You Carry Ancient DNA: Here’s What It Reveals About You

Relic Archives
18 followers
13 Video Views·Jan 4, 2026
I totally thought this was a joke.
You thought it was a joke?
I'm of course from Sweden, so I know many people in Sweden, so there was someone speaking
Swedish calling me, claiming that it was from the Nobel Committee.
And I sort of, yeah, yeah, sure, tell me more, tell me more.
And like after 30 seconds it started sounding too serious, so I sort of realized this may
not be a joke.
I'm Insoo Hyun, Director of the Center for Life Sciences at the Museum of Science.
Today, my guest is Svante Paabo, the founding director of the Max Planck Institute for Evolutionary
Anthropology in Leipzig, Germany.
He won the Nobel Prize in 2022 for his work in ancient genetics, which includes sequencing
the Neanderthal genome and discovering a whole new group of ancient humans called the Denisovans.
Svante, it's so great to have you here on our program.
Thank you so much for joining us.
I'm very happy to be here.
You know, you and I met a while ago in 2017.
It was at a conference at Cold Spring Harbor, where I know you've been there many, many
times.
It was a brain organoid conference, and you gave the scientific keynote, and I gave the
ethics keynote.
And that was the first time I actually heard you in person speak about your work so eloquently.
And I remember going back to my room at Cold Spring Harbor and just staring out the window,
just thinking about what you said about human migration and the mixing of human with early
human hominins.
And it was one of those moments where I thought, I didn't really appreciate, or it didn't sink
in until then, how significant your work is in how we think about ourselves and how we
think about human life.
So I'd love to just get into a conversation with you about your key discoveries, your
key work.
In 1997, you and others sequenced the mitochondrial DNA of Neanderthals.
And then in 2010, you led a team that sequenced the entire nuclear DNA, the nuclear genome
of Neanderthals.
And it was also in that year that you announced the discovery of another group of ancient
humans called the Denisovans.
And so what I heard from your talk in Cold Spring Harbor and ever since then was the
fact that there's been a lot of mixing between humans, what we call humans today, modern
humans, and these earlier groups, and that we can trace that DNA even today in people's
DNA samples.
What does that tell us about how human beings developed?
I think the simplistic picture that a lot of kids get in school is that if they do teach
evolution at all, it's about a very smooth, singular progression from a single common
ancestor.
And that's how we got to who we are today.
But it's much more complex than that, right?
So in terms of the origin of the direct ancestors of everyone alive today, what we call modern
humans, that sort of ancestral populations was probably also a group of populations where
this transformation to modern humans happened in Africa.
But at that time, one was not alone on the planet.
Of course, there were many other forms of humans around.
And that is actually typical, I think, of human evolution, that there was almost always
different forms of humans around.
And these modern humans, like 200,000, 300,000 years ago, spread across Africa and spread
out of Africa and met these other groups.
And what we then found out when we studied the genome of our closest evolutionary relatives
and Neanderthals is that one mixed with each other when one met and actually had babies.
And those babies were successful enough to be incorporated in the modern human societies
and in turn have babies such that for everyone whose genetic roots are outside Africa today,
carry one or 2% of their DNA comes from Neanderthals.
So many of us today sort of Neanderthals live on a little bit in us, so to say.
Yeah, you've written once, I thought it was so beautiful.
You said, Neanderthals are not completely extinct.
Their DNA, some of their DNA still lives within us.
I thought that was wonderful.
Yes, because sort of each of us carry different fragments of the Neanderthal genome across
our genome.
So if we sort of jump from person to person, we can see how much can we puzzle together
of the Neanderthal genome in people today.
And the jury's a bit out on that still, but at least 60%, say, of the Neanderthal genome
is still walking around on two legs, so to say, today.
So they are not totally extinct.
They sort of live on in many of us still.
That's wonderful.
So it's not just the Neanderthals.
There are the Denisovans.
It looks like maybe the Denisovans and the Neanderthals also mixed.
And then human, maybe the Denisovan DNA is also found in humans, especially kind of in
southern Asia.
Yes, actually all over Asia and sort of Asian mainland, there is a small contribution from
Denisovans, less than a percent, less than half a percent.
But it's more varied than the Neanderthal contribution.
So say in Oceania, there's up to five, six percent of the DNA of people there come from
Denisovans.
Wow, that's amazing.
So let me get this right.
So the picture is that modern humans are migrating out of Africa, and as they're migrating out,
they encounter Neanderthals kind of in the European sort of zone.
And then furthermore, as you're going toward the east, toward Asia, then that's where the
Denisovans were, and there's mixing there.
You imagine kind of a migration out of Africa and then encountering these other populations
and coexisting with them.
Yes, so that's a big picture.
We're in the process of sort of learning more about the details of this, how this happened.
