Did Empress Dowager Xiaozhuang (Dayuer) and Dorgon truly have a romantic relationship?

Ancient Humans
24 followers
5 Video Views·Jan 15, 2026
Did Empress Dowager Xiaozhuang (Dayuer) and Dorgon truly have a romantic relationship?
Hello everyone, welcome to History and Culture.
If someone asks what kind of person Eisen Jorodwa Ergun really was.
Many might immediately reply, he was the Great Qing's foremost romantic.
That's because in modern TV dramas and films, he's portrayed as deeply affectionate,
forbearing, and willing to give up everything for the one he loves.
Even handing over the throne that was practically within his grasp.
This image has been repeatedly performed, endlessly amplified.
And by many people taken as historical fact itself.
But is history really like that?
Here, let's set aside the dramas and legends.
And slowly talk about a Dwa Ergun much closer to reality.
Dwa Ergun was the 14th son of Nurhaci.
And the younger brother of Huang Taiji, Emperor Taizong of Qing.
He grew up in an environment intertwined with power and warfare from childhood.
And very early on learned one thing, in this world.
Emotion is never the top priority, survival and position are.
Later generations depicted his relationship with Empress Dowager Xiaoshuang,
commonly called Dayuer, or Bumbutai.
As a decade-spanning deep romance.
They supposedly met as youths, were childhood sweethearts.
But were torn apart by fate.
And could only gaze longingly at each other across palace walls for the rest of their lives.
The story sounds beautiful.
But the problem is, it has almost no historical evidence to support it.
Dwa Ergun was born in Hechuala.
While Dayuer, Bumbutai, was born on the Khorchin Mongol grasslands.
The two places were far apart.
In that era when travel depended on horses and information on word of mouth.
A Manchu noble youth and a Mongol tribal princess.
Simply did not have the conditions for long-term interaction.
Even more importantly, Dayuer married Huang Taiji at age 12.
This was a clear-cut political marriage.
Symbolizing the alliance between the Khorchin tribe and the later Jin, Hojin, regime.
From historical records that can be verified.
The times they truly met were extremely few.
And all occurred in public ceremonial settings.
There were no private exchanges, no love letters.
And certainly no youthful deep affection.
The so-called childhood sweethearts is more like an imagination added by later people.
So why, after Huang Taiji's sudden death.
Did Dwa Ergun not seize the throne when he had the chance?
But instead choose to support the young Fulin, the future Xuanji Emperor?
This is the key reason many believe he gave up the throne for love.
But if we look at the actual situation at the time.
We'll see that this was not a matter of emotion.
But a very pragmatic political choice.
Huang Taiji died suddenly without leaving clear arrangements.
And the court immediately fell into uncertainty.
Dwa Ergun did hold significant military power.
But that didn't mean he could ascend the throne without any resistance.
Other imperial clansmen, banner leaders.
And nobles each had their own positions.
Forcing the issue could very likely trigger internal turmoil.
At that stage, what Dwa Ergun needed was not merely a nominal highest position.
But real control.
Supporting a child emperor.
While taking the role of regent to grasp core power.
Was actually the choice with less risk and greater reward.
Facts later proved his judgment was accurate.
In the following years.
Dwa Ergun enjoyed almost unrestricted decision-making power in court.
Military, administration, rewards and punishments.
All decided by him.
He was later honored as, Imperial Father Prince Regent.
A status infinitely close to the emperor himself.
If this was for love, then the, returns, from such love.
Seem far too aligned with political logic.
Now let's talk about the most overlooked person.
His original principal wife.
The woman later called, Little Yue'er, a Borjigit Mongol noblewoman.
She married Dwa Ergun at 13.
Accompanied him for over 20 years.
From youth to middle age.
From rising to the peak of power.
Historical records about her are scarce.
But it's clear that Dwa Ergun's attitude toward her.
Was distinctly different from his other marriages.
When she passed away.
Dwa Ergun displayed an extremely rare depth of grief.
Bestowing posthumous honors on her and holding a grand funeral with the highest ritual standards.
This relationship comes much closer to what we understand as a true, husband and wife bond.
In contrast, the so-called deep affection for Da Yue'er.
Left almost no trace of direct interaction.
No letters, no special bestowals.
And even records of private meetings are extremely rare.
If this was a soul-searing love.
Its presence in the historical books is really too faint.
As for the later circulated, Daueger Empress's marriage, to Dwa Ergun.
It feels more like an extension of political rumors.
In that era of highly concentrated power.
Any change in status would be loaded with symbolic meaning.
Dwa Ergun needed more solid legitimacy.
While Da Yue'er needed to ensure her son's throne remained secure.
Their relationship.
Resembled a tacit mutual cooperation rather than an emotional haven.
If it truly had been mutual affection.
Then what happened after Dwa Ergun's death would be hard to explain.
After the Xuanji Emperor took personal power.
He quickly purged and adjusted Dwa Ergun's posthumous treatment.
As Empress Daueger.
Da Yue'er showed no strong intent to intervene.
From a political perspective.
This was very reasonable.
While Dwa Ergun was alive, he was a pillar.
But once gone, he could become a historical burden.
Denouncing him.
Actually helped consolidate the independence of imperial authority.
Looking back at Dwa Ergun's lifetime of marriages.
A very clear pattern emerges.
Marriages to Mongol nobles were to stabilize border-tribal relations.
Marriages to Korean royalty.
Were to reinforce suzerain status.
Almost every one of his marriages.
Can find a corresponding meaning in the political landscape of the time.
This isn't a moral judgment.
It's simply a factual description.
In that era, marriage was inherently part of the power structure.
So when we look back at the title, Great Qing's Foremost Romantic.
It feels more like a projection of later generations' emotions.
People hope to find a bit of warmth.
In the coldness of history.
Hope to see a pure emotion.
Amid the complex game of power.
Thus, Dwa Ergun was shaped into the figure who bears all this romantic imagination.
But the real Dwa Ergun.
Was more like a highly rational actor.
He was not without feelings.
But he never placed feelings first.
At critical moments.
He always prioritized the situation, position, and outcome.
This doesn't make him base.
Nor does it make him noble.
It simply makes him a person.
Who, in a special era.
Made choices in line with his own interests.
Historical figures are inherently complex.
Rarely pure black or white.
Dwa Ergun was neither the infatuated prince of the dramas.
Nor a simple symbol of cold ruthlessness.
He was a man who understood trade-offs and excelled at judgment.
This is the History and Culture channel.
Liking and subscribing are the greatest help and support to us.
Thank you everyone and see you in the next time.
