How to Do Research

Global Affairs Academy
6 followers
Jan 7, 2026
Bismillahirrahmanirrahim. Welcome to our session on how to do research. My name is Zubair Abbasi and
I'll be leading this session today. Before we start, I just want you to think about this picture.
Just take a few minutes and think who, according to your view, is the most important person in
this picture. So this is the picture that will be coming back at the end of this session and
we'll explore this question further. Now, when we talk about research, an important aspect of
research is asking about research questions. And the main point that I want to emphasize today is
that a good research is basically asking good research questions. And then, from then on,
going step by step and exploring different sources by adopting different methodologies.
So, first of all, what is important for you is to find your niche, your area, your genre.
We live in a world where there is lots of information. It's really easy for us to get distracted
or to get lost in different fields. So one phenomenon, one particular area could be
discussed from several different perspectives. So when you're embarking on your research,
first of all, try to situate yourself. So what is the area you want to explore? In law, you can
explore a particular field, a particular research question, a particular area, a particular
phenomenon from so many different perspectives. So not to speak about other disciplines such as
anthropology or sociology or political science, even within law, a particular phenomenon could
be explored from different perspectives. It could be from private law perspective, from public law
perspective. It could be from property law perspective. I'll be giving you more examples
later. It's really important for you to situate yourself. And this is really a hard question
because the material that you're reading is cross-cutting and there is lots of emphasis
on interdisciplinary. But it's really important when you're doing your research, try to
situate yourself in a particular field, in a particular area. And once you have it,
then the next step is to find out what are the expectations of the field. So when you want to
master, it has particular standards, criteria for assessing you. Generally in research,
there are three main expectations from research scholars. First and foremost,
your research must be original. It must not be copy-pasted. It's really tempting
that your research end up becoming a compilation. So John said this, Hart said this, and William
said this. And what do you think? Oh, I am just a humble student. This is not how PhD research is
done. So there must be originality in your work. And then there must be critical engagement.
So I'm not arguing that you should not quote anyone and all your thesis should be written
in one person. I saw this, I say this, I argue this. But the point is that whichever view you
take, you critically evaluate it, engage with it. Maybe Hart was a great scholar,
but your research must be original. Whatever view you quote, whatever scholar you rely upon,
whatever fact you mentioned in your research, it must be critically evaluated by you and assessed.
I'll say more about evaluation analysis and critical engagement in a bit. And the third
most important, that there must be academic rigor. So your research is complete, thorough,
exhaustive. So whatever area you have chosen, you have looked into it thoroughly. You have not left
any important scholar, any important book or article or source unexplored. And after you
have this, then you refine your research question. So it's very tempting that you accept
the existing framework. It's very tempting. And in human nature, we are very good imitators.
We like to copy. And you see when you read wonderful research, wonderful articles,
you want to really quote them, want to embellish your research with them.
Important point here is that you must question the question, question the framing. So that's
the next step. You don't take things for granted. So whatever statement is there in your research
article, in your PhD thesis, it must have been critically evaluated and it must have gone through
your reflection. You have thought about it. No matter how great a scholar is, that person might
have some things untouched, something unexplored. Or maybe you can bring a different perspective.
So all these Western scholars whose books we read, they don't know our context. Our context
is different. So we can always try to come up with a different view, with a different perspective
based on our own context. Now, before going further, I must emphasize here that research
is not a very clean process. It's not that you start with a question, then you refine your
research question, and then you question the framework. It's a very messy process. So there is
no step-by-step process. Each person, each research topic will have its own process.
So start from wherever you want to. Maybe start by reading an article or maybe a judgment,
maybe a statute, maybe a newspaper article. You might have come across a documentary,
maybe a film made you interested into it. Start from it and then what you need to do is that
you have fulfilled the conditions or the elements of research, no matter where you start from.
So what are the basic elements of research? So based on my experience as a student,
a doctoral candidate, then a supervisor and then examiner of a PhD and master's theses,
I can tell you that any examiner would be looking for four things in your thesis.
First and foremost, what is your research question? So what is your working hypothesis?
What is the main point that you want to raise in your research? And second,
what are the sources that you have used in order to explore to find answer to your question? And
while finding answer to your question, what methodology have you used to find your answer?
