The new Roman emperor discovered from a coin - Domitianus

The Roman Legacy - The Strength of Rome Endures.
17 followers
2 Video Views·Jan 11, 2026
This ancient Roman coin hoard was discovered by a metal detectorist called Brian Mallin
in 2003 near Chalgrove, which is about 10 miles from Oxford.
This giant jar contained nearly 5,000 coins, mainly made of copper, but a few silvery copper
coins were mixed in as well.
After painstakingly identifying every single coin, numismatists made an incredible discovery
that no one was expecting.
This coin here is that discovery.
It does look just like every other coin in the hoard.
Copper alloy, quite a crude design of a Roman emperor wearing a sun crown, very typical
of the time.
But his name, Domitianus, doesn't match any emperor of the time.
What was discovered was a brand new Roman emperor.
Hello, my name is Hadley and I'm an archaeologist.
Here is me actually excavating a Roman coin, one of my favourite things to do.
Unfortunately, this coin, like the vast, vast majority of Roman coins you find on archaeological
sites, was a common coin.
Silver coins are rarer than copper coins and gold coins are even rarer than that.
But it's usually quite easy to identify the Roman emperor or member of the imperial family
on the coin.
So when this mysterious coin caught the eye of numismatists, people who study coins, it
must have caused a few butterflies.
To understand why a Roman emperor might have been missed from the annals of history, we
have to understand what was happening in the Roman Empire at that time.
In AD 260, the emperor Valerian was trying to claw back some cities from the resurging
Persians under Shah Shapur.
He didn't do very well and his army was decimated by plague and constant harrying.
Valerian decided to speak to the Shah in person and tried to hash out a peace deal.
He foolishly took only a small retinue with him.
The Shah naturally jumped on this opportunity and seized the Roman emperor and he forced
him to be a slave for the rest of his miserable life, even using the former Roman emperor
as a stool to mount his horse.
The western provinces broke away from central authority.
The eastern provinces were ruled by a provincial queen.
The Persians and the barbarians were knocking on the empire's door.
Not only was this politically disastrous for the central empire, or what was left of it,
but it was humiliating.
These civil wars and external invasions led to the central empire and even the breakaway
provinces running out of gold and silver to pay the soldiers and state officials.
Gold coins were effectively no longer minted and silver coins, which prior to this disaster
had about 50% silver by mass, were progressively debased by adding more and more copper and
other base metals.
By about AD 270, these silver coins only had about 1% silver in them by mass.
That's pathetic.
Anyone who held one of these discs of copper in their hand could plainly see that there
was no silver in this coin.
In response, the mints of the central empire and the breakaway provinces had to mint millions
of the tiny coins to make up for their pitiful value.
People carried around whole sacks of coins to pay for everyday transactions that previously
could have been paid with a single silver coin.
A curious effect of having low value coins circulating is something described as Gresham's
Law.
People started keeping the good old coins with high amounts of silver in them and only
used the bad new coins for transactions.
The good old coins were eventually melted down and the metal was sold for its market
value.
Bad money drives out good money.
This meant by the time that the Trowgrove Hoard was assembled and buried, overwhelmingly
it was made up of the new bad coins that were in circulation, with very few of the older
coins hanging on.
That explains why almost every coin looks identical with only the emperor and the design
on the reverse changing.
The size, shape, material and style remain the same.
That's the context for this coin here and the nearly 5,000 coins from the Hoard.
So where does Domitianus fit into all of this?
Firstly, let's not get confused with the 1st century AD emperor also called Domitianus
Domitian was assassinated in AD 96.
He was beardless and the only coins he authorised with the sun crown were known as dupondii.
These are quite large copper coins that, combined with Gresham's Law, allows us to say with
certainty that Domitian's coins couldn't have ended up in the Trowgrove Hoard.
If we search through the annals of the ancient Roman historians, they do mention a general
by the name of Domitianus active in the Balkans in AD 262 and perhaps the same Domitianus
being recorded as being punished in Rome in AD 271.
But this coin clearly shows a man claiming to be emperor.
If we expand the text around the imperial portrait, it reads Imperator Caesar Domitianus
Pius Felix Augustus.
They're imperial titles.
It translates to the victorious general Caesar Domitianus Augustus, dutiful and fortunate.
