What can ancient DNA tell us about the first homo sapiens to arrive in Arabia over 50,000 years ago? Tristan Hughes is joined by Prof. Pierre Zalloua to delve into the groundbreaking advances in ancient DNA research that illuminate the complex journeys of these early human populations.
They discuss the challenges of extracting ancient DNA in harsh desert environments, the role of climate in human migration, and the archaeological evidence of early human presence, which shows continuous population movements over millennia.
0:00 Introduction to the First Arabians 1:55 The Ancient DNA Paradigm Shift 4:40 How to Extract DNA from Ancient Bones 8:17 Why Humans Left Africa: Climate Drivers 10:50 The Lost Refugees of the Persian Gulf 14:55 Neanderthals and Sapiens in the Levant 19:40 Rethinking the 400,000-Year Timeline 24:35 The Migration from the North into Arabia 31:15 Who Were the Natufians? 35:36 When Did the Word 'Arab' First Appear? 43:00 How Culture and Geography Shape Our DNA 50:30 Identity Beyond Genetics: 'Ancestors'
Presented by Tristan Hughes. Producers are Joseph Knight & McKenna Fernandez, senior producer is Anne-Marie Luff. Editor is Matthew Wilson. Channel manager is Vilde Øksnes.
AI Generated·May contain errors
Comments are disabled for this video.
Arabia. At the dawn of human history, this vast and dramatic landscape became a gateway to the
wider world. The story of the first Arabians begins with the earliest Homo Sapiens to migrate
out of Africa. Today is an especially exciting time, thanks to groundbreaking advances in ancient
DNA research that are illuminating the complex and fascinating journey of our ancestors.
In this video, we'll explore how genetics can help us understand the connections
between those first Homo Sapiens who arrived in Arabia and the modern-day Arabian populations.
We'll also look at what life might have been like for these early human communities living in Arabia
around 50,000 years ago. Most importantly, we are now closer than ever to answering one of
history's most profound questions. When did modern humans first step out of Africa
and which routes did they take? Now, I was delighted to have the opportunity to speak
with Pierre Zaloua, Professor of Genetics at Khalifa University, to answer some of these
questions. Let's go. Pierre, it is such a pleasure to have you on the podcast and to be doing it in
person. Welcome. Thank you. Actually, we've met three years ago. Yes, we did. Yeah, two years ago
and then I'm happy that we finally made it. We met at an archaeological conference in Saudi Arabia,
of all places. But it feels fitting for today's topic on the first Arabians, but also the first
Homo Sapiens in the wider region as well, because you've just written a brand new book,
Ancestors, all about the history of the Levant, or the Levant as well. I mean, in regards with DNA
and exploring the stories of these earliest people to these areas of the world,
is it a really exciting time with new scientific developments and so on?
I think ancient DNA has transformed the way we look at population migrations and who populated
which part of the world first. I think ancient DNA was, I would say,
caused a paradigm shift in the way we do population genetics. And no wonder that Papus
got the Nobel Prize for it. I mean, it's transformed the way we look at human migrations.
And in a lot of places, actually, it made a huge impact and it made major discoveries that
made us change our ideas or our theories about when and how humans migrated out of Africa.
The challenge, I have to just put it here, is Arabia. The challenge in Arabia because of the
heat and because of the conditions where the remnants of humans in the desert actually
extracting DNA from human remains has been extremely, extremely challenging. And to date,
I will tell you that there has not been a, maybe apart from a couple of samples,
no DNA beyond 5,000 years. We have not been able to get any DNA out of samples that are more than
a few thousand years old from Arabia, from the entire Arabia, which is a huge challenge.
It's a huge challenge. And is that in contrast to places a bit further north,
like the Levant, where you have more human bones today?
Exactly, exactly. So in the Levant and in northern Levant, in the Caucasus even, and in Iran,
the Zagros Mountains, and in Anatolia, we've had ample, ample DNA samples. And that's why the story
is so exciting up to the point where we get to Arabia. But we have other tools at our disposal
that have given us ideas about when Arabia was populated and how Arabia was populated, etc.
