A discussion of a particularly fine and interesting example of Directorate period furniture, in rare lemonwood and amaranth wood, enhanced with bedazzling brass ornamentation. Such fall front desks or "secrétaires à abattants" were one staples in domestic interiors (from the mid 18th up to the late 19th centuries).
They remain highly versatile, complicated, and sophisticated pieces for decoration, storage, and the occasional thank you note. They generally present hefty locking mechanisms which once protected one's private correspondences, and a lower compartment referred to as the "safe" or "coffre" in French for storing other valuables. True to their name, secret-ary, they are also known for their various secret compartments.
This piece has been in a private collection for the last 50 years, and will soon be in another - so the video serves to capture it online to share it with other collectors or enthusiasts. These videos should also help orient new collectors in the face of so many items to choose from, namely by shedding light on objectively outstanding period antiques (from the early, pre-industrial timeline in furniture history of about the year 1500 to 1840).
Hello everybody and welcome back to another video
about furniture from the past.
What an interesting topic.
I do hope that these videos will help everybody
better understand the difference between general antiques
and these early pre-industrial works of art,
such as this interesting cultural artifact here
from the 1790s, a pretty outstanding example
of a French secretary desk.
This one is in lemonwood, a very rare choice of wood
for the period.
The more predictable and iconic model of desk from the time
would have been in mahogany, pretty much just like this one,
which was brought back by President James Monroe in 1797,
brought back to America, which is indeed in that direction.
America is over there relative to where I'm standing.
Anyway, in addition to not being
in this eccentric lemonwood contrasted
by this purple heart or amaranth wood,
the Monroe Doctrine desk had rounded fluted side posts
simulating a classical column.
These ones are quite a bit rarer.
It's in a way, maybe they're simpler,
but I like them if anything for the rarity
in their novelty compared to what we normally see
on directorate furniture.
There are subtle, subtle touches of quality here,
though, that are mind boggling, such as the notched corner.
We see that it comes to a corner and it's notched.
It has an extra 90 degree angle.
Well, that square in the middle of the corner
tapers down into a point.
If you can just imagine how tedious
that would have been to sculpt.
So the light colored models are exponentially rarer
and they sort of announce the trend of the use
of lighter colored woods in the decorative arts,
which comes about 30 years later.
So the Louvre actually conserves and displays
a set of this lemon wood and purple heart
or amaranth wood furniture,
a very graceful set of salon furniture for Madame Roquemier.
That might be some of my favorite work
from this short-lived period.
But basically directorate furniture is already a bubble
within the bubble of period furniture
that is a bubble relative to all antiques,
which is a bubble relative to the real world
where people don't talk about antiques all of the time.
And then within the bubble, within the bubble,
within the bubble, we have specs like this,
the most outstanding and unusual pieces
of a particular micro style.
And that's part of why I wanted to conserve this online.
It's also interesting to mention that even though today
we might look at this as something that has developed
a certain traditional connotation,
at the time in the 1790s, this was very much avant-garde,
very much eccentric for someone of rather independent tastes.
It was new at the time.
Anyway, we will discuss the directorate period
a little bit at the end of the video,
but for now, let's go ahead and take a look inside
at the secret compartment.
This is a secretary after all.
Now the upper keyhole is an original trefoil mechanism.
It's this clover shape column to the key,
which is consistent with very fine pieces of the time.
We'd expect to find that on such an astonishingly nice
directorate model.
The fall front here has had its key revised.
The column has been replaced with a normal one.
The trefoil mechanism must have given out
after many years of being opened and closed.
But anyway, what you do,
once the fall front is open,
and I do like the metal bars here.
They don't always have that.
Some of them have an internal mechanism,
but nowadays I think the metal bars help to reassure you
when you want to just put your computer on this
and press your elbows onto this surface.
You feel a little bit more secure with the bars.
Anyway, you remove the central drawer here
with its charming ink stains.
At least we hope that that is ink.
And then you remove the bottom right drawer,
which is the drawer that used to hold the ink well.
That's why it's stained with ink.
And this would have been for the little sand shaker
that you would use to dry the ink
after you finished writing.
And so underneath that bottom right drawer,
there is a little slider that you move
and that releases.
No, I just locked it.
You move it backwards, it was unlocked.
How irresponsible of me.
And then you can access that little compartment
beneath the sliding cover that is now unlocked
underneath the central bottom drawer.
And if you want to lock it, you slide it forward
and you move the little lever back in place,
at which point you hide all of that with the drawers.
And anyone who hasn't watched this video
has no idea that your secret compartment is there.
Come to think of it, we might as well
just take a look at the joinery here,
the typical oak construction of these drawers.
That's what we want to see.
They are in oak, beautifully veneered
with more lemon wood and amaranth wood
as like what we see on the exterior.
They have been fielded, the bottoms have.
Anyway, I bet you we can see the same construction
on this upper drawer.
Yes, that's nice to see.
