San Francisco (1936) is a sweeping musical drama starring Clark Gable, Jeanette MacDonald, and Spencer Tracy. Set in the vibrant city before the devastating 1906 earthquake, the film follows nightclub owner Blackie Norton and talented singer Mary Blake as ambition, romance, and conflicting values draw their lives together.
Filled with memorable music and spectacular scenes of old San Francisco, the film shifts dramatically when disaster strikes. In the ruins of the earthquake, personal ambitions give way to courage, faith, compassion, and the determination to rebuild.
Tiffany and Rebecca Brannan analyze the 1936 MGM film *San Francisco*, exploring its blend of disaster, romance, and opera. They discuss the career impacts on its stars, the film's technical achievements in depicting the 1906 earthquake, and how the narrative serves as an allegory for Hollywood's transition toward moral self-regulation under the Motion Picture Production Code.
It takes a tiny corner of this great big world to make a place you love.
My home upon the hill, I find I love you still.
I've been away, but now I'm back to tell you.
San Francisco, open your golden gate.
You let no stranger wait outside your door.
San Francisco, here is your wandering one,
saying, I want her no more.
Other places only make me love you best.
Tell me you're the heart of all the Golden West.
The Golden West.
San Francisco, welcome me home again.
I'm coming home to go roaming no more.
What was that?
What was what?
Didn't you feel it?
It was an earthquake.
No, it probably was just a truck driving by.
Was it?
You're probably right.
I just, you know how I am about earthquakes.
Well, I don't blame you.
They are pretty scary.
And we do have a lot of them here in California.
Yeah, especially because there's no way of knowing when they're going to strike.
Right.
One minute you can be in a nightclub singing and winning a trophy full of gold.
And the next minute the whole room could start shaking and the ceiling fall in.
Thanks.
That's a fine thing to say to somebody who's deathly afraid of earthquakes.
But how often does that happen?
That's an oddly specific scenario you're describing, by the way.
Well, whenever I think of earthquakes,
I can't help but picture the most dramatic earthquake sequence ever put to film.
Oh, you mean San Francisco.
I'm Tiffany Brannan.
I'm Rebecca Brannan.
Welcome to Real Thoughts on Cinema.
In recent months, the number one topic of conversation,
in entertainment circles at least,
has been whether or not society at large cares about the classical arts.
Nevertheless, it only takes one positive experience with opera
to turn a hater into a diehard fan.
In the classic era of Hollywood,
many films brilliantly worked opera into their plots
in a way that made it palatable and entertaining for the masses.
Some of these films even featured characters
who experienced sort of a transformation in their relationship to the arts
as they grow to appreciate them throughout the course of the film.
One of the most famous classic disaster films, surprisingly,
is set against a story of opera, faith, and redemption.
This movie is San Francisco from 1936.
The story takes place in San Francisco on the Barbary Coast in the year 1906.
Mary Blake, a country parson's daughter,
has come to the big city to try to become an opera singer.
However, not having any success at this,
she must seek employment as a singer in a saloon,
the Paradise, run by Blackie Norton.
Finding the young woman very attractive, Blackie gives her the job.
However, on her first night,
the kindly pianist has her sing a classical song
to impress an opera impresario who was present that evening.
He offers her a job at the Tivoli,
but Blackie will not let her out of her contract.
Amongst the rabble and immorality of the Barbary Coast,
Mary meets a kindly priest, Tim Mullen,
who was childhood friends with Blackie,
and the two of them determined together to try to save him from himself.
This movie was produced by MGM.
It was directed by W.S. Van Dyck II
with uncredited directorial help from Erich von Stroheim and D.W. Griffith.
It was produced by John Emerson and Bernard H. Hyman.
The stars of this picture are Jeanette MacDonald, Clark Gable, and Spencer Tracy.
Clark Gable is remembered as one of those great actors of old Hollywood
who is almost more famous just by his name than his movies
because he was in Gone with the Wind.
That's a really good point.
But before that and after that, he was one of the top stars at MGM.
So when this movie was released in 1936,
this is definitely in his early heyday.
And I would say that this is a somewhat unlikely pairing
because this movie is very reliant on these three main actors,
but it's unusual that they would be together like this
because this is the first pairing of any of these three.
You're right.