But until we get ancient DNA, and I'm hoping we will, I mean, we're trying so hard. And actually,
from that visit that you and I had, colleagues there, they're trying to actually get some
good quality DNA out of the samples that they have. But still to date, we have not been able
to get that. You are a brilliant geneticist. I mean, can you explain a bit more of the process
behind how you would try to extract ancient DNA from these remains?
So every single cell of our body, or the skeleton, supposedly has DNA. But when, you know,
with time, cells get very porous, and then if there's no collagen to keep the bones together,
so you lose a lot of the skeletons of the cell itself, and DNA is no longer there. So you need
some form of skeleton to fix the DNA to it. So we basically use certain parts of the skeleton,
namely the, you know, the teeth and the molar, precisely because, you know, if you can actually
drill within the molar part, you can actually extract DNA, and you hope that there is DNA inside.
So that's one part that we can get DNA from. But most recently, and I would say recently,
over the last five years or so, we discovered that the petrous bone, which is, yes, which is,
you know, below the ear, right at the end of the mandible, it's very thick. It's actually one of
the thickest, if not the thickest bone in the body. Because it's thick, it actually can withstand a
lot of heat and a lot of, you know, climatic changes, etc. And we can actually extract DNA
from. And that's what most scientists have been successful with, is extracting DNA from petrous
bones. And actually, this was a major shift in the way we extract DNA. So basically, you grind
that bone, and then when you grind that bone, you basically, you dissolve all the material into an
aqueous phase and then a liquid phase, and then you get the DNA out and you analyse the DNA.
And how can you then use that DNA to track prehistoric migrations of people that in some
cases occur tens of thousands of years ago?
Well, I think the beauty of ancient DNA is because you can archaeologically date, because
you can carbon date and use other methods to actually date that material. So we know
exactly using ancient DNA or ancient material is how old the material is. So that's something
that we have now. So for example, when you discover, you know, Neanderthal DNA, which is a
very old DNA. So from other methods, you can actually date that skeleton or those remains,
and you can actually put a date to it. And then when you extract the DNA, you now know that people
who lived 100,000 years ago or 50,000 years ago, this is what their DNA looked like. And you
compare it to what the DNA looked like today. And then you can actually look how much did it change
in 50,000 years ago, knowing that knowing what we know from science is, yes, DNA changes every
generation. But it's like a clock, we know exactly the changes that actually can happen through time.
And by doing this comparison, we will be able to know if this change is actually a normal timeline
change, or if something else happened to these people. Did they disappear, or the people living
today are the direct descendants of these skeletal remains?
Mason Pierre, it is such a fascinating scientific field. And I must admit, I'm someone who doesn't
have a big scientific background at all. So I'm loving learning more about this.
If we go back to Arabia, and you've highlighted how it's more tricky learning more about the
earliest people populating Arabia because of the temperatures. I mean, to learn more therefore
about that, what other methods do you have to use alongside ancient DNA?
Okay. So let's discuss first, why do people move? Okay. So why did our ancestors leave Africa? Okay.
Well, they need better, you know, better place to live, you know, because either heat was too much,
or the hunting grounds were actually, you know, getting, they shrunk, etc. So they go from one
environment to another, because to survive. So people move throughout history, they've been
moving throughout history to seek better climate, better places to hunt, better places to live,
etc. So why would actually people move into Arabia? And that's, that's the question that we
that we had. So I would say throughout the last, you know, 100,000 years, the climate was the main
driver for human migration. So you have to look at climate maps and see how did Arabia look like
50,000 years ago? How did Arabia look like 100,000 years ago? How does Arabia look like today?
And so it's extremely important for us to understand how the area looked, how the area
behaved, you know, how was the environment in that area before we can actually say, well, human lived
or didn't live. So this is a huge element that we need in place first. So looking at climate shifts,
looking at was it wet? Did it actually, did it have enough green pastures for actually
people to live, for animals to graze? And then, you know, you need, so when we talk about humans,
you need, you know, subsidies for humans as well, right? I mean, you need the animals that they hunt,
you need the plants that they eat, et cetera. So that's extremely important. So climatology
or the science of environmental changes is extremely important. So that's one aspect that
we look at. So the second aspect is archaeology. You know, is there any archaeological remain
that actually can tell us that humans did in fact live in that place? The problem with Arabia
is that we see some evidence of human presence 130,000 years ago, maybe 210,000 years ago.
