Firstly, this unusual commode table offers a surprising enhancement of my understanding of design from this final decade of the traditional decorative arts (1830-1840). This is a striking and memorable example of high quality Louis-Philippe furniture (a period and style which hasn't gone down in history for much finesse or innovation in design).
In line with how outstanding pieces from this late, almost industrial time have been so misunderstood and improperly categorized, this commode bears apocryphal signatures of the celebrated Empire period master cabinetaker, Bernard Molitor. Some dishonest dealer applied these stamps, probably him or herself unaware that this piece dates to circa 1835-40 and not 1810-15 (or really from any point during the Molitor's life which ended in 1833). The JME stamp also appears fraudulently on this piece... even though the JME stamp was abolished twenty years before the period this bygone forger was trying to attribute to the commode!
My hope is that the video will yet again help beginners to gain a basic understanding of what types of furniture from the past are most artistically valuable and why....particularly how these great and sometimes eccentric period pieces differ from most "antiques." Intermediate and advanced collectors and scholars may enjoy having access to these pieces virtually, despite my relatively limited understanding and presentations of them.
If you are interested in purchasing a piece please reach out in the comments or via the contact page of Myersandmonroe.com. For anyone decorating a fine home with older pieces, please be advised to learn the difference between general antiques and these earlier, more beautiful period antiques of which regular "antiques" are usually pale and common factory made reinterpretations.
Hello everybody. So this piece has some fake signatures on it, which intended to make some
purchaser believe that it was in fact made by the celebrated Napoleonic master cabinet maker
Bernard Molitor. It is a chest of drawers, a commode in French, and you know there is something
kind of Napoleonic about it. Empire in its presence. This massive block of red mahogany
with gilded bronze that we have here could pass for something vaguely empire if one wasn't schooled
in the late and eccentric period, which actually provided us with this unusual treasure. But
regardless of the dating issues going on between when this was made and when the dealer tried to
pass it off as having been made, this is an unusually fine commode, albeit very different
than what we're probably used to looking at. Now this commode actually dates from about 1835 to 1840
at the end of our traditional timeline in the decorative arts. This is an eclectic and obscure
time in furniture history, the beginning of the Louis-Philippe period, the Romantic period. There
are other videos on the channel which attempt to describe some of the better pieces from this time
as, for a while, pretty much anything made in the 1830s, certainly the 1840s, was written off as being
from an industrial paradigm, not this earlier artistic paradigm, which predicates our interest
in furniture from the past in the first place. Ironically, very few antiques that are out there
actually come from this earlier timeline, and that's sort of one of the main points of this
whole channel is to just familiarize people with great works from the past. Well, I have mentioned
that pieces from the 1830s, the fine luxury production of the 1830s, deserve a little bit
more attention and that they are generally misunderstood. And case in point, apparently
the dealer who trafficked this at some point with these fake signatures misunderstood this 1835 piece
as something which could actually be empire. Perhaps he was just counting on the naivety of
his financial victims, their inability to discern that this piece is 1835 and could therefore no
way be made by Bernard Molitor, but I happen to think that he himself probably had no clue what
this was as well. Layers of dishonesty and incompetence involved in the scam, the traces
of which we are now examining. But Bernard Molitor actually died in 1833, and this commode could be
as early as 1833, so perhaps it is after all not a fake. And anyway, we shouldn't go down that road.