One can perceive a little bit of shrinkage
that's occurred over the last 230 years.
And clearly the leather has been replaced.
At least it's very well done.
Some of the time you'll find these
with their original leathers,
but they're often not in very good shape.
And I never want to take the conservational responsibility
of ripping out the old leathers
to replace them with something more aesthetic like this.
It's nice that this has been done.
This was actually in the collection
of an antique dealer for the last 50 years.
It's the exact type of piece that a dealer would covet.
And I actually had it restored again
because the dealer in question's previous restoration
from the 1980s, particularly the pad polish,
the French polish, it had yellowed as varnish tends to do.
And so we stripped all of that off naturally
to replace it with a new pad polish.
Now, continental furniture like this
has generally been refinished many, many times.
So it's not like American furniture
where any and all patina is sacred.
Removing a previously applied varnish from the 1980s
is not a conservational issue in any way.
It was in fact an aesthetic issue
because it obscured the beauty of this blonde wood
and it turned it darker brown.
But here it is in the middle of this restoration process
on its back.
We can look around at some of the hidden parts of the piece.
It's interesting to kind of be able to see the lock,
the plate up here which corresponds
to the bars of the locking mechanism.
I didn't find any treasure in the piece.
There was a speck of paper which could have been
from the 18th century.
I spent a little bit of time investigating the font.
Now in English, I'm not sure that a varnish makes sense.
We say in French a vernis au tampon, a tampon varnish,
probably isn't the greatest direct translation.
But I've been criticized before
as apparently varnish in English
doesn't necessarily convey this natural lacquer finish
that's historically been used at the time
throughout the 19th century and the late 18th century.
I went ahead and had it done in a fairly low sheen way.
It's a thin pad polish, a little bit truer
to the more muted tones of the 18th century.
Although we could have doubled it
and made it extremely shiny,
but that might have given the piece a tackier, newer vibe.
I've been guilty of that in the past.
Actually on some pieces, it's what you want.
The pieces look better that way.
But I thought a more muted pad polish
was the way to go with this.
And anyway, we actually removed the marble
looking for a stamp.
Of course, that was necessary
because we removed the brass gallery in order to clean it.
This brass gallery, which is brazed together
every 10 or 12 inches or so.
On later copies, you'll find much longer
contiguous pieces of brass.
So at a glance, a way just to verify
that something is probably from the true period
and not a later 19th century copy,
is just to see if these galleries are brazed together
every so often, as opposed to a long single piece of brass.
Anyway, with the brass off,
we had access to the thin blue marble,
which is another outstanding subtle feature of this piece.
Most of the time on fine directorate pieces,
you would expect to find a white marble.
So the use of blue turquoise here
is similar to the blonde wood.
It's actually announcing 30 years earlier,
the trend of using blue turquoise
that we mainly associate with the late 1810s and 1820s.
So we removed the frame underneath the marble
in an attempt to find some sort of a signature
or a stamp on the tops of these side posts
where they are joined together.
Now this piece was made after the 1791 abolition of the law,
which mandated that pieces be signed
for tax and quality control reasons.
So it was a bit of a stretch to think
that there would be a signature here,
but the piece is interesting enough
that maybe it would have been signed
out of some form of discreet pride.
Anyway, nothing was found,
but it gave us the opportunity to film parts of this piece
that might interest furniture makers,
parts that you would normally never see.
So in addition to the amaranth and the lemon wood,
very rare wood choices, and the eccentric marble color,
there are other details of quality here
that help make this piece one which is worthy of study
as a benchmark for furniture of the directory, period.
I mentioned that the side posts are flat here.
That's very eccentric, as I said.
And I think that it enhances or dialogues
with the rectilinearity of the style.
And then if we look at these corners here,
the gallery, which itself presents relief.
It's not just flat,
but there's a recession along the middle.
It breaks the monotony
of what would otherwise just be a flat brass line.
There's now three lines.
Anyway, these corners are squared as well.
And then to transition between the case and the top,
there is a pretty complicated series of moldings
that ripple upward here.
There's also a use of inlay here
with these alternating fillets of amaranth and lemon wood.
That actually adds nine extra lines here
that you wouldn't otherwise have.
And they create what a Paris court expert pointed out to me.
He comes over here to make sure
I'm not presenting anything too dubious to all of you.
But it creates this sort of rippled perspective effect
as you look into the piece
from different levels moving inward,
especially that's visible over here on the side.
There's a type of inward perspective
that's created by the addition of those lines.
And when you consider how much extra work that requires,
you know why little details like that
are not found on all pieces.
And that's why they make up for a certain jump
in the aesthetic and financial value of one of these items.
Now let's go down below
where we can open up the armoire part of this secretary.
Sometimes these are referred to as secretaire en armoire
because they have an armoire in the bottom.
And this compartment is also referred to as the safe
for the lockable drawer there.