Even though under the studio system at the time, they were all MGM actors,
but even within a studio, there are certain people
you just wouldn't usually see together in a movie,
and I think this is definitely an unlikely pairing.
Now, after this, Clark Gable and Spencer Tracy would make a few other movies together,
but the especially unlikely pairing here
is having romantic leads played by Clark Gable and Jeanette MacDonald.
Jeanette MacDonald really was undergoing a transformation, I think,
at this point in her career or had just made a transformation
going from the pre-code era, 1930 to 1934.
She had been the lingerie diva,
so she often was in her lingerie and her legs were quite famous,
but she did sing and she was in sort of musical comedies,
very famously with Maurice Chevalier, Love Me Tonight, The Merry Widow.
With the introduction of moral standards in Hollywood in 1934,
she really had to make a turnaround
because any actors who couldn't get out of just being about
taking their clothes off or something like that
really didn't last into this new era.
So she really was transformed into now being this opera singer,
even though she wasn't really, she didn't have that kind of training,
but she had a classical sound.
The popular style of the day just was more classical,
the 20s and the 30s, it was a different sound.
So you hear her using that somewhat pseudo-classical style farther back.
So by this point she'd made two movies with Nelson Eddy,
who would become her frequent co-star,
but at this point he was touring because in his contract
he was allotted a certain amount of time to tour per year.
Because he was a classically trained opera singer
and he wanted to bring opera to the masses in his own way.
And a lot of reviews of this movie to say,
while her frequent co-star was away, but I think that's not entirely true.
She was a star long before she worked with Nelson Eddy,
so I think they didn't want her to only work with him,
I think they wanted her to continue working with other actors.
I think he was an important part of her transformation into this new identity,
but then they wanted her to be able to stand on her own as well.
She continued making at least one movie with another co-star per year,
approximately throughout her MGM years with him through 1942.
So I think this is actually one of her strongest movies aside from Nelson Eddy.
It's right up there in the top three probably.
And it's unusual in that The Leading Man has absolutely nothing to do with music,
but that's kind of the power of it.
There's this very unlikely romance between them,
reflected by how much they didn't like each other in real life.
The irony of that to me is that, if this is to be believed,
I read that she wanted him for this part.
She specifically requested to have him as her leading man.
I guess she liked what she'd seen of him on the screen better than actually working with him.
That's understandable. That can happen easily.
And I agree that he's excellent for this part.
Yes. He didn't want to make this movie, is that right?
Yeah, I think that was really what the problem was. He had a bad attitude.
As a contract player.
They tell you this and if you don't then you get put on suspension,
which is always happening at Warner Brothers.
Similarly, Spencer Tracy had some slight reservations about making this movie
because he would play the role of a priest.
And he was a devout Catholic,
so he didn't know if it was quite the right thing to do to be playing a priest.
So he had to think about that a while, but ultimately he decided to do it.
And I'd say this marks a turning point in his career.
Absolutely.
Because, of course, he had played a mixture of nice guys and thugs throughout his career thus far,
but playing this really sensitive character of the priest
who is not afraid to physically fight for what he believes,
yet he's fighting for something greater than himself.
And he ended up winning an Academy Award nomination for Best Actor for this.
Best Leading Actor. That's interesting.
Because it really is more of a supporting role.
But Spencer Tracy couldn't be supporting at this point,
which is obviously why he didn't win.
I believe it's notably short in terms of how much screen time the character has for a Best Actor nomination.
It still holds the record.
It's only 14 minutes as being the shortest performance nominated for Best Actor.
This was his first Academy Award nomination,
but he would go on to win Best Actor the next two years.
Which is one of only two times I think that that's happened.
And funnily enough, one of those wins was for playing a priest again.
So I guess he went on to decide that that was alright for him to do.
As a musical, it almost seems wrong to call this movie a musical
because it is quite a cross of several genres.
So I think it should be approached as such.
Someone might think, oh, a musical. I don't want to watch a musical.
But it's not that kind of a musical.
And that's absolutely what I would say to a lot of people who don't have much experience with classic films.
If they're musical haters, there are a lot of classic films that you could technically call musicals
that are not what most people are probably going to think of going into a musical.
They're expecting everybody singing and dancing randomly.
And that's not this at all. It's always in context.
And there are so many musicals of the day that were like that.
Almost all the movies Jeanette MacDonald made were, for the most part, like that.