Find, for example, that the very earliest modern humans that come to Europe, sort of
40,000, 45,000 years ago, seem to, at least some of those groups, mixed a lot with Neanderthals.
So we find that almost everyone, there's a site in Bulgaria, for example, where we have
three individuals from around 45,000 years ago, modern humans, and they all have Neanderthals
in their family history in the last five, six, seven generations.
But those very early modern humans that came hardly contributed anything to people today.
So it's sort of later then where it comes to other modern humans that replace all these
other forms, which eventually then leads to that the last 30,000, 40,000 years of our
history is actually unique in that there's only one form of humans around on the planet.
We are alone, if you like, for the almost first time in our history.
People are not aware that Neanderthals were on Earth maybe four times longer than modern
humans.
They've been around for a very long time.
They didn't leave much behind.
So the key here then is to work with ancient DNA, is to work with DNA that's very, very
old, maybe preserved in some non-ideal conditions, right?
So we have ancient DNA you can find in amber.
We have ancient DNA that's coming out from the permafrost, as multi-permafrost kind of
reveals more and more full specimens, like saber-toothed tiger cubs, things like that.
And then in your case, ancient bone that's found in caves.
So the process of extracting DNA from very old specimens, that was something you were
very interested in when you were much younger.
You were interested in eutectology.
You were interested in mummies.
You had this idea of maybe the possibility of extracting DNA and analyzing DNA from mummies,
which sounds like it would just be almost impossible.
So I heard a story, I read a story where you practiced by purchasing a little bit of liver
from the supermarket near the lab when you were a student and taking it back to the lab
and trying to use that to maybe come up with a way to extract DNA from something that's
dried and preserved.
So tell me a little bit about that liver experience.
Well, I had studied eutectology actually at the university before I studied medicine
and molecular biology.
So I knew there were these thousands and tens of thousands of mummies of animals and humans
in museum collections from Egypt around.
So it was a rather obvious thing to say, could we apply these new techniques of retrieving
and cloning DNA to these remains?
Most people thought that DNA was a very unstable molecule that would very rapidly after death
be degraded.
So that liver experiment was really to take a liver from a calf and dry it in some way
sort of imitate mummification in ancient Egypt to see if any DNA survived.
And there were sort of tweaks to that.
It smelled pretty bad in the lab when I did it, but it turned out that yes, DNA was preserved.
It was degraded to shorter fragments, but it was indeed preserved, which encouraged
me to go on and try with mummies that are 2,000, 3,000 years old from Egypt.
And then I actually retrieved some DNA from that.
In hindsight, over the years, it had become pretty clear that that first DNA was for sure
contaminations of present-day people, from myself or museum curator or who it could have been.
Right, yeah, I'd love to get into the idea of contamination, how prevalent that is in
just a moment.
But what was striking to me when I was reading your work about the mummies was when you were
working with the mummy samples, you wrote that it smells like warm baking bread as you
were working with the samples.
Why did it give off the smell of warm baking bread?
Well, so sort of mummies tend to be brownish in color, right, the tissues in the skin.
And a part of that is from a chemical reaction between sugars and proteins and other things
called the Maillard reaction.
That is actually the same reaction as when you bake bread and it becomes brown.
So sort of cross-links between molecules and this sort of smell then can come, you can
even feel it when you sort of say drill in the mummy or something gets warm.
So you went from terrible smelling dry liver to like a nice bakery smell.
I'm sure you prefer the latter.
So going back to contamination, what was so fascinating is the enormous puzzle, the
difficulty of separating out contaminating DNA from the DNA you want to study in the
sample.
So sometimes dust lands on the sample.
Dust is often just dry skin.
So you have human DNA sort of like snowflakes kind of cascading down.
You have people who handle the specimen, human beings who handle it.
Some curators seem to even like lick the bone to see, I don't know exactly why they're
licking the bone, but he gets a life on there too.
So there's so many other challenges.
What other kinds of contaminants are present?
How else might the sample be contaminated with other DNA?
Well, so what one came to realize then over the first sort of decade in the way of working
with this was that ancient DNA is sometimes preserved, but it's degraded to short fragments.
And the vast majority of the DNA in old specimens and bones are from microorganisms that have
colonized the bone, say when it was in the ground for tens of thousands of years.
And then what is even more, if you study human remains, what's particularly serious is, as
you say, contamination of present-day human DNA.
That can come, yes, from dust particles or chemicals you buy have tiny amounts of human
DNA.
Oh, the people who work in the factory that create the chemicals.
Yes, yes.
Right.
So that is sort of a big, big issue that you have to deal with.
We learned, though, with time, that there are chemical modifications that accumulate
in DNA over thousands of years when it's preserved.
And those modifications you can use as a sort of tag to say, this molecule that have these
errors in them when I sequence them are actually old.
