Why I Embrace Tradition(al Martial Arts)

Martial arts originated from Japan
137 followers
I have many criticisms of traditional martial arts. My previous video, which I will link at
the end of this one, was all about a problem that probably bothers me the most about the
traditional martial arts space. But at the end of the day, all my primary styles are traditional
in nature. Despite my critiques, which come from a place of love, mind you, I still choose to invest
a majority of my time into traditional martial arts systems. Why?
Before I dive headlong into that question, I want to point out something that has
really been concerning me for a while in online martial arts spaces.
It seems like everything outside of a person's experience is somehow a cult these days.
I was recently watching an Instagram reel in which a BJJ practitioner, I believe,
was rattling off so-called red flags for gyms. Among them were any type of bowing,
teacher-student hierarchy, turning away from others to fix your gi, and the use of foreign
terminology. In many of these cases, this individual went a step farther even and said
that these were indicators of not only a bad gym, but of a cult.
Now, in my view, we have as a society sort of ruined the word cult. It is today taken to be
something explicitly negative when it was once much more academic and neutral. Basically,
every religion is a cult. That doesn't mean they are all evil. Cult is the root of the word
culture, which is neither a holy good or bad thing unto itself, much like religion. Ironically,
though, what the individual in the reel was doing was acting out the very behavior he claimed to
be fighting. His stance was essentially, any gym that does anything different than mine is a cult
and no one should attend them, which is actually very cultish behavior in the same way we would
that term today. Here's the thing. I actually really appreciate all the bowing and rules
around fixing your gi and things like that in traditional martial arts. And no, it doesn't
actually have much to do with my appreciation for Japanese culture either. A bow takes time
and conscious effort. It's a gesture not only of respect but of mutual awareness. If you are
conscientious enough to bow to your partner, you are conscientious enough to be extra careful not
to harm him in practice. And I know some people might say, well, we fist bump, but that's a little
different. That's more of a gesture of friendliness or of let's just start. It also doesn't take much
time. I'm not necessarily saying you must bow to one another, but I do think you should at least
be shaking hands. Because again, it takes time. You must be conscientious of one another. And in
that vein, if you are conscientious about properly turning away and fixing your gi in class so your
partner doesn't have to watch you do it, then you are typically conscientious enough to keep the
damn thing clean and free of your stench. A student-teacher hierarchy, while of course could
be abused, is still crucial for class structure, flow, and crucially, safety. Even the usage of
foreign terminology is a quiet suggestion that participating in a martial art is also going to
be about learning things cerebrally as much as physically. But I think the key thing I really
like about everything I just mentioned is that it hammers home that training isn't about you.
And in fact, training a martial art really cannot be about you. You need a teacher. You need
training partners. Their health and engagement are necessary to your own skill development. In fact,
the better your peers do in a given room, the better you will do. Even the bowing to a dead
on the wall isn't really about reverence for said dead guy. More often than not, as it's been taught
to be many times over, it's about being thankful that people have been considerate enough for
generations so that you get the opportunity to practice at all today. Because it's not a given
that you would have that opportunity. Not all systems survive to current date.
As viewers of my channel surely know, I have been quite critical of the character of certain
founders. Nor do I see founders as the pinnacle of skill. But I still bow because it's not about me
and my opinions. I'll let you in on a little secret too. I bow to teachers that are still
very much alive that I really don't like or even have much respect for. Why? Because life is filled
with instances in which humility towards other people is necessary. Even people you don't like
or you disagree with. You will one day likely have a boss that you don't very much care for.
You're still going to have to show up if you want to get paid. And it's going to only make
your life easier if your relationship with that person is at least cordial.
If I'm right about these teachers that I don't like so much, they will one day be forgotten
because they've contributed very little to our collective Marshall Project. I don't need to do
anything to tear them down. I don't need to beat them up. I don't need to embarrass them.
