In this history documentary we take a look at surviving a pandemic in ancient Rome with a specific focus on the Antonine Plage. Check out Ancient History Magazine: https://www.karwansaraypublishers.com...
We begin with an overview of ancient diseases and Roman medicine. What did people think of diseases and how did they treat them? Turns out there are a ton of answers to this question so we focus in on the main philosophy involving the four fundamental elements of earth, air, fire, and water. With this context in mind, we then turn to the topic of ancient pandemics.
Our primary case study is the Antonine Plague which broke out in the 2nd Century AD of the Roman Empire. We cover its origin and spread across ancient Rome. We then talk about its impact on Roman society, the Roman Economy, and the Roman Army. There are a ton of parallels to modern times which prove quite fascinating to compare and contrast. Enjoy!
Bibliography and Recommended Reading The Prince of Medicine, Susan P. Mattern Ancient Medicine, Vivian Nutton Greek Rational Medicine, James Longrigg Roman Disasters, Jerry Toner Man and Wound in the Ancient World, Richard Gabriel
The world is currently dealing with a massive pandemic which has impacted society from the
macro to the individual level. It's honestly an incredible historical moment to be living through.
But what was it like for past generations? Today we'll be exploring what it was like
to live through a pandemic in ancient Rome. If you find yourself asking these sorts of
questions a lot I definitely recommend you check out our friends over at Ancient History Magazine.
They publish awesome issues covering all sorts of aspects of daily life in the past
with great articles, images, and illustrations which bring it all to life.
As we sit through quarantine you should definitely download their digital issues
using the discount link in the description below. We get a small cut of sales but more
importantly your business helps keep them afloat in these troubling times so check them out.
To get started let's talk generally about diseases in the ancient world.
Simply put they were just a part of daily life that we all too often
overlook when thinking about the past. After all our ancestors dealt with many of the same
health issues as us be they common diseases, seasonal illnesses, or large-scale outbreaks.
Things like pneumonia, tuberculosis, strep throat, and pinkeye pop up quite often in our records.
In the winters cold weather brought things like the flu while the summers might herald
the spread of malaria. In fact in Rome malaria was a huge endemic issue which is estimated to
have killed more Romans than every war combined. So if these diseases were so common what did
people think of them? Answering this question is quite tough in a world before modern medicine
where the true vectors of disease were not understood. Without the germ theory of disease
as a guide people instead turned to a host of other ideas which ranged from the religious and
magical to the rational and scientific. It would take an entire episode to discuss this complex
mix of philosophies but for now it will be enough to state that one of the leading philosophies
revolved around the four classical elements of earth, water, air, and fire. In this model diseases
would be seen as arising from various elements and in particular their imbalance within a person
or the environment. Here's a quote from the first century AD that sums things up quite nicely.
Philistion of Locri thinks that we are composed of four forms, that is of four elements, fire, air,
water, earth. Each of these two has its own power. Of fire the power is the hot, of air is the cold,
of water the moist, and of earth the dry. According to him diseases come into being in many ways but
speaking more generally and in the outline it is possible to speak of a threefold causation.
One because of the elements, two because of the condition of our bodies, and three because of
external causes. Diseases are caused by the elements when the hot and moist are in excess
or when the hot becomes less and weak. They arise through three types of external causes.
One by wounds and sores, two by excess heat cold and the like or change from heat to cold or cold
to heat, and three by change of nutriment to what is unsuitable or destructive. Diseases are caused
by the condition of the body in the following way. When he says the whole body breathes well
and the breath passes through without hindrance health ensues. For breathing takes place not only
through the mouth and nostrils but also throughout the whole body. When the body does not breathe
well diseases ensue and in different ways. So as you can see while it's clearly not aligned with
our modern scientific model the passage still shows that people were capable of generating quite
sophisticated models based on their own limited understanding of the world around them. For
instance there was this idea of miasma which was basically noxious corrupting odors emanating from
things like rotting organic matter or regions like swamps. So clearly they could generally
point in the direction of where diseases came from but not describe how they arose or spread.
Okay so if people had their own model of disease how did they treat them?