So it's sort of, there are ways around this.
So today, I think one can work pretty confidently and realize when you have preserved genuine,
authentic, ancient DNA or not in a specimen.
Yeah.
So the Neanderthal specimens are so small.
There are not very many of them.
So you don't want to waste the resources by practicing on them.
So it seems like you and your team practice, quote unquote, on cave bear specimens and
other bone fragments from the ancient past.
Is that reasonable to say that you're not only trying to learn more about the cave bear,
but that also helped refine the protocol that you would then use on the Neanderthal specimens?
I mean, much of this was and is about improving the techniques.
And then working on animals is actually a lot easier than human remains.
Because as you say, if you extract DNA from a cave bear and get sequences that are bear-like,
but not identical to a present-day bear, you're pretty sure you have the right thing.
Whereas humans are much more difficult, actually, because it can often be difficult to distinguish
a genuine DNA sequence from one that is from a present-day person.
Yeah, I want to ask you next about the caves in which these specimens were found.
But before that, something else that was very striking from your book was that,
and this was actually quite chilling for me to read, that it seems like the Neanderthals
were cannibals.
Because it seems like some of the specimens were the byproducts of butchering and eating
one another.
And in fact, because it was the byproduct of that food process, it seems to preserve
better the DNA, because you maybe stripped away the flesh, and it dried quicker than
just a decomposing body would.
So that was fascinating, because on the one hand, it sounds quite chilling, but that also
enabled the research, made the research easier, because the specimens were easier to work
with and to extract DNA.
Is that correct?
Yes.
I mean, there are Neanderthal burials where you find the intact skeleton, but there are
also many, many sites where the bones are crushed, as you say, and say bones that have
bone marrow in them are crushed to get to the bone marrow and so on.
We, of course, don't know why they did this.
It could even be that you wanted to eat your relatives to incorporate them in you, or it
could be that you treated them more like meat.
But the result of that was that bones were in small fragments and probably lying around
on the surface, and as you say, drying out fast, which limits the amount of microorganisms
that will live in them compared to when you bury a body in the ground.
So obviously, these are specimens discovered in caves, and it looks then like these caves
were populated by living Neanderthals, early humans.
Do you have a sense of just how long they may have been living in these caves?
Was it multi-generations?
Was it thousands of years?
I'm trying to get a picture of the cave and sort of that being sort of the Neanderthal
equivalent of a city or a small town, and that's where life happened.
Does it seem like that they lived in caves for that long?
Well, talking to archaeologists to excavate these sites, I think there are both things
that happened.
There are sites that I think are more seasonal dwellings, perhaps, that they followed animals
and lived in certain periods there.
And there are others that seem to have been much more continuous habitation, and many
of these caves are excellent places to live.
So there are Neanderthals that lived there, and modern humans, and even people in medieval
times have lived in them.
And we do find sort of family groups.
We do find parents, offspring, for example, suggesting that one had lived for a longer
time at the site.
Yeah.
I would imagine there could be a little bit of a tension between some of the paleontologists
and others who excavate the sites with whom you would have to do some coordination with,
because you depend on the samples to do the genetic analysis.
And typically, the paleontologists may have a different view of whether it's migration
or kind of like multiple emergence of these early humans.
And so there may be a little conflict, I would imagine, between kind of the way in which
they envisioned the past and what you're uncovering with the genetic research.
Is there, in your view, a little bit of a tension of, on one hand, you need to sort
of depend on them for the samples, but on the other hand, your discoveries could be
a little bit disruptive of the paradigms?
I don't know.
I mean, it is certainly an intimate collaboration.
We rely on working together with paleontologists and archaeologists to get the samples.
And then what we study is, of course, the genetic history of humans, right?
And there are sort of other things that we can't approach, sort of the cultural history,
what technology did one use?
Was that transferred between groups?
What did one hunt, et cetera?
So I think one complements each other much, much more than that there is any kind of conflict.
There have, of course, been different theories in the past about the origin of modern humans
with a sort of strict out-of-Africa idea, where modern humans come out of Africa and
replace everyone else without any mixture, to other extreme views where one says
modern human groups, continental groups, go back millions of years, essentially independently
of each other.
And of course, the genetic history turns out to be somewhere in between, right?
Yes, the big picture is we come out of Africa, but there is also contribution locally from
these earlier groups that existed.
There are some people who think that by genealogy, do you imagine the family tree,
relatives in the past that then reproduce and produce particular genomes, and so your entire
genome has a genealogy.
Something that you've written about that I thought was very fascinating was actually
each chromosome in your genome may have its separate genealogy, and each region of the
chromosome may have its own genealogy.
So in light of that, saying that we have a little bit of Neanderthal DNA or Denisovan DNA
makes more sense in that reframing of what we mean by genealogy.
