The Controversial 2023 Nobel Prize Explained

Scientists won the Nobel Prize
12 followers
1 Video View·Mar 1, 2026
This video is sponsored by Brave VPN.
The Sveriges Riksbank Prize in Economic Sciences, in honor of Alfred Nobel,
known most commonly as simply the Nobel Prize in Economics, is awarded every year to researchers
that have made outstanding contributions to the field, with a particular emphasis on those who
put forward new economic theories with real-world applications. Economics was a later subject added
in addition to the original Nobel Prize fields of physics, chemistry, medicine, literature,
and peace. The Sveriges Riksbank, Sweden's central bank, pushed for that addition,
and they pay the prize money to the winners in the field of economics, where the winners of all
of the original fields are paid out of the estate of Alfred Nobel, who made his fortune after
inventing dynamite. This year's winner was Claudia Golden, who is currently an economics professor at
Harvard University, who won the prize for her work on mapping out the intricacies of gender pay
inequality. Golden's work is worth talking about, not only because she has now won the most
prestigious prize in all of academic economics for it, but because her work does what most people
fail to do when talking about this subject, which is that it removes a lot of the emotion from the
debate. Her award-winning papers collect as much data from as many different economies over as many
different time periods as possible to reveal patterns that show the issue of the gender pay
gap is in many ways very misunderstood on both sides of the argument. So, what were the economic
discoveries that won Claudia Golden this year's Nobel Prize? What have most people been getting
wrong about this very controversial economic issue? And finally, how could this work influence
policies going forward to address these issues? You might not be surprised to hear this, but
because your smartphone has so many apps connected to everything from your bank to your social media
and your shopping, a lot of cybercriminals are targeting you through your mobile first.
That's why we're excited that Brave VPN is sponsoring this video, because their VPN works
on all of your devices and can help protect you from people trying to steal your identity.
Brave VPN is built right into the already super secure Brave browser. The beauty of Brave's VPN
is that it will automatically safeguard connections on your phone or computer,
even outside the Brave browser. It brings secure connections on every app, everywhere.
I feel a lot less anxious when I'm working at a cafe on my laptop, because I know that even
connected to a public Wi-Fi, my phone and laptop have extra protection against that guy in the
corner wearing shades and an overcoat. Unlike incognito or privacy browser modes, which give
you a false sense of security, Brave VPN encrypts your web traffic against prying eyes like nearby
lurkers or even hidden ones like your ISP. Just download Brave at brave.com slash economics to
get started. To get 25% off your first three months, open Brave on your computer and click
VPN in the address bar. Enter code economics at checkout for 25% off your first three months.
Then follow the instructions to get started. Bonus, one subscription covers up to five devices
across Android and iOS, Windows and Mac. And as an added bonus, you'll be supporting this
channel and saving some money at the same time. Now, before we get into Golden's work,
we need to give the big disclaimer. The gender pay gap is something that to be honest,
we have avoided covering on this channel for over four years now. The ratio of strong opinions to
lessons that can be learned by looking at this issue as a case study have always made it just
a bit too scary. Nobody should be taking sides on what is ultimately just labor market dynamics.
And this video will purely be an exploration of the work of this year's Nobel laureate from the
perspective of a macroeconomist with the singular focus on maximizing quality of life for all
participants. With that out of the way, the collective earnings of women is less than the
collective earnings of men in every economy around the world today. And as far as we're aware,
throughout all of history, this by itself is not anything new, nor is it necessarily even a problem.
One of the biggest reasons that women collectively earn less is that less of them work in traditional
paid jobs. The opening line of the Nobel Foundation's summary of Golden's research
recognizes this much. Globally, around half of all women are in paid employment,
while the equivalent figure for men is 80%. The stated goal of Golden's work is not to
achieve equality by any means necessary. It's simply to ensure that an economy is
utilizing its labor resources most effectively. If women do not have the same opportunity to
participate in the labor market, or they participate on unequal terms, then potential
labor and expertise are wasted. So the real question and controversy is in the why, of
why do women participate less and earn less when they do?
Now, the proposed answers to this question range anywhere from men choosing to do more lucrative
jobs even if they're less fulfilling, more dangerous and more stressful at a higher rate
than women. Some speculate that the difference is caused by other life choices, like women
choosing to leave the workforce to raise a family, and therefore missing out on crucial
years of career development. And then of course, there is the argument that women are victims of
systemic discrimination. There is also just pure circumstance. In what is probably some tragic
irony, this year was one out of only three times that the Nobel Prize in Economics has been awarded
to a woman. But thanks to the declining value of the Swedish krona, the prize money was about 10%
less than it was for the male winners last year. Now, good economists should look at a potential
issue like this and first work out if it really is a problem at all, and then work out what's
causing it. Because the best solution to an issue like this is going to depend a lot on that cause.
As golden frequently points out in her work, even policy solutions made with the best intentions of
fixing a complex problem can sometimes have the opposite effect and make things worse if it
doesn't correctly address why that problem exists in the first place.
What made golden's work Nobel prize worthy was above all else her examination of data
from across different economies across different time periods. In the world today, there are
genuinely economies that operate where women are at a significant disadvantage to men in earning
power, amongst other things, because of cultural norms or legal policies that make it harder for
women to get an education or pursue a career. In these instances, golden makes the obvious
suggestion that the removal of these institutional barriers and investments into information and
education for women will over time help to close the earnings gap, even if it doesn't
remove it entirely. So far, not necessarily groundbreaking stuff. But golden also pointed
out that in a lot of modern advanced economies today, women already have high levels of employment
and in many cases are even more educated than men with higher attainment rates of university degrees.