Again because of the wide variety of medical philosophies there would be treatments ranging
from the magical to the scientific. The healing power of the gods for instance might be sought
by prayer vows and offerings while magical incantations and amulets could be used to drive
away illness. Herbs and drugs were also widely leveraged for their supposed magical properties
as much as for their proven effectiveness. Individuals often treated themselves using
home remedies or might turn to more professional doctors and physicians.
However there were no set qualifications or standardized forms of training for these
experts so the level of care was highly dependent on the doctor in question. People like Galen and
Kelsis were highly regarded in their day but even they advocated for some wild treatment.
Here is one of the more outlandish cures mentioned by Kelsis in his medical encyclopedia.
I hear it commonly said that if a man eat a nestling swallow for a whole year he is not in
danger from angina and that when the disease attacks anyone it is also beneficial to burn
a nestling which has been preserved in salt and to crumble the powdered ash into hydromel which
is administered as a draught. Since this remedy has considerable popular authority and cannot
possibly be a danger, although I have not read of it in medical authorities, I thought it should
be inserted here in my work. Now that we have contextualized disease in the ancient world
let's now turn to the primary subject of the video, pandemics in ancient Rome. These occurred
throughout history with many potential case studies to explore. For this episode we'll be
looking at the Antonine Plague of the 2nd century AD. Let's begin from the start, where did it come
from? Just as today it's an important question but one which requires a lot of research and
investigation to answer. This is even more true given the state of science at the time and the
fact that we are left with just fragmentary evidence today. That being said it seems that
the disease originated from the near east with ancient sources first reporting its appearance
during the siege of Seleucia around 165 AD during the Roman-Parthian wars. Like many plagues this
one is often given a supernatural origin. As an example one text claims that a soldier opened a
golden casket in a temple of Apollo which immediately let forth the plague in a choking
miasma. Regardless of how it infected the first person cases quickly spread like wildfire through
the packed military camp and likely jumped to nearby merchants and camp followers. As the army
returned home these then served as vectors for the further spread of the disease across the highly
interconnected mediterranean trade network. We don't have good data to track cases with much
granularity but the disease likely would have been able to spread quite quickly in all directions.
Just as today its spread would in many ways be undetected with its identification struggling to
keep up. In some cases their speeds would match when the diseased merchants arrived in cities
bearing news of the pandemic. Pretty soon many major urban centers were infected which then
spread to the countryside as people fled. This plague would last for over 15 years with many
waves. We can get a glimpse of what this spread was like by turning to the writings of the famed
Dr. Galen who is our primary source for the outbreak. He had been practicing medicine in the
Roman east and eventually made his way to Rome in 162 AD. Four years later the plague arrived in Rome.
Galen promptly packed up and fled blaming political issues with other physicians for his
flight. As an imperial doctor though he was recalled within a couple of years by the twin emperors
Lucius Verus and Marcus Aurelius. He was to meet them in Aquileia where Roman troops involved in
the Marcomannic wars were gathering. Almost as soon as Galen arrived however the plague descended
upon the region. The emperors fled for their lives with only handpicked group of bodyguards.
It appears that they may not have been fast enough as the emperor Verus died on the road to Rome.
The panic must have been palpable. At this point Galen found another excuse to avoid returning to
the city of Rome with the imperial entourage by claiming that the god Asclepius himself had
appeared to him in a dream and told him not to go. Yet despite keeping his distances from the plague
Galen leaves us with the best description of its symptoms. He speaks of a rash covering the
victim's body which became rough, scabby, and often black. Symptoms also included coughing,
fever, inflammation, vomiting, ulceration of the larynx, and fetid breath. These and other
clues have led modern scientists to blame smallpox or measles for the pandemic. Quantifying the impact
of the Antonine plague can be tough. When it comes to ancient history there are always caveats and
debates. Historians tease out morsels of evidence from what remains but it's always difficult to
form a clear picture from the fragments of the past. That being said there is a general consensus
that the Antonine plague was devastating. As we stated before it tore across the Roman Empire
spreading even further to the lands around it. In Egypt for instance entire villages simply
disappeared from the tax rolls as they melted away from death or abandonment. Estimates on the
mortality rate generally hover around two to ten percent however these were likely higher in large
unsanitary urban areas. The historian Dio Cassius for instance claims that in Rome alone it killed
a quarter of those affected with 2,000 deaths a day. In all it is estimated that upwards of 5
million were killed across the empire. So how did people deal with this? Well the first thing they
did was panic. Often that meant literally running away. However while the rich might have their
countryside villas to flee to many especially the urban poor didn't have that luxury. So what did
those who remained in the city do? Well we have no real records of any active measures like those
common today. There were no quarantines, no work stoppages, no disease screening, and no emergency
supplies. However people did still understand the dangers of close contact and those with obvious
symptoms of the plague were often quickly shunned. Even their houses were left untouched and abandoned
with people afraid to enter a place that had harbored such a horror. Some exceptions to this
were the brave doctors who at least tried to help. Ancient historians however predictably note that
they were often the first to die in these cases. In this panic the Romans clung to anything they
thought would help. Just as today this unfortunately made them easy prey for mystics and con artists.
