What's the Best Impact Driver for YOU?

Power Machine Tools
2 followers
In this video we compare three completely different impact drivers at completely different prices. first is the skill 12 volt brushless impact driver. up next is the Milwaukee M12 fuel impact driver and finally the DeWalt DCF860 high torque impact driver. who is the target market for each of these and what is the cost. finally what would you recommend based on your circumstances and use case. watch this video to find out.
#machine #tools #Powertools
Welcome back to Drudo's Tools. If you're looking for an impact driver, you've come to the right
spot. We're going to look at three different options here. We're going to see what they cost,
what they can do, and who they're really for. Check it out. So what are we comparing today?
First up, we've got a Skill 12-volt brushless impact driver. We've got a Milwaukee Fuel
12-volt impact driver and a Dewalt 20-volt XR impact driver. Now these are primarily going
to be used for driving fast. So for today's test, we've got three different size fasteners to show
what they can do, what they can't do, and which one you need for your application.
Let's start with the Skill. So this is a Skill 12-volt brushless impact driver. I got this with
their brushless drill driver, a battery, and a charger for $39. So pretty inexpensive. Everyone
knows Skill. It's not a generic brand. It's not a Timu or Amazon brand, but it was definitely
the cheapest of the three. Real briefly, some of the features. It's got this really nice ring light.
It has three different speeds, a sort of specialized fastener speed. So let's see how
it does. Now this is marketed as a homeowner DIY grade tool. Most professionals probably aren't
going to go with something like this. Carpenters that don't need a lot of power and just like the
Skill brand or the Skill price might like something like this. So people, if you're a
homeowner or DIYer, what are you going to be doing with this? Probably something like this,
building a deck, building a fence, hanging a shelf, something using fasteners of about this
size, 4-inch deck screws. Let's see how it does. We're in speed three, fully charged, 12-volt,
2-amp hour battery. Not really much of an issue for it. It wasn't the fastest. For something like
this, I think this has plenty of power for that. One thing that's kind of cool is this specialized,
they call it CCM mode. Check out what it does. I'm going full trigger the whole time.
So you can see it starts off really slow, then kind of ramps up to help you get it started.
Kind of cool, but maybe not for everyone. Now something that might challenge us a little more
is a 516 by 8-inch structural screw here. Let's see how it does. We're going to put it back in
speed three. Not terrible, but if you're building something where you need a lot of these,
this is going to get old really fast. But just for the heck of it, let's say you need something
even bigger, like a 3-8 by 6 SPAC structural lag here. Let's see how it does. You might be able to
see it just about finished, but it actually started stuttering and actually stopped making
progress. So I would probably call this a fail for that kind of fastener, especially if you had
more than one to drive. So that's pretty much the limit for something like this.
If you're not concerned about speed, you still got to be concerned about where its limits are.
Maybe you'll never need to do something like that. And if so, this could be a good choice,
especially at 39 bucks. I think this has a three-year warranty. And then if you register it,
you get a five-year warranty, if you can still find it at Lowe's or really wherever they're
sold. So let's step up a little bit in price and performance and see what you get there.
So this is one of the most popular impact drivers on the market. This is the Milwaukee
Fuel, I think Gen 4 impact driver, their newest fuel impact driver. So you could see it's actually
a little bit more compact than the Skill. And if you use one of the smaller cylindrical batteries,
it's definitely a lot smaller and lighter than even the Skill 12-volt. You're actually not
sacrificing size and weight. And as you'll see, you're going to get a lot more performance.
So again, if you're a DIYer, if you're a homeowner, a lot of professional carpenters
love this, cabinet makers. So just because it's small, I wouldn't call it DIY grade.
You might look at it as a just professional or premium compact line of tools or an impact
driver in this case. So let's see where its limits are in respect to these three fasteners.
