Best CHEAPEST Brushless Impact Drivers?? - Let's Find Out!

Power Machine Tools
2 followers
Today I'm comparing six of the cheapest brushless impact drivers to see which is the best option.
Now I bought all of these tools myself, but I'll leave a link down below with current
pricing and more information on each one.
I figured I would put each of the brands in a playoff bracket, so I'm putting two brands
from the same stores against each other.
One brand will be eliminated and then move on to the next round.
So let's go ahead and get started.
Now when it comes to Hart vs. HyperTuff, HyperTuff is the cheapest option at about $55.
Hart is currently $89 for their kit.
Both kits come with 2Ah 20V batteries and a belt clip.
Hart is one of the few that comes with a bag included, so that's nice.
HyperTuff is a little more compact, but is actually taller than Hart when standing up.
When it comes to weight, HyperTuff is a little bit lighter at 1,367 grams with the battery
connected versus 1,450 for Hart.
Kind of a small thing, but I did notice how much easier it is to connect and remove the
battery on the Hart impact driver.
With HyperTuff, it just feels way too hard to remove the battery for some reason.
Hopefully that loosens up over time.
The HyperTuff battery also feels quite a bit cheaper as far as build quality as well.
You've got a fast charger that only takes about one hour to charge with Hart, where
with HyperTuff, it's probably going to take half the day to charge back up.
When it comes to the built-in lights, Hart is definitely one of the brightest lights
compared to most others that I've tested, where as you can see HyperTuff is pretty dim.
You've also got a quick change collet on Hart, so you can easily change it out with one hand,
where HyperTuff, you've got to use two hands.
Nice thing is, both of these impact drivers have a bit holder there on the back towards
the bottom.
Now as far as how loud these are, HyperTuff is a little bit quieter at 86 decibels versus
91.6 for Hart, and that's with no load.
Now when it comes to the overall power, HyperTuff has up to 1,800 inch-pounds of torque at up
to 3,300 IPM, or impacts per minute, at a max of 3,600 RPM, or revolutions per minute,
versus 2,200 inch-pounds of torque for Hart, at up to 3,900 IPM, and a max of 3,000 RPM.
So Hart is definitely a little more powerful, but is also quite a bit more expensive, and
not a huge surprise in my speed test of driving three-inch deck screws.
But Hart was consistently faster, but not by as much as you would think, considering
the price difference.
Overall, I think HyperTuff is much better than expected.
It's got good grip, feels like it has plenty of power to do most things.
Really if they just improved the battery build quality, this could be a serious contender
in most categories.
Hart definitely feels more premium than HyperTuff.
The light is super bright.
It's got the quick change collet, and it's more powerful.
So not a huge surprise, but Hart wins this one.
The downside is, Hart is more expensive than Craftsman, and Ryobi, when those are on sale.
It's a pretty tough competition.
HyperTuff, you have been... eliminated.
When it comes to Hercules versus Bauer, obviously Bauer is going to be the cheaper kid at only
$69 normally, versus $97 for Hercules.
Keep in mind though, it's only a 1.5Ah battery with Bauer, versus 2Ah for Hercules.
And if you have the ITC, or Inside Track Club membership at Harbor Freight, you can usually
get both of these even cheaper.
Even though both of these are usually pretty affordable.
Both kids come with battery, charger, and belt clip.
Hercules is a little more compact, Bauer is a little bit taller.
As far as the weight, Hercules is a little bit lighter at 1,465 grams, versus 1,548 grams
for Bauer.
Kind of odd, but Bauer is a little top heavy as well.
So if you stand it up without the battery, it's going to fall over.
If you have the battery connected, then it's fine.
I also noticed when removing the battery, it's definitely a little bit harder with Bauer.
I don't know if it's just going to take some time to loosen up, but Hercules is much easier
to remove the battery.
I feel like the batteries on both of these actually feel quite a bit cheaper than most
of the bigger name brands that I've tested.
Nice thing is, both of these have rapid chargers, so you don't have to wait very long, regardless
of which one you go with.
They're also the only ones that I've tested that have a silicone type of grippy material.
They're on the bottom of the batteries.
One advantage with both of these, is you have three different modes, or speeds, depending
on how much power you want.
