All-Terrain Tires Off-Road – 2025 Test 9

Car Tires TV
5 followers
7 Video Views·Jan 3, 2026
In a Tire Rack first, we took popular On-Road, Off-Road, and Rugged All-Terrain, as well as Off-Road Max Traction tires, to an off-road driving park to see how these categories compare off the beaten path! As we continue to expand our testing program, we are working towards a full-scale off-road portion that aligns with the objective and subjective format of our road-focused testing. In the meantime, there’s no time like the present to kick up some dust and get a feel for these tires in an off-road environment. So, join us as TJ and Brent take a subjective ride in the sand, across river rock, and attempt a hill climb
At Tire Act, we've been testing all-terrain tires for over a decade, providing drivers with the
information they need to make the right tire decision based on what, where, and how they drive.
Our testing has included evaluations on the road for the daily drive, wet and dry traction for
emergency situations or day-to-day motoring, even on the ice and in the snow to find out which tire
is best when winter weather is at its worst. One thing we've never been able to properly evaluate
though is these tires off-road prowess, but that all changes now. The thing about off-road testing
is it's extremely difficult to do it properly. By the very nature of the testing, every time you
drive over your test surface, you're changing it and that introduces a variable. Of course,
there's also the variable of the composition of what you're driving over. You've got rock and mud
and sand and silt and then, of course, differing moisture contents and it creates a situation where
it's essentially impossible to control every variable as much as we'd really like to when
we're testing. Then, of course, there's the underlying issue that when you say off-road,
it's going to mean something different to different people in different parts of the country.
Some people might picture mud bogging or desert running or rock climbing or just gravel roads or
oil fields or maybe even just getting from point A to point B on your property. Being Tire Rack,
where testing is what we do, we want to make sure we do it right. Now, we've been in the process with
our partners down at Treadwell Research Park developing repeatable objective off-road testing,
but we're eager to get our boots dirty. We want to start experiencing these tires even if it's just
a taste of what their full capabilities are. We want to start differentiating these tires off-road
for our customers, so the first step is, of course, finding the right spot to do that.
For that, we've hit the road to Badlands Off-Road Park in Attica, Indiana, a 1,400-acre off-road
paradise with trails, dunes, tracks, rock gardens, mud pits, and more. We chose three distinct areas
to evaluate our tires' off-road capabilities. Sandy dunes complete with a hill climb and a
challenging pit of river rock, a narrow, somewhat high-speed loop of mostly hard-packed dirt and
sand, and a dirt drag strip to see if we could find a difference in how well these tires turn
the vehicle's power into forward motion. Since gathering objective data off-road is fraught with
major pitfalls, we've chosen to perform a subjective evaluation, so our drivers' scores
and impressions will tell the story. The criteria we're going to evaluate are acceleration traction,
steering traction and response, and rear axle traction and stability.
For our initial foray into off-road testing, we're performing a category evaluation.
We'll compare a chosen representative tire from four different all-terrain categories,
on-road all-terrain, off-road all-terrain, rugged all-terrain, and off-road max traction.
Of course, we've picked the biggest names in the space to see if both the tires and the categories
they represent can live up to their reputations. The Dueler AT Ascent is Bridgestone's latest entry
in the on-road all-terrain category. In our testing, we found it delivers a very balanced
mix of performance on the road and in the wet and snow, and we're excited to see how this mild
all-terrain tire compares to the more aggressive offerings. The BFGoodrich All-Terrain TA KO3 is
the current model from a legendary lineage. With a long history of Baja 1000 championship wins,
the KO line has been proven time and again in real-world competition, so we knew it would be
a strong representative for the off-road all-terrain category. The Nitto Ridge Grappler could very well
be the most popular rugged all-terrain tire on the market. It's the paradigm of this relatively
new category, and we're going to see if its performance fits between AT and MT, or if rugged
all-terrain is more marketing hype than substance. The BFGoodrich Mud Terrain TA KM3 represents the
most aggressive, most off-road focused category in the evaluation. Off-road max traction tires are
specialized performers, and we're going to see how well this mud specialist can compete with the
more broadly focused all-terrain tires. Over the years, we've tested all four of these tires on the
road, plus wet, dry, snow, and ice, so now it's time to put them to the test in what some enthusiasts
view as their natural habitats. To do that, we used a 2025 Toyota Tacoma TRD Off-Road with our
usual 17x8.5 Method MR703 test wheels. All the tires in the test were LT265 7017
load range E, and were aired down to 20 psi before we started.
Getting ready to start the hill climb in our on-road all-terrain tire.
Up we go. 5, 6, 7, 8, 9, 10, 11, 12, 13 miles an hour. Up, up, up, up, up, up.
