Were there really such things as a Medieval Thieves Guild or Assassins Guild? Let's find out! Get Surfshark VPN at https://Surfshark.deals/invicta and enter promo code INVICTA for 83% off and 3 extra months for free!
Its a common medieval and fantasy trope to see organized crime take the form of powerful guilds like the Thieves Guilds or Assassins Guilds of the Elder Scrolls series. But were these real?
We begin to answer this question but speaking generally about Medieval Crime and Law. Next we turn to one of the most widely attested to forms of criminal activity in Medieval daily life, banditry. We cover the various forms of bandits which might be encountered on the roads or in the forests and wilds of the past. Some of these assailants were criminals of opportunity while others were professional criminals. However a large portion of bandits were actually medieval soldiers. We then move on to talk about other common groups of law breakers such as criminal families, gangs, and mafias. All of these have quite a strong historical presence.
We then turn to the more specific form of organized crime that would rise to the level of something like a D&D thieves guild or a Skyrim assassins guild. The subject is explored by looking at three key examples from our records, the story of the Coquillards, the Garduna, and the Banu Sasan. Watch the video to learn more about whether these supposed thieves guilds were real.
Sources and Suggested Reading Trevor Dean, Crime in Medieval Europe Mike Dash, “Islam’s Medieval Underworld” Norman Cohen, “Europe’s Inner Demons” Andrew Ayton, “Robin Hood and Military Service in the Fourteenth Century” Laura Crombie, “Archery and Crossbow Guilds in Medieval Flanders, 1300-1500” B. Anne Tlusty, “The Martial Ethic in Early Modern Germany” Gervase Rosser, “The Art of Solidarity in the Middle Ages” "The Iberian Mafia de la Garduña"
It's a common trope to see medieval or pseudo-medieval fantasy settings swarming with criminal activity.
The depictions vary along multiple dimensions.
One spectrum is the morality of these criminal actors.
For instance, they can be forces for good, as with the mythology of Robin Hood and his Merry Men,
or forces for bad, as with the ruthless, predatory bandits of The Witcher 3.
Another spectrum is the level of organization of these criminals.
Sometimes they can be aimless, independent thugs, as with the generic starter bad guys encountered in many RPGs,
or they can be goal-driven institutions with ranks and recruiters,
as with the thieves' guilds and assassins' guilds of the Elder Scrolls series.
These types of medieval criminals are amazing concepts to play with,
but how much of it is actually based in history?
Let's find out.
This video was sponsored by Surfshark VPN.
They've got your back when it comes to the dangers of the internet,
like surveillance, data mining, theft, and locked content.
In addition to top-of-the-line industry offerings, Surfshark VPN's awesome features also include
MultiHop, which lets you connect using two different servers for increased security,
Whitelister, which allows apps or sites of your choosing to bypass the VPN for things like banking,
CleanWeb, which blocks malware, trackers, phishing, and ads,
Killswitch, which protects against accidental exposure if the server connection gets interrupted,
and NoBordersMode, which maximizes your access in the most restrictive of regions.
In addition, Surfshark VPN has very generous terms of use,
with unlimited devices, 24-7 customer support, and a 30-day money-back guarantee.
Try it today by clicking the link in the description below and using the promo code INVICTA to get 83% off,
plus three extra months for free.
The topic of crime in the medieval era can be a bit of a fuzzy subject.
One reason for this is the limited nature of our ancient sources.
Sure, we have a lot of material to sift through with which to attempt an analysis,
but it's very hard to come up with any statistics on things like murder rates with much confidence.
That being said, it does appear that crime and violence in the medieval world
was much more of a presence in the daily life of people than it is today.
However, we should not go to the extreme stereotype of the past as being some hyper-violent barbaric time.
After all, the medieval era covers a vast geographic and temporal domain,
with many different experiences to be had.
Another important reason why discussing crime can be a fuzzy subject
is due to the blurred lines of the law itself.
Medieval law was complex, with numerous layers of power overlapping and sometimes conflicting.
In the absence of a universal code of laws that governed everyone,
the church, a monarch, a local landowner, a municipality like a town or city,
guilds, and even common people would all try to exert what they believed to be their authority and privileges.
One person's right could just as easily be another's crime.
With this understanding in mind, let's now address one of the most common forms of criminals in the medieval world,
the bandit.
The presence of bandits is widely attested to by our sources,
especially those of the early medieval period.