But then because of the climate, because of the shift in climate, then the area was no longer
inhabited. So people actually escaped. And when they escape, either they move long distances,
went back to Africa, or they went up north, or they live in refugia. And usually these refugia,
from what we know today, have been around the Gulf area, so close to the water.
Okay, so like the Gulf of Aden or the Persian Gulf today?
The Persian Gulf, exactly. So basically, we know that people move to these areas and they shrink.
I mean, these areas, livable areas, they shrink so much because of the climate.
And of course, we have the glacial ages, right? I mean, the last glaciation that happened 25,000
years ago to 18,000 years ago, this is the last glacial maximum that you talk about,
was also a major player. And we'll talk about this. Because during that period,
Arabia was not a place where you can actually sustain life. So these fluctuations that happen,
so if we talk about, let's go back to 130,000 to 110,000 years ago, and then for a long period of
time, Arabia was not populated because people cannot live there. And then perhaps around,
I would say, 65,000 to 50,000, there has been a cooling area in there, more humid.
And we have evidence that some people may have lived there. But then soon after that came the
last glacial maximum, and then the entire population disappeared up until, I would say,
6,000 years ago, where we call it the African Humid Period, which actually, anywhere between
14,000 to 6,000 years, that's when Arabia was mostly populated. I would say around 7,000
prior to today, we see a, I would say, the largest number of people moved into Arabia,
based on the archaeological evidence that we have. So if we're going to talk about
when was Arabia populated, I would say my guess would be around that time, 7,000 years ago,
started to see strong evidence of populations that actually remained. One thing I have to
mention as well is after the ice melted around 18,000 years ago, what happened to the Persian
Gulf? What happened to the sea level? It rose significantly. So those people, the ancient
people who actually may have lived around there, what happened to them? They're underwater now.
So that's why it's very hard to find these archaeological remains from 50,000 years ago,
or 20,000 years ago, if they exist because they're underwater. So hopefully one day,
we can actually have underwater archaeology and then discover those. Some have now started to
being discovered. I know the evidence is more tentative, but I hope you don't mind if we go
before 7,000 years ago right now with these earlier, I don't know if I want to say
unsuccessful, but more temporary occupations of people in Arabia. So you mentioned that evidence
from 130,000, 120,000 years ago. So do we have these brief moments which seems like there is
human occupation in Arabia earlier on? These are based purely on certain archaeological findings
and no humans. Actually, they have not been able to find human remains. But the archaeology actually
is telling that these may have been occupied. And the problem is, again, as I said,
we have not been able to find human remains up until 7,000 or 6,000 prior. And we are working,
I am with some collaborators that we're working on some of these remains. So far,
we're not very successful, but we are pushing on that. So it's really hard to pinpoint the
evidence right now of these ancient, ancient people who actually lived. I think as we do more
archaeological studies, underwater archaeological studies, we will find
numerous sites across the Persian Gulf where we can actually see remnants of these ancient
populations. And is this also important to highlight? Because I know you also have done
a lot of work on the Levant, where there's the presence of Neanderthals and of early Homo sapiens
together. Do we not think that Neanderthals made it into Arabia? Do we think that the Levant is
the cutoff point? It's a very difficult question to answer, because we don't have any DNA. But
the most likely path is the Sinai, up to the Levant, where Neanderthals lived for a very long
time, moved into Europe. And we know there's strong evidence now that most likely the first
interaction between, or the first cross between Neanderthals and Homo sapiens...
Was interbreeding.
Interbreeding happened in the Levant, and perhaps happened more than once.
So we know for a fact that they existed together at some point in the Levant.
Now, how did the Neanderthals get there? Yes, I mean, you can argue that they may have also
come through the Bab el-Mandab. You have to realize that through Bab el-Mandab in Yemen,
they could cross it. You don't need to. I mean, the water was so shallow there, so people could
cross. And the Sinai was very different back then. I mean, you can actually cross it much
easier than today. It was not all that desert like today. And again, as we learn more about
how people moved, I mean, this one out of Africa migration is no longer sustainable.
And one thing I have to also mention is, we don't talk about migration. Back migration also
played a huge role. People moved out of Africa, but a lot of people moved back into Africa.