Yeah, even if there was...
Okay, maybe this is kind of an odd situation to be singing.
The characters were usually identified as being singers within the plot of the story.
She played an opera singer a lot.
And in this particular film, it's very appropriate for you to go into it as a bit of a music or opera hater
because that's what Blackie Norton is at the beginning.
He obviously likes the showy burlesque tunes that are being performed at the Paradise.
But he has no understanding of music himself
and no real appreciation for how much better a performer Mary is
than a lot of the other girls he hires.
But he comes to have an appreciation when he actually goes to see her at the opera in Faust.
And this film has an interesting mixture of music
because it has some original songs, very few,
but a few original songs by Branislaw Kepper and...
Ghas Khan.
Ghas Khan wrote the lyrics.
As well as several songs that were from that era.
Right.
Things like the Darktown Strutters' Ball, which technically is from 1917,
but it's close.
Or Love Me and the World is Mine.
Those are some old songs.
But then original songs that they wrote for the movie, like Would You,
which is best known from Singing in the Rain.
Right.
That was actually written for this.
And the title song, San Francisco.
I found it so interesting that that was written for this film,
but now it's considered the anthem of San Francisco
and it will be played and sung at memorials of the San Francisco earthquake.
That's right.
It's really...
It just says what needs to be said.
That's right.
But besides that,
there also is a lot of classical music featured in this film.
That's right.
A lot of beautiful operas.
The two most notably featured are Faust and La Traviata.
They show excerpts from quite a bit of Faust, honestly.
Sort of an overview of the whole opera.
That's true, because Blackie goes to see Faust and shut it down,
since technically she's still under contract to him.
Right.
But as he's watching it,
he tells the process server not to stop the performance
because he's struck by how beautiful it is.
And then there's a scene of her singing the famous aria
Sempre Libera from Verdi's La Traviata.
And I think there's such a brilliant use of opera in this particular film
because it's not just there are opera excerpts,
they're paralleling the story.
So if you are familiar with opera,
if you're an opera fan, you'll see parallels.
And she's in Faust,
and they show the beautiful conclusion of that opera.
The final scene, she's this very innocent girl,
but she's led astray by this evil man.
She's tempted by jewels,
by sort of the glitz and glamour.
And that's very much paralleling how she's being tempted
by Blackie and the lifestyle of the Barbary Coast.
And then later on, she's in La Traviata.
While Violetta is not an especially innocent character,
there's a very memorable scene in La Traviata
when she has left her beloved and he throws money in her face.
And later on in the film,
when she wins this trophy full of gold for Blackie,
he doesn't throw it in her face,
but he throws it down on stage and says,
I don't need this.
And that's subtle.
I didn't even think about that until the last time we watched this movie.
Watched again, it's like, that's sort of a parallel to La Traviata.
I assume that was intentional.
Yeah.
And the way that character also is torn between
the more respectable man and the man she loves.
In the very aria Sempre Libera, that's what Violetta is expressing.
Just as at that point,
Mary goes back and forth so many times between Jack Burley,
this respectable man who is from Nob Hill.
He basically owns the Tivoli Opera House.
And then Blackie Norton, this kind of rough around the edges,
common man of the people who's built himself up from the ground.
I don't want to say more than around the edges.
He's rough through and through.
That's a good point.
And she's torn between that she really loves Blackie
and feels that there's still some good in him.
Whereas she knows that Jack is more the man she should love.
The sort of husband she should want.
That's a very operatic premise.
Yes, yes it is.
I think it's interesting in a conversation she has with his conductor, right?
She makes mention of that she really loves Puccini,
but no Puccini music is actually featured in this film.
True.
But I appreciate that when saying she loves Puccini,
she mentions La Boheme and Tosca,
both of which were early Puccini works that he'd written.
That's right, because he was alive at the time.
This is 1906, so it's still in his somewhat early period.
She didn't mention something like Johnny Schicke
or even Madame Butterfly, neither of which had debuted yet.
So that's a nice attention to historical detail.
This movie is made in 1936,
so that's very early comparatively in the history of film,
especially for people who aren't really into old movies.
Still less than 10 years from the beginning of sound,
but they'd had plenty of time to really develop
all the techniques which were used in making very effective sound films.