And finally, and perhaps most importantly, what is your finding? So you raised a question,
you read lots of books, you adopted quantitative or qualitative methodology or mixed methods,
and then you came up with some findings. So these are the four basic elements of research that would
be required from a PhD thesis. Now, it's really important that you master the art of framing
questions, or maybe give it some consideration. And it's not that you start with a very nice,
very clear question. You may reformulate it, change it, adopt it, or may ultimately leave
the question which you have started with. My own research had started with, I wanted to explore
the history of corporations. So how modern corporations came about, and then end up
writing a thesis about OKA, about what completely disconnected. So whatever the research I have
been doing during my first year did not form part of my final thesis, because it was a process.
So I would urge you to appreciate that research is a process, and you have to go through it.
And it's during the process that you will learn. It's like a proverbial, that alchemist, right?
So maybe you will find your treasure where you're sleeping, but you'll have to go through,
you have to take the journey. And during that journey, you will have new experiences,
you'll meet new people, you'll develop new insight, and then you'll reach where you have started.
And it's the journey, it's the process, and the insights that you gain during that process,
that is what matters. Maybe the end product that you have produced, it's something which
you already had in your mind. It may not be very revolutionary, but by taking this journey,
you will develop certain skills, and that will be acquired during that process.
Now, here are some examples of questions and their reframing. So often we say,
what can we do about it? Yeah, so we have lots of economic problems in Pakistan,
what should we do about it? The better question is, how do we understand it?
Once we understand it, then the process of solving it will become easier. So most of
our problems you'll see, whether in our personal life or in our collective life,
culminate from a situation where we don't understand. We have seen people just become
raged, they just lose themselves. It's because they can't make sense of it.
But once you understand things, then you are able to control them,
or maybe engage with them effectively. So the question is not, what do we do about it?
You may ask, how do we understand this? And then you provide a solution to it.
How do we make law effective? So this is a question that has been raised time and again.
Oh, in Pakistan, we have good laws, but they are not enforced. If only these laws would be
enforced, our society will become Riyasat-e-Madina, right? It's not a very effective way of raising
a good question. A good question would be, what functions law play in the society? And why law
is not effective? It's a deeper question. It will give you deeper insights. And then
asking the question, does the law fulfil its objectives? A better question would be,
what kind of relations law creates? What kind of power structures law builds into the society?
Then it will give you a better understanding of the workings of the legal system.
I'll concretise these questions in my later slide. Now, after you have your questions,
then you have to think about your methodology. So you have a question, and now how do you go about
finding answer to it? So generally, either quantitative, qualitative, or mixed methods,
you can adopt based on your research. Most of the time, but most of us do, we read texts.
So our research does not start either from going to collect, do interviews, or maybe do surveys,
or maybe do participation observation, or maybe do focus group. Our research starts from
reading texts. So that's why before going further, I'll be talking about how to read texts also.
But before I go into the methodology, let me also talk about sources. You have research
questions, you have methodology now, where will you find your answers from? And generally,
you have primary sources, or you have secondary sources, or you can go and generate your own
data. Maybe collect case law judgments. Maybe what I have done during the past years,
I was working on divorce law. So I collected all the reported judgments on dissolution of marriage
from 1947 to 2017. So I had a rich data of 70 years, and then I could see trends. So whether
courts were more lenient in granting divorce, how our law transformed over the period of time,
from fault-based first into hula-based. And then there were so many other sub-questions or
sub-themes that I could explore. When courts grant dissolution of marriage, if there are children,
are courts more inclined towards making sure that there is a reconciliation, just for the
sake of children? So what are the circumstances? What kind of people, what are the backgrounds of
the people who are getting their marriages dissolved? What are the trends of judges?
So which judges have delivered landmark judgments? So all these sub-questions,
they were just based on my primary data. Then I could read secondary literature. I could read
articles and books, and there I could explore what are the research questions. So one of the
research questions in a secondary literature was that our superior courts are pro-women.