Nice thing is, both of these have three lights up at the top.
Hercules is a little bit brighter.
Bauer's pretty close, but it has some weird shapes.
It's not quite as solid as Hercules.
Neither of these impact drivers have a bit holder, unfortunately.
But there is a belt clip included for both.
Hercules has sort of a quick change collet, where you can easily pop the bit in with one
hand, where Bauer doesn't.
You do have to pull the bit out using two hands, though, on both of these.
As far as how loud these are, they're actually very similar.
Bauer was just a tad louder at 90.4 decibels, versus 90.1 for Hercules.
As far as overall power, Bauer has up to 2,000 inch-pounds of torque, at up to 3,200 IPM,
and a max of 3,200 RPM, versus 2,200 inch-pounds of torque for Hercules, up to 4,400 IPM, and
a max of 3,600 RPM.
So Hercules is going to be more powerful, which makes sense, since it's the more expensive
tool.
And Hercules can drive three-inch deck screws faster pretty consistently, but it's actually
pretty close.
Bauer actually feels like it has nice power, and definitely feels like a step up in most
categories from the HyperTough impact driver.
I think Bauer actually surprised me after using it with the power and what features
you get for the price.
I think they just need to improve the build quality on the battery.
Hercules feels more premium, and definitely more powerful.
It's a nice step up from Bauer, especially when you consider the five-year warranty plus
three-year warranty on the battery for Hercules, versus only 90-day warranty for Bauer.
Sort of personal preference, but these two definitely have some more weight to them versus
the competition.
Really, I feel like they just need to improve the build quality on the batteries for both
of these brands, but they definitely actually feel pretty nice when using both.
Not a huge surprise, but Hercules wins this one in most categories, except the price.
Bauer, you have been eliminated.
When it comes to Ryobi versus Hart, Ryobi is the cheaper one at $69, at least one on
sale here recently, versus $89 for Hart.
Hart comes with battery, charger, and belt clip, and even comes with a bag.
Ryobi is one of the few that doesn't have any extras, so just the battery and charger
is included.
Ryobi is a little bit lighter at 1233 grams versus 1450 grams for Hart.
I think Ryobi is one of the more comfortable impact drivers, but Hart's actually pretty
nice as well.
I feel like the batteries and chargers for both Hart and Ryobi feel like pretty nice
quality.
Even if the battery for Hart wiggles a little bit when connected, Ryobi has the older design
or style of battery, which allows you to use some of the older Ryobi batteries.
If this is your first Ryobi tool, I'm not sure if that's going to matter.
Both of these come with rapid battery chargers, so you won't have to wait regardless of which
one you go with.
The built-in lights are both at the bottom.
Hart is quite a bit brighter though, as you can see when you put them next to each other.
And it's nice Hart has a bit holder on the back where Ryobi doesn't.
As far as how loud they are, Ryobi is a little bit quieter at 87.6 decibels versus 91.6
for Hart, and that's with no load on both.
Ryobi has up to 1900 inch pounds of torque at up to 3900 IPM, and a max of 3000 RPM
versus 2200 inch pounds of torque for Hart at up to 3900 IPM, and a max of 3000 RPM.
Hart also seems to drive three inch deck screws in faster consistently versus Ryobi.
I'm not sure why, but Ryobi felt a little underpowered compared to most others that
I've tested.
And it doesn't really seem that much lower on paper considering the specs.
Not really sure why that is.
I think Ryobi is actually one of the most comfortable impact drivers I've used.
It's lightweight.
Feels a tad bit underpowered though.
I don't really think you can go wrong with this one because the amount of Ryobi tools
out there.
If you're trying to decide which platform or ecosystem to go with.
But in my testing, Hart feels more powerful.
Has pretty nice build quality.
So pretty close between these two.
But I would give the slight edge to Hart because you can definitely feel the extra power when
using it.
Ryobi, you have been eliminated.
Now when it comes to Craftsman versus Hercules.
The Craftsman is on sale for only $79 versus $97 for Hercules.
Both kits come with a battery, charger, and belt clip.
As far as the weight goes, I really like how compact both of these are.