But just as this story is about redemption,
I think the story behind the story in this movie
tells us so much about Hollywood,
talking about how all these actors were making transformations in their careers,
but so was Hollywood.
Because in 1934, that was the beginning of the Production Code Administration,
which finally enforced the Motion Picture Production Code
under the guidance of Joseph Breen.
And it was an impossible dream, it would seem,
to transform Hollywood from this corrupt, evil place
into a place where they could actually make films
that focused on having decent values
and put something above just making money,
because this was the height of the Great Depression,
and they reasoned, we need to make these scandalous films
or we'll never be able to survive.
When you think about it, it's kind of crazy and amazing
that they actually did that.
It is.
I mean, in a good way.
It's sort of like the story of the American Revolution,
or anything when a tyrant is overthrown.
Can there be a positive change,
or is everything governed by the second law of thermodynamics?
It's such a good way of looking at it.
And all things are tending toward entropy.
Right, this kind of panic, concern about losing money,
and this feeling to hand out a scandalous content
was like this tyrant that was ruling Hollywood.
Yeah, and they weren't doing well financially.
They were in the red, as they say.
By 1934, they were caught between a rock and a hard place.
They had the Legion of Decency,
was showing moral pressure from people who were religious,
and who said, we don't want these corrupt films.
And then Franklin D. Roosevelt, the somewhat new president,
was threatening to start a new organization
to actually have government censorship.
And Hollywood didn't want that, so they realized,
we have one more chance to clean up things for ourselves,
so let's put somebody in charge who actually will get things done.
Someone who's from among us.
And that's when they chose Joseph Breen,
who had been working behind the scenes for years.
And for those who don't understand the subtleties of it,
censorship was when an outside force would just take a finished film
and then hack it to pieces,
and then the new process was so it was made correctly in the first place,
so they didn't have to do that.
Which they called self-regulation.
And we watched this movie for the first time nine years ago,
which is 2017.
That's within less than a year from when we started our blog,
the Pure Entertainment Preservation Society,
that was all about bringing back the code.
So we were still relatively new to the whole code thing,
but studying everything from that point of view.
So it's so interesting, it's been a couple of years now
since we've even seen this movie,
to go back and watch it with that understanding,
with more knowledge of opera.
But it really struck me this last time
that this film is not only an example
of an early perfect code film,
but a parallel for the battle within Hollywood itself.
You could say that Mary is a representation
of the film industry itself.
She's sort of like this idea, this concept,
if you consider Hollywood to be like this.
Or even the audience,
the audience who's inherently innocent,
but can be swayed one way or the other.
And there's this one side,
which wants to sell her out, corrupt her,
sell her soul, that's Blackie,
who loves and admires Mary,
but basically just wants to use her
because he thinks that her beauty and talent
should be exploited by wearing cheap costumes.
And then on the other hand, we have Tim Mullen,
who loves her in a brotherly or fatherly way,
but who fights against his friend
and says, you're not going to corrupt this girl.
I think Tim Mullen is a representation
of what Joseph Breen was,
a man who would be friends
with the very evil, corrupt filmmakers
who not only didn't agree with what he believed,
but mocked it.
Like, Blackie consistently refers to religion
as hocus pocus.
Now, he has enough respect to send an organ
to his friend's church,
because he still likes him.
Father Mullen says he's always hided up in a code.
He doesn't lie or cheat.
He doesn't take an underhanded advantage of anyone.
So it's interesting how people can not have morals
or religion and still have just sort of
an ethical code, I guess,
would be more accurate than a moral code.
That's right.
Which is a deep philosophical point
about how the innate sense of right or wrong
does exist in every human being.
And this is his friend.
He still really likes him, even though he doesn't...
They don't agree with each other's life choices,
but they're still very good friends.
They still have a lot of love for each other.
So he's just like, oh, this is my friend.
He needs something.
I'll give it to him.
So it's not for the church. It's not for religion.
It's just, this is something for my friend.
It's a personal gift.
But that is still coming from his heart.
And then Father Mullen says,
don't tell him that I told you about that,
because he's ashamed of his good impulses.
As other men are ashamed of their sins.
And similarly, you could see Hollywood
didn't want to reform.
They were fighting tooth and nail.