They give judgments which protect women and children. But lower court judges, they are very
conservative-minded. Even when the higher court precedents are there, it takes a long time for it
to trickle down to lower judiciary. And then there was a book written by my colleague, Dr. Azeem,
about the judiciary and the class structure in the judiciary. So the judges of the superior courts,
higher court, and in Supreme Court, they come from a particular class. And judges for the lower
court, they come from a different class. And then based on my own research on legal history,
I could relate that during the colonial period, the lower court judges were primarily Indians,
and the superior court judges were British. So independence has happened, a lot has happened,
but those structures have remained. So I had this data in front of me,
then I can relate it with history, I can relate it with sociology. So that's the example of
matching your primary data with your secondary data. Or you can just go and collect your own
data. So what I did for my research on Hula, I interviewed and surveyed a thousand people,
250 lawyers, 250 judges, 250 muftis, and 250 litigants. So it just gave me a big chunk of data
to look into that we have law that has been transformed and see what is the perception of
people about this law. What do women think? Do they really get this right? Is it easier for them?
What do ulama think? So muftis. What do judges think? What do lawyers think?
So this is how different types of primary, secondary, and data collection and data
generation mechanisms I have experienced with. Now, you may ask that where to start from.
There is no particular method that, oh, whether you should start with primary data or secondary
data. All your research basically goes into circles. From a newspaper, you may come across
a reference to a case law. From a case law, you may learn about a statute. From a statute,
you may learn about an official report, maybe just like the Family Reform Law Commission that
was formed in 1956 on the basis of which MFLO was formulated. Now, it may be the secondary
literature that may take you to primary literature. So there is no kind of a fit or a fixed
criteria that where you have to go from. It's an iterative process. Based on my own experience,
I would urge you to go hand in hand because when you're just dealing with primary data,
it could be very frustrating. It could be very hard. A few summers I have spent in reading
judgments of Federal Sheriff's Court and Sheriff's Appeal at Bench, and it was like hell. Really
long judgments. I had no idea where I'm going. So I was just reading judgments. There were facts,
there were procedural history, there was a lot going on. It was not making much sense to me.
And ideally, I think it should have been great if I should have been reading
Martin Louw's book, Kennedy's articles, and those judgments side by side. Then I should know that
what's happening, what scholars are picking up from these judgments. And then I could also focus
on those specific questions. Now, here is a tip for you. Whenever you're reading, ask yourself
why you are reading. And take notes. Mark whatever you are reading. Most of the time now,
I think we are prone to reading online, and there are lots of distractions. It's very easy to get
distracted just to check Facebook for two minutes, and you end up spending one hour.
So it has become really, really difficult for you to focus, to read even for 20 minutes.
And if you want to read a book, it's just like a mammoth task. But one thing that will make it
easier, that will keep you focused if you know what you are looking for. Then it may even make
a very boring book very interesting for you because you know why you are reading it. I'll
say more about different types of texts that you will be reading. Now, it's really important for
you to know how to read a text. First and foremost, is it worth reading it? Not every book,
not every article requires to be read in total. So in your research, you'll be skimming, you'll
be just taking information in bits and pieces from different articles and different books.
Now, how to read a research paper? First of all, read the abstract, then go through its headings
and see if it relates to your area. If it's something that interests you,
that you may use for your research, then go through, skim through it, its headings.
If it's really interesting, read introduction and conclusion. It will give you the main idea
and then go through the whole article. So skimming, first of all, do your inspection
and same is the case with a book. Go through the blog of the book, maybe read about the article,
about the author of the book, read the introduction and conclusion. If it's a well-written book,
it will give you the main idea. Then go through the relevant chapters and I must say that there
would be most of the books that you don't need to read from cover to cover. But there would be
some books that you may have to read multiple times. I have some books, they are so fundamental
to my research that I just call them my Bible. I'm doing research on judicial Islamization in
Pakistan. Martin Lau's book is my Bible. I have read it, I don't know how many times,
discussed it with him, came across some errors, some typos, some miscitations and told Martin
and had a good laugh about it. Same, I have read Clark Lombardi's book on state law as Islamic law
because it relates to the same process but in Egypt. And there is another recently published
book, it was published last month by Michelle Scott, recasting Islamic law about Islamic
constitutionalism in Egypt. It's freely available online, beautifully written. So one of the key
tricks or the tip for writing good PhD thesis or writing a good research article is to read
good research articles and good books. In your area, there would be at least 3-4 books that you
must have read it and absorbed it. And you may have to go back to them time and again. So some
books would be key to you and then there would be other books which you just need to skin through.
