Caravaggio Oil Painting Masterclass | Part 1: Dramatic Underpainting Technique
Welcome to the first part of my masterclass series where I explore the dramatic and powerful painting technique of Caravaggio — one of the greatest masters of the Baroque era.
In this episode, we begin with the foundational step of any classical oil painting: the underpainting. Using a fragment from David with the Head of Goliath (1607), I demonstrate how to establish values, form, and composition using the grisaille method — just as Caravaggio might have done.
What you'll learn:
- How to start an oil painting in the style of the Old Masters - Caravaggio’s chiaroscuro and dramatic lighting techniques - Step-by-step underpainting process using a limited palette - Tips for creating strong value contrasts and mood
Chapters: 00:00 Introduction 00:48 Toning the Canvas 01:23 Tranfering the Drawing 02:05 Underpainting with Burnt Umber 03:54 Adding Titanium White 05:48 Painting the Background 06:52 Working on Details 09:00 Stages of Work using Caravaggio's Technique 09:48 What is Chiaroscuro
🖌️ Whether you're a beginner or an experienced painter, this video will help you understand the power of a strong underpainting and how to bring drama into your work — the Caravaggio way.
👉 Don’t forget to subscribe to catch Part 2 — where we start layering color!
Would you believe me if I told you that you actually can paint like Caravaggio?
My name is Nick, this is my art channel, and today I'm going to try to prove it to you.
Caravaggio has always inspired and fascinated me, so I finally decided to make a short masterclass
in which we will explore the technique of this great artist and try to paint a master copy
of a fragment of the painting David with the head of Goliath, originally painted in 1607.
I think it will be several videos because I won't be able to fit it all into one.
Anyway, as usual, I start by toning the canvas, applying the imprimatur.
As you know, the imprimatur is a layer of paint mixed with a thinner
that is applied to the canvas or wooden board in order to get rid of the white at the very
beginning of the work and provide a mid-tone from which you can move both towards the shadows and
towards the light. Caravaggio approached surface preparation differently, and I will return to this
little later and talk about his method. After I applied the imprimatur and let the paint dry
completely, I began to transfer the prepared drawing. It is worth noting that Caravaggio
didn't make a preparatory drawing. Researches on his paintings suggest that he immediately
sketched the outlines of the figures with a brush, correcting and modifying them as he went along.
He used earth tones for this, so I also will use burnt umber, and immediately after transferring
the drawing, I will begin creating a monochrome underpainting. X-ray images of Caravaggio's
paintings give us some idea of how he worked. Unfortunately, he left nothing written, unlike
Leonardo, for example, who left posterity a wealth of information about his painting methods
in countless notes. But in any case, we know for sure that Caravaggio always started his work
with a monochrome underpainting. Therefore, we will follow his example. We also know,
from some evidence, that he worked very quickly, applying paint with three confident brush strokes.
Therefore, I also try to paint quickly, without delving too deeply into details at this stage of
work. Because right now it's important to create a general impression of form and volume,
and to establish the correct tonal relationships. That's why I have taken a fairly large brush,
and I'm trying to maracle the shadow areas of the painting as quickly as possible.
Then I will switch to a smaller brush and work on the details.
Once the underpainting is finished, I will let the painting dry for a couple of days. Burnt
umber dries fairly quickly, as do other airy pigments, which is why they are commonly used
to create the underpainting. Once the painting has dried, I begin working with white,
covering all the light areas of the painting with it. Caravaggio worked in the same way.
He made a kind of grisaille, first marking the shadow areas, and then the light areas.
For this purpose, I usually use titanium white, although Caravaggio used lead white.
But in this video, we will not delve into the study of historical materials,
because our goal is not to completely reconstruct the painting using historical pigments.
Our goal is to explore the stages of Caravaggio's work,
to try to touch upon his painting technique, and then to use this knowledge in our own original
works. That's why I use modern pigments, which are available to everyone today in any art store.
In Caravaggio's time, titanium white had not yet been invented, and all artists used lead white.
In terms of its characteristics, it's undoubtedly better than titanium white,
frankly speaking. Firstly, its shade is much warmer and more natural. Titanium white is too cold,
and you will not find such a cold, lifeless white in nature. Secondly, it forms a denser surface,
and is less susceptible to changes over time. And finally, the last advantage is that it dries
much faster. However, lead white has one but very big drawback. It's incredibly toxic,
and that's exactly why many countries have restricted its production.
Nevertheless, titanium white is also an excellent option, so don't worry about it.
As you can see, at this stage of the work, I use the same approach as in the previous one.
I cover large areas of the work with a large brush, without thinking about the details yet.
I apply the strokes quickly and confidently, forcing myself to think globally,
without getting distracted by the details. Then I take a smaller brush again,
and work out the small details more carefully and precisely.
When I have finished the first layer of white, I let the work dry a little bit again,
and then add a little of black to my palette to work out the shadows and details in more detail.
In addition, I will apply another layer of white to make the surface more uniform and smooth,
to level out these large rough strokes a little bit.
Returning to the question of historical pigments, Caravaggio used carbon black,
but you can use whatever black you have available.
Remember, at the very beginning of the video, when we were talking about the imprimatur,
I mentioned that Caravaggio used a different approach.
I have to apply a colored imprimatur, because for these demonstrations I buy cheap wooden panels,
which are already primed with white acrylic primer, while Caravaggio introduced the base
color he needed at the priming stage. That is, the primer, the base that he applied to
rough thick linen canvas, already contained the pigment of the required color.
The basis of Caravaggio's paintings is earthy, warm, brown tones,
often reddish. Such colors are, in general, very characteristic of the Italian school.
In my case, I used a mixture of burnt sienna and burnt umber for imprimatur,
to get closer to the shades used by great Caravaggio.
And I think I succeeded. I mixed a very good shade of a base and, in fact,
I hardly need to darken it at all. Caravaggio did the same thing. In some places,
he left areas of brown ground untouched. And you can see this for yourself by
carefully observing his paintings. Anyway, we have gone through the steps
that will allow us to easily create a good solid foundation for the future painting
in Caravaggio's style. Let's list them again. Preparation of the canvas, applying a dark
imprimatur, transferring the drawing, painting with burnt umber, then working with white,
and then working with detail. You may also notice that in the early stages of working on the
painting, I created a dark, saturated background, which is very typical of Caravaggio's paintings.
This technique, founded by Caravaggio himself, is called chiaroscuro, which translates from the
Italian as light and shadow. This technique involves a sharp contrast between light and
shadow to achieve the effect of greater volume and three-dimensionality of the object.
It also creates a feeling of tension and drama, and indeed, how much more expressive my work
became when I made that dark black background. I believe that this is the key to Caravaggio's
technique. It is this striking contrast that creates the gloomy and dramatic atmosphere
so characteristic of all his works. Well, my friends, I think that's enough for today.
We will definitely continue in the next video, so stay tuned. If you have any questions,
feel free to ask them in the comments, as usual. I wish you all the best and see you in the next
episode. Bye!