Five Nobel Laureates discuss: The future of creativity

Scientists won the Nobel Prize
12 followers
2 Video Views·Jan 19, 2026
Okay, so we're on to the final panel
Which is on the future of creativity and for this i'd like to ask our five nobel laureates to come on stage, please
michael
bradley in the middle
edvard and my brit
We don't know we were discussing earlier whether it's good to see the husband and wife team together or separated
We didn't know so we just went for together
So I think everybody knows everybody but just in case carl wyman michael levitt brandy shakeman edvard moza my brit moza
Since we had this critical mass of nobel laureates present
We thought it would be good to explore the theme of creativity just raised in the last panel, especially by olafur
and we might start by
Uh asking what we mean by creativity. So, uh, randy
What do you think of when you think of creativity?
um, I guess when I when I think of creativity, uh, it's the um,
the ability or the chance to put two or more
Seemingly disparate observations or ideas together in in an unexpected combination
to
yield some novel insight that you you couldn't have imagined and
I'm reminded of this by the wonderful book by francis jacob called the statue within in which he described
The two kinds of science one was daytime science and the other was nighttime science daytime science was to him
The usual observations and ideas that come together that are logical
Nighttime science on the other hand was this, uh, rare combination of things that
Could not be anticipated
Very nice
michael
You know, the obvious definitions are that you find something that was unexpected and is useful
but I would say it's the
How moment that you get while you're having a shower
It's not what you think
My bread creativity, so of course I agree with uh with these people but I I think
Going back to science where I like to be then
You you become
Creative if you have the ability to listen to other people
That have different views from yourself, but throw don't throw the baby out with the water
So you have to keep something for yourself and then select
what is good and what is not so good from what other people try to
Tell you and then you should be able to see
The the pattern that is coming in front of your eyes
But you can talk about the same thing in in music
We come from trondheim, which is the town for jazz
And jazz is to put
Different pieces of music together that wasn't combined before but you can't do that if you haven't
played beautiful music
So you need something there and then as you say combine it in new ways
I think we should get everyone's comments on this. So edvard
Somewhat similar. I think it's about putting together
Pieces of information that your brain has collected over long times which haven't been seen together before and using that to
solve some
Either solve the problem or just create an insight. So I think it's somewhat like
Dreaming where this happens to I mean random pieces of information occur together. Sometimes that even leads to new insight
Yeah, technically is benzene ringing. Yeah
car
um
so
Naturally when I was thinking about teaching and learning studying this spent quite a bit of time thinking about it and I and I think it's
It's with it. It always really has to be within the context of kind of an
existing issue or question and so it's very much
In scientific creativity is very much residing in a discipline and kind of all the things you know about it
but it's then coming as other people have said sort of recognizing a
A different pattern or some new information from somewhere else that's relevant really just
and what the real test is it's things that
turn out to be useful that other people haven't seen yet or recognized yet and
I'll just put in one little plug that what we came to recognize was the the educational system really
teaches
Anti-creativity because it's really about you know
Teachers are giving students problems to solve and the goal is to have an answer that looks like what the teacher was looking for
and that's exactly
not being creative and so
When we tied to experiments of giving problems that didn't have answers
The teachers were looking for the students actually perform much more creatively on further tasks
But as you and others are pointing out there needs to be a foundational base
Absolutely. Yes
So 70 of the audience or the audience responders we gathered
positive about the idea that
We will be more creative in 30 years that humans will be they either think it's likely or extremely likely
Do you think that's the case?
I think we'll be creative in a different way. You didn't have a box for that apparently
So I think it's not more or less
But we will interact much more with the computers and use
Information that can pop up within the milliseconds
Of course that will make us think and act in a different way, but I think it's not a more or less question
but that's
That's how nature works too because you not not creativity that has a positive value for us
But but nature is filled with mutations
And that is how we get variation and we get new species. We get new behavior
So we need this variation and of course for us to be creative
Then it's more positive that we think that we see things in a better way and we're smarter
randy
well, one of the trends in the life sciences, and I think probably in all science is the
The need to collaborate across lines
People who bring different technologies to bear on a problem and that that
Will reinforce the creative experience because you will have to deal with other people who have very different perspective
And if it's a if it's an effective team effort
Then I think there'll be there there will be some creative tension that arises from that collaboration
I would say almost certainly yes, and it goes down to the
Definitions that have been given before that creativity involves
Interaction of several things the world is becoming a much more interactive place and people who were unempowered
Can now go online and often do some really creative things. So I think that
the
Creativity divided by the population is going to increase enormously
What's the population? Okay
Do you find that in your own life technology makes you more creative?