And after you have chosen your key texts, now you have to do analytical readings. Now if an article
relates to your area, you're not simply supposed to read all the articles which have been referred
in that article. This is how you do analytical study, analytical reading. Read the article,
what's the argument, how the author has come about this argument, what are the sources
the author is relying upon. Then look into those sources. Ideally, I can only read one article in
a day. I can't read more than that. But by reading, I mean I read the whole article, the resources the
article mentions and sometimes those new resources may lead you to other sources. So research
sometimes is just like a detective. So you have to detect from one source to another source to
another source and then you just reach to the actual secret that you have been looking to
to unearth or explore. And the third technique which is really important, it is you compare,
contrast and evaluate. All right, so this is what Martin has said. But David Kennedy or Charles
Kennedy has a different view. Matthew Nelson has a different view. Clark Lombardi has written about
Islamization in Pakistan, has an entirely different view. So now how many views I have?
I have Martin Lau, I have Kennedy, I have Matthew Nelson and I have Clark Lombardi.
There are some similarities but then there are differences also. So instead of just simply
quoting them and say, hey, I have done my research, I can add a fifth view, that is my view.
And what is my view? It may not be original. I may say that look, Martin says that judicial
Islamization was good for human rights in Pakistan. Clark Lombardi also says this.
But Matthew Nelson and Charles Kennedy have a different view. I compare and contrast them
and then I say, well, look, Martin's view seems more accurate or maybe based on my data.
So this is actually I have done a few years back, I have published an article on Qazilbash Waqf case.
So this is how I formulate it. So my formulation was that Martin Lau and Kennedy are of the view
that judiciary enhanced its authority based on judicial Islamization of laws. Now they can refer
to article to a objectives resolution and can come up with any argument. But Matthew Nelson
and Konrad, a German professor, argue that no, it's not the judiciary, rather it's the legislature
which has the impetus or is the focus point for Islamization. So and then I applied those
theses to Qazilbash Waqf case and Syed Kamal Shah case and other cases also discussed
and reached the conclusion that actually it's Martin Lau whose view is more appropriate,
better explain the situation. So you first of all do an inspection. If it's worth reading,
go read it thoroughly and then compare and contrast it with other scholars and their views.
Now that was about textual research, what we call desk-based research. So most of you,
I guess, would be doing this. But I think it would be interesting or maybe it would be useful for you
if you want to do qualitative research, you want to go into the field and want to talk to people.
So I just want to run you through some information about interviews. So interview is a process,
you just go and you talk to people, you want to get some information about their views, about facts,
or maybe about their emotions, how they feel about it. You may or may not formally incorporate
interviews in your research, but I would really urge you that whatever area you're doing your
research, go and talk to people. I've got wonderful insights by simply taxi drivers or maybe
rickshaw drivers. They just ask me,
So talk to people, even if you may not incorporate that in your research. And then if you decide to
include interviews in your research, there could be different types of it. It could be conversational,
just I have had with the rickshaw driver. It could be structured. So you just go, you have a
questionnaire and you ask them. Or it could be semi-structured. You can have some closed-ended
questions and some open-ended questions. When you're doing your interviews, take into account
these points. Structure may not give you freedom. You have to think about it. If you have set
questions, it may not give you more insights. While I was talking to people in family courts
in Lahore, there were so many surprises. I was really surprised that the most enlightened
answers were coming from the villagers. I was talking to a guy,
I said, Oh my God, I was just expecting that this is a guy, a farmer from very far off area,
who does not seem to be schooled. I had such enlightened views as against that
very well-educated lawyers, their views were so regressive. So when you go into actual field,
you may have very surprises, so many surprises. As they say that sometimes fact is stranger than
fiction. And then sequencing and framing of your questions, how you would bridge the topics,
do you want to maintain your interview with the natural flow? You have to formulate your
question. Do you want to do improvisation? Uniqueness of your question, narrow or broad
scope. If you do plan to conduct interviews, I would urge you to just read a book at least,
or at least listen to some lecture, or read an article on how to do an interview. That will
save you from so many problems afterwards. So based on my research, what I had got that we were
filling in surveys, we had several questions. Not all the questions were filled in properly.