And so a lot of movement happened over the last 50,000 years. During the last glacial maximum,
people escaped the Levant, escaped Arabia. And I won't be surprised, actually, we have
evidence to show that they actually moved back into East Africa and some other parts of Africa.
The Natufians, which we'll talk about, we believe that after the Younger Dryas, which is a very
cold period that happened around 11,000 years ago, the population of Natufians who lived in
the Levant shrunk. And some of them may have actually escaped. Some of them went north,
but others actually went south and perhaps crossed back into Africa to escape. Because
we see material culture that, in Natufian culture, that is more impacted by Africa,
whether because they interacted with them or whether they have actually moved there and
interacted with them in Africa and they brought them back. So really, it's a, we have to think
about, you know, it's not always one direction of movement. It's actually, you know, it's a
corridor back and forth. If we can focus quickly also on those out of Africa migrations, Pierre,
I know you've done a lot of work around this as well. Can you tell us how they relate to those
early groups of Homo sapiens going into Arabia? And then, as you mentioned, they ultimately,
some of them retreat back into Africa. But can you explain how DNA is making us rethink
the nature of those migrations into Arabia at that time?
So, you see, the reason the 50,000 years out of African migration has been highly documented
because we have strong archaeology and we have also strong DNA to show we can time that migration.
Through DNA mutations that happened and the fact that, you know, now Homo sapiens,
you know, initially we thought, you know, when I first started to study population genetics,
the whole idea was like, we are 150,000 years old. Of course, now we've pushed that to 400,000 years.
We think some Homo sapiens actually are 400,000 years old now. And again, because of ancient DNA
that made us change these theories. But the most striking idea is that the population in Africa
shrunk so much during that time that those who actually migrated out of Africa were very few.
And we're talking maybe in the thousands, maybe a few thousands only. And that's why
we're not as genetically diverse as you would expect. If we were evolving without this bottleneck
through 400,000 years ago, we would be a lot more diverse than we are today.
So this is what DNA is telling us. So DNA tells us these stories that we shrunk and then we
expanded again when we left Africa. And then from that point on, when you study people today,
you compare their DNA and you can actually tell how many generations passed through mutations that
we calculate. So we know that if we say a generation is 25 years, so we expect certain
changes based on DNA mutations. And then we can calculate and figure out when a mutation appeared.
So we start actually understanding when people moved, how they moved, and who moved
to certain places and who established those places. And once we start looking at populations
living today, we start actually constructing reverse engineering. We actually start to say,
oh, this group who lives in the Levant today, we know where they come from. Because we have
ancient DNA from people in situ in specific places, we can compare this ancient DNA to
modern DNA and say, is this a likely descendant? And that's how we do it. So we compare ancient DNA
to modern DNA and we do the calculation of time by generation and we can tell. So for example,
in the Levant, we know that the Levant, the modern day Levant, is made of mostly three or at the most
four major genetic components. In other words, who are the ancestral populations of the Levant?
We know that the Natufians who lived in the Levant 14,000 years ago were actually the original
or the first inhabitants of the Levant that are continuously, their DNA is continuously present
until today. And then these people were mixed from the Neolithic Anatolian, talking 12,000 years,
12 to 8,000 years, who came from Anatolia. And then we also know that from the Zarus mountains,
the foothill of Iran's mountains, they also came into the Levant. And that's how the Levant is
actually populated. And I'll continue the story. So from that point on, because of climate,
we understand how climate was. We understand also that, yes, the Levant at that point was
sustainable for having people in. And then we have evidence now that these people migrated south
into Arabia. So Arabia is actually heavily populated by ancient Levantine populations.
So if you think about Arabia, modern Arabia was not populated from Africa. No, it was populated
from the north. So this is what ancient DNA is actually making us correct what we didn't know
before. And then that's how we do it. I think the reason I ask also is that because I know,
as you mentioned, no remains before 7,000 years ago, so it is much more tricky in Arabia.
But I've got on my notes things like the Gate of Tears and how with early successful migrations of
humans out of Africa, that it seems likely that they went along the Arabian coast. And although
it wasn't enduring there, because ultimately they have to leave Arabia when the climate gets much
worse, as you mentioned some 23,000 years ago. Because of that, I mean, do we ever have any sense,
any idea of how those early communities lived in Arabia and how they got to America,
how they got to Arabia, just anything about their lives?