So it's also got three speeds. It also has a special fastener mode. I think it's for metal
screws, self-tapping screws, not positive. I don't really use it much. Here we go with the
deck screw, speed three. So considerably faster than the Skill. With this battery though,
you're getting a lot more runtime out of this than you would with the Skill for the same size.
Now, I should probably talk about price. So I paid about 100 bucks for this tool only,
no batteries. Depending on the deals, you might be able to get this on discount. You probably want
to get it in a kit with their field drill driver. You might even be able to find it as part of a
combo where you get this free if you buy some other kit. So I'm just going to call it 100 bucks
because that's what I paid for it. So more than double the price, about two and a half times the
price as the Skill. You are getting a lot more performance. Okay, so let's see how it does with
the 5.8 by 8. Yeah, no problem there. Now on to this big 3.8 SPAC. Again, the Skill just about
drove it in one time and then just stopped making progress. So let's see what the Milwaukee can do.
So a little bit slow going, but no problem, made it all the way through. So you're going to be able
to do multiple fasteners like that before you're either out of battery or this thing overheats,
depending on how hard you're going with it. So again, smaller size, but lots more performance
and quite a bit pricier. And then finally, what many would consider to be a professional grade,
way beyond what a DIY or your average homeowner might need is the DeWalt DCF860.
This is their newest, fastest, what they call a high torque impact. They do have one newer impact
driver, but it's more about being quiet. This is just all outperforming. This again, tool only,
I paid about $200 for it. You might, again, depending on where you're buying from and what
deals are running, you might be able to get it for more or less than that. So we're going from
the Skill doubling in price to the M12 and then doubling in price again to get something like this
without a battery. But what do you get for your money? Let's do the test. All right.
This also has three speeds. It has a, not a ring light, but pretty close to it. Also it has a
button. So you could leave this on for 20 minutes kind of as a flashlight, which is pretty,
pretty handy. But we're going to go speed three, run one of these four inch deck screws.
Here we go. So right off the bat, I mean, that was like twice or three times as fast as the other.
So you're building it there, but if you don't want to be there for days, you can see the,
the appeal here. Something someone that buys this might be doing is running these all day.
So let's see how it does. Piece of cake, much faster, easier on the tool. So it's not going to
overheat if you're running a lot of these. So again, lots of appeal there. And lastly, one of
these three H lags or structural fat, let's see how it can, how it does again. No problem. Something
to know about this is it does kick down in speed after impacting for awhile. Some people say that's
to save the tool, which is important. If you're buying something like this, you're using it every
day, you want it to last. And it's certainly has a warranty like the other ones, but again,
no issue for that took a little longer because it's a bigger fastener, but you're saving a lot
of time. If this is your job and you can really benefit from something like this. So that's it
clear differences in performance, very clear differences in price, some overlap and who
these might be for. So I want to know from you guys, which one of these would you recommend
to your friends and why let me know in the comments. So hopefully this showed,
it's not always just about speed. It's also about capability. We can see things that these two
just can't really do, whereas something like this can. And also just because something's
smaller doesn't mean it's not professional or used by professionals in the field. For me,
this is my everyday impact driver. It's the one I go to pretty much anytime, unless I need
something really big, which I'll go with this. You can see it doesn't get a whole lot of use.
This kind of frustrates me a little bit, except for like small fasteners or real little thing.
I don't really go, but for anyone who just needs the impact driver just to have in their house
or in their toolbox. I mean, it's hard to go wrong with that one, but I want to know from you guys,
which one of these would you pick? Have you already bought one of them? If you haven't,
what did you buy? I'd love to know. How do you use it? Are you a professional DIY or homeowner?
Let me know in the comments. I'd love to hear from you guys. And just to end, I do want to say
thank you guys so much for subscribing. We are at over 2000 subscribers. I can't believe it.
Channel is doing great as far as growth, which means I get to make more videos for you guys.
So thank you. If you haven't subscribed, you like some of this stuff, you want to see
other tool tests and reviews, please subscribe,
like this video. It keeps the channel going. See you on the next one.