Now, if all the questions are not properly answered, then it just becomes redundant for
I have to do quantitative analysis also. So if you do decide conducting of interviews,
please go with some preparation. Or maybe just test it. First of all, maybe test run
on a small group. And if it really seems to be working, then properly design it,
work on it, and then go with full preparation. After interviewing, this is ethnographic research,
sociologists and anthropologists do it. But actually, this is not very kind of as complicated
as the name actually sounds. So ethnographic research, Ibn Battuta, Marco Polo, they were
ethnographical. So what ethnographic research means that you just go and live and get
internal perspective. So you're already part of a society where you're living, you do observations.
And then there are different techniques of ethnographic. So it could be peers,
it could be a participant observer. I went to family courts, sat into the courtrooms
and observe what's going on. So you try to provide an internal perspective. Now,
when you do qualitative research, or I think research generally, three processes you have to
bear in mind. So one process is you're describing what's going on, what's the state of the law. And
at the same time, you're also interpreting it. You're interpreting your primary and then
secondary data. So no matter what Martin Lau or maybe Matthew Nelson or maybe Dr. Muhammad Amin
or Rabia Mehdi have written about Islamization in Pakistan. So I have to interpret them,
their views, their arguments, and then analyze them. Same applies to secondary literature.
You might have conducted your interviews. You might have collected your judgments.
You have to describe them, interpret them, and then analyze them. Now, before we stop,
I want to draw your attention towards research ethics. If you do decide to engage with human
participants, get informed consent. In most of the universities, there are institutional review
boards. You would require written permission from your review board if you want to do primary
research which involves human beings. If you want to do interviews, you'll require permission from
your IRB. And make sure that you take into account the privacy of your participants.
That's really important. And first and foremost principle of doing research is do no harm.
And there must not be any exploitation that you just pay, try to ask, to get information
from them by simply exploiting them, either financially or maybe offering them job
incentives or maybe legal advice or whatever. It's not ethical. And it may
have adverse consequences for future research. If people are afraid of interviewers,
if they become afraid of researchers or university students, it will have harmful
effect on future research. Now, this is the last thing I wanted to say to you.
And now we proceed to Q&A. And now we'll open the floor for questions and answers.
So, if you have any questions, you feel free to ask.
Yes, Asif.
I'm good. How are you, Asif?
I'm fine, sir. Sir, I was wondering that what is the subtle difference between
doctrinal research and qualitative research?
Okay. I must caution you that don't go for the labels, right? Sometimes label don't
give you anything. So, an actual phenomena is much more complex. We just know that everything
is connected to the other. Even within our research, we just say there is constitutional
law, then there is, you know, at the lower end family law. But if you see that,
they're intricately connected. So, lots of constitutional principles, they're applied
in family law. I mean, you know that 99% of reported cases are in the writ jurisdiction
of high courts, of family law. There you go. You say, no, I will only look at the family,
I don't have anything to do with the constitution. So, there are court processes,
you have revision, remand, right? There are appeal processes, right? So, all of that
law as a whole, as a system, as a holistic system, it operates. And in research, you have to show
universe in the sand, right? If you take a small piece of data, the arguments you are
building will be universal. You asked what is the difference between doctrinal and qualitative.
So, basically, at a very general level, theoretical research is just that you are
just dealing with ideas. But now, I want to pose this question to you. Can you think of
an idea which is not related to a fact, right? Unless they are metaphysical questions.
Metaphysical questions, right? But law, specifically, is all about facts.
There is lots of, I know, in Pakistan, there is a lot of emphasis on doctrinal because it is
easy to do. You don't have to do anything else. You can sit in your office or library and say,
I am doing doctrinal research. Doctrinal research does not mean that you will not engage in facts.
If you are doing legal philosophy, right? So, this is what people do.
But the rigor required in that is by no means less than the one that is required for
doing actual work, where you go and collect data. You talk to people.
I just know,
but you have to do it.
I mean, just going to the courts, right?
Time-consuming, right? But it's worth doing it, right? Honestly.
It would be great.
Go and talk to people.
Go and explore them.
Okay, so that you have to just come up, right?
Talk to people.
Or there is lots of debate. Yes, Daniel, do you have more questions?
Thank you very much. We have another question from Shaji, please.
Another question.
Yeah.
Shaji is serving as a senior civil judge. So, he's also PhD candidate here.
Oh, great. Very nice. Very nice to have you with us.
I'm sorry.
You're just doing wonderful work.
