The Surprising Origins of Japanese Martial Arts

Martial arts originated from Japan
137 followers
What if I told you that the origin of Japanese martial arts begins with topless women?
Well, it sort of does. Imagine this. In the mid-5th century, a carpenter is masterfully
planing timber when the emperor approaches him and asks if he has ever made a mistake.
The carpenter replies that he does not know what it means to be an error. And so, in response,
the emperor calls forth his female servants. He orders that they strip down to their waistcloths
and engage in sumo bouts. The carpenter is understandably distracted and falls into the
trap. The emperor, acknowledging the mistakes that he has made, orders the carpenter executed.
But eventually, the mournful protests of the carpenter's friends earn him a pardon.
This story about an emperor awakening a very specific fetish in a carpenter is the very first
use of the term sumo. The episode in question comes from the Nihongi, one of Japan's oldest
texts. The text itself was composed nearly three centuries after the telling of this supposed event,
which casts some doubt on its historiosity. Regardless, there is no grand origin story
for sumo here, despite many martial arts aficionados trying to dubiously interpret one
from similar texts, such as the Kojiki. More on that later. Instead, sumo takes a backseat role
as a plot device and is first known to history through the participation of unnamed, half-naked
female servants. This nonchalant presentation leads one to assume that the readers of the
Nihongi were well-acquainted with sumo, and that it probably happened normally at court.
The participation of women is strange, but the eccentric nature of the emperor in question
makes the demand a bit more believable. My choosing to start here, however, isn't just
because this is chronologically the first use of sumo as a term. It also serves to undermine
many popular assumptions about martial arts. Speaking to sumo specifically, it is often
imagined as something sacred, more of a ritual than a martial art. Yet, this display of sumo
is a spur-of-the-moment affair, and the participation of naked women would almost
have certainly been spiritually transgressive were sumo purely a religious activity. This is
definitely an unusual and inauspicious introduction to the Japanese martial arts.
The origins of Japanese martial arts are a murky thing, though. In this video,
I'm going to give you four different origin stories. You just heard the first one.
This is the part, though, where I have to give a bit of a disclaimer.
The history of Japanese martial arts is a very deep topic, and I am painting
with a very broad brush. Unfortunately, it's just impossible for me to cover everything,
and even making generalizations, this is definitely a multi-video project.
Maybe if my channel gets to the big-boy numbers of more than 50 subscribers, I can somehow string
together enough nickels and dimes to do a deeper dive in the future. For now, however, keep in
mind that this video targets macro-level patterns rather than niches or specific martial arts
schools, as fun as those kinds of looks can be. To that end, like and share this if you find it
useful and make my graduate degree mean something. Disclaimers aside, you might be wondering,
why start with sumo? Surely, there are more iconic martial arts systems in Japan,
like swordsmanship. And while we will definitely get there, this video argues that sumo is the
fundamental basis for all open-handed Japanese martial arts. And as the fundamental basis,
the first question we have to ask is, where did sumo come from? We immediately run into problems
when trying to answer that question. As I mentioned before, if we believe the mytho-history
of the nihongi, the two female servants locked in a titty-tussle is the first chronological
appearance of the word sumo. Both the kojiki and the nihongi were compiled to demonstrate
the imperial line's legitimacy through historical precedent. They aren't pure histories so much as
an unholy matrimony of mythology, history, and curated political precedents. Everything from
before about 600 AD becomes increasingly hazy in the record. Despite the problems with the
nihongi account, I actually prefer it over the more traditional origin of sumo in the older,
sister text, the kojiki. Here, the gods Takemikazuchi and Takeminakata had a test of
strength in which both take turns seizing one another's arms until the former finally breaks
the latter's arm and sends him fleeing. The reward for Takemikazuchi's victory is claim over
Takeminakata's lands. This story is repeated not only in sumo circles, but in later jiu-jitsu
schools it is cited as the beginning of Japanese martial arts. At face value, it definitely seems
to neatly lay the foundation for modern ideas about sumo, right down to the religious overtones.
So why do I prefer the other account? To me, this origin story requires some very liberal
interpretation to link it back to sumo. For one thing, a test of strength could mean anything,
and what is described could as much be an arm wrestling match as it is a sumo bout. There are
also fantastical elements at play here, such as participants' arms shapeshifting into ice and
swords. In short, this account is marred by ambiguity in terms of what is actually happening,
and the other account has boobs. Still, my top-heavy preferences aside, both of the texts
have similar basic flaws. Even if we charitably assume that both of them are indeed records of
sumo matches, all this proves is that the authors knew of sumo, not necessarily that sumo was
actually present in the period that the texts cover. In other words, we can say that sumo
was in the cultural consciousness of the noble elite in the early 8th century,
but not that sumo itself had been around for a very long time before that.