There are eight stamps. Nothing was ever signed eight times. That's insane. We must have boundaries
against lies and not entertain them. I try to present things for their relevance and beauty,
and in that department we are in luck. But in order to understand the style that we have here,
we're going to have to take a look at an earlier version of this genre of decoration which seems
to take place in the 1820s. We're talking pieces that are ornamented with gilded bronze, namely
thin fillets of it that frame the main panels of the piece. We can take a look at some very fine
pieces made by Jean-Christophe Fischer in the Louvre, the Paris Museum of Decorative Arts, which is
part of the whole Louvre complex, and we can see that the drawers of those two pieces, like the
face of the drawer here, well they are ornamented with encadrements, framings in gilded bronze that
scroll together in a neoclassical fashion with a little flourish of acanthus before deploying
palmettes that point towards the center of the drawer. We have a similar deployment here of a
type of bellflower, a different style of bronze, but you get the idea. And in addition to those museum
pieces, something that's much more colorful, seeing as I don't have color images of those museum ones,
we can actually take a look at a restoration period circa 1825, 10 years before this commode,
bed, a sleigh bed or a li bateau, a boat bed, going to sail you off to sleep. Now this particular bed
is signed by Jacob. They are one of the most important furniture firms in history, and we can
safely use nice examples of their work today as a benchmark comparison. But by God, what do we see
with that bed? None other than the precursor, the bedrock, the father of the decorative idea of this
commode. The effect is the same with that blood red mahogany, just like what we have here, ornamented
by those thin strips of gilded bronze, which on the bed scroll together and deploy a palmette,
with again that flourish of acanthus that we see there. Now for the record, the Paris Museum of
Creative Arts does present one of those beds, which is fully upholstered. Furniture like this is in a way
a frame with which you present the woven art of silk, and that bed is a little earlier. It is more
empire. Although it might seem a little larger or more elaborate, it's really in the same vein of
quality as the one we're looking at here. They're just two different models, that one being
more empire, and this one being more specifically restoration in its style, which is actually quite
rare, very rare to have a restoration period Jacob bed of this variety. It's more interesting.
You won't see but one bed like that one for every 20... ----, for every 200. In fact, that's
the only one I've seen, other than the museum things. So let's just appreciate the Jacob bed,
even if it looks a little shorter and it doesn't have as many bronzes. So it's not just with
wacky and eclectic neo-baroque or neo-Louis XIV pieces from 1835 that we're going to see this.
No, we will see pieces of this type of bronze decoration in the Paris Museum of Decorative Arts
and on pieces made by a really special and celebrated firm in furniture history. It's not
just crazy pieces like this from the 1830s that I'm trying to promote. It's a real respected thing
somewhere. But anyway, that little walk down memory lane is necessary to see how we evolve
stylistically and arrive at something like this in 1835 to 1840. Now, interestingly though,
we notice that the style of these gilded bronzes, well, it is not neoclassical in the same sense
that pure neo-Roman neoclassicism of the Empire and the Restoration period. Here we have something
that is very neo-Louis XIV. Still neoclassical, as you know, the Baroque period after the Renaissance
was using a lot of classical ideas in decoration. But we have these motifs that kind of remind me of
the ornamentalists of the late 17th century. These entrelacs, Louis XIV, interlacings, however you
want to say that in English. But these are typical motifs of the Louis XIV period. Although the central
keyhole entry plate is stylistically lingering from that Charles X or Restoration neoclassicism
with the little rosettes here and little tiny neoclassical palmettes, scrolls of a canthus.
That is very much styled to the tune of the previous decade, whereas the rest of this
bronze work being neo-Baroque, neo-Louis XIV, speaks to this early part of the Romantic period's
interest, burgeoning interest in revival. Of course, the revivals of the 19th century as that
period progresses will become more and more intense and the pieces themselves will rely almost
entirely on revival, whereas here we seem to have an eclectic mix of many different things going on.
It actually strikes us as something quite new and interesting, not just a copy. This definitely
isn't a copy of something that existed during the time of Louis XIV. It's a mix of several
different things. So it turns out that we don't have the boldness of Napoleon being evoked here,
but rather that of Louis XIV. This is an example of the early Romantic period looking back to
France's bygone glory with, albeit a sort of late use of these Napoleonic primary materials,
mahogany and gilded bronze, but they're looking back to the bygone glory of the Grand Siècle of
the Sun King. So this piece, 190 years old now, is in fact a 190-year-old dream of something which was
135 years old, give or take, when this was made. Layers of Romanticism going on with this
sarcophagus of a chest of drawers. The marble, a white Carrara, which I think goes quite well with
this wood, yes, it is framed inset by this interesting molding here itself made out of
mahogany that was selected to be striated. We can see the striations as it catches the light. It is
striped. That's quite nice. Those little details are worth noting as you examine a piece and try to
discern whether it's worth a damn or not. And boy, these little strips are punctuated by these
octagonally faceted shields. Are those shields? And we can notice that the inside of this drawer
is divided into three sections, and it is in a lighter wood which, dare I say, beautifully
contrasts with the darker wood of the exterior. Look, it opened on its own. It wants to be opened.
