Chicago’s Best Burgers: The Loyalist

Chicago Cuisine
3 followers
So, John, this is kind of a pilgrimage for me,
where I feel like I'm finally here at the Promised Land
being the Loyalist for your incredible burger.
It better not suck, right? I mean...
Well, I mean, I know it doesn't suck.
The Loyalist comes with a reputation.
You guys are always mentioning those top five lists,
top ten lists.
Clearly, you have something special.
Where did that begin?
Yeah, well, thanks to Phil Votel and the Tribune.
I think that was what sort of catapulted us.
The title was Burger That Beats Oshabal.
So, Phil Votel started the ball rolling.
The Burger That Beats Oshabal.
Then what happened next?
Everyone just piled in here?
Yeah, that happened, and then Bon Appetit
came out with their best burgers in the country.
They did three.
We got two, so they sort of got it wrong,
but that's okay, you know.
We'll take it, but it was literally overnight.
We had no idea the article was coming out,
and, like, the next day, it was just,
it went from, like, you know, 60, 70 burgers a night
to 200-plus.
So, you guys are in the heart of the West Loop.
What can you tell people about the place
if they've not been here before?
Sure, yeah, so we have two restaurants.
We have Smith, which is sort of our upstairs
fine dining restaurant, if you will.
It does have a few Michelin stars,
so it sort of puts us in that category,
but it's really casual.
And then we have the Loyalist,
which is sort of our subterranean
little neighborhood restaurant.
You literally walk through the door,
and there's a split.
You go Smith upstairs, you go Loyalist downstairs.
Exactly.
They drive business between the two, in a way, you know.
It's like siblings do.
Somebody comes to Loyalist, and they go,
I gotta try out Smith, and vice versa.
So, it works.
And you guys, trust me, I mean, like,
you wanna go upstairs, it is exquisite.
Follow your nose for the burger
and the American cheese.
Downstairs is where it's at for the Loyalist.
We do sell a lot of burgers upstairs, too.
Oh, really?
Oh, yeah.
Okay, well, you can go to both.
Thank you for ruining my, like,
pretending I know what I'm talking about.
We'll let it at that first.
But you can go to both, obviously.
You can go upstairs to Smith
or downstairs to the Loyalist.
Chef, I'm just gonna stop talking.
No, you're perfect.
How does it come together?
What's the blend in that meat,
and how do you cook that?
We start with chuck every morning.
We break it down, we clean it,
and then short ribs,
so it's a proportion of the two.
We make a mayonnaise from onions,
so we take onions and we caramelize the onions.
We'll let them kind of fry, basically, in oil,
and then we strain that oil out,
and that oil makes the aioli.
And then homemade pickles, pickled onions,
and a little bit of fried onion on top.
And then our secret kind of beef sauce,
if you will.
I just want to get covered in all the glory
that the Dirty Burger can offer.
Let's do it.
Yeah?
Yeah.
You ready?
I'm ready.
Okay, I was born ready for this.
Like I said, it's a pilgrimage.
This is clearly why we're here,
why I'm here,
what it's all about,
but I do have a question.
Yep.
Because in your kitchen,
there's this frame of you.
I've been told this moves around inside the kitchen.
This is pre-COVID me.
We move it around,
let everybody know I'm always watching.
So even when I'm not there,
I'm still always there.
So it's not an homage to you,
it's not that they love you that much,
they just want to be near you.
They want to be near me all the time.
Well, seeing as you're at the table with me already,
I don't know if we necessarily need this.
Okay.
However, I freaking love it.
Yeah.
So I think it should still be on the table.
Great.
And we've also got,
we got beer and shot.
You knew I was coming.
Yeah?
Are we doing it?
Why not?
And here's to the Loyalist Burger.
Clink me.
Thank you.
I like my meat to talk to me.
Yeah.
And this is meat-driven.
It's the simplicity.
There's cheese,
there is beef,
we've got the sesame bun,
we've got some onions.
Yep.
And a little bit of secret,
secret things happening underneath it.
A little secret sauce, you know,
so to speak.
But the reality is,
your burger has to be superior
if you're doing it that simple.
And my God.
It's just about just drawing the flavor out
as much as you possibly can.
Taking the onions
and pulling the onion flavor out,
but softening it up
so it's not just raw onion in your face.
This is more delicate.
It's a special burger.
And one bite confirms everything
that you want it to be.
It's just the product.
It's the technique behind it.
Simplicity is key.
Less is more.
It's a testament to what you guys do here.
Thank you.
It's a special moment for me
in Chicago's Best History
because my pilgrimage is over.
I've reached the promised land.
Great to meet you.
Cheers to you.
If you want, I can leave you two alone.
Well, no, no.
I've got the real thing right next to me.