But because they grew to trust Mr. Breen,
seeing him as someone who would
joke around with them,
fight them if necessary,
there's actually, interestingly,
because this movie is by Woody Van Dyke,
I have to tell this story,
that one of the other members of the PCA told,
apparently there was some incident
in the screening room where Joe Breen
ended up socking Woody Van Dyke
and knocking him out.
That was probably not true.
He was known for telling stories
just to make an impact.
But it seems like something
you could imagine happening.
Good old Irish Blarney.
The directors liked having that kind of sparring with him.
Just as,
the first time we see
Father Tim, he's actually
fighting in a boxing ring with Blackie.
And he's just in black, so you don't know.
And then he goes into the changing room
and he comes out and he's wearing the collar.
And you're like, oh, he's pretty surprised.
And I think this character is not quite the beginning,
but one of the first of a new type
of character that really became popular
under the coat.
The sort of two-fisted priest.
The fact that they had
a young, bankable
leading man playing a priest.
Usually he would be an older man.
Very much a father figure. But this is the kind of
leading man who easily could be the romantic lead
to Jenna McDonald. Or could be
Clark Gable's romantic rival in this story.
If he weren't a priest, he probably would be.
But instead, he's his
spiritual rival. And because of
the success of this film, I think that's why you see movies
like Boys Town, Going My Way,
Angels With Dirty Faces,
where you had these
oftentimes Irish actors
playing these important priest roles.
But the point isn't about
selling Catholicism or even Christianity.
It's about that selling
your soul will ultimately
not bring you any happiness or contentment.
And there's an interesting conversation
later when Mary meets
Jack's mother.
And she talks about how there
was a handsome,
adorable scoundrel whom she loved in her
youth, but that he was killing
her soul. And you see that really
strikes Mary. She repeats,
killing your soul.
And that San Francisco is
similarly, like Hollywood, a wild
town because it needed that kind
of hot blood to be
founded. Yet now, the people are just
reveling in all sorts of immorality.
And it takes a cleansing
by an act of God,
an earthquake and a fire, to
catharsis, cleansing by fire,
and renew it. Just as Hollywood had
to be cleansed by earthquakes
and fires, and then the code
could come in. And besides these
obvious parallels, I think you see some things
that would become popular in the code era. Firstly, of course,
the priest, but also
the ecumenical message.
Mary describes that she's the
daughter of a parson. So obviously, she's a Protestant
because her father was a minister, not
a priest. Yet she and Tim
instantly bond over their shared
faith. They don't get into squabbles
about little denominational differences, which
was a pretty big deal still in the 1930s.
There was still a lot of
hostility between the two
denominations. But
like she says, even if I didn't believe
the same thing, seeing his faith would
convince me. And they,
you could say they unite over a common enemy,
namely Blackie and his
sinful lifestyle, so that maybe together
we can help show him
the error of his ways by
not preaching at him, but just showing him
what love and faith are. And that's exactly
what had to happen for the code
to succeed. The Legion of Decency was
originally called the Catholic Legion of Decency, but they
quickly renamed it to the National Legion
of Decency because a lot of Protestants
and even Jews joined.
People who believed that Hollywood was
corrupting the whole country, and it didn't matter
what your religion was.
If you believed in any kind of decency, you'd see
that what they were doing wasn't good.
And the code continued,
although Joseph Breen and some of his
authors, both of his authors were Catholic,
to promote what they considered just basic
Christian morality that all Americans
could support. Similar to
the great Christian apologist
C.S. Lewis and his Mirror Christianity
talking about just the basic principles of Christianity.
I think those are the same basic principles
that the code tried to have. Classical
music. You wouldn't think there would be any real
connection between classical music
and the code, yet during
the code era, you see
opera, ballet, and classical music
included just art for art's sake
in a way you don't in any other time period.
Well, whenever you take something
away, something has to go in its place, and there was
so much stuff that they were just wasting a bunch of
screen time with in the pre-code era
that they had to
find something to replace that.
And I think it became
classical arts. It kind of
took that place.
If you want
to have something that's just kind of extraneous,
just kind of there just for entertainment purposes,
what better than music?
And good music. I think sometimes
it was even like, here, look, we're
trying to be good. We're putting classical music in.
I think there was a show like, let's act
cultured because we're being
accused of just having no culture and no class.
So both classical
music and then the era of
making more classic stories,
classic novels and Shakespeare very much
came in, and it was just all part of this
sort of tidal wave of culture.
