Enduring Mystery Of The Roman Dodecahedrons

The Roman Legacy - The Strength of Rome Endures.
17 followers
Fran Blanche investigates the enduring puzzle of Roman dodecahedrons. The video explores various theories, from games to tools, examining examples and their features. A maker's perspective adds insight into potential functions.
#franlab #secret #mystery
Okay, so here's something I've been wanting to talk about for a while.
It started out with a video that I caught on Joe Scott's channel. He actually did
two videos, but he did a... I didn't see the original one originally, but he did a follow-up
a few months ago that I did see. But this is the original one. These have been found all
across ancient Rome, and nobody knows why. Everybody had one. And it's about these Roman
dodecahedrons. And he did a follow-up video, like I said, a few months ago, where he talked about
all of the things that people had sent to him as suggestions of what those dodecahedrons were.
Like, this is some of them. Some of the dodecahedrons that I found online. There are
dozens of them that... well, hundreds of them have been found. I spent weeks trying to find
examples of ones that have been shown online. Here's another set. Here's some more. And
they come in all kinds of different sizes. The proportions are always the same. It's 12 sides
with six pairs of holes. They're all mostly made out of copper alloy. So some of these look like
they might be iron. Some of them look like they might be even zinc or like a white... kind of a
white metal. And some of them look like that they've actually been painted or gilded, or both,
after the fact. But they come in all kinds of different sizes and designs. But they do have,
you know, some common features. Like, they have the knobs on each corner. So it's dodecahedron
12 sides, six pairs of holes. And all the holes are different sizes. So each pair of holes has
a larger hole and a smaller hole. They range in size from like the size of a squash ball, maybe,
to like bigger than a grapefruit or like a large grapefruit. And it's a big mystery.
Joe Scott, in his video, he basically said, well, there are lots of things that are common
everyday items that, after decades or centuries go by, the usage of the thing gets completely lost.
Because at the time that the thing was made, it was so common and ubiquitous that nobody even
bothered to mention it in writing because everybody knew what it was. There was no reason to say,
this is the thing that does the thing because everybody knows that. So no one bothered to,
you know, write it down or explain what this thing was. It was just something everyone had
and everyone used. And then, you know, when times change, and things fall out of favor,
and people die off and generations go by, it just ends up being something that all of a sudden,
nobody knows what the hell it is. And these Roman dodecahedrons is one of these mysteries.
So I spent weeks thinking about the dodecahedrons and what they could possibly be, what it could
mean. And Joe Scott's suggestions, the people who were putting in their two bits, it was a
combination of, oh, it's a decorative item, it's something for a game, you know, like a die or
that. Maybe it's a functional thing like a candle holder, because some of the dodecahedrons that
were found had residues of wax on them. So I thought, well, maybe it's candle related.
Some people thought maybe it's ceremonial. Many of them are found in burial sites along with
coins and currency. So I thought maybe it had some kind of monetary thing, maybe it's like a weight
or something. Many of them were found either in sites that were former military encampments, or
the burial sites of wealthy women. So these were all the kind of clues of what it could be.
So people had speculations that it was an ornamental thing, or it's like a religious
rite thing, or it's something, or it's part of a game. A woman thought that it was a tool that
was done, a particular kind of weave, to do like tubular weaving, which was an interesting
hypothesis. Another guy thought that maybe it was a sighting tool, you know, you can use the two
differing sized holes to determine distance using a calculation and everything. But I don't think
any of that stuff is true for a number of reasons. I'll show you here. I was trying to get
a dodecahedron myself, because I really wanted to have it in my hand, so I could figure
probably maybe get some more insight if I could play with one for a while. But you can get 3D
printed dodecahedrons, the reproduction ones, they're all over the internet, eBay, Etsy and
stuff. Lots of people are doing resin printed versions of them. But I thought that the only
way that I could understand the dodecahedron is if I had one that was made of copper.
It's listed as copper alloys. I think a lot of them are bronze. Some of them might be a kind of
a tin or maybe a version of a brass type alloy with a little bit of tin or nickel or some other
kind of white metal in with the copper. Some of them look like they might actually be like this
one. This one looks like this is bronze, clearly. And this one is sort of like a more of like a
white metal, maybe a little copper and zinc or something. But you see the the oxide. So these
are my observations. One is that these circular bullseye patterns is a very common decoration.