We have any other sources we can use then? Well, a cursory scan of the internet has references to,
and I quote, ancient cave art that indicate sumo was derived from a ritual dance that would bring
about a good harvest. End quote. This is possible, I guess, but I have yet to find a citation,
or a book, or a paper that confirms this art actually exists and that it has been interpreted
by scholars as being somewhere in sumo's lineage. Instead, this idea is thrown around on countless
websites without any source. In those sites' defense, however, I even found this claim
unsourced in more scholarly work. I want to be clear that dance and martial arts, especially in
Asia, have significant and real historical connections. I also do not necessarily doubt
that such cave art really exists. If anything, my concern lies with how it has been interpreted.
Much like our previous sources, art is subjective and is prone to a lot of conflicting interpretations.
This is how the ancient alien people get a lot of their so-called evidence, by interpreting
drawings of corn cobs as rocket ships, and then dramatically narrating goofy stuff about the image.
I also want to point out again that the idea that sumo developed from religion lines up
conveniently with the popular narrative. People like sources that confirm their own beliefs and
biases. I go through great pains not to do that here. But let's be charitable for a moment and
assume this cave art does exist, and, without a shadow of a doubt, it depicts something that
looks like wrestling in a harvest ritual context. The Chronicle of Wei is the oldest document we
have, and it describes, from a Chinese perspective, the Japanese archipelago. Here, the land is called
Hua, and it seemingly describes a much less unified, homogenous group of people than what
we're normally used to seeing on the islands. In this text, there is mention of dance, and it's in
celebration of throwing seeds, in other words, harvest ritual. There is not, however, an explicit mention
of what this dance looks like, or if it looks anything like wrestling at all. It is also possible
that the Chronicle is only describing one clan's customs, while somewhere else on the islands,
wrestling might have been much more common. If we take the most optimistic position and assume that
these dances were sumo's origin, then this would place wrestling proper sometime after the very late
3rd century. Finally, let's return to the Nihongi for one more alternative look at sumo's origins.
If we ignore the supposed bout between the two gods in the Kojiki, this next mythological fight
is usually considered the true beginning of sumo by traditional narratives. Here, the Emperor Suinin
orders a fight between Nomi no Sukune and Taima no Kehaya. Sukune wins by kicking Kehaya, breaking
his ribs and then stomping him to death. In the aftermath, Sukune is awarded the lands that Kehaya
had presided over. This bout predates the episode of the carpenter getting distracted by his own
wood, but it never explicitly calls what's happening sumo, even though it's a pretty clear
example of what sumo is. It is an account that lays the foundation, in fact, for a lot of what
sumo would be in its earliest form. Strongmen being called forth from the countryside to compete
for noble entertainment. To we modern observers, though, some things probably stand out immediately.
For example, the wrestlers in this bout were kicking the hell out of each other. In fact,
the death-dealing blow was a kick to Kehaya's testicles. That outcome being something that
totally tracks in my experience, but at least in modern sumo, this would of course be extremely
illegal. Putting Kehaya's tragic testy demolition aside, this account really sets a lot of precedence.
We see sumo long before the rule set that would come to define it nearly a thousand years later.
In this early variation of the sport, it is clear that severe injury and even death were much less
of a concern. I do, however, believe it was definitely a sport. I will go into this a bit
more in a future video, but I want you to note here that the match in this account was arranged,
seen by an audience, there was a prize for victory, and as will become clear in that later video,
both wrestlers probably had sponsors. Not to mention that the word champion is initially
used to describe Kehaya. While this title might have been self-awarded in this case,
it hints that sumo was already an institution in these days. The only thing really separating this
ancient sumo from our modern idea of combat sports is a coherent rule set and protection
of the participants through said rule set. That was a lot of information, so let's do a
really quick recap just for the sake of organizing some core ideas. We have four
very different introductions to sumo at play here. The first comes from the Nihongi and is a
lewd display of two half-naked women having a bout and is our first example of the word sumo in use.