Could you speak a little bit more to that?
Yes, of course.
The case that sort of in each generation, our chromosomes are broken up by recombination.
So if I pass on one of my chromosomes, it's not an exact copy of my chromosome, it sort
of have parts of the two chromosomes I have inherited from my parents.
And this means that each region of the chromosome has its own history.
So for example, if you just walk along a chromosome, in one part of it, say I may be closer
to Neanderthal than you are, and then a bit further down the chromosome, you are closer
to the Neanderthal than what I am, and so on.
So we are a sort of mosaic of different genetic histories, if you like, our genomes.
So what we talk about when we say, say the chimpanzee are our closest evolutionary living
relative, and gorillas are a bit further away, is sort of the average across these histories.
But it's still true that sort of for 20-30% of my genome, I'm closer to a gorilla.
But for the majority of it, I'm closer to a chimpanzee.
So that is sort of something we shouldn't lose track of.
But it is sort of a mosaic of different histories.
That's fascinating, right.
So people may be tempted to think about your DNA as almost like an analog thing, but it's
really kind of digital, that these little components that are being swapped out.
So I want to ask some more about the Denisovans, but let me just stay on the Neanderthals a
little bit longer.
So Neanderthals have been around for quite a while.
What do we know and what do we not know about them?
So it sounds like, and this is obviously other areas of research outside of your area, but
we have this picture of Neanderthals as being very simple, kind of crude, brutish, right,
maybe very powerful.
There's this whole kind of cultural ethos around it.
Where did that come from?
Where did we get that idea about the Neanderthals?
I don't really know.
I think it's more historians of science that really study that.
I mean, yes, it is sort of a tendency to regard sort of present-day humans and maybe Europeans
when one discovered Neanderthals as sort of the crown of human evolution and everything
else as somehow brutish, inferior.
Of course, in some sense, one could say Neanderthals were more successful than we are,
because they survived much longer than we have so far, at least, when we don't know
what the future holds.
But it's also true, for example, that what came with modern humans, like time is a very
rapid cultural evolution, much, much more rapid than what the Neanderthals ever did.
And that modern humans did a lot of things that other forms of humans did not do.
I often am struck by the fact that over just 50,000 years, humans crossed water where you
don't see land on the other side, and that's not a few times.
They came to every little island in the Pacific, something that these other forms never did,
for example.
That probably has to do with technology, but it also has to do with some kind of an attitude
to life and your environment that's different.
So you're saying that when modern humans came to a large body of water, they were curious,
it seems, to want to know what was on the other side, and they would cross that, but
the Neanderthals would stop.
They wouldn't cross.
Yes.
So sometimes I say modern humans are sort of crazy, and Neanderthals were not.
I mean, you have to be crazy, I think, to sail out on the Pacific Ocean not knowing
if anything is out there.
And we don't seem to be able to stop.
Now we have to go to Mars, and no one can really explain to me why, but you have to
do it.
There's no stopping.
So there wouldn't be Neanderthal astronauts.
Do you think they had any kind of culture?
Absolutely, yes.
How would you describe that?
Oh, I'm not an expert on this.
They clearly had typical stone tools that you produce, that you find, et cetera.
They had no fire, et cetera, hunting cooperatively, et cetera.
Right.
I think there was a paper published a few months ago that suggested that there were
some arrowheads that were found that were produced about 80,000 years ago in a region
of Uzbekistan that was heavily populated at that time by Neanderthals.
And they're surmising whether those could possibly have been created by Neanderthals.
So the tips were too small to do anything other than to be on the end of some kind of
projectile shaft, suggesting an arrow.
And so it just left the researchers scratching their heads.
Well, the timelines don't match up about who was in that area.
And when they date these what look like arrowheads, it looks like, are they Neanderthal
arrowheads?
So that really got me fascinated about maybe Neanderthals are a little bit more
clever than we give them credit for.
And one had these spears in Europe that are 400,000 years old that are very sophisticated
spears.
They dated these as 80,000 years old when it was published in PLOS ONE.
Yeah, yeah.
That is interesting if that holds up because often we think that sort of bow and arrow
comes with modern humans.
Right, right.
So let me ask you about the Denise events.
As you were getting ready to publish the whole genome sequence in 2010, somebody called
you and said, we have this finger bone, a little tiny bit of a finger.
And I think it was one of your colleagues that discovered that the mitochondrial DNA
of that was neither human nor Neanderthal.
Well, we had actually sequenced the mitochondrial DNA of that, yes.
Yeah, yeah, yes, yes.
And that turned out to be quite different, yes, being outside Neanderthals and modern
humans.
Yeah, yeah.
So let's speak a little bit about mitochondrial DNA sequencing that versus nuclear DNA.
So mitochondria are the powerhouses of the human cell.