It's not on all of them, but you can see here this one has the bullseye decorations. This one also
has some of these bullseye with the dot in the middle decorations. And a lot of them have the
concentric circles on the holes. You see these as concentric circle and like these embossed
characteristics. Some of them like this one has some like very clear signs of being struck with
like a blade. Like you see these slice marks here on the left corner, like being hit by something
like hard and sharp, like a like a blade or something. That's one of the things that I
was a clue about how they might have been used. But some of them like this one,
like this one looks like it had been gilded and painted. It's got gold and also red. There's
like this red paint. So it may be possible that some of these or maybe all of them had
the circular sort of decorations, but maybe the ones that don't have them embossed like this
plain gray one. Like maybe this one, it seems like it has no adornment, but maybe it was gilded and
painted and those designs would have been painted on it after the fact. You know, it's hard to know.
But one of the things that's a feature of all these, of course, are the knobs. And what I
noticed about the knobs is the shape is very specific. The smaller the dodecahedron, like
this little one, this one looks like it's actually cast out of iron. That looks like iron. But the
little ones have really, really big knobs, right? Like the ones that are teeny tiny. And the largest
ones, like the grapefruit sized ones, the knobs are much smaller proportionally. And so it seems
that regardless of the size of the dodecahedron, that the knobs seem to be the same size.
And I think that's a clue. Also a clue is the shape of the knob. Because if you look at this one,
the ones in the far end, like on the top and the far, you can see that the knob, it's not like a
ball that's stuck to it. It's like a rounded top and then sort of like a taper to the bottom. And
many of them have that kind of shape. Here's another one. This is another large one. You can
see, look at the ones at the top there, that the knobs, they're sort of, yeah, sort of a, it's like
a mushroom top, like it's a round, like a half round, and then it kind of comes in a cone.
I think that's also a clue. Because the fact that all of the knobs are about the same size, the
really large dodecahedrons have relatively smaller knobs. The teeny tiny ones have really, really
large knobs. So I think it's a part of the function. I'm convinced that the dodecahedrons
are not decorative. I think it is a tool. I think it's a hand tool. It's something made to be
manipulated in one hand, to be held in the hand. The knobs obviously help you manipulate it in the
hand. Because if you put your hand around it, the knobs allow you to rotate it and manipulate it,
use it as a tool, as a hand tool. I think it is a hand tool of some kind.
One of the other things I noticed, at least just for the photos of dodecahedrons that I could find,
is that, you know, they have 12 different holes. And, you know, it's like they all have these kind
of, the ones that are embossed, I'm going to say, the ones that are embossed have these circular
patterns around all of the holes, you know, where you have these circular patterns here on all the
holes. And you see, like, the different hole sizes have different patterns of rings. There's
another one, show one here. But the ones that I could find online that showed most of the sides,
they all had this sort of embossed. And I'm assuming that the ones that don't seem to have
any designs at all might have been, the circular pattern might have been painted on top in a paint.
But what I found is that of the 12 holes, the largest hole, the largest hole in the dodecahedron
is not embellished. The biggest hole, like this one here, it shows, this one shows that the largest
hole, it doesn't have any embossing around the ring. There's no decoration around it. And it
shows a lot of wear, a lot of wear. And that, that I think also is a clue. I think the largest hole,
because it's not decorated, that is either the bottom of the dodecahedron, or it's the output,
it's the output hole. So if the dodecahedron is a tool that's used for sizing, or for tapering,
or for, if it's food-related, like, you know, those that have the, sort of seem to have the
knife dents in them, if it's meant to, to portion off something, like portion off a kind of a food
for a specific kind of a dish, that needed to have, for stylistic reasons, you know, a round
character to it, that you could push, you know, a kind of a food into it, and then cut it off with
the knife, and then, but it would come out the bottom, something that you would do repetitively.
You'd be holding it in the hand, you'd be putting something in there, cutting it off, putting it in,
cutting it off, and it would be dropping out the bottom for a kind of a dish, or a food of some
kind, like it would be a culinary kind of tool, you know. That's one possibility. The other thing
is that because each set of holes has one larger, one smaller, it kind of also is a taper. So the
other possible thing is that those knobs could be for retaining the dodecahedron onto something like
the end of a shaft. So if you have a wooden shaft with a taper on the end, that the dodecahedron
would fit onto that, like if you needed something that would universally fit onto a bunch of
different poles, or if it wasn't like made for one pole, that you had a pole with a taper on,
and then regardless of the size of it, you'd have a set of holes where the taper would work,
and the dodecahedron would sit on, but then a simple leather strap with a slot in it would
snap onto the little knobs and hold it on. Because I thought that a slotted leather strap
would be the obvious interface for these knobs as like a way of retaining the dodecahedron onto
something, something tapered. I also thought for a while that maybe it was a taper, maybe it was
a kind of a tapering tool, because some of them seemed to have like a sharpened edge.