We're slowing down, we're slowing down. That's it. It started decently, and then once we got to
serious incline and resistance, you could see the momentum was just sapped away. Right, and pretty
quickly at that, and then it just starts to dig in and you're toast. Yeah, it can't make up for
that loss of momentum. Here's some heavy river rock. Okay, there we go. Found a little grip and
started making some progress. Oh, that gets deeper. We're bogging down. Momentum, keep the
momentum. I'm trying. Still moving. We haven't stopped yet. Now we have. Okay, all right, all
right. That's the end of it. Four-wheel drive saved me. Ready for the short track. Mini hill
climb, sand dune. That's a little bit of a struggle. You give it a little input and there's
some response, but then it just stops. It just washes out, kicks sideways, digs in. Oh, look at
this input. And there we go now. If you get enough speed, it can kind of float on top of it,
but if you ask for acceleration, you slow down, then it really starts to sink in. Dirt loop. This
is definitely hard pack. It's just a fine layer of very loose, dry, powdery sand. It's a little
light on the front, but it's fine. It's responsive. Very responsive, right? Yeah, right. Not bad. I
Okay. Off-road all-terrain. Here we go. Get to the prescribed speed. Yeah, it's glorious.
It's glorious. That's a solid, like, half truck. Me? Three-quarters of a truck longer. Yep.
One thing that I noticed compared to the on-road all-terrain is it feels like you can make more
forward progress once it starts slipping. Yes. On the on-road all-terrain, it was kind of, oh,
once I get slip, it's like, stop. We're going to run it out. All we're doing is spinning. Whereas
this one, it has a bit more like clawing traction to where it makes progress. Now,
the river rock pit. Those lugs are cool, but when they start slipping, they sure do move a lot of
stuff. They do. It's like a badger claw. Oh, we totally got it. You can tell it's got more prowess.
Like, it's trying harder. There's the clawing action, the momentum building. Look at us.
We're picking up speed even. Right. Yep. See, as long as you don't give up, it keeps powering
through. It keeps chugging along. It's like a diesel locomotive. Okay. No, the front-end
authority, absolutely. Yes. There's more bite. There's faster response. It's a different driving
experience. For sure. More controllability. It does more of what you're asking it to,
less of, wow, I'm just along for the ride. Oh yeah, the acceleration. It's not crabbing
off to the side immediately like the last time it did. It's a stronger grip, better control.
On all three of these tests over here on this side.
Okay. It takes more input to elicit a response. See this? Yeah. And then it responds.
The on-road all-terrain tire was much quicker. It is fine on traction. It is good on traction,
but just the steering is, it feels duller. It feels less responsive than the on-road all-terrain,
so it just takes more input and I'm thinking further ahead. Rugged all-terrain category
represented by the Nitto Ridge Grappler. The big name in this space. Yeah. All right. Let's set up
for the old hill climb and off we go. Appropriate speed. There we go. Keep on keeping on. Hop,
wheel hop, axle hop. Oh my, oh my. Good sir. We didn't make it very far up this.
Let's try that again. Go, go, go, go. Oh yeah, I thought I had some fight in that bit. Well,
that was it. Exactly. Okay. Okay. It's certainly not, not capable. Yeah. But I mean, that was
about as good as the on-road, maybe as good as the off-road. Kind of in between. Climbing power.
Not this tire's. Necessarily not necessarily this tire's forte. Let's see how we do through the
river rock. Here a little bit deeper stuff. Not, not the deepest out there. That's for sure. But
this is test bed. Oh, we're doing this. We're moving. We're chugging along. Chugging along.
Okay. And now into the deep stuff. Oh no. Yeah. That's, that's it. We're just,
we're just digging a hole. Try it again. Yeah. Try again. Oh, whoa. Okay. No,
I got, it gave me, it gave me hope there for a minute, but. Oh, it's like,
real talk. It's kind of between the on-road and the off-road, but it's closer to
that. That's the thing with the off-road all-terrain tire is like we said before,
it wasn't moving quickly. It didn't just like waltz through it, but it just kept chugging along.
It was like a diesel locomotive. It just, it just went and he never really stopped. He never really
slowed down. But this one is just not, not doing it. All right. Crabs a little, crabs a little,
but does then make pretty good forward progress. So I get some more responsive. I am adding a lot
of wheel. I agree. I add my input and then half a truck length later. Now it responds and does what
I want it to. Yeah. There's, there's less steering response. The rear end is moving around a little
bit more. It definitely doesn't have the bite of the off-road. No way. Doesn't have the rear
end authority of the off-road either. I mean, good acceleration. Let's put some power down nicely. So
do you think the rear end doesn't step out like right there because it has good traction or
because the front pushes? Because it's understeer. Okay. I absolutely felt some understeer a couple
times and that, yeah, that's, I think you're right. It doesn't feel as tail happy. Yep. I know we've
sort of disagreed a couple of times on steering, but this, this does feel a little slow to me.
Okay. Off-road maximum traction. Yes. This one is focused on mud traction. So more specialized
you get, more specialized. Theoretically, the worse you are at other things, right?
I feel you tiptoeing around it. Lovely amount of throttle control. Oh, so much. Perfect. Okay.
