What were the symbols on hoplite shields? Taking a closer look at ancient Greek shields

Eternal Shield
2 followers
99 Video ViewsยทSep 15, 2024
In this video we take a look at the striking blazons (designs) on hoplite shields, presenting the consensus on what is commonly believed they were!
As a re-enactor, one of the most common questions we get asked is
what did the symbols on the shields mean? And, well, that's what I'm going to attempt to answer
for you today. The answer is unfortunately not as simple as the shields meant this and this design
meant that. There's a lot of grey area and sort of educated guesses and speculation that go into
answering that question of what these blazons, is what we call them, what the blazons mean.
There are a few leading theories and a few historical nudges that I will be sort of
mentioning today to hopefully give you a better idea of what we believe these blazons and symbols
sort of meant and stood for in the Hoplite Phalanx. Now, to either side of me you can
see sort of two different types of shield designs, one of them being a sort of geometric
solar symbol, a star, and the other being a very famous Gorgonian. We sort of see a lot
of different types of blazons and designs on shields from geometric patterns to mythical
beasts to helmets to satires with questionable members. We see a lot of disparity and a lot of
uniqueness within this which sort of fits in with the rest of the Hoplite and I mention this a lot
in all of my other previous videos in this sort of style. Hoplites were not professional soldiers,
they were citizen militia forces essentially, who'd have to afford and purchase all of their
own equipment and arms which then resulted in a lot of personalization and customized
sort of pieces of that. And that sort of brings us on to one of our leading theories which is
that it was just that, something which the Hoplite wanted to paint on a shield. Maybe there was a
religious meaning to that, maybe there was a spiritual meaning to that, but it was essentially
something that that Hoplite felt that they wanted to paint. Maybe it was a Gorgon they thought would
strike fear into their enemy if they were staring at it in the face, maybe the solar symbol can sort
of relate to Apollo, or maybe it's a distraction for archers and make them more likely to hit the
shield or it might disorientate your enemy, or it's just a design that you liked. Maybe you painted
a dog on your shield because you have a beloved companion that you want to take with you on
campaign and sort of the options are endless. We have a description from Plutarch who writes
about a Spartan who painted a life-sized fly on his shield who supposedly wanted to get so close
to his enemy the fly appeared to them as a lion or its true form, different sort of translations
use different words. So we do have period descriptions of what seemed to be personal
choice on what these blazons were. Another theory is that they are perhaps sort of a heraldic sort
of symbol, perhaps your family sort of had an animal or a symbol that sort of every generation
of your family had, so perhaps the boar was sort of your family crest or this specific sort of
symbol is what your family used, so perhaps it's sort of a family crest, a heraldic symbol similar
to sort of later medieval style designs and that sort of passed on through a family. And another
very popular theory is that they were religious which likely a lot of them do have a lot of
religious connotation, as I said earlier the royal star here, the sort of solar symbol is commonly
associated with the god Apollo, you could see boars for Ares, you could see the eagle for Zeus,
obviously the owl for Athena, we see a lot of sort of different creatures and different symbols that
that have meaning and significance to the gods they have worshipped at the time, so perhaps you
could have painted the eagle of Zeus if you wanted Zeus to favour you and look out for you
in battle, or it was simply the god that you dedicated yourself to the most. A very popular
design that we often see is the very famous Spartan lambda and the club of Heracles for Thebes.
We do have I think one or two descriptions of the Laconians wearing the lambda on the shield,
no mention at all to the Spartans necessarily having them, this is a later source, a Peloponnesian
warrior source, and what I personally believe and what many other scholars believe is that it was
actually a state-issued shield. So the L, the lambda, stood for Laconia and during the Peloponnesian
war where Laconia was having to muster many more soldiers to fight in the massive war,
was essentially saying you were too poor to afford your own equipment, here's a shield,
here's a spear, get out there and fight. The lambda standing for the Laconian shield,
that was given to residents of Laconia by essentially Laconian governments. So not
likely the Spartans, which is kind of ironic how the lambda has sort of become so associated with
the Spartans, the upper class, when it was likely used by such lower class citizens or residents
that they couldn't even afford their own equipment at all. Now of course it's very difficult for us
to give a concrete answer and likely all of these could have been the case, some of these could have
been the case. There might have been other reasons as well that we haven't really thought of and it
also quite possibly changed over time, but again the sort of stance that I take on most of it is
that it was up to the wearers or the owner's choice as to what he decided went on his shield.
If he wanted a religious symbol, for instance the royal star, he'd paint that on it. If he wanted
a dog, he'd paint that on it. If he wanted an octopus, he'd paint on it. If he wanted a helmet,
he painted that on it. If he was a bit of a jokester and he wanted a satire with a ginormous
certain body parts, he would paint that on there as well. The fly, for example. So we sort of see
this trend of individualized elements of the Hoplites panoply, which is where I tend to sit,
is that it was likely at the end of the day down to your choice. Maybe you would have got tent mates
or mess mates that decided to sort of paint the same design. We have some people suggesting that
the Spartan Mori and Lokoi had the same shield blazons, but there's really no evidence for that
at all. And in artwork we see a lot and a lot of disparity and individuality within basically every
depiction. Something that is also important to note is that it's highly likely that lots of these
shields didn't actually have a blazon on it at all. They might have been blank. If you weren't very
artistically minded and you didn't want to spend the money to get someone to professionally paint
your aspis device, your blazon, then you would likely have just left it blank. Which doesn't
look as cool in artwork, so most vase depictions show quite elaborate designs. And that poses an
issue as well for us when we're trying to recreate these blazons, which are, do we vase depictions
and transfer them onto our shield, sort of more like this one, or do we elaborate it and sort of
go, well vase paintings aren't realism, so perhaps these sort of blazons were more realistic.
And that's why I actually tend, I like the look of this design. It's also found in Messinia,
so a Spartan subterritory. But I like the geometric symbols because there's sort of less
of a question of is that what it would have looked like, because it is just a geometric pattern.
As opposed to, if you could look at a lion or a bull, is it really that sort of vase art
replicated in real life, or could it have been more of a, not necessarily realism, but you know,
a little bit more realistic and shaded and everything like that. So there's another sort
of issue that we have if you go with something like this, that is very similar to ancient Greek
art, and at least the artwork on your shield fits in with period sources and would fit in in
the time, even if it was a little bit obscure. But of course, if you decide to go for the more
realism route, it could have fit in, but it also might not be the art style of the time. And I
think it's highly likely that we would have seen certain individuals try and sort of replicate
what they see in vase art, the same way that modern people today sort of replicate clothing
that they see in modern media and artwork and film. So there's really a lot of questions there,
but at the end of the day, to answer the question of what did the symbols on hoplite shields mean,
we don't know, but these are sort of our best guesses, which likely did sort of take place in
the world of ancient Greece. Thank you very much for watching this video, I hope that you enjoyed
it and learned something. If you do have any questions about anything I've said, or even stuff
that I haven't said, feel free to drop them below and I'll try my best to answer them.
Thank you very much to our members for going the extra mile and supporting the channel, and
thank you everyone for watching this video. I hope we see you in the next one. If you want to check
out our previous videos where we sort of cover the whole hoplite, I'll link down below the
video where I go over all of the armor of the ancient Greek hoplite, and also where I go over
weaponry as well. Thank you very much for watching, and I'll hopefully see you in the next one.