Some of them looked like they definitely have like wear or like denting on the faces,
like it's being pushed into something. And some of them definitely show signs of wear around
some of the larger holes. Yeah, so the actual use of the dodecahedron, it is going to be
a mystery. I don't think it's solvable, because the thing that it was used for doesn't exist
anymore. If it was ritualistic, if it was ornamental, if it was a tool, whatever it
is that it was meant to do are things that we aren't doing anymore. If it is a culinary tool,
then it was used for a kind of food or delicacy that isn't really known anymore, isn't made
anymore. But it certainly has the potential to be all those things. The fact that some of them
had wax residue, I think is a big indicator of the fact that it might have been a hand tool to be
force fit onto something, because wax would have been used as a lubricant. That was one of the
things I thought that it might have been some kind of a taper, something made to shape something
into a rod form, or to smooth out something, some kind of thing. But it's like, what would you
really need a tool like that to taper, that you couldn't make something else? It's such a
complex shape, and such an interesting form. It seems to be designed to be a universal tool
for something that's very difficult to do. Otherwise, you would just have a set of things.
If you have a scale with weights, you have sets of weights, different size weights, and it's a
scale and weights. This is a singular tool that's meant to do something that has a lot of different
functions. It's like a Swiss army knife of mystery, because it does have all these different things.
But that bottom or largest hole, the fact that the largest hole is undecorated, and that they
do seem to have more wear, is an indication, I think, that it is a tool, and that the biggest
hole is the output. So whatever you're forcing into the dodecahedron that you're using as a
tool, you're forcing it into the dodecahedron to size something. It comes out the bottom.
But it's some kind of sizing thing, I think, for sizing something for some purpose. But I don't
think it has anything to do with coins. I don't think it's meant to test anything. I don't feel
that. But the fact that they're made out of metal, you know, bronze, or other copper alloys, or iron,
it's made out of a hard metal. It's meant to be durable. It's meant to resist wear.
So, I mean, if it would have been something ornamental, or something that had more delicate
function, they would have made them out of wood, or ivory, or anything else. But they didn't have
to cast them out of bronze. The fact that they did cast them out of bronze, and iron, and such,
is indicative, again, that it is a tool. It's something that's supposed to be resilient,
and hardy. And, you know, maybe people would take my observations, and maybe run with it,
and come up with maybe really what it did do. But I do think the knobs are a definite key.
I do think that a strap retainer function, that those knobs might be to retain the dodecahedron
onto something with a leather strap, with a slot, that would just snap over the knobs like a bulb.
Like, if you had three straps on three corners, to hold it onto a post, or something to be used,
you know. Even if it was a decorative, that you stick it on something, like a handle of some kind,
like a universal tool to go on a universal handle. The handle just have to have a taper,
and you figure it will go on one way. But the fact that the largest hole is undecorated,
that seems to be the biggest indication that it's actually something to size. It's something
made to size something. You're going to be pushing something through a hole, sizing it.
It's going to be coming out the biggest hole, which is the bottom hole. So, this particular
dodecahedron, whoa, yeah that one, that particular one, that would be upside down in my definition
then. That that largest hole would be the bottom, and that all the other sides, the other 11 sides,
those would be the ones that you're going to be using. Yeah, still a mystery, but that's my take
on it. I don't know if my observations have any merit. I don't know. It is a complete mystery,
but string netting, well, that was one of the things that was explored. The woman who was a
knitter found a knitting pattern that could be used with that, but I think it's too complex
and too expensive an item to be made to do something so simple as a knitting pattern.