Yeah, and including
actual operas, I think Hollywood
probably looked to opera as an example
of opera's famous for including
very scandalous things, lots of
affairs and death. That's a good point.
But if you actually watch an
opera and study the text, you'll see that
it's not, when done traditionally
as it should be, it's not obscene.
It's not lurid. Just like
adapting a classic novel
or any kind of story to film, a lot of times
just the story on paper could easily
be really horrible. It could
turn into an R-rated film. Or it could be like
this, and I think opera's the same way.
If you look at staging, it makes all the
difference. And it's the same thing with writing a film.
So code films follow that similar example of
using decorum
and then, of course,
costuming was an important part of
code. I think movies around this time
you see, they would include
just enough
briskety in costumes with
some very short skirts or even
a little short outfit she wears, which was
quite scandalous at the time, and an occasional
slightly lower neckline
only for a point, to show this is a woman
of low moral character. There's a good phrase
in the code for plot or proper
characterization. Yes. And the
costumes in this movie
reflect that. My outfit
is inspired by the more fancy
styles that you see Mary wearing
in several scenes. The cut
of this dress is very much
signature of the era, 1906.
In one gown, she wears
a notable brooch and a
couple of very large, elaborate hats.
My outfit is based
on the first costume which we see
Mary wear, and which she wears later
as well, which is a simple walking
skirt with a white
shirt waist and a
matching bow at the neck, and she's
wearing a tilted hat in that first scene.
Of course, this movie
is a musical, a story of redemption,
a drama, but it's
most famous for being a disaster film.
Although the disaster
is really only the very last part
of the film. It's very cleverly
done, I think, that
in case you don't immediately
see the date and you're, oh, this
is going to be involving
the earthquake, they tell you with a
little card at the end of the opening credits.
Yes. So, there's this little teaser
like, you know what's coming.
So, as the drama of the story is playing,
I know it's building toward this
epic disaster.
And, boy, do they pay off
with that sequence. The way they filmed
this is, people still
wonder how they actually did it.
And it's believed that W.S. Van Dyke
brought in D.W. Griffith to
help him specifically on the earthquake sequence
because Griffith was his mentor
and considered, really,
the first real Hollywood director
right alongside Cecil B. DeMille.
But he made Birth of a Nation
and some of the movies that are
considered the first Hollywood films around the year 1915.
So, by this point, his
career was basically over, but he
would sometimes still do little bit parts
and he really helped
Woody develop the techniques needed
to make this. Obviously, they used things like
putting the sets on rockers. Right.
Even moving
the film a few times, they might have done.
I'm assuming they used miniatures
for when you're seeing the buildings
collapse? I think they did use some
miniatures. I think they also just blew up some buildings.
Well, yeah, I mean, on the back lot, they had
They liked doing that. They were like, well,
we need to clear all this junk anyway. Let's blow up
some buildings. Like in Gone with the Wind, they
burnt so many old sets to film
the famous fire scene.
And this disaster scene
includes two earthquakes
and fire.
There's the main earthquake,
then there's another serious aftershock,
and then there
are all these fires that happened.
And they're dynamiting the buildings to try to
stop the spread of the fire. Yes.
And all this is based on what really happened.
And because this is an early
film, the footage
looks so real, because there actually is
some footage from around that time, before and
after the disaster, and
obviously it's grainier, but it looks similar.
So that black and white quality
of the early film.
I almost wondered if they
did something different
with the film for the earthquake sequence. The earthquake
sequence looks older than the rest of the movie. They might have
tried to make it look older. Or maybe even that's
something that was done in the remastering process. Maybe
they didn't remaster that part quite as much for effect.
I really don't know, but it strikes
me as having almost the look of
when you see in a World War II movie,
now they're showing actual war footage. It feels a little bit
like that. One thing is that at this point,
they still filmed action sequences
without sound, because
cameras were very loud,
so they couldn't move them around.
They had to have them in boxes.
So if they needed to move a camera around, they would use their
silent cameras. So the film
is a little bit faster.
It gives it that little
silent film quality of running around,
which also makes it seem older.
You see that throughout the
1930s.
Sometimes you even see it later.
It's like, why did they film that without sound?
I think it's for effect. Westerns
later on, they would do that sometimes.
It has to do with the speed
and the amount of frames per second.