Yes. So when we talk about Bab-el-Mandeb or Gate of Tears, it is most likely ancient Arabia,
not the one that we know today, was populated most likely from the Gate of Tears, from Bab-el-Mandeb.
So basically, the most likely scenario is ancient Arabia was populated through that route,
but also other people tracked even more eastward, and that's how they populated East Asia up to
Australia. But what we know of these ancient people who actually came to Arabia, not very much,
because the climate changed so much in Arabia that I would say some of these early cultures,
who were actually hunter-gatherers, of course, they lived in very small communities,
and they lived close to the water. And then as the last glacial period happened,
with the ice melting around 18,000 years ago, these communities actually either escaped or
went underwater. That's why we still haven't discovered those people yet. So after that,
Arabia was dry for a long time, up until, as I said, the last, we call it the African human
period, which started to happen around 14,000 years ago, and then it peaked around eight to
7,000 years ago in Arabia, and then that's when Arabia was populated again.
And do we see, and so the people are coming at that time, they're coming from many different
places, including the Levant, do we think? Well, this is what I think, and I could be wrong,
but this is what so far the DNA that I've worked with have told us, is yes, most of modern
Arabians that we see today have a huge DNA component from the Levant and that region.
Of course, you also have the Iranian component as well present, you have the Natufian present as
well, and importantly, you have two other components into modern Arabia. One from East
Africa, you see it, you see another one from Egypt, there's a lot of common lineages between
Egypt and Arabia, and you see from the East through Dilmun, you know, the Bahrain interaction
with the East, you know, with the Indian trade and all of this. But these last three are more
recent. So Egypt, East Africa, and India were much more recent, whereas the Levant
input was much older than this to Arabia. So if I want to say, you know, the population of Arabia
today, I would say, yes, Levantine, mostly Egypt, East Africa, and some part of India.
Thank you for letting me ask so many questions about the pre 7,000 years ago. I do appreciate
it. I love exploring that kind of deep ice age story of it all. But does it therefore seem that
by 8,000, 7,000 years ago, there is quite a population boom in Arabia at that time?
Around 7,000 years ago, we believe there was a population boom. And that's what we see today. I
mean, these are the people who actually survived over the last 7,000 years. Although, if you look
at Arabia today, and compare it to 7,000 years ago, of course, it was a much different place. I
mean, it was you had much greener places in Arabia than what you see today.
Yes. What do we know about the environment at that time?
You know, there's still, you know, small communities, as I said, so you don't see
very large communities and mostly around places where you have water. Of course, there were a lot
lakes present. So they were more nomadic. And actually, they kept the name. You know,
we believe the name Arabia, which is, you know, it's also a term that, you know,
needs to be studied extensively. It's, you know, it's described nomadic people who lived in Arabia.
So I think that's how these people live. They moved around these lakes around places where
there's water and the remnants of those are these oasis that you still have today in Arabia.
So I was actually going to ask my next question was, when do we think that the people who then
populate Arabia, of course, massive landmass, I mean, when do they become more sedentary? I mean,
do they bring farming with them? But it doesn't seem like it's a straightforward answer that.
Yes. It's not a straightforward answer. No, absolutely not. I think the nomadic lifestyle
of Arabia has dominated most of the last three, four millennia. You know, they moved from one
place to another, you know, after 6000 years, actually, Arabia started to become more arid,
and more, more desert up until today. So yes, people, their movement were a bit
difficult. They moved with difficulty because of the land, you know, sustainable land actually
shrunk. And I think they lived nomadic life for the last, you know, few millennia. And some of
them still do today. You know, these caravans that we talked about, that we all learned about,
they were only recent.
You also mentioned in passing earlier, and I know, and its involvement in the story,
the story of the Natufians. Now, can you explain who they are, and how they relate to the story
of Arabia by this time a few 1000 years ago?