It was the done thing for new emperors to adopt the name of Caesar Augustus, the first
emperor who himself adopted the name Caesar from Gaius Julius Caesar.
We don't have any ancient text that can be attributed to the person on this coin with
any degree of certainty.
That tells us something very, very interesting though.
Even very short-lived emperors make it into the Roman annals.
Marius, for example, a soldier who worked his way up to becoming emperor of the Western
provinces in AD 269 lasted a few months at best, yet he's still recorded in the histories
and certainly through his coins.
What probably happened, given the extremely sparse evidence, is that sometime around the
end of the tumultuous reign of Victorinus in AD 271, a commander of a single legion
or multiple legions called Domitianus was proclaimed as emperor by his troops.
He accepted.
I mean, what choice did he have?
He ordered some coins be minted to pay his troops and then was probably assassinated
very soon afterwards.
Rest in peace, usurper emperor Domitianus.
To spice up matters even more, we need to apologise to a French numismatist by the name
François-Maurice Ollotte de Lafoye.
An amazing name for such a dapper looking gentleman.
Back in 1900, well over a hundred years ago, French agricultural workers were doing some
work on a vineyard outside of the city of Nantes.
They found a hoard of nearly 1500 coins, most of which were very similar to the coins in
the jar found at Chalgrove.
One coin stood out to the numismatist who studied the hoard.
This one.
You recognise that face and name?
Yeah, Domitianus.
The coin was declared as the only piece of evidence for an emperor Domitianus in the
late 3rd century.
But many people were unconvinced.
The landowner who legally owned the coin demanded a whopping 8,000 gold francs to the cabinet
which in today's modern money would equate to an eye-watering £245,000.
The cabinet declined this request, but a plaster cast was made for a reference collection,
something that was far more common in the past before photographs became good enough
for examination.
Since the Domitianus coin wasn't in a national or prominent collection, it fell into relative
obscurity.
Loderico La Franchi, an Italian numismatist, declared it a forgery without ever seeing
the coin in person, only referencing the plaster cast.
He claimed that the coin was clearly retooled from a common coin of Tetrarchus.
I mean, they certainly did look similar because they reigned at similar times.
This was a damning conclusion though, and the emperor Domitianus, for the time being,
was no longer an emperor.
But that of course changed with the discovery of the coin hoard in England.
The coins from Chalgrove were literally fused together through hundreds of years of chemical
reaction, meaning that the inclusion of a modern forged coin is simply not possible.
What's more, the Domitianus coin found in France was then re-examined using modern techniques
rather than just looking at the plaster cast.
The legend that contained Domitianus' name was encrusted into the coin itself, meaning
that it couldn't have been retooled in modern times.
Not only do these coins show the same reverse type, but they're an exact die match.
When mint workers made an ancient coin, they engraved two pieces of iron or bronze.
These were known as dies.
The mint workers then placed a puck or disc of metal between these two dies and then bang,
a large hammer struck the top die, imprinting the pattern of both dies onto the coin.
Although die engravers were very talented people, of course, when they made multiple
dies they were slightly different, even when the design itself was meant to be the same.
But numismatists have closely examined both of these coins and have determined that the
dies are identical, meaning they were made from the same batch.
Dies could mint tens of thousands of coins before they degraded beyond use, so it's
very likely that Domitianus had up to 100,000 coins or so minted in his very short reign,
but only two have been identified today.
The implications are huge.
When these generalissimos were declared emperor by their army, one of the first things they
did was to mint coins in their name to manifest their claim to the throne.
Domitianus can't have lasted much more than a month or so, because his reign is only known
from these two coins and no written documents.
Are there any other emperors that are just known from two coins like Domitianus?
Well at least one, and maybe two.
This chap here is called Sylvanicus, and not a single thing is known about him because
not a single word is written about him by the ancient historians.
In 1937 the British Museum bought this coin from a certain Dr Hans Nausbaum, a Swiss dealer
who claimed that it had been found in Lorraine, France.
The numismatist at the British Museum had no doubt about its authenticity.
Judging by the composition, denomination and style of the coin, Sylvanicus was probably
a usurper emperor during the mid 3rd century, possibly during or after the reign of Philip
the Arab, who Sylvanicus looks remarkably alike.