I don't need to argue with them. They're doing that plenty well on their own. Instead,
showing deference and being dignified is a training opportunity for me unto itself.
And plus, I don't know these people's whole story. They may have reasons for acting the way they do,
even if I don't necessarily agree with those reasons. You have to try and understand people
on their own terms. Again, it's not about you. It's not about me.
I've really come to just openly detest the model now popular in the US in which people claim,
I'm the customer, and then go on to state their expectations for martial arts training.
To a point, yes, you should get what you're paying for. And I'm totally okay with people
quitting my institution to go find what it is they want to invest in. That's just
how free markets work. Go for it. I'm not against that. This isn't a cult, like I said before.
However, I've worked in dojos before, and I have to say that most consumers are
very clearly irrational and extremely under-researched. Most traditional martial
arts put strong emphasis on attitudes, etiquette, and personal growth. In my experience,
these things are plastered all over marketing material almost excessively. I've had to give
a speech many a time for new people coming in to try out training about what we value
and what we put emphasis on. Yet, these things almost often just get ignored and like,
okay, but how do you punch good? People will come in and complain that, as the customer,
they're not paying for all this etiquette ----. But yes, you are. It's on the marketing material.
I just explained it to you the other day. It's never been a secret.
In the same vein, a lot of so-called modern martial arts schools I've been to are
essentially frat boy sandboxes, quite frankly. Not all of them, but many. I've been in rooms
where the mats are gross, geese stink of sweat and weed, and there is no discernible authority
figure in the room. I once visited a gym in which I saw a white belt get his ankle broken
and he was told to walk it off, bro. This is a combat sport, after all.
That is probably the most egregious example I've ever personally witnessed,
but I've seen a lot of similar stuff go on in MMA and boxing gyms. Sparring partners clearly don't
care about the other person. They just see them like another piece of gym equipment there for
the sake of their own personal growth. They have no sense of mutual development, no sense of
institutional or sport health, and no real camaraderie, which is kind of sad.
I think what so many young combat sport enthusiasts fail to recognize, and indeed what so many
keyboard warrior types fail to appreciate, is that the martial arts industry is largely sustained on
children and their middle-aged parents. I shouldn't need to outright say this,
but I will for the people in the back. Most people do not want to brawl for their lives
in class. Most people want to move around, be part of a community, learn something new,
do cool things, and maybe learn a little bit of fighting. In fact, in all of my experience,
while notions of fighting or self-defense do tend to be the thing that get people in the door,
those motivations almost immediately begin to wane as students integrate into the training space.
They are replaced by other factors very, very quickly. Yes, the interest will remain,
but it isn't typically what's going to sustain a student roster. This is why the whole,
well I could beat you up, argument against traditional martial arts has always struck me
wildly tone-deaf and almost antisocial. Do you really think that Barb, 42-year-old soccer mom
of three elementary school children, cares about her fighting ability? More than likely,
she joined because her kids loved being there, and she loved her kids being there because
they were unwittingly learning important skills like patience, respect, and the ability to follow
instructions well. Now, all of this is not the only reason why I stay in the traditional martial
arts. I admit that what I'm about to go into is certainly much more tangible in places like Japan,
but tradition is genuinely such an anchoring thing. I've been to many of the places that
various martial arts began, for example. I've walked the same paths that people doing roughly
similar things to me now walked over a century ago. It doesn't mean I always agree with them,
or even like those people, but I can see the continuity. Nor does any of that, by the way,
make me a better fighter, but it does texture my training, it enriches it, it gives me a sense of
place. And it's that shared experience that enables communities to have high trust.
Many of my friends in Japan come from Aikido, for example. Our friendships began long before
I could communicate well in the local language, and arguably, I still can't communicate super
well in the local language. We simply knew that we shared similar values by our mere presence
on the mat space. To finish this video, I want to make very clear that martial arts do not
make better people. There are plenty of pricks in martial arts, and even in traditional martial
arts, but I think it is a mistake to lay the blame on the martial arts themselves for this.