So the Natufians, the name, the name of Natufians comes from, you know, the valley of Natuf,
which is in Jordan. This is where actually, the late period Natufian were. So the Natufians are
the earliest cultures that we know of in the Levant, anywhere between 12,000 and 14,000 years
ago, we can, we can start seeing, I mean, they lived in many caves, of course, and maybe some
early, early community life of the Natufians. The difficulty that we have with the Natufians today
is we don't have too many samples to look for. I mean, most of what we know, comes from half a
dozen samples that have actually been sampled successfully. But, and most data comes from
David Reich, who is a very famous ancient DNA specialist as well. And so, so these are the
people who lived in the Levant. They occupied parts of Syria, modern day, modern day Syria,
Lebanon, and Jordan. And then after the Younger Dryas happened, you know, 11,000 years where you
have this major climate shift, they split. We believe that they split. Some went south,
further south, and perhaps they reached Africa, and some went further north. But they shrunk in
size because of the climate. They shrunk so much. And then after, when the climate changed again,
then they spread again. And while they were spreading, at the same time, people were coming
down from the Caucasus, from the Anatolian plains, and from the Zagros. So as people expanded,
because the climate got better after the last glacial maximum, and they started mixing. So we
see evidence of mixing between the Natufians and the Neolithic Anatolians, and the people coming
from Iran, from the Zagros Mountains. And that's what constituted the Levant today, that we know
today. And then part of the Southern Natufians that actually escaped, we believe that actually
led to most of the inhabitants of Arabia. So we think that, yes. So, but they also mixed from the
Levantine as well. And this is still up in the air. It's not 100% solid, but this is what the
early evidence is showing us. So following 7,000 years ago, do you as a geneticist and your team,
do you have more information available for learning more, as you mentioned there with
the Natufian link, for instance, about the makeup of these early populations in Arabia? I guess it's
the Stone Age at that time, or deep in prehistory, but less than 7,000 years ago?
I would say, let's talk maybe 5,000. 5,000 and 4,000 years ago. And this is where we start
seeing the evidence right now. Arabia has not been studied extensively archaeologically. It's
now been, I would say over the last maybe five to seven years, where a lot of activities have
been going on. And Al-Ula as a site, but it's much later than this Al-Ula. We're talking the
Sabaean and the, no, it's Sabaean. The Nabataean. Yeah, the Nabataean. And this is much recent. So
we know more about this. And frankly, what I know about this is much more recent than the 7,000.
So I couldn't tell much about, prior to these people who actually lived in Arabia. We still
don't know. Or I don't know. I'll ask you a question then, because the word, obviously,
people who live in Arabia today are called Arabs. Do you think we can use that term
for these people who lived several thousand years ago? Should we explore the word?
Well, I think the word Arab has not been used prior to, I would say, a thousand years
BCE. So I think the Neo-Assyrians were the first ones who used the word Arab in a war context,
maybe 900 years ago, 900 years before our common era. So no, I don't think we can use the word
Arab, but these were the ancestors of the Arabs, of course. So yeah, and I'm not sure that
until today we know of a description of Arabs prior to that time. So I wouldn't call them
Arabs at that stage.
So Pierre, of course, we're covering a huge geographic region with Arabia, you know,
several modern countries today. I mean, how do we think the whole region was ultimately
populated? What do we know about that?
Yes, I think one of the most important things to note here is we believe a lot of things happened
in that region. Really, the first communities that existed were in the Euphrates, in Mesopotamia,
right? And I mean, we're not too far…
The fertile crescent.
Yes, the fertile crescent, exactly. So the first communities, the first cities,
the first real populations, as we call them, populations actually started there. So this
region has been continuously populated over the last 7,000 years, which makes it a fascinating
region. So when you approach and you want to study this region, you have to look at
this massive shift of populations and cultures. And you say, you know, how am I going to decipher
all of this by looking at modern DNA today? And it's really, it's a puzzle. It's a huge puzzle.
So if we think about it, so if we go back 7,000 years ago, or a bit earlier during the Neolithic
time, and the agricultural expansion, let's put it this way. So let's talk 8,000 to 9,000 years
when actually people started to leave their hunter-gatherer styles into small communities
and agricultural expansions and start farming. So this happened in the fertile crescent. This
happened in Mesopotamia. And who were the cultures that actually lived there back then? So there were
very few of them. And as I said earlier, these actually were the people who lived in the Zagros
mountains at the foot of the Zagros, these people who lived in Anatolia, and the Natufians. So this
is how it all started. So these are the people who actually were the ancestors of the Sumerians.