They're inherited from the maternal line from mothers.
It's passed on, and the egg, the sperm doesn't really have that.
That moves on to the babies.
So you can sort of, you can trace maternal lineage and maybe migration that way.
Your first work was the mitochondrial Neanderthal genome.
So that was what was sequenced.
And then what you really were interested in is, could we possibly sequence the nuclear
genome of the Denisovans?
So tell me about that work, and was that difficult to do, to move to that?
Yeah, I mean, the mitochondria has the advantage that there are many, many copies per cell,
just sort of easier to retrieve from badly degraded small amounts of DNA.
But as you say, it sort of represents just one side of history, the female side, and
it's also one unit.
So it isn't this mosaic where you have an average of many histories.
So there's a lot of stochasticity of just chance that comes into play there.
So that's why sort of the mitochondria, yes, it's interesting, but it's really not the
full story of the genetic history of the group.
So the Denisovans are a great example of that.
So when we sequenced the mitochondrial genome first, we thought we had something like homoerectus
or so, because the common ancestor with the mitochondria went back like a million years,
very deep, whereas present-day human mitochondria and Neanderthal mitochondria go back half
a million years or so.
So we thought it was something outside.
And then when we got the nuclear genome, we realized that actually the Denisovans are
the sister group of Neanderthals, and modern humans are outside of them.
That is sort of the true story of what has happened.
Do we have an idea of what they look like?
I think recently they've been uncovering skulls.
Yes, very recently.
There is a skull from Harbin in China where one was able to retrieve mitochondrial DNA
and show that it is Denisovan.
And they have very big teeth and are quite robust.
And there are actually a number of other sites in China that have things that look
morphologically related to this.
So Denisovans are clearly sort of widespread in Asia.
Yeah, so the samples you worked with for the Denisovan DNA, it was the finger bone, very,
very small fragment of what's thought to be a child, a female child's finger bone,
pinky, tip of the pinky, and then another Denisovan's molar.
And the molar tooth you wrote looked like it was like 50% bigger than your molar.
So you mentioned large teeth.
That's a large tooth.
So I want to ask you about the mixing of both modern human and Neanderthal and also the
Denisovan.
And by the way, let me ask you, I mean, we, in everyday life, use the word human to refer
to us, what we call modern humans.
But in your line of work, you also call Neanderthals humans, right, and Denisovans humans.
Can you tell me a little bit about how you use some of these terms?
Because I think it's a little bit more, it's not quite what everyday people think of when
they think of the word human.
Well, so, I mean, there's always this discussion, what were the Neanderthals and Denisovans?
Were they another species or what?
And I think, in some sense, I say that's a sort of very academic discussion that only
some professors are interested in, really.
If we describe that, yes, Neanderthals and modern humans met, were mixed with each other,
and some of these children were successful and contributed to people today, that is an
interesting story.
And I would clearly call them human since this happened.
So, we tend to say it was another form of human or another group of human or something
like that.
I'm fascinated by that.
I know that you seem not to be that interested in was it mainly Neanderthal men mating with
human women or the other way around.
I think some people are quite fascinated with that question, because I might say something
about sort of the social interaction of the two groups, but clearly, I'm raising it for
the following reason.
If at that time, as in many parts of the world today, women, females are responsible for
raising the offspring, then if it was a Neanderthal man mating with a modern human woman, then
that child would have been raised in a human community.
I think that's fascinating as opposed to maybe the other way around.
So, I think personally, you may not be so interested.
You're more interested in the fact that the mixing happened, but whether it was mainly
male to female or female to male, I think for some people, when they try to imagine
the social life of that mixing could be significant.
I agree that if we can find out about socially how this happened, that would be fascinating.
I mean, it's clearly not just one way, I think.
It could have been preferentially one way.
But there's no way for us of telling.
So, I mean, as an attempt to become what I call paleo-fantasy, where we project our
sort of ideas back into the past, and it says more about ourselves and our proclivities
than what's really happened.
It's people writing Savanti-Papal fan fiction about what's happening at that time.
Right.
Well, so if they are getting together, then were they sharing ideas?
How are they able to communicate with one another?
These are all questions that I think are interesting.
I mean, there are evidence from archaeology that Neanderthals seem to have picked up some
modern human technology in these transitional industries.
For Chateau Perron in France, for example, and there are several other such industries.
I do think there were also cultural interactions.
And we will probably learn more about that over the next few years.
Because there's also this cool development where one is able to now often retrieve DNA
from archaeological sediments.
So that one is not just limited to finding bones.
That's right.
So you could go sort of through the different layers where you find stone tools, for example,
and see what humans, whether it's Neanderthals or modern humans that did it.
And then much better associate ancient industries with what groups made them.
Yeah.
And I think the sort of direction is going in the direction that, yes, one did exchange
sort of cultural things also.