I think if you were going to make a tool specifically to do a pattern, I would design
it differently. So, the only reason I'm convinced that this is a hand tool is because I've made a
lot of tools in my life, and as a person who's made a lot of tools, it just really smacks of
of a single-hand tool to me. It's not that it's impossible that it could be like a knitting guide,
or that it could be some kind of a sighting tool. It's not impossible, certainly, but I think it's
it would be really an over-designed, over-built thing to do any of those very specialized tasks,
because if I were going to make a tool for any one of those things, I wouldn't make a dodecahedron
like that. I would make something that's much easier to reproduce and much more specific to
that task. This doesn't seem to be like ideally made for any of those explanations. It's clearly
made for something that we haven't thought of, which is why I kind of keep leaning back to the
idea of a culinary tool, because foods, especially foods like pastas and others that we take for
granted, that require tools to make, you know, a food can be very specific and very cherished,
even sacred. And so, you know, when you have a food that's beloved, and it's got to be a certain
thing, like let's say you've got a food that has to have, you know, balls in it of a certain size,
and they have to be just the right size, or the right shape, or they've all got to be the right
shape, and people complain if they're all lumpy, or if they're too big or too small,
that something like that, that you could see making a tool to consistently make a food,
so that everything is exactly the same size, even if it's like a portioning dough, that, you know,
you wanted it to be a certain size, and then so you have to have them all be the same size,
and you roll them into balls or something, or make them into shapes, that it would have some kind of
a culinary application that was very valued, and like people would complain if it wasn't just so
at the time, and then it just moved on, and people don't even make that food anymore, and
then no one remembers what the hell those things were for. I mean, that's sort of what Joe Scott
was saying in his video about the three condiment jars, that were a big, and back in the 19th
century, that these assortments of shakers would come in threes, not twos, because today we have
salt and pepper, and in the 19th century, these antique sets always had three shakers, and the
debate was, what was the third thing? Because nobody knew. But yeah, it could be food-related,
which would explain why it's found in military barracks and in the graves of wealthy women,
because maybe it's made for a specific kind of food that people who had military rank would want,
or people who were in aristocracy would want. But it could be something as silly as that,
as something that a status food that you had to have, and you had to have a dodecahedron to make
the food just right, to have it sized just right, or mix it up just right. I also thought that it
might have been used in pitting, because some of the holes are very small, and I thought, well,
maybe it was used to pit olives, or peaches, or plums, or some kind of a pitted fruit that you
would have the hole, and you could actually just... Like if you were making preserves,
or making jams, or like a fruit jam or something, like peach preserves, that you needed to get the
pits out of thousands of peaches, that you would have to spin it around to find the right hole for
whatever the size of the pit is, and then you could just kind of rapid-fire pit a fruit,
or pit olives, or core a fruit or something. But for making something that would be mashed,
like a marmalade or something like that, it could very well have a universal food preparation
application. It could. But the idea, like I said, just perhaps a measuring gauge for something,
Joe Scott and other people kind of poo-pooed that, because it doesn't have any like embossed
markings. It has symbols, and it has like designs embossed in it, but nothing like a Roman numeral
of a number that would show that this is the size for this thing. So as a gauge, it wouldn't work,
because there's nothing universal in any of them for sizing. They're all kind of just made just so.
So there's a standard that they could be measured to, and because there's no numerical designations,
which they obviously could have done if it was going to be a gauge like a weight, because they
had weights for scales, and if you have a weight for a scale, it's going to be stamped with a
number or a symbol or something like that to let you know what the size or the weight is.
And there's none of that on the dodecahedrons. That's one of the things that adds to the mystery,
which is why I don't think it is a gauge. I do think it's a tool. I think it's a hand tool
to be used in one hand, but that's about as far as I could get about what it is. Exactly what it's
used for is still being mysterious. The knobs though, the knobs are a clue. I think that the
knobs could be part of a retaining system with a leather strap. It could be part of a used as
taper, because I said each pair of holes has a larger hole and a smaller hole, which represents
a taper. So it could have some kind of tapering function. But, you know, I keep coming, the more
I think about it, I keep coming back to something food related, just because it's made out of
fronds, because of those, you know, the wear and tear on some of them around the apertures,
where it seems like it might be used with a knife, like a knife might be up against the surface or
something. So, but yeah, or, but I think it might have some kind of food function. That's, that's
kind of where I keep parking it. Every time I go around the block thinking about it, it comes back
to, it's got to have, it's some kind of culinary tool, you know. Total mystery, you know. I wanted
to, like I said, I wanted to get one made out of bronze or brass. I wanted a metal one, because I
only, if I had one that had the proper weight, could I really understand what it could do.
And if I had a metal one that I could maybe experiment with it to see, you know, if any of
these things really would work. But a 3D printed one, it wouldn't have the right weight, it wouldn't
have the right rigidity, it wouldn't have the right strength. So I really wouldn't have the
ability to, to really, you know, think about, you know, what, what it could possibly be.
But maybe you can figure it out, you know. The mystery of the Roman dodecahedrons.
You figure it out. Go berserk. That's what you're watching. Friend, that's what I'm doing.