That's all you get. All right. I really, I really want to say, oh yeah, the max traction tire just
completed the hill climb. Didn't complete the hill climb. It's not done completely. Not at our
speeds. The issue I think we're encountering is if this tire starts to slip, it starts to
dig so aggressively that kind of stops everything, especially in two-wheel drive,
which we're doing this in. What's your result? It's not significantly better than the off-road
all-terrain tire. It's, it's arguably harder to drive than the off-road all-terrain. Oh,
look at you. Okay. Yeah. Okay. Chug-a-lugging through the river rock. Still moving. Oh,
it's still moving. It's close though. That was it. That noise indicates that we're done.
Similar thought process. This is a luggy tire similar to the rugged all-terrain tire. It digs
aggressively. People have a tendency to automatically start thinking that a more
aggressive tire is going to be better in every non-paved road situation. And that's just not
the case. Up the hill. A little bit of crab. A little bit. Oh, cool. It is. Yeah. If you let it
dig into something hard, it's, it's, it's got some momentum. Yes, it does. Struggles a little
bit in the super deep sand. Yeah. But no, it's good here. Right. It's not quite off-road all-terrain
good. Correct. Which is something. Yeah. It's more responsive, but not as tight.
Ooh, now the hard question. Off-road all-terrain or max traction on the short course? That's not
a hard question. Oh, okay. What is it? Off-road. The off-road all-terrain. Me too. What happened?
It wants to drift. It does, doesn't it? It has good front end traction, but the rear wants to
move around on you. So you can use it around turns, powering out of turns. Uh, but when you
want to put the power down, sometimes it just sings at you. It barks at you as it, as it slips
and moves the rear end around. I mean, this is hard pack. This is a real surface that people
drive on and the KM3 is, it's good. I mean, it's good. Don't get, don't get it wrong, but it's a,
it is distinct from some of the others, from all of the others, in my opinion, not hugely, but
different. To test the raw acceleration traction of our four tires, we use the Badlands side-by-side
drag strip, which is a mostly level field of hard pack dirt. We use the manual shifting feature of
the Tacoma and with left foot braking, we built the engine speed to 2000 RPMs for the launch.
We performed multiple zero to 30 runs in each direction to help eliminate variables from the
surface as best we could. We measured our results in feet required to accelerate to 30 instead of
seconds. More tire spin meant more distance traveled before the vehicle reached the target
speed. The tightly packed dirt didn't provide much for the tires to bite into and the on-road
all-terrain and off-road all-terrain tires with their tighter patterns led the test.
The results between the two were close enough that they should be considered a tie,
but the off-road all-terrain tire edged out the objective results with a 90.3 foot average
compared to 91.2 for the on-road all-terrain. From there, the rugged all-terrain tire needed
97.7 feet and the off-road max traction tire took a foot further at 98.8 feet.
The results were very close, but the BFGoodrich All-Terrain TAK-03 represented the off-road
all-terrain category masterfully and rose to the top leading on the dunes, in the dirt,
and on the drag strip. It delivered the highest level of lateral grip at both the front and rear
axles in most conditions and earned the highest subjective scoring every metric but one,
and even that was somewhat contested between our drivers. Without any real mud in this comparison,
the BFGoodrich Mud Terrain TAK-03 didn't have the opportunity to show its true strengths,
but nonetheless it performed very well overall, earning a runner-up position for the off-road
max traction category. The contrast between its results in the loose surfaces found on the dunes
and the hard pack of the dirt track and drag strip are an excellent illustration of an important
point. The words off-road can mean different things, and depending on what your off-road is,
simply moving to a more aggressive tire may not always provide more traction.
The rugged all-terrain category as a whole is still struggling to carve out its place in the
tire world. Are rugged all-terrain tires detuned MT products? Are they more aggressive ATs? Are
they intended to look the part without any real traction benefits? Our evaluation of the Ridge
Grappler didn't do anything to clear those muddy waters, as it fell into a middle ground finishing
third in all three aspects of our evaluation. We liked its acceleration traction in the planted
rear end in the dirt, but its modest front axle traction in the sand and the dirt made us wonder
if the rear only felt stable because the front didn't have the grip to elicit any rotation.
As much as we try to avoid any preconceived notions when we're evaluating tires,
the Bridgestone Dueler ATSN's results were in line with what one might expect from an
on-road all-terrain tire in the conditions we encountered. In loose rock, dirt, or sand,
the lack of void space in the pattern limited its clawing traction compared to the more aggressive
categories. But on the hard pack of the dirt loop and the drag strip, more rubber in the contact
patch meant more grip, which turned the tables on the competition. We hope you found this video
helpful for finding the right all-terrain tire based on what, where, and how you drive. Later
on in the year, we're going to take the four tires featured in this video and we're going to
run them through our gravel road cut-and-chip durability testing, so be on the lookout for
that update in early 2026. In the meantime, if you have any questions or other feedback,
leave them in the comment section below. We try to read and respond to as many of those as we can,
and of course, be sure to like and subscribe. And as always, thanks for watching.