But Craftsman feels quite a bit lighter at 1256 grams versus 1465 for Hercules.
The Craftsman battery and charger feels more modern versus Hercules.
Hercules just feels like a cheaper build quality.
Nice thing is both of these have rapid chargers which is always nice to have.
Hercules also has a silicone type of material on the bottom of the battery where Craftsman
doesn't.
One advantage with Hercules is you have three different modes depending on how much power
you need where you don't have that with Craftsman.
The Hercules light is quite a bit brighter than Craftsman.
They're both delayed after you let off the trigger.
But Craftsman definitely lasts longer.
Almost too long in my opinion.
Kind of makes me wonder if that's going to cut into your battery life.
Unfortunately neither of these impact drivers have a bit holder.
But they do have a quick change collet where you can easily pop in the bit with one hand
on both.
Slight edge for Craftsman though just pops right out using one hand where you have to
use two hands with Hercules.
It's actually really close on how loud these are at 90.4 decibels for Hercules versus 91.1
decibels for Craftsman.
As far as the power goes, Craftsman has up to 2,100 inch pounds of torque versus 2,200
inch pounds of torque for Hercules.
Up to 3,500 IPM for Craftsman versus 4,400 for Hercules.
Only 2,900 RPM on Craftsman versus 3,600 RPM on Hercules.
So Hercules is more powerful but Craftsman actually feels really nice and lightweight
in the hand.
Hercules can drive three inch deck screws faster, more consistently, but sometimes it's
actually pretty close.
Hercules does feel a little bit heavier, but I think these two are pretty close in power
and features.
I feel like Craftsman is a good option if you just want something that has decent power
and is lightweight, but you've got the brighter light to work with on Hercules, plus the three
different modes or speeds.
If you're wanting to expand your tool collection, Craftsman's gonna win that one.
But just looking at this specific test, I would give the slight edge to Hercules.
Craftsman, you have been eliminated.
Now when it comes to Hart versus Hercules, Hart's a little bit cheaper at $89 normally
versus $97 for Hercules.
Both kits come with battery, charger, and belt clip.
You also get a bag with Hart.
As far as the weight goes, they're actually two of the heavier tools that I've tested.
Hercules is a little bit more compact, but is heavier at 1,465 grams versus 1,450 for
Hart.
I think the Hart battery feels more modern, has better build quality.
It's a little easier to connect and remove versus Hercules.
To me, that's the only thing that feels cheap on the Hercules impact driver is the battery.
Nice thing is both of these have rapid chargers, so you don't have to wait that long to charge
back up.
One advantage with Hercules is you get three different modes or speeds depending on how
much power you want or you don't have that with Hart.
Now when it comes to the lights, it's down at the bottom for Hart.
You've got three up top for Hercules.
These two are definitely some of the best as far as how bright the lights are with Hercules
being a little bit brighter.
They're both delayed after you release the trigger, but Hercules stays on a little bit
longer.
Nice thing is you've got a bit holder on the back for Hart or you don't have that with
Hercules.
You also have a quick change collet where you can easily pop the bit in and out with
one hand on Hart.
The bit just pops right out with Hart, but with Hercules, you do have to use two hands
to release the bit.
As far as how loud they are, it's actually pretty close with Hercules at 90.4 decibels
versus 91.6 decibels for Hart.
Up to 2,200 inch-pounds of torque, Hart has 3,900 IPM versus 4,400 for Hercules, and then
a max of 3,000 RPM for Hart versus 3,600 for Hercules.
Now usually Hercules can drive three-inch deck screws faster, but sometimes Hart actually
wins, so it's actually really close.
Both of these are very close in power and features.
I actually think Hart might be just a tad better build quality, but I think with Hercules
giving you more power plus the three different modes or speeds to choose from gives it the
slight advantage.
If you're wanting to expand your tool collection, you're probably going to want to go with Hart,
at least right now.
I know Hercules has announced they're coming out with quite a few more tools for 2026.
It may just come down to personal preference.
I would say my top three out of testing so far is probably going to be Craftsman, Hart,
and Hercules.
But again, in my testing, when comparing Hart and Hercules, I would have to give the slight
edge to Hercules.
Hart, you have been eliminated.