But there's
double exposure, there's
all sorts of symbolism
in this, and it's exciting.
Even if you've seen modern films,
it's exciting because it's real.
People are having things falling on them,
and it's
very real.
It's very refreshing compared to
CGI, AI.
It's real.
We almost can't even look back at old movies and say,
oh, it's not as clear.
Films now don't even look like film anymore.
They look like cartoons. It's nice to see
that this actually looks like film.
One of the
most chilling moments in it is
almost, I'd say, a technical
error, where there's this
woman who seems to be maybe holding a child
on a second story after a building
has opened up, and she jumps
off, but she's so
much in shadows that you can almost
see through her. I think this
was a double exposure that
just resulted in a slight
transparency, because sometimes you'll see in double exposure
you can see through things.
But I've never seen it to such a dramatic extent.
Some people even say it's supposed to be a
ghost. I don't think it's supposed to be a ghost,
but I think that this probably happened
accidentally, and then when they saw,
oh, that's really neat, they probably went with it
because I think if they didn't want it to look
like that, they would have changed it.
I know what you mean. There's something about it. It's like this tiny
moment in this very long sequence, and that's
the first thing you think of when you think of
this sequence. Because it's freaky!
But it's chilling.
Another really dramatic moment
in it is in the second part of the earthquake,
the ground splits
and a few people fall into
the crack, like they're falling into hell.
And then one guy gets grabbed and
dragged out.
Then there's this, on
one side there's a woman who's praying,
and it's very symbolic that she doesn't fall
in because she's praying, so she's
spared from falling into hell.
There's so much you can say about it.
You really have to watch it to experience it.
I would definitely say, if you
are looking for sort of an
entry-level classic film,
but not just one like, oh, it's really palatable
if you're not into old movies. No. If you really want
to see what old movies are like,
if you want to understand what
the motion picture production code was like,
and what Hollywood was capable of doing
in 1936, I would
say San Francisco's at the top of the list.
It was MGM's top-earning film of the year,
nominated for many Academy Awards,
and it won one. Not a very
notable one, but... People were commenting
that it didn't win Best Special Effect because
that was not a category yet. That's right.
This is still within the first ten years of the Academy Awards,
so they were still figuring things out.
If they'd had that, I'm sure this would have won it.
Yeah, I think if you're
trying to just dip your
toes and ease into classic films,
probably don't start with a movie from the 30s.
Because it's just, there's a very definite
style of the 30s, which we both adore,
and I think you can learn to love it very easily.
I think it's more if you just want to jump in with both
feet, just like you said, really see
what classic films have to offer, but also
maybe see something and be like, wow, I didn't know they could do
that back then. I think this is a really...
It will defy your expectations.
I think it's a level of special effects
that you won't say it's impressive for the era.
People like to say that. This one is impressive
for any era. Yeah, I challenge
Hollywood of any time to do something
that looks this good without using
computer effects, which
you can always tell.
So it's a challenge because of
the ingenuity used. There's
just some great dramatic acting.
Some of the most dramatic performances from all
three of these actors. Beautiful costumes.
Great music, but
not too much.
There are some opera.
There are some opera type.
There are some more
show tunes.
Minstrel type numbers.
No blackface, though, so
you won't be offended by that.
Because, you know, you see that in films of this era.
But there are some actual, very talented
black performers who are doing a
minstrel type number.
I think it's a very
historically accurate look at 1906
besides the one inclusion of the Darktown Strutters
with the combination of the
costumes, the hairstyling.
It's a good look at 1936,
1906, and
you can see what they could do
90 years ago.
This is the 90th anniversary this year.
It's amazing.
And you can find a clear
beautiful black and white copy
for rent or purchase
on Amazon Prime Video,
on YouTube, on several other
streaming platforms, as well
as on DVD. It's been nicely
remastered by Warner
Classic Archives, and you can
find it on Amazon, eBay,
Walmart, wherever you buy
DVDs. Barnes & Noble as well.
Nowadays, many films' run time
well exceeds two hours.
But this was not the case in the classic era.
Most often, only a
film depicting a person's whole life
such as the famous Citizen Kane
would be allowed this much screen time.
Join us next time as we talk about
an amazing, epic, classic film
all about a selfish woman
who has to gain everything and then
lose it to learn what she really needed
all along.
Thank you for watching.
Goodbye.