It often gets ignored by the popular narrative because it doesn't really play well with
modern images of sumo. Namely, modern sumo is culturally venerated and has supposed deep
religious roots, yet none of that is present in this first account. The second account comes from
the Kojiki and it is the favored classical origin of Japanese martial arts as found in the popular
narrative. It depicts two gods locked in an ambiguous test of strength that decides the
ownership of land. What this test of strength actually is, however, is debatable at best.
The third source comes from supposed cave art that depicts wrestling in the context of harvest
rituals, and if my viewers have a source for this claim, particularly images accompanied by a
scholarly write-up, that would be very useful. For now, however, our most charitable interpretation
only circumstantially relates the alleged art to religious activity. Our fourth source is again
pooled from the Nihon-gi. Here we see our first clear description of sumo, despite it not actually
being referred to as such. It is clear that even with the absence of rules, the brutal activity is
definitely akin to a sport. There is no mention of religion or religious dimension at all, but land
is awarded for Sukune's victory. So what can we conclude from all of this? Well, the first major
point is that the popular idea of sumo being an activity steeped in native religion is contestable.
I'm not arguing that later Shinto influences sumo, not at all, but that comes further along in history,
I think. In the very earliest days of sumo, the evidence we have for it coming from or even being
related to religion is mostly circumstantial. On the other hand, sumo does appear to have a
In the earliest Kojiki story and in the final Nihon-gi Sukune story, the victors both receive
land. Whether or not this was just the traditional prize or perhaps some kind of warfare by proxy
is unclear. Finally, we can tell that sumo has a lot of characteristics of modern sport,
even if it will lack a defined, standardized rule set for centuries to come. What we are left with
from these four sources is a hazy picture of what the original sumo must have looked like.
Brutal, but ultimately not unrecognizable as a sport. What these sources fail to
concretely tell us, though, is the actual origin of sumo. For a hint at that, I offer you
one final bonus twist source. Here is one way that the word sumo was written in the ancient
Japanese script. And here is how it was written in the Chinese script. Oh, would you look at that?
It's the exact same rendering. You might have some reservations about this, though.
Hasn't Japan historically been an isolated country? The answer really depends on when you're
about. The reality is that early Japan imported tons of culture, religion, political ideology,
and, obviously, language from China. The transfer wasn't one-to-one, of course,
and these mainland ideas went through a lot of adaptation to suit unique Japanese needs.
Regardless, early Japan just wasn't as isolated as might be popularly imagined.
Historian Amino Yoshihiko, for example, argues that the waters that surrounded Japan could be
as much a highway for trade and cultural exchange as they could serve as a treacherous barrier.
Primary sources even spell this out. The Shinsen Shojiroku has a compiled list of 1,182 court
lineages, and of those, nearly a third are considered barbarian in origin. Read as,
they were foreigners. And that was just in the court. Who knows how large the immigrant population
was among commoners. At this point, you may be thinking, ladies and gentlemen, we got him.
Unfortunately, this isn't really a smoking gun either, though. While the written language used
to describe these wrestling bouts was the same here, plenty of other terms would also be used to
describe sumo that were not at all the same. It also might be possible that the Chinese wrestling
tradition may have not been imported at all, and that the terminology I'm showing you here
was simply used to describe a wrestling tradition that already existed on the Japanese isles.
Still, I wanted to point this out though, because what pre-modern Chinese wrestling
eventually evolved into does vaguely resemble sumo in some respects. Also,
and somewhat more importantly, the Chinese will appear again and again in this series of videos,
like the inevitable cameo in an after credits Marvel movie scene.
I'm just pointing out this pattern now because it really does keep popping up.
Oh whoa, conclusion you say? What about the swords and the samurai? Well, don't you worry,
we will be discussing Glorious Nippon Steel in part two, which will be linked here as soon as
I release it. In the meantime, there will be a reading list in the description if you want to
personally dig into some of the material that I used to make this video. As for the answer to
where sumo came from, well the answer is somewhat anticlimactically up to interpretation. Maybe it
was imported from China, maybe it was a harvest ritual, or maybe it was a way to dispute land
rights. It was definitely a way for nobles to keep themselves entertained though, and it may
have very well been some combination of all of the above. Sometimes we can simply only know what we
know. The good news though is that these vague and unsatisfying answers should mostly be behind
us as we dive into much better recorded history from here onward. So get subbed up and stay tuned
as next time we'll look at just how badly movies have lied to you about samurai. Spoilers, they've
lied to you like a lot.
