be lit up with,
that isn't X, Y, or Z style.
And to me,
now call me a radical, I know,
but maybe, just maybe,
the guy in the ring is the one who ought to have the first say on his stylistic influences.
Another of my favorite pieces of bad faith analysis is
one I've been lucky enough to experience in real life.
The old do-that-to-me-while-I-resist trick.
And I call it a trick because it's much closer to being something like that
than the scientific experiment it's often presented as.
The parameters of this are really fun.
Usually the person challenging the other guy will claim some technique doesn't work
and then, to prove it, he will want you to apply it to him.
A couple things are at play here.
First off, it's honestly really, really easy to be 100% committed to defense.
If you have two people of roughly the same skill level,
even if one guy is actually a little bit lower than the other,
the guy whose win condition is just to shut down the other dude's offense
and make him miserable is, well, I mean, I'm betting on him every time.
There's that old piece of military wisdom that it takes a 3-to-1 troop advantage
to take a defensive position, and I think this translates well into martial arts.
While there absolutely are levels to defensive play,
defense is almost always less energy intensive.
Definitionally, it's less risky, and it's more intuitive to learn.
Second, if someone is being purely defensive, it isn't actually a martial test, is it?
The attacker is never in any danger, so there is no reason to apply technique.
The basic premise is moot from the outset.
Third, the defender has a huge information advantage.
They know exactly what you're going to do while they are allowed to do anything to shut it down.
And finally, techniques don't really work this way.
Whether we are talking about knockout punches or takedowns,
half or more of an art is setup and subterfuge.
There are very few techniques that you can get to work consistently in a complete vacuum,
and if you can, it usually implies a very large skill gap or strength gap or something similar.
Don't get me wrong, this kind of thing as a drill can actually be very good training,
but I think you have to be either pretty out of touch or pretty disingenuous to suggest that it's
somehow proof of a technique's efficacy or lack thereof.
The defender has all of the cards.
Speaking of cards, a lot of analyses of arts treat them like trading cards in a competitive game.
They view them as fixed in time.
They are characterized as being unable to have some good features,
nor can they be better in the future.
They are a static generalization, an unmoving stereotype, and a trope.
And again, I find this interesting because it seems like a lot of modern martial arts communities
love and look forward to the evolution of their chosen system.
This enjoyment, however, is denied to the dead horse arts.
The message is pretty clear, at least to me.
You should stay bad, is what people are saying.
Now, having said all this, keep in mind that while every village needs a witch,
the inverse is also true.
Every witch needs a village.
While the villagers in our analogy could certainly afford to be more genuine and constructive,
too many witches just peace out into the wilderness.
When a traditional martial artist just screams in their corner that everything the mainstream
says is wrong and then retreats into a bubble of their own making,
this is almost always the first step into a kind of pseudo-religious zealotry.
I'm pretty convinced this is ultimately how you get narcissists saying that they can no-touch-throw
people or that they alone know the quote-unquote true expression of a martial art,
only accessible through esoteric knowledge that they conveniently have a monopoly over.
Please pay your monthly membership fees on time.
Obviously, this is also deeply unhealthy and not constructive.
The real pain point for me in all of this is that it's a bit of a self-fulfilling prophecy.
If Aikido, for example, had as many people in it as, say, BJJ, and 10% of those people were dead
set on making it very martial, I think the art makes a martial comeback within, I don't know,
15 years.
How we pull that off is another topic for another video.
But for now, I'm just saying that if we were organizing training properly,
sparring, and had these super-solid athletes and all these minds on the mats,
I don't really think it would take that long to produce martially viable results.
I've said this in previous videos, but as it stands, I would bet that less than,
like, a thousand Aikido people in the states are experimenting with Aikido
in a genuinely martial way.
Maybe even just, like, a hundred.
Maybe 10k globally.
Perhaps less.
Maybe I'm wrong, but I'd bet the number is very, very low is what I'm getting at here.
The pity is that the whole dead horse game is very much a vicious cycle
because it keeps talented athletes and fresh minds out of the art.
The message is clear, you can't really be in the in crowd if you do these arts seriously.
As it stands, I think a true martial revitalization of Aikido would require
multiple generations of effort, at least a revitalization on a large scale.
The art just doesn't have the athletes, it doesn't have the young people,
and it doesn't have the people willing to break from tradition.
Also, it's ---- at marketing.
I suspect a lot of these other dead horse arts are either in the same boat,
getting into the same boat, or are in some variation of said boat.
But again, it seems like people don't really want that in popular martial arts culture.
The truth is, even if Aikido had an influx of resources and manpower and
by 2040 was this massive successful practical system,
there would still be another art to take its place in the pantheon of dead horses.
Because people crave not to be the lowest on the pecking order.
They crave comfort in that even on their worst day in the gym,
at least they aren't in those arts.
Now, obviously, as much as this whole yin yang thing and
light always casts a shadow dynamic interests me,
I also pity the whole situation.
My hope with this channel is not really to disprove martial arts or prove my own ideas,
or to preach the underrated supremacy of niche styles or anything silly like that.
I think those kinds of conversations are very worn out in the space.
The premise of the Tengu channel,
aside from approaching martial arts history and philosophy with sources,
is to help people look at things in an alternative way.
Because at the end of the day,
very little in our day-to-day life hinges on the success or demise of martial arts.
We all operate in a space with very little money in it,
very little practical carryover into society in terms of usefulness to others,
and we play sports games, folks.
I take this niche pretty seriously,
and even I fail to see the point in all the tribalism and cultural dogma.
Do I think these dead horse arts are the best out there?
Maybe for someone, but they'd be far from my first choice,
martially speaking, at least in their current states.
But does that mean there's nothing we can pull from them?
Does that mean they can't evolve and adapt?
Does the runt of a litter deserve to just die?
I don't think so.
I'll leave you with this.
These dead horse arts, as I've called them in this video, have a lot of issues.
There are outliers, of course, there are good practitioners,
but generally speaking, they could use a lot of work.
On the other hand, a great deal of our artistic, scientific, and philosophic tradition
is built on the ideas of people who were witches in their own times.
Where would we be if Galileo was still living in the proverbial rickety house
on a hill in our modern culture?
How far set back would our understanding of the heavens be?
I'm not saying these martial arts are perfect,
nor am I saying they'll ever elevate to such a lofty standard,
not even saying that they'll change modern MMA metagames or anything like that.
All I'm saying is that the precursors to chemists were alchemists
looking to change lead into gold.
Maybe we shouldn't write martial practices off just for a passing dopamine hit.
That's all.
But I'll get off my soapbox for now.
I recently put up a community post asking for video topics, and many of you obliged.
I've gotten a list, and I'll be looking to put a dent into it in the coming weeks.
Thank you so much for your engagement there, and, of course, here.
I will catch you all in the next one.
Peace.