And this particular safe in line with the quality
that I've been expounding upon for the last 10 minutes
is pretty exceptional in that it is not just in simple oak
with some sort of a border inlaid around it,
but it is veneered in amaranth wood,
the same fine exotic wood
that's used to decorate the exterior of the piece.
We see that veneer as well on the insides of the doors.
And then finally, the locking mechanism here
spans the entire height of this small door.
Most of the time we'll see a little square one here.
So that's kind of exceptional to see even the lock
if we know our late 18th century furniture.
Well, we would expect to see a smaller lock here
and not one that spans the entire door.
Now, I always tell people to maybe not lock these pieces
because when you try to lock it,
that doesn't go down all the way.
So I suppose it could be locked shut
and you couldn't open it
if you screw with these keys too much.
So luckily for us,
the way this piece has shrunk and expanded
and torqued itself over the years,
well, you don't even need to lock the bottom compartment.
It just stays shut on its own.
Pied-to-pied, top-shaped feet,
these are called in French.
You'll see those on classical furniture of long ago,
the few surviving examples of actual Roman furniture.
You'll see feet like that.
So for more depth on this period
and to take a look at some other pieces,
there are videos to watch on the channel
about a secretary in mahogany like this one,
but specifically identical to the one
that James Monroe brought back in 1797.
There's a video on a commode.
There's a video on a sommelier type of tall dresser,
tall commode.
But I am still going to expound a little bit
about this directorate period and style right now.
In 1789, the French Revolution marks the end
of an epic and prestigious tale,
which is the story of French 18th century furniture.
It's an art form that's represented
in pretty much every major art museum,
general art museum worldwide.
French 18th century furniture has been copied
to hell and back since then.
It's still very present in the collective consciousness.
And anyway, the brilliance of this tradition
of French furniture does not end at the French Revolution.
It will be reborn under a different light
during the Napoleonic Empire and the subsequent restoration
of the Bourbon monarchy throughout the 1820s,
as we mentioned, that this piece kind of announces
with its use of lighter colored woods.
But the revolution didn't just do away with the old
and create its new style.
The revolutionary government didn't really have
any furniture other than what was left over
from the old regime.
They plunged makers into a transitional period
between the lighthearted neoclassicism
of the Louis XVI period, old regime,
and the soon to come stark monolithic neoclassicism
of the Napoleonic Empire.
So this is a short-lived and transitional period.
The actual governmental period only lasted five years,
from 1795 to 1799.
But furniture styles only loosely correspond
to these governmental periods, literally,
after which they were named.
And so the directorate style actually emerges
near the end of the old regime,
and then it lingers up into the first few years
of the 19th century.
And so some of the precursors to the directorate style
could be, for instance, pieces which were drawn
by the famous painter, Hubert Robert,
who studied under Panini in Italy.
He was very much a part of this romantization
of the ancients when you look at his art.
He drew a set of open-worked, lattice-backed chairs
for the Laetri de Marie Antoinette at Rambouillet.
And that was 1787.
So those are kind of quintessentially
directoire, directorate chairs,
but there they are in 1787.
And then also we have Heppelwhite and Sheraton,
these English cabinet makers,
and the English with their love of mahogany
and those open-worked chairs
with those open-worked splats on the back.
Well, they published guides in 1788 and 1791, respectively.
Presiding over that Hubert Robert and those chairs,
that single anecdote, would be the fact
that from 1785 to 1790, architects and ornamentalists
were publishing designs that turned more
to an archeological approach
to reproposing classical styles,
rather than a lighthearted and interpretive approach.
A more serious neoclassicism was being promoted,
which is what directorate furniture is
compared to the previous Louis XVI style.
There are fewer useless frills and fantasies
with directoire work than what we see on Louis XVI work.
It conserves the simple shapes, the straight lines,
the right angles of Louis XVI furniture,
but it accentuates those aspects
and makes them more austere,
really favoring wide open surfaces like this
and starker ornamentation,
such as these somewhat cold brass lines
that we see everywhere.
This is actually kind of a typical directoire
decorative device.
Often, it's a grattoir.
Gratté is to be scratched,
and you'll see these little plaques of brass,
which appear to have been stamped or embossed
with a type of raised miniature frieze,
sometimes little specks, little friezes of lozenges.
Let me see if we can find a picture of a grattoir
or a video to look at one.
These grattoirs are actually blank,
but nevertheless, it's a stark decorative device
relative to the frillier ornaments
that we might have seen on a Louis XVI piece.
Anyway, for more information on the directoire period,
this short-lived and transitional style
in furniture history,
there are other videos to take a look at on the channel,
but I do hope you've enjoyed taking a look
at this particularly rare example of the period
and that studying some of its virtues
will help everybody to enhance their own collecting,
to better understand the difference between antiques
and these early pre-industrial works of art.
So if this information has been useful
and you'd like to help promote it,
please do subscribe to the channel.
That would be much appreciated.
I'll see you at the next video.