Records are replete with references to the dangers of roads, forests, and the wild lands.
Such fears stem from the highly communal nature of medieval Europe,
which had a tendency to fear those who lived apart from and in opposition to their local societal nucleus.
But these fears often had a rational grounding.
A perfect example of this comes from 16th century Germany,
where stories abounded of notorious murderer bandits preying upon the land.
One such tale spoke of an infamous villain by the name of Crispin Gnipotenga.
It was claimed that he occupied an elaborate cave system overlooking local roads,
and would routinely descend upon unsuspecting victims, alone or with some accomplices.
Adding up all the reports, estimates for his death toll reached nearly 1,000 lives,
and by many accounts he is regarded as an ancient serial killer.
Finally, his decade-long reign of terror came to an end when one of the women he had kidnapped and enslaved,
managed to escape and lead authorities back to Gnipotenga's lair.
For his horrific crimes, the bandit was sentenced to death by the breaking wheel.
True or not, the story captures the populace's fears when it came to bandits,
and the severe punishment that would be meted out to such outlaws.
In many places, such men were treated similarly to the wolves who preyed on their herds.
Bounties might be placed on the head of a bandit,
while legal principles like wolfsteed allowed them to be hunted and killed as animals.
But just who were these feared and hated bandits?
Well, one category consisted of criminals of opportunity,
who robbed, kidnapped, or attacked others as a means of making ends meet.
Another category consisted of career bandits,
who were capable of carrying out more organized and sophisticated activities like racketeering or heists.
But perhaps the largest category of bandits were those with military ties.
This should come as no surprise, since much of medieval warfare was based on large-scale looting.
Plundering the land was simply standard procedure for most campaigns,
and represented a significant source of income for the troops.
When a war ended, and the field army began to dissolve,
the men were not so quick to demobilize while there were still fortunes to be made.
This sentiment could be reinforced by a lack of pay,
an unwillingness to return to ordinary society,
or a habituation to the activities of military raiding.
Thus, ex-soldiers often ended up forming into small groups
to continue their depredations both abroad and at home.
For instance, the cyclic mobilization and demobilization of the Hundred Years' War
produced many soldier bandits during the downtime between official campaigns.
In particular, the prevalence of poorer English archers turning bandit
helped popularize and shape the legend of Robin Hood we know of today.
But Robin was not the only famous medieval criminal hood.
In medieval Flanders, the cities of Ghent, Bruges, and Ypres
had militia forces known as the White, Red, or Blue Hoods, respectively.
These groups quickly turned to violence directed at other towns
or even rival factions in their own native cities
and became little more than a faction of armed criminals.
Authorities often had to step in and curb the activities of these bandits.
However, sometimes, they might co-opt them for their own purposes,
pardoning criminals in exchange for military service.
Other times, the authorities simply joined in on the action,
engaging in theft or brain-ditch of their own.
This ran the gauntlet from extortion at the tip of a sword
to actual violence.
For instance, some noble could easily set up tolls at bridges and chokepoints
without the legal authority to do so.
This was an extremely common issue in an age of decentralized power,
which has given rise to the term Robber Baron.
Now that we've covered the idea of banditry,
let's turn to the more specific idea of organized crime.
In the medieval era, this would have taken many forms.
You would undoubtedly have had your fair share of criminal families,
gangs, and mafia-type groups.
Their existence is not that controversial,
considering we can find such elements throughout human history
who always seem to worm their way into the criminal niches of commerce, trade, and politics.
But for our purposes, we are more interested in the criminal entities
which took on the trappings of structured, guild-like organizations.
After all, the medieval world was filled with all manner of guilds, even for beggars,
so it stands to reason that perhaps the criminals also had some of their own.
Interestingly enough, the mythology of a supposed thieves' guild or criminal fraternity
stretches back to our medieval sources,
who were equally as fascinated by such a concept as we are.
Let's start with a few examples before assessing their validity.
One of the most famous cases comes from 15th century France
with a group operating out of Dijon.
It is here that in 1455 the Trial of the Coquillard was underway
with some shocking allegations.
A dozen suspects had been arrested, but refused to reveal any secrets
until finally, the youngest among them broke.
Apparently, he revealed to local authorities 60 names
associated with the existence of an underground group of criminals and outcasts.
They were reported to have formed an organization equivalent in power to the guilds of medieval cities
and had even crowned their own king.