One particularly interesting anecdote about this involves a man by the name of Alexander who headed
the cult of Glycon, a snake god who whispered prophecies into his ear. Alexander would then
recite these in the form of oracular poetry. One of his famous lines was a prayer against the plague
which was shared widely across Rome and the provinces. It simply stated, unshorn Phoebus keep
away the cloud of plague. In an odd turn of events though the verse is reported to have had the
opposite effect. Those who put it over their doorways often were the first to be stricken by
the plague. Most probably those who fell for the scam and put the verse over their door had put
all faith in it and did not take care to avoid the disease. Or perhaps as some of you who know
your mythology might recall Phoebus Apollo's arrows were actually thought to bring plague. Whatever
the reason we might never know the true answer. Just as today this all had a major impact on
economic activity. Archaeologists examining inscription patterns in the city of Rome
around this time have spotted an ominous drop in activity. Meanwhile the brick making business
seems to have completely collapsed with less than 50 percent of its normal production and there are
no inscriptions from the plague period in imperial marble quarries. Land prices also fell dramatically
in places like Roman Egypt never fully returning to normal while wheat prices nearly doubled. Even
the production of the golden Aureus coin nearly ceased as gold mines were abandoned. In short
the imperial economy seems to have been shredded by 15 years of epidemic. In modern times we might
expect the government to get involved in economic recovery efforts. Ancient governments however
function in a very different way and didn't really have the same ability to control the economy.
Usually what you got would be spending on public projects like aqueducts
or subsidized grain doles but these were never really deployed as stimulative tools.
Occasionally you might have the government step in to mint more coins or attempt price regulations
but these were largely met with failure and rampant inflation. Those in power however were
not totally useless and did take some steps to alleviate the problem. Augustus for example set
a precedent 150 years before the Antonine Plague by using the imperial treasury as an ultimate
insurance to soften the blows of disaster. Though this mostly came in the grim form of government
stepping in to clear the piles of corpses from the streets, paying for their burial and providing men
to bury them since oftentimes the usual corpse collectors had long since died. Marcus Aurelius
being the man that he was funded ceremonial funerals across the board though this notably
helped to wipe out the imperial treasury. I did also want to note that all of this damage
and disruption also extended to the Roman army. The plague took a huge chunk out of its active
duty troops while its recruitment pool simultaneously evaporated and imperial coffers ran dry.
As a result of these manpower and supply shortages major campaigns were postponed and the defensive
frontiers left heavily weakened. This in turn allowed barbarian tribes to increasingly pour
over the border to raid Roman lands. Such problems would only get worse in the decades which followed
and would eventually precipitate the crisis of the third century that nearly saw Rome destroyed.
Plagues would continue to ravage the empire over the centuries slowly chipping away at its stability.
One of the most damaging of these was the plague of Justinian which struck in the 6th century AD
and would be one of the deadliest pandemics in history. But that story will have to wait for
another time. For now, stay safe and be sure to check out Ancient History Magazine for more
awesome content on daily life in the past. A huge thanks to our researchers, writers,
and artists who made this video possible as well as our patrons who fund the channel.
I hope you enjoyed and see you in the next one.