Sumer, the first city in the world, right, as we call it, you know, 3,100 years ago, 100 BC.
So these are the original cultures that actually led to the people who live today. I mean,
all of us. So you have Sumer that started around 3,100. And then after Sumer, then came
the Akkadians. And the Akkadians came somewhere from, you know, northern Euphrates, perhaps
more from, you know, West Asia, perhaps the Levant. They were Semitic people. The Akkadians
and they came and they took over and they destroyed, well, they dominated Sumer. And then
after that, you know, you had so many different cultures that actually fought. You had the
Babylonians, right? You had the Assyrians. And so all of these people actually that moved in that
region make our work extremely difficult to understand. But at the end of the day,
when you do the analysis, you see that all of these actually came from these three distinct
original cultures, which I think is fascinating. If I continue through that, so if we go from,
you know, what happened to the Babylonians, then, you know, you have the Assyrians and
Neo-Assyrians that they actually came and they, you know, took over. Neo-Assyrians actually took
over the entire region up until North Egypt. So they had a major presence. So when all these
cultures actually dominate, you still, you say, you know, what am I doing now? You know,
5,000 years later, what am I doing? How can I actually decipher all of this?
So it's not an easy task. So when I did my work on, and I say identity and the Levant,
identity and DNA in the Levant, is just, I'm trying to figure out, you know, who are these
people, you know, and when did they arrive and where did they come from? So it's really fascinating
when you start putting archaeology, history, and genetic together to understand, you know, our
ancestry. And that's what's fascinating about all of this. So you have to think and you have to put
in perspective, you know, that, you know, it's not always a linear approach. It's very,
you know, complex, interactive approach. And you have to come, you know, come to the idea
that it's not going to be an easy answer. It's not going to be a simple, linear answer.
It's a very complex topic. And you've highlighted the wider region there, of course,
and I'm guessing it also filters into Arabian populations as well.
That's right. I mean, you know, part of, if we look at Mesopotamia, right, and if you look at
Iran, I mean, if you go south, right, I mean, that's where you are. You have Yemen and you have
Arabia, right? I mean, this interaction, it's a continuum. We don't know if actually people moved
from Arabia into Iran or from Iran into Arabia. And I think we're seeing both. We're seeing this
interaction, ancient up until today. And when we talk ancient, we're talking 7,000 years.
When you use, I'm presuming then you've also looked at DNA from people who live in Arabia
today. Do you notice significant differences in the genetic, is it the ancestry, I guess,
of people, let's say, from Yemen compared to Amman and so on? Is that also an interesting
component to look at? Yes. So, when you do DNA analysis on modern people who live in Arabia or
in any region, there's something you have to really understand is that culture actually
makes an impact on how our DNA is. So, what you choose to do in your life, where you migrate,
where you move, who you marry, you know, makes your DNA different. So, if you migrate into an
area where nobody lived before as a small group and you grow, your DNA is going to look very
different than the initial group because actually, you know, you're actually breeding
within a very small group. So, culture actually, in that sense, changes the way the DNA is going
to look like. And this is something that we don't often think about. So, when you tell me that,
you know, if you take the genes or the genomes or the genetic makeup of people who lived in Yemen
versus people who lived in Jeddah, for example, Saudi Arabia, yes, you're going to find differences
because there is a geographical barrier. You know, these people have been living together for a long
time. But if you take it a step further or if you take it a step deeper than this, no, the changes
are not very different. So, yes, you could see some changes that are modern changes,
that are new changes that you can actually describe, but the stock remains the same.
So, and that's descended from those prehistoric migrations to Arabia thousands of years ago.
You could see them.
That's an amazing line then, right down to the present day. I mean, Pierre,
lots of this science sometimes goes over my head, but you've explained lots of it brilliantly in
understanding the kind of story of this early populating of this such an important, crucial
region of South West Asia. Is there anything else you'd like to highlight that we really should
talk about with these earliest populations in Arabia? And I guess, if you want, the wider
region that we should think about when looking at ancient DNA and other fields today?