We'll have a more interactive session.
Okay.
So, basically, it's just about forming up of questions.
And then, sir, you're very much trained. Like, I have always learned from the judges, right?
Actual research. You are actual researchers. We are fake researchers, right?
So, your thesis is just like your judgment, right? It's a crude analogy.
So, it's a wonderful, I think it's this wonderful topic.
Maybe we should have one-to-one session on it. You can get my details from Daniel.
Thank you very much, sir. Thank you very much.
We have another question. Hopefully, the last question.
Sir, my question is being a student of PhD, sir. I'm a practicing advocate, sir.
When I'm reading some article, especially written by some expert and some PhD doctors,
how should I frame my mind to keep things in my mind? And especially with critical approach,
sir. I mean, what should be the frame of a student by reading an article of a scholar
with critical approach?
Thank you very much. This is very, very important question. First of all, I would tell everyone,
have confidence, right? Don't you just think that, oh, I'm just a humble student.
Hey, does not matter.
High level, that is not required. As long as your concepts are clear.
We keep on learning for all of our life.
But you should know,
then you can get back to it.
If I'm just reading any book, say for instance,
chapter content.
Okay. So, so this is how. And then,
you can go back to it, right? It's not like, as I told you, that you have to read the text
bars again and again, okay? It's not like you read it once and that's it, now I have
read it and that is it, no. There would be some texts you have to go again and again,
you have to go and make reference to it, okay? So, more important, have confidence, take
notes and then later, compare and contrast, okay? There is a scholar, if his student
can criticize him, then why can't we do it? Why can't you do it? Bring a different perspective
too, okay? Okay, Hart and Dworkin and, okay, Vaiz, etc. were very great scholars, were
great professors in Oxford, okay? But they didn't know about Bakhriya or Multan, right?
The law, our interaction with the police and the court, the context is different, right?
I can say, okay, according to Hart, law is a combination of primary and secondary rules,
okay? But if I am an ordinary person, for me, law is probably the police, right? The
police officer, okay, who slaps, so, for me, law is basically force. I don't know what
is written in the constitution, that there is dignity and equality and due process,
okay? For me, the police officer is law. Forget about what is happening in big politics,
that what is the role of the army in politics, okay? And what is the role of politicians?
At a lower level, for me, you know, maybe the landlord of the area, okay? He is law
for me, right? So, those perspectives could be brought in, okay?
Daniyal, I just finally need five more minutes just to go back to the question and that will
help us summarise it, okay? Okay. So, I showed you this picture. Now, tell me, who is the
most important person in your opinion in this picture? Daniyal, can you please let me know
what people are talking about? What do you think is the most person in this picture?
Majority of them are raw baby. Spot on. Fantastic. I also like this cute baby, okay? So, I think
your intuition is absolutely correct. But the question that who is the most important
person in this picture, it depends on which perspective you are taking, okay? In some
people's perspective, the judge is the most important. The one who has to decide that
who will get custody of this baby. According to some people, basically, the parents are
important. In the issue of custody, the baby has a right. So, basically, baby is an object
on which mother and father are fighting. So, maybe these are the mother and father.
And perhaps, I'll ask you to think about, the question that you have to ask after framing,
maybe the person who took this picture is the most important. Without him, this picture
would not have come to us. And you are seeing this, I think a journalist has taken this
picture in secret because cameras are not allowed in the court, right? So, maybe it's
the person who, photographer, is perhaps the most important person, right? This is a loaded
question. So, the purpose of this whole exercise was just to recap whatever we have been discussing
that different perspectives, different framing of the questions is really important. And
this is an iterative process, okay? Convoluted process. The research is not very clear. It
is very muddy. You just start and then you have to go back. You make different drafts
and then you have to just restart it, okay? It is not a very simple process. First, the
research is a complicated process. And in that, there is its fun. In that, there is
its learning. And that is your basic objective, okay? So, basically, the take-home point from
this is that doing research is a process. You have to master this process. And there
is no clear answer how to do it. You have to learn it by doing it. So, with this, I
would end this session. Thank you very much for your invitation. And I look forward to
interacting with you in future. Thank you, sir. Thank you very much. Thank you for joining
us. It was really great. Students, I hope all of them, they learned quite a good deal
of research methodology. And thank you. You're welcome.