The Coquillard had supposedly managed to thrive in the shadows using a law of silence
and by adopting their own form of criminal sling, the argot.
For instance, pickpockets in their ranks were referred to as harvesters
and forced entry into homes was referred to as la soire roulant.
Another famous example comes from Spain.
Here, the Gardugna supposedly got its start as a group waging guerrilla action against the Moors
and expanded as a secret criminal enterprise.
Members were supposedly identified by tattoos on their right hand
and were organized into a vast hierarchy.
At the top was a grandmaster with foremen who controlled individual cities.
Beneath these were various thugs, thieves, and other groups referred to by codenames.
Sneaks were young children with nimble hands,
mermaids were good-looking youths with charisma,
and the handsome ones were sword-armed muscle men.
Together, the organization collected its own taxes,
pulled the strings of government, and carried out all manner of robbery, kidnapping, arson, and murder.
Legend even tells of how they got called upon by the Inquisition to do their dirty work.
Meanwhile, in the Islamic world, we hear of another vast underground group,
known as the Banu Sassan.
All sorts of crimes were pinned on them,
ranging from pickpocketing to murder.
Some claim they made a habit of robbing houses
under the illumination of a candle placed on the back of a turtle.
Others tell of how they were specialist con artists and forgers
who made their money as pretend mystics or merchants of fake holy relics.
One source even claims that there was a Banu Sassan poet named Al-Ukbar
who self-described himself as being a member of a noble house among, quote,
the influential and bold ones.
So what do we make of all this?
Let's start with the first story of the Kokyar.
Returning to this case, we find that the gang members which had been detained
were mostly charged of basic crimes like petty theft.
Additional witnesses who were called in were not able to corroborate
many of the sensational allegations that had been previously made,
and such a vast organization failed to materialize in the aftermath of the investigation.
Well, of course, you might say.
It's a secret society. They must have simply faded back into the shadows.
Perhaps. However, this line of thinking can be quite dangerous.
Sure, it's possible some secret society like that existed,
but we should always reserve belief in the absence of evidence.
To do the opposite, and to twist a lack of evidence
into some confirmation of the original thesis,
is at the core of conspiratorial thinking.
With that point made, let's turn to our other two examples
to see if these yield more concrete results.
Unfortunately, neither the claims of the Gardunia nor the Benusasan
are given much credibility by historians either.
They largely seem to have evolved in popular mythology
as catch-all labels placed on unrelated criminals
who existed across a wide geographic and temporal period.
This practice was put to paper by medieval writers,
often commissioned by or hailing from the wealthier parts of society,
who wished to create conspiracies among their perceived enemies.
These literary descriptions often took the form of inversions
whereby the particular conspiracy in question
had deliberately mocked some proper social order.
We see this a lot with the witch and satanic crazes
with things like the Black Mass, which purport an inversion
of the practices found in a traditional Catholic Mass.
It seems that later authors picked up on these medieval writings
and ran with them, adding their own layers of mythology over the top.
The detailed account of the Gardunia hierarchy we shared earlier, for example,
dates to a book written in the 1800s called The Mysteries of the Inquisition.
Its contents are treated as highly suspect today,
but at the time found an avid audience.
These readers were part of a new wave of urban mystery literature
that saw an explosion of best-selling titles along the same lines
like The Mysteries of Paris and The Mysteries of London.
Such tales were understandably fascinating
and would continue to echo through pop culture.
Fantasy writers from the 1900s seemed to have latched onto them
as great writing material, with many sword and sorcery stories
like Fafhrd and the Grey Mouser, in particular,
incorporating powerful thieves' guild into their settings and narratives.
These tropes were in turn absorbed into early versions
of role-playing games like Dungeons and Dragons.
From there, the idea was solidly established as a core element
of the medieval fantasy genre, despite having no confirmed historical basis.
But at the same time, I don't want to shut down the whole idea as ridiculous.
As we discussed, there are many other forms of organized crime
in the medieval world, from bandits to robber barons,
gangs and mafias, all of which are just as fascinating
as the yet-to-be-proven thieves' guild.
I hope you've enjoyed this deeper look
into the history of medieval banditry and organized crime.
A huge thanks to the patrons for funding the channel
and to the researchers, writers and artists who made this video possible.
Be sure to like and subscribe for more content
and check out these other related videos.
See you in the next one.