Well, I think it's important to understand that people moved a lot. And it's also important to
understand that there's not going to be a single story about human populations. I think there's
going to be many, many stories. And these stories, I would say, will change because science will
change. What we understand today is based on what we've learned. But then maybe 10 years from now,
new evidence comes, and then it will change the way we understood things. We keep on changing
many things. As I said earlier, we thought Homo sapiens were only 150,000 years old. Now we think
they are 400,000 years ago. So initially, when I was studying genetics, my professor told us that
Neanderthals and Homo sapiens never mixed because they based all of this on mitochondrial DNA.
Now we know that they mixed at least four times. We know now there is Denisovans as well
in the East. And we know that there's a mix between Denisovan, Neanderthal, and Homo sapiens
as well. So what I'm trying to say is we're learning. We should not simplify the story. I
think simplifying the story, yes, we would like to say we descended from X population
at that particular time, but it's not always as simple. I think the complexity of it makes it
more interesting, especially for people like me. And as I give examples, there are multiple,
multiple populations or cultures that lived in a very small region, which is the Fertile
Crescent all the way down to the Levant. But then if we go back 10,000, 12,000 years ago,
we know that the source of these populations were only three cultures. So these are fascinating
stories. I'll give you an example. The Levant today is populated, yes, you have all of these
invaders that we talk about, like the Romans, the Persians came, and then the Romans. So you have
all of these mix that happened in the Levant. And then you would expect to see a lot of these
DNA remains of Romans and Persians and the Crusades later, but you don't. You see only
very small fraction that actually is actually changing only, which is fascinating, which is
fascinating. I mean, I think these tell stories that actually make us say, yes, people come,
especially in the past, these waves of people moving through wars, Alexander with his army,
and they didn't leave any DNA or very, very little DNA to mention.
But it's so interesting going back to those three groups that you highlighted earlier that they
stem from. So I guess that's also in the case with the famous Arabian kingdoms, like the Nabataeans
or the Sabaeans in Yemen. They also have their links to those three from earlier.
That's right. That's right.
That's right. My last question must also be, if you're happy to answer it, because it's almost
a bit of an add-on question at the end, Semitic languages. Can ancient DNA and your studies
help us learn about the spread of Semitic languages into the Arabian Peninsula?
Well, I write about Semitic languages in my book, and something that fascinates me,
and I learned so much about languages. I'm not a linguist, of course, but languages move very
differently than DNA. The two are not tied together at all. I think it'll be a mistake to
think that we can associate language movement with DNA. I'll give you an example. Persia,
when Persia dominated the entire region, including the Levant, you know what the lingua franca was?
Aramaic.
Yes. So it was not Persian at all. So that tells you, I mean, about, you know, languages
move very differently than people, and I think it's a very difficult thing to actually
conflate the two together. It's just going to be very difficult.
Pierre, this has been such a deep dive into ancient genetics and its links to the Arabian
Peninsula and the wider Levant, the fertile crescent. Talk to us a little bit about your
new book, Ancestors.
Yes. Ancestors, it's a book about the Levant, mostly, and it's a book that tells the story
about who the ancestors of the Levant were. And it's not only about ancestry or ancestors of the
Levant. It tells a story about cultures, the cultures that lived in the Levant and how these
cultures manifested themselves, how we can look at, you know, DNA to just understand
how these cultures moved. But most importantly, the message in this book is to basically state
that DNA is only a thread about these cultures. So it tells you how these cultures moved,
but it doesn't tell you anything about these cultures. These cultures, we talk about languages,
we talk about lifestyles, we talk about habits, rituals, and all of this. And I think
that's what this book talks about. It talks about that we should not limit a culture to a DNA test,
should not limit identities to a DNA test. I always say that roots is not a word to be used
for humans, maybe certain plants, but origin is something that you carry with you as a human being.
And then your identity is something that you modulate and you evolve. So DNA does not
have any impact or should not have the impact that, you know, initially we thought it would
have on identities and cultures. So that's what I talk about in the book.
Pierre, it's a great book. As I said, you cover all of that area and the long
history and prehistory of those areas and the makeup of the populations. It just goes to me
to say thank you so much for taking the time to come on the podcast today.
Thank you. Thank you. It's a pleasure. I'm very happy and I'm glad we had this talk. Thanks so much.