It's hard because as you get older, you know, you're losing neurons all the time and it's not clear that maybe it makes you stay
More or less the same
Um, I guess there's one interesting thing and that is as you get older
Well, normally in life, it's much easier to do something. You know how to do that. You do something new
When you have no memory
There's no nothing that you actually make it easier. So actually everything's about the same
You know just
Randy I've heard you say some things about people
People at the who are older scientists who say they're doing the best work of their career before you you're a bit scathing about that
Well, i'm a little worried about that
I've told my friends that if I ever at this point
For the rest of my life say that i'm doing the best work of my life then then it is a sure sign of senility
and delusion
So, um, I feel that I did my best work when I was 30 years old, uh
Because I had no preconceived notions about the field I had no prejudices built up over many decades
And I could do something that other people thought was crazy and feel good about it
Edward and margaret
um
What about being creative? I still think i'm creative. I think there are some advantages of getting older, too
That's an advantage of getting older is that you accumulate more and more these random information you get more and more exposed to
Knowledge outside your own field something that is quite often not the case for young people when they start in a difficult field
So and so I said in a different way
So I don't think i'm done yet
No, so I I just want to reflect also on what is stopping creativity and that is fair
And you can get fair. Of course if people tell you that you're stupid you shouldn't think about
These topics or you shouldn't think along these lines
But also fear that you don't have the methods or the techniques to address your question
And that has happened now in neuroscience that we have got all these wonderful wonderful techniques
So that we are much tougher than when we were young
To to address questions that we couldn't try even to think of
addressing earlier
For example with optogenetics or all these new techniques that we can use and then we are so creative
Sorry
I I tend to think I
I don't think the biggest barrier is fear
I think the biggest barrier is habits and you just get deeper and deeper into those as you get old and so you're
Not going to be as creative
I just wanted to follow up on what randy said. Um, I think I did my best work when I was like 21 years old
And I knew nothing and what really worries me today
Is that people become independent and I know too much
I've already done a six-year phd and a six-year postdoc
They are too old
And I really believe that there's a something really wrong with the system
So I think when I talked about creativity, I think the world is going to be more creative
I actually think that science
Per dollar spent is going to become less creative. I have exactly that worry and it's because people are just too long
The whole system has become
People have okay when you're older so for me right now 64 is super young, right?
And but you know people have forgotten that there's an absolute youngness
40 is not the new 20 20 is the new 20
and
We're making a huge mistake because we sort of say well
Science is so complicated. Then you should learn all these new things and it's basically just a way to have you know
Really good labor in your lab
Doing things for you and it's a huge mistake. I think the system is
Really rotten for this reason I think
what well
So my generation baby boomer generation were lucky because when people older than us were sort of taken out of the system
By the great depression in the second world war
Unfortunately people young growing up now still have us
clogging up the whole system
So I I don't know i'm worried from that point of view
I share all of those concerns on the other hand
Robert shows that you can teach people to be much more creative
I mean, you know if they actually set about actively doing that and and probably at any age, although we haven't tested that
No, so in in our field, uh, we don't have this
Einstein at least not myself, but I work in a group
And I depend on all these beautiful young people in our lab
and we are facilitating creativity in our lab by
Having an environment where
you
Are allowed to ask questions and you are reforced to ask questions and then it's a brainstorming
Which creates creativity?
And I I find it so fascinating. So when we have
meetings with our people
I'm, so happy and
passion
makes creativity
Is there is there almost a kind of conflict though between the the collaboration that randy mentioned for instance that you need
the meeting of ideas to be creative but also the kind of being on your own
and fresh
and sort of solo that you were when you were doing your best work maybe and you were michael when you were doing your work
at 21, I mean there's
Almost there's a conflict between the need to collaborate and the need to be an individual
but some problems now are um
So complicated that they require different technologies for for progress so you are forced I I think
not in a bad way, but forced to
reach out
To collaborate with people who have a technique that you can't easily apply
And I think that from that can come some creative tension as long as the two
Is that as the collaborators are open?