The reality is that martial arts have made me a better person, but I think it's because,
for most of my life, barring my teenage years when I was rebellious and stupid,
I've really believed in their power to make me a better person. What I find almost universally
in people who are not improved by their training as a person is that they are almost singularly
focused on themselves and the combat outcomes of their training. Now, this does not mean a
combat sport athlete who is very competitive is necessarily going to be a jerk. That is not what
I'm saying. My point is that for a martial art to make you into a better person, you have to be
open to those lessons. If you're seeing your training only as a transaction and only for
the purpose of competition or fighting or whatever else, then no, it's unlikely that
such training is going to make you into a better person. But, I'm just seeing more and more these
days that the internet is pushing for this super-sanitized, commodified version of martial
arts, all while, in the same breath, demonizing everything traditional. And frankly, I just don't
get it. I can't even empathize with it or sympathize with it. I wouldn't be in Japan
today without embracing traditional martial arts. I wouldn't speak the languages that I speak. I
wouldn't be married to the person I'm married to. I would be far less traveled than I am. I
wouldn't have the job I do. This YouTube channel would not exist, and you would not be watching
right now. While it might be an overstatement to trace literally everything back to starting
traditional Japanese martial arts for me, what I can say with absolute confidence is this.
I would not be me without traditional martial arts. Much of my value system,
my personality, and my current lifestyle is just inextricably linked to traditional systems of
training. Whether or not I can fight good is kind of immaterial in the face of all that,
from where I sit. This video is not to demonize the combat sport enthusiast.
If you enjoy competition and want a very sanitized, transactional customer experience,
then by all means, have at it. I'm not trying to argue that no one should want that type of
experience. But what I am arguing is that traditional martial arts and the things they
purport to emphasize when committed to seriously and professionally are not inferior. They just
have different goals. Again, much of my life is a direct result of traditional martial arts.
If you've ever looked at some of my posts of traveling and thought,
man, I kind of wish I could do things like that, it's thanks to traditional martial arts that I
can do things like that. All I'm saying is that traditional systems have plenty to offer people.
Most of the time, they aren't cults and aren't any more likely to be cults than
modern martial arts gyms, at least in my experience. But they do tend to emphasize
different things outside of fighting good. It's not even a secret, and most pure traditionalists
aren't really going to be out here looking to transition into MMA. In fact, most of the
traditional guys that I know and who I respect their skill outright refuse to engage with online
martial arts discourse because they see it as a waste of time. To them, it seems everyone has
already decided on their tribe, and engagement is sort of pointless. The time for negotiation
is already over. They're on a team. And so a lot of really good traditional martial artists
aren't online. They aren't posting anything. Not on YouTube. Not on Instagram. Nowhere.
They just operate their businesses by word of mouth. The reason I stick with my online presence
is mostly because I think we owe it to people to keep the narrative balanced and transparent.
In an era of clips, hot takes, and, I'll be honest, poor yet somehow viral communicators,
I think we need more people clearly discussing the rhetoric behind traditional systems.
And beyond that, in a world of low attention spans, instant gratification, and a growing epidemic of
isolation, I really don't think tradition is such a bad thing, especially if everything I just
described is what modern progress actually looks like. Again, I'm not trying to detract from
MMA, BJJ, wrestling, Muay Thai, boxing, and so much more. There are things on offer in those
spaces. But also, you cannot punch your loneliness and a lack of connection away. You can't make a
shot attention span or an overemphasis on the self tap out. When traditional martial arts are taught
well and correctly, I do think they are better equipped to answer these sorts of problems.
So, if you want to fight and be a champion, probably something like boxing or MMA is going
to be more your speed. But if you're looking for place and for purpose, a traditional martial art
can be an awfully good start. Anyway, I'll leave it at that for today. Thank you all so much for
listening, and I will catch you all in the next one. Peace.