And that Neanderthals were probably involved in doing some modern human technology.
Yeah, that makes a lot of sense.
I mean, it's almost like doing forensics, like what we do today on crime scenes, and
try to collect DNA from just the environment, because we're constantly shedding DNA into
the environment.
So tell me, you've been to Denisova Cave.
Tell me, what is that like?
I mean, so it must be a limestone cave, and that's favorable?
Yes.
It's sort of, it's a limestone cave.
And that is very favorable for preservation, because it makes the pH neutral or slightly
basic.
What's really bad for the preservation of DNA is acidic conditions, because it sort
of degrades the DNA.
So in fact, almost all caves where one has successfully retrieved DNA are limestone caves.
And it's a fascinating site.
It's a sort of three chambers, and the main chamber is really high, and has a crack up
in the ceilings.
It's sort of like almost a bit like a church.
So the light comes down in a big shaft of light.
And it's fascinating to realize that Neanderthals have lived there, Denisovans have lived there,
modern humans have lived there at this place.
So there must be so much to uncover in that site.
Yes.
And I mean, it's been excavated every year.
There's work going on there from the Russian archaeologists.
Wow.
So this reminds me then of your early interest in just Egyptology and just other artifacts.
I heard one time that when you were a child, you found a large shattered pot, a very old
pot in some site.
And you were able to actually piece it back together into something quite large.
And that's just a beautiful metaphor for me about just the work you've also done with
DNA and being able to reconstruct it.
I mean, tell me, so what was this pot and tell me about where you found it.
I think that it's sort of like many kids that was fascinated by sort of archaeology and
finding old things.
And my mom was very supportive of that.
So one thing in Sweden that was, there's often sort of storms in the fall, the trees fall
over.
So you have these roots that sort of can sort of get out sort of lots of the soil.
It brings up the past.
Yes.
So she would drive me to places where we would chance to find something.
And at one place, I found a pot from the Stone Age.
They're like 4,000, 4,200 years old.
And lots of these little sherds.
And one could actually fit them together to quite a big piece of a pot, which was absolutely
fascinating to me.
And sometimes you can even see imprint of fingers.
Oh, wow.
That must have been so exciting.
But I just thought that's just a wonderful metaphor, just kind of, again, that mindset
of going back and retrieving items from the past and piecing together the history and
finding kind of the DNA fingerprint of the life that was around what you're looking at.
I mean, you're not only just looking at physical specimens, but you're looking at
something about people who existed, who were living in Denisova Cave.
So I just, when I heard this, I just thought it was just so wonderful.
There are people who think it's quite something that, you know, your discovery that we have,
like the Neanderthal DNA lives among us today.
And I think you've got some, like, contacts and people saying things like, oh, you know,
here's a picture of my husband, and I think he must be part Neanderthal.
And lots of people, like, kind of, in a way, kind of proud that they may have Neanderthal.
I mean, tell me about that experience of people reaching out to you and saying,
and like offering pictures and other stories.
I mean, it sort of was very early on, it started back in 2010,
when we published this mixing that started getting letters and emails from people
claiming that they know people who are Neanderthals.
And there's this interesting pattern that sort of,
there are quite a lot of women who write that their men are Neanderthals,
and there's almost no men who claim their wives are Neanderthals,
which also says something about how we think about Neanderthals,
and that it can almost, for men, be sort of a positive trait
to be Neanderthal in our imagination, and not so much for women.
Yeah, I told my kickboxing coach one time, he's a very big, you know, man from Hungary,
and I said, yeah, did you know that you may have some Neanderthal DNA?
He was very happy to hear that, you know, yeah, well, that must make me a good fighter.
So let me ask you then, for the Denisovans,
there's been some really rapid research on sort of the DNA found in existing people,
and there may be some health implications of that, also for the Neanderthals.
So there was a paper that was published recently,
which suggests that about 33% of Mexicans have this gene
that is associated with Denisovans, and could be protective against infection.
And so maybe as humans were migrating into South America,
that was competitively advantageous somehow for their survival.
So can you speak more to other findings we're seeing about, you know,
presence of ancient DNA in humans, and how that might have some health effects on people today?
Yes, I think one is learning more and more of that.
There is both that there are genetic variants that one already knew about since decades
that are medically important that turn out to come from Neanderthals or from Denisovans.
So there are sort of a variant that you test clinically if you give blood thinners to people,
if you have an artificial heart valve, for example, because with those variants,
you have to give lower doses of your blood thinner, so you don't have serious bleeding.
And that variant that is a higher risk for bleeding comes from Neanderthals, for example.
And then it's sort of also that one discovers now that things can become important that come
from Neanderthals. And the most striking example to me was in the COVID pandemic,
where there were risk factors that we all know about, old age, male sex, and so on.
