THE GEOPOLITICAL IMPACT OF CRYPTO AND DIGITAL CURRENCIES

Parliamentary Intelligence-Security Forum
3 followers
Dec 28, 2025
Dr. Oonagh McDonald- CBE- Former Member OF Parliament, United Kingdom
29th Parliamentary Intelligence- Security Forum- Madrid-Spain 🇪🇸
Dr. McDonald, the floor is yours.
Well thank you very much, I'm delighted to be here and I've enjoyed some disputes I would have with some people in the last session, but that's the way we learn and develop.
I'm going to start by talking, I want to focus on stable coins.
And first of all a little bit of history before I move on to current situation.
Some of you may remember, still around, Mark Zuckerberg, but what you may remember was his efforts to introduce a stable coin called Libra.
And what he wanted to do was to set that, not against one currency, but a basket of currencies.
Which immediately raised the question, well who's to judge the value of Libra against a basket of currencies as opposed to the much more simple exchanges that most of us are used to.
Why was he seeking to do this? Ah, Zuckerberg told us, this was all around the issue of remittances.
Which is, of course, from families living in better off countries sending money back to their relatives at home very often and wanted to send it quickly and safely.
But I watched with interest because I knew that with 20 central bank governors advising FINMA that Libra was never going to take off.
Okay, so why should remittances just be left in the hands of a stable coin company such as Zuckerberg's?
Well, I would say no, but there are two issues that countries have to take on board.
First of all, for the UK for a long time and the EU as well, we have had access to the banking system through a basic bank account.
People who really don't earn very much money and whose money would be into a bank account one month or one week and all of it would go out on all of their commitments at the end of that month.
So a basic bank account but served as a means for keeping your money in a safe place and the possibility of transferring that money.
What was needed was quicker, safer, simpler payment systems and they came into being in the UK, in the EU and America is moving forward.
I say moving forward now because they were behind the trajectory that was needed to transfer money quickly and safely.