And uh share everything and they're willing to consider alternatives
Michael I think a key thing here is
Certainly when I was a young scientist
People people's phd supervisor does not expect the names to be on your papers
Max perutz was francis crick's phd supervisor
And it's not perutz watson and crick
And it was never expected that it would be and I think that people you know in science
The reward for working so hard is recognition
And I think that it's great to work with young people
But I think today we're not giving them anything like the opportunities
That we had when we were that age, and I think it's a problem
Did you want to say something about here? I just wanted to add about
Your question about collaboration versus actually being alone. I think the latter is also important
I noticed with myself that
Some of the times when i'm most creative is when i'm sitting on an airplane
Airplane and one without wi-fi
Just sitting there for eight hours
Do nothing and then things pop up randomly and I get the idea for a new experiment that I would never got at home because
There's so much going on all the time
So I think these moments of just sitting there having nothing to do
It's so important and it's so easy to lose in the times when especially people like we are like all the time to do things
And that's one aspect of information technology
Really hinders creativity because you just don't get those times of not being accessible of not being interrupted
So you need time to yourself
and perhaps
elevated co2 levels
But so
That touches on something that a member of the audience jefferson has asked which is speaking about creativity
How much did creativity contribute to your own success in being becoming a nobel laureate
Was it all creativity or was it a lot of hard work as well? I don't know
Who wants to answer that?
Would you like to yeah, um, I would say that creativity is important
But I think it's an awful lot of luck
And you know one ends up being where one is because of other people's decisions that you didn't even understand at the time
Uh hard work is also very important. I think you'll notice that
Almost all successful scientists have a lot of stamina
And you know that kind of energy to just keep on going is really important
But I think you know creativity in some ways is the drug
That drives us. I mean when you have an idea that it's it's a high that you know, I could buy it. I would
It's just amazing and you know, and it doesn't have to be a big it's not like oh, I just solved
How the universe works it could just be oh, I suddenly realized while my experiments being going wrong for two weeks
It's it's an amazing feeling and and it doesn't actually come
You know
I've often thought where does creativity come from and you don't sit down with a list and say in the morning
Potential good ideas for today. No, no bad one
It's usually when you're doing something different, you know, you're out for a walk with the dog in an airplane
I guess it doesn't work for me having a shower
Something that kind of you know, so I think the worst invention is going to be a waterproof iphone
So i'll just put in a
counter to that I mean for me that the things that I
you know got most successful was
I mean, I picked some area that seemed like it was going to be
Potentially important and I spent years plotting way at it and and at some point there was some big challenge
And I just you know thought oh, well, this is the way to tackle it
I don't I wonder why nobody else is working on it this way. So I I never got these great inspirations for me
It was always I wonder why nobody else thought to do it this way
You know, but there was a whole lot of work to set that up but
yeah, I wish I got these things I could get excited in the shower about but
So
We we've just got a minute left and um
I guess you forgive me for asking this question, but it's sort of
I think we probably have to ask it at this meeting
Can you foresee a day when you're sitting here and or others are sitting here in your place and one of you is a machine?
Will there be a machine that can be awarded a nobel prize?
Go on go for it. So so I I would say no because I go back to the original
Claim I made is creativity is looking at things in some
Basically different way than people have before machines are taught how to look at things. It's it's it's built into them
and so
there there's sort of it's going to be a vastly different machine than anything we're thinking of now where we build in rules because
You follow those rules. It's not going to be creative
Michael, yeah, I have no problem thinking about that. I think it would also be
You know great for publicity
It'd be a real machine not uh, even better than frank wheelchair
He already has one
Anyone else want to try that one?
Well, I I don't I would never say never but I don't think in my lifetime that i'll see a machine up here answering that question
uh, I I watched, uh, you know, watson, uh play jeopardy and um
marveled at the ability the computer to recall rare information
but putting uh
Unexpected things together in the way that generates the creative idea
Um, I think is that for the time being not not something that i'm going to see in a machine
Okay. Thank you very much. Yeah, do you want I think maybe when the unexpected happens then we will notice the difference I think
A machine can be taught to do the most incredible things including being creative in a way
If you prescribe the rules for creativity, which we have talked about today
So we can make a machine actually be creative within certain limits
But then something happens that is not in the rules and then we'll see the difference
Everyone else has had a word last word to you my brief
Well, I I just want to say what is so fantastic by being a scientist
It's all the passion by seeing things that we haven't seen before
And that the machine can't that's a nice place to end. Let's have a round of applause for human passion and creativity
So, thank you all and that unfortunately is it for the day we're out of time
So I just like to thank you all for being here
For what's been a really splendid day
We've enjoyed it tremendously and we look forward to seeing you again on the 9th of december in stockholm next year