But there were also genetic risk factors. And there's one factor on chromosome three
that doubles or triples your risk of becoming severely ill or even dying when you're infected
with the SARS-CoV-2 virus. And that risk variant comes from Neanderthals, it turns out.
So it is in a way fascinating to me that Neanderthals disappeared 40,000 years ago,
but suddenly a contribution for them becomes very important when a new virus
comes around. And that results in at least a million extra deaths in the pandemic, this variant.
Yeah, there seems to be some more findings of maybe having Neanderthal DNA doesn't necessarily
make you stronger or tougher, but may make you more vulnerable to certain things. And you also
spoke about the pain pathway, that might be more sensitive in Neanderthals.
But in general, I think there's a message there. Say, for example, that thing that makes you more
at risk to become severely ill if you're infected with SARS-CoV-2. The very same variant also
down-regulates a protein that is a receptor for HIV, so the virus that gives us HCCR5.
So if you have this variant, you're worse off if you're infected by SARS-CoV-2,
but you're actually better off if you're exposed to HIV because you're less likely to be infected,
about 25% less likely. And I think that illustrates that almost all genetic variants,
it's really an interaction with the environment. In this case, which virus you're exposed to.
So variant is often good in one situation and bad in another situation.
So yes, there is this sort of variant that comes from Neanderthals that makes you more
sort of sensitive to pain. And that can be bad, obviously, but it can also be sort of a good thing
to be more sensitive, sense more when something is wrong in your body. That affects a protein that
people who have a total lack of that protein, it's actually very bad. You feel sense no pain,
and your life expectancy is actually quite short in that situation.
Yeah, going back to sort of, you know, people feeling proud about having
maybe some Neanderthal DNA. So I have to admit, there was a study that came out that showed that
the very, very few, small percentage of East Asians that are lactose tolerant seem to have
that gene from the Neanderthals. I'm lactose tolerant. Yeah, I'm lactose tolerant. And I
enjoy milk and ice cream and everything. And I like to thank my Neanderthal ancestor for that.
So I guess, you know, in some respects, yeah, people do, like me, get excited about maybe
that possible link to the past. So there are these tools now, CRISPR, there are, you know,
stem cells that you can create from biospecimens. So the combination of creating cells from
specimens, manipulating melimpia. So the possibility of creating cells from specimens,
that could be any kind of cell type and manipulating them genetically with CRISPR.
Are those tools interesting to you and the kind of work you want to pursue?
Absolutely. So my own group, we have actually evolved more into looking into the functional
differences between Neanderthals and modern humans. One area we're particularly interested
in is sort of genetic changes that happen since we separate from Neanderthals and
Denisovans and spread to everyone today. So these are sort of changes then that define us
genetically, if you like, as modern humans. And one interesting question is, do any of them have
sort of physiological consequences? And it's a dilemma, of course, to study something that
everyone has today, because we cannot just take people who have it and don't have it and compare
them to each other. So then we will have to work in model systems. And one really good one is,
as you say, human stem cells, that you can then use CRISPR-Cas9 to edit back to the ancestral
state that's also in Neanderthals. And then you can differentiate these cells, for example,
to brain organoids, where you sort of induce the cells to make little sort of balls or tissue a
few millimeters big, that sort of mimic early stages in brain development. So for some such
changes, we have done that, and others have done that, to look at things that found changes then
in modern humans that, for example, influence how chromosomes segregate in early stem cells.
And it seems that they segregate more accurately in the modern human state than ancestral state,
for example. Or there are changes there that seems to make for slightly more neurons being born.
So Neanderthals, for example, had just as big brains as we have, but it's sort of an
outstanding question that would be really fascinating to learn something about in the next
five years or so, if it's organized in the same way as our brains. So all their subtle differences
there. Recently, I was a bioethics reviewer for a manuscript for Nature, and in the methods section,
they mentioned that they had used a chimpanzee iPS cell line, the Sandra A
iPS cell line. I believe that you were behind the creation of that, is that correct?
Why did you create that iPS cell line? By the way, I mean, the way that you make an iPS cell line is
non-invasive. You can just take some blood from the chimpanzee, reprogram the cells there into a
stem cell, and then do all kinds of crazy things with that stem cell line. So it was non-invasive
work. But why did you create the Sandra A line? Well, back in 2010, 2015, one direction of our
work was to compare these brain organoids from humans, chimpanzees, gorillas, orangutans,
to look for differences. Because as you say, you want to do these things in a non-invasive way.
You sort of cannot use embryos of humans or these species to do this. So this is sort of
almost the only approach to study brain development in a sort of ethical way.
In your book, you mentioned that there was a time where you contemplated whether it would be prudent
to patent or have some kind of restrictions on how people could use a nano-remote genome data.