It was quite a common thing to style yourself as the current or previous emperor, to kind
of establish your claim to the throne and add to your legitimacy.
Sylvanicus was welcomed into the ranks of the emperors for certain when this coin was
published in 1996.
This coin was reportedly found near Paris.
Although the obverse, that's the head side, is identical to the obverse on the coin from
Lorraine, the reverse depicts Mars as opposed to Mercury.
Sylvanicus and Domitianus stand as testament to the value in the study of ancient coins.
These little corroded disks of metal are only worth a few pennies in scrap value, but historically,
they bring to life the tumultuous reigns of the usurper emperors, banished from the annals
of history by time.
Before I leave you, I did say one or two emperors, I have to talk about this man here, Spontianus.
Are we looking at a lost emperor or an 18th century fantasy?
Carl Gustav Horaeus, this rather ornate looking Swedish antiquarian, purchased a number of
gold coins for the Habsburgs collection in Vienna in 1713.
These gold Roman coins were supposedly found in Transylvania and among them was a coin
of Spontianus.
Just like Sylvanicus, there is no reference to any man named Spontianus in any position
to become emperor.
But that doesn't mean that someone with his name didn't organise an armed coup against
the sitting emperor of course.
The thing is with this coin though, is that it was universally dismissed as a poor quality
modern forgery when it was brought to the public eye.
This coin is cast in a mould rather than struck.
Official Roman coins and even most ancient forgeries were almost always struck.
The coin is probably a double Horaeus, which are exceptionally rare, but even then it's
slightly too heavy to be a double Horaeus being on no known Roman weight system.
The style of the emperor is completely unknown.
The coins aren't as pure as official or even imitation Roman coins from antiquity.
The obverse legend is totally unique for this coin type, being restricted to the right hand
side.
His name is in the genitive case for some strange reason, whereas the overwhelming majority
of official Roman coins feature the emperor's name in the nominative.
It has been pointed out that this letter I, indicative of the genitive case, could actually
be a casting error from the mould itself.
So this coin was very poorly made either way.
Other coins supposedly found in this Transylvania hoard feature strange legends, wrongly weighted
coins, metal compositions that aren't right and odd looking portraits.
The other coins place the hoard to the middle of the 3rd century AD, around about AD 250
or so.
That being said, the reverse features a design from a Republican coin 400 years before Spontianus
is supposed to have made his claim to the throne.
Suspicious.
This coin certainly isn't minted by an ancient Roman authority backing a usurper called Spontianus,
but there is a 1 in a billion chance that it was an ancient forgery.
That Spontianus put to bed then?
No.
In 2022, a team led by a geologist slash paleoclimatologist analysed the Hunterian Museum's Spontianus
coin.
A few collections in Europe managed to obtain the 4 surviving examples over the years.
The team concluded that the micro abrasions were indicative of ancient circulation of
up to a century.
Moreover, specks of dirt embedded into the surface of the coin clearly showed that the
coins were buried for a number of years, presumably for centuries, and then unearthed in the 1700s.
These incredible findings caught the headlines, just as these things typically do.
Just one major problem though.
These observations do not prove what the authors of the study think they proved.
Every numismatist with an interest in Spontianus shunned the study for neglecting to apply
numismatic analysis, opting instead to make false conclusions with legitimate observations.
This micro abrasion is not necessarily from where.
We have no idea how the coins were kept or handled in the over 300 years since it was
brought out of Transylvania.
The embedded dirt too proved nothing.
Forgers would have been wise to bury their fake coins to add a sense of false authenticity.
What's particularly interesting here is that numismatists from the moment these Spontianus
coins were made public dismissed them as poorly executed modern fakes.
That's still the opinion today, besides a few hardcore believers.
Spontianus for now is an 18th century fantasy, but Domitianus was certainly a usurper emperor
from the western provinces of the Roman Empire in around about AD 271.
Silvanicus, although far less certain than Domitianus, was probably a usurper emperor
from around AD 244 to 249, during or immediately after the reign of Philip the Arab.
Anyway, thank you so much for watching to the end of this video and coming on this numismatic
journey with me.
I do hope you enjoyed it.
Until next time, vale.