The same kind of policies in these instances will be likely to create worse outcomes for
all economic participants in the country, both men and women. When there are already
policies in place that mandate that pay can't be based on gender, and men and women have equal
access to democratic representation, education and employment, then pushing policies that give
even more resources towards one gender over another will just be a waste at best or cause
misalignments in the labor market at worst. Again, the goal of good policies, at least from
a macroeconomics perspective, is to make sure that everybody can and is incentivized to make
their maximum contributions towards the labor market. This is all to say that, for example,
a potential Nobel Prize winning economist isn't forced out of academia because they're a woman,
and simultaneously a man didn't miss out on an opportunity to develop some amazing new technology
that could benefit humanity because of something like gender quotas. Because the consequences of
bad policy can be so severe, golden's work also looked at the non-policy variables that could lead
to the labor market outcomes we see today. And one of the most important places she went to look for
that data was history. She used historical records to create something that radically reshaped most
economists' perception of how labor market participation between genders has evolved over
time, the U-shaped model. Golden was not the first economist to study the gender pay gap,
but she did look a lot further back than any serious research had before. Before golden's work
most economists only looked at data beginning in the 20th century because that's when records were
most reliable and because too much further before that economies didn't really function in the same
way they do today. Golden spent a lot of time finding sources from as far back as the late 1700s
cleaning up records that worked with modern data sets. One example was that in old census reports
married women's occupation was often just listed as wife even if they had other work outside of
pure domestic labor. What golden found after putting all of this data together was a U-shaped
curve of women's involvement in the workforce over time. Before the widespread adoption of
modern industry women would be involved in agriculture at rates similar to men as basic
or even subsistence farming required the full-time attention of the whole family.
As farming gave way to modern industry the participation of women in the workforce started
to fall because of a combination of the fact that they didn't necessarily need to work thanks to
higher individual labor productivity, but also factory work was distinctly separate from the
home so it was harder to balance domestic duties with a traditional job. Golden's work found that
despite the previous assumption that pay equality was only getting better over time thanks to
societal progression like giving women the right to vote and equal pay laws, gender equality due
discrimination was quite low at this time. Now to be clear men still did earn more than women,
but the pay difference that could not be explained by the observed differences in
factors such as productivity, education and experience were lower because at this time
work in most industrializing economies was paid based on unit output rather than a standard wage
based on how many hours someone worked. Factories didn't care who produced whatever it is that they
were making, men, women, children, it was all the same and they just paid on how much was made.
At this time since most work was still pretty physical men who were generally larger and
stronger could produce more and got paid more and while that may feel unfair it was the outcome that
maximized economic utility. If women or children got paid more per unit to make up for the fact
that men could produce more in the same time then no factory owners would want to hire women
reducing opportunities on an individual level and overall output on an economy-wide level.
Over time that is exactly what happened. The participation of women in the workforce
continued to decline as jobs became more formal affairs where workers would be paid for their time
more than their output. This was especially true of the growing service sector where people were
working more and more in white-collar roles that required an education as well as a lot of
experience. Golden found that even in the early 20th century more women than most economists
expected still worked in manufacturing and agriculture but those industries were becoming
a smaller part of the overall labor force giving way to a lot of the jobs that we have today.
Now at this time something unusual happened. Because people were working less in jobs that
depended on physical strength the explained earning gaps between men and women fell but
the unexplained gap increased. The reason for this golden found was that pay in these new
white-collar jobs was based mainly on seniority in the business rather than individual output
which was much harder to track than it was in a factory production line. To get paid more people
needed to get promoted but women who left the workforce to go and have children found that
difficult because that pause in their career would be hard to catch up from. Even women that didn't
have children still suffered from this problem because businesses would expect that they might
have a child at some point so they didn't want to put them in any job that was too important.
Eventually what was arguably just a pragmatic solution to a reality turned into a culture in
most of the early advanced service-based economies where men wore suits and did business and women
working in the service sector could be receptionists or any other role that was
easy to switch out when their time came. The professional roles where women still
maintained a large share of representation were unsurprisingly ones where they were more hands-on
like nursing and teaching. Roles that perhaps because of these opportunities became known
as fields for women rather than the other way around. Golden found that since then this has
been improving as women are now able to move into advanced professional careers because of changes
in family planning and simply the changing societal expectation that all women are ticking
time bombs just waiting to explode with a baby. One of the most important policy suggestions that
has come from Golden's work is that just like in the transition from industry to services is that
if governments push for equality at all costs it can result in worse outcomes for everybody,
men, women and the businesses they work for. Something like mandating that a certain
percentage of a company's leadership has to be one gender or another is just reactionary and
could result in the same kind of discrimination that economists are trying to avoid in the labour
market. The solutions that Golden proposes are consistently ones that remove structural
barriers for women instead of putting up policy barriers for men. It's naive and unproductive to
think that men and women are going to have identical problems but things like allowing
for more flexible working arrangements for everybody reduces those barriers for women
without denying opportunities to anybody else. Her final major contribution was the empirical
evidence that changes in the labour force take time and that any change should be slowly and
carefully considered because it can often take decades for their full effects to become obvious.
Nobody can fully predict the effect that new technologies like AI and advanced automation
is going to have on labour force. Those changes could be easily just as if not more impactful
than the switch from agriculture to industry or industry to services and with that there is going
to be a new set of challenges that policy makers will need to work around. So perhaps more than
ever Golden's thorough exploration of the past is going to prove incredibly useful for our future.
Now surprisingly Golden's work is probably less controversial than last year's winners who won
the prize for their research on the role of banks in the economy. The problem was that one of the
winners was Ben Bernanke the former chairman of the fed during the global financial crisis of 2008.
Despite that minor hiccup his contributions alongside last year's other winners are worth
learning about and you should be able to click to that video on your screen now.
Thanks for watching mate, bye.