Maybe there are some concerns about people kind of commercially kind of using that for some kind
of ancestry testing and other things, and kind of uses that maybe you wouldn't really be super
excited about. Whatever happened with that, it's not restricted in any way. So a researcher could
say, I want to get a stem cell line from human or chimpanzee and try to make it a Neanderthal line
and make it embryo model or something like that. Just describing my book, we had a big debate in
the group of sort of if we would sort of patent the use of the patent. You can patent a genome,
you can patent the use of it. If we would sort of patent the use of studying, say, your Neanderthal
ancestry, because we realized it would probably be a big commercial thing to test these things.
And some people were furiously against patenting it in groups and sort of backed away and did not
do that. Of course, it is now a big thing. There are many companies that provide these services,
which is fine. I mean, I think there's sort of no issue with that, but there are sort of no
patent limitations. Yeah, I get frequently asked to be an ethics reviewer for some of
these high-profile journals when they get a manuscript that they're not really sure what
to do with because legally, it was permissible, but it makes people uncomfortable. So, you can get
stem cell lines from chimpanzee, from human. You can make these models where you mix the stem cells
together. So, you kind of see how did they compete, and you might learn something about human
development versus other animals. So, these mixture combination model systems are concerning
to some people. And you can make an embryo model of human, but maybe you can even do an embryo model
of chimpanzee or embryo model of something like a Neanderthal. What are your thoughts about some
of these possibilities of, in the lab, creating these cell models that seem to recapitulate early
life? You are much more an expert and have thought more deeply about this than me, probably. I mean,
I feel comfortable with studying things as long as it's sort of very early stages in development,
which is really just a ball of cells that make some neurons from stem cells.
That is not an embryo that have different organs or could start sort of having sort of functions,
as we think of a fetus or so. But so, and I think in the time I have left in science,
one would not be able to do these things anyway to go further than this. But yeah.
You must get this question a lot. What do you think makes us uniquely human?
Uniquely human, meaning a modern human. What makes us uniquely human? How would you answer that?
Well, I don't know. But what I do, I'm struck by is this thing we discussed earlier,
how technology and culture start changing very rapidly and how modern humans spread
across the whole globe. And there is also good evidence that one were lived in bigger groups and
were more numerous. And it may be, but now I'm speculating that having bigger groups and more
individuals is behind much of this fast cultural development. That is just more chance for
innovation in bigger groups, and also bigger chance to transmit it to the next generation,
because groups don't go extinct so quickly. So it may be that, for example, at the end of the day,
there may be something that seems trivial, such as something that makes us have bigger groups and
bigger social systems. That is crucial. The question is then, what is that propensity in us?
Can we get at that? Is there also a biological component to that? That's not going to be a
biological thing, but there may be some propensity for being in bigger social systems.
So what have you not discovered yet that you would love to discover?
I mean, a total dream would be to understand at least some aspects of this. What made
modern human history that, to my mind, is so special compared to other human groups possible?
So can you tell me, what was it like to get the call from Stockholm? What went through your mind
when that phone rang and they told you the news? Well, I think that I actually totally didn't
anticipate this, because I had the feeling our work is maybe interesting to many people, but
not really fits the categories of the Nobel Prizes. So I totally thought this was a joke.
You thought it was a joke? I'm of course from Sweden, so I know many people in Sweden. There
was someone speaking Swedish, calling me, claiming that he was from the Nobel Committee.
And I thought, yeah, yeah, sure, tell me more, tell me more. And after 30 seconds,
it started sounding too serious. I started to realize this may not be a joke.
I've heard that in a phone call, they ask you, do you accept? Did they ask you that question?
No, they did not really ask that.
Now, what's fascinating about your personal history, in Korea, some people believe that
in order to really understand somebody, you have to go back at least two generations. I mean,
your work shows that we may have to go back 200,000 years. But let me ask you a little bit
about your family. So you were raised, you were a single child raised by your mother,
and your father, you saw not that often, but your father also won the Nobel Prize
in physiology or medicine. So did you have thoughts of your father when you got the
phone call from Stockholm? Of course, after a while, it was struck me that it was strange
that exactly 40 years earlier, my father also got the Nobel Prize. I do think that it's really my
mother who influenced me. I grew up as a single child when my mom saw my father, sometimes on
Saturdays for a few hours. So I think the person that has really influenced me is my mom.
Maybe the only influence from my father is to realize that it's not so special to be a Nobel
Laureate. So I guess, how do your children feel? Do they feel any pressure? I told my son that he
don't think they feel that, no. They just think it's not that special.
How can it be special with grandpa and dad? Especially when you're a teenager.
Exactly, yeah. All the allure is gone now, because it's something dad got.
Well, thank you so much for sharing your time with us today and
telling us all about your experiences with your research. That was really fascinating.
Thanks, it was fun.