And one of the innovations that we appear to have with this commode avanto, a doored commode,
sometimes called a commode à l'anglaise or an English commode in French, is the addition of
these special, let's say, the invention of these special hinges which allow the doors to open at a
fuller and wider angle than the normal hinges that we see on these types of commodes. I'll try to
show a picture or two or a quick clip of another doored commode that we've looked at, and we will
see that it apparently predated the point in time when they figured out how to make hinges like that.
I've seen these hinges only on one other commode which itself was also a bit late in the timeline,
1835-1840, so we might surmise that these interesting semi-circular hinges were simply
not invented in the previous decades where you might generally be focusing in study or acquisition.
But that allows for these beautifully paneled doors, mind you, to open at a wider angle so
that they're not closing in an annoying fashion as you try to pull out these English drawers
and sometimes, you know, knock into your doors. So bravo to Bernard Molitor or whoever actually
designed this commode for doing that. Now, once again, these English drawers are veneered in
maple, a lighter wood chosen simply to contrast the dark wood of the exterior, and we have little
tiny fillets that frame the facades. That's a nice touch of quality. Why don't we take one out,
just make a lot of noise and break stuff while we're at it. Oh, it's numbered. Somebody took
a marker and labeled that one three. The original maker appears to have labeled it one, and I'm using
it as drawer number two, just paving my own way. I'm going to the beat of my own drum here. I'm
just going to ignore Bernard Molitor and whoever the restorer was. We're going to call that drawer
number two. I do think it's beautiful with the doors open. I wonder what we would call that type
of mahogany, perhaps a acajou moiré, kind of a shimmering mahogany. There's moucheté, which is
speckled. The side is not really moucheté. No, it is not. It is more of this moiré, this kind of
shimmering vein. In any case, it's quite a special type of mahogany that they have chosen here, and
I don't think we've seen this exact grain pattern on many other pieces. Some of you may have noticed
that there is a little bit of the frieze of beads and reels. These are neoclassical, kind of
renaissance motifs, but we've seen these beads and reels used on other pieces of the 1830s, namely
a mechanical desk, which actually had beads and reels and gilded bronze. We also saw them again
on a console étagère, also circa 1835, contemporary to this piece. We know that the bead and
reel motif, this classical motif, is being used here in the mid-1830s. And then this, what I would
have thought would have been a frieze of eggs and darts. There are no darts. It's a dartless frieze
of eggs and darts. It's simply a frieze of eggs. I'll be damned. And let's take a look at the back.
Again, we are in a late moment, the dawn of the industrial era, so the back of the piece is not
going to be rough, hewn-like backs of some of these regional armoires that we've looked at.
It's actually quite flat, smooth, regular in the back, but very much oxidized. What happens if we
take a look under the marble here? Is there a way to do this and show you the fake stamps without
this marble seesawing backwards and breaking into 700 pieces after all the trouble I've gone to
There is a way. There is a way. Ah, we have a screw, the apparition of a screw. Isn't that
lovely? My God, there's a Daddy Longlegs on this piece. The Daddy Longlegs has been released
outside humanely. Very serious business. No trespassers. This is a private facility. I accept
guests only if they have spent $10,000 or more. That Daddy Longlegs has not spent a dime to fund
this operation, so he was removed from the premises like this piece soon will be. So I'm
glad that we had the time to go over it as, you know, this might not be the height of French taste
in the decorative arts, but I do believe that this is not a piece the likes of which we're really
ever going to see again. So please do subscribe to this channel if you find the information useful.
If you would like to help promote it, that will help these videos become more available to
others, and I do think that looking at pieces like this, certainly all of the ones on the channel,
will help inform everyone's collecting. It'll certainly serve as a good introduction to the
topic of furniture from the past for those of you who are starting out, and then for those of you
who know far more than I do, I'm really pleased to be able to share these interesting pieces
during their brief time with me. So thank you all for watching, and I'll see you all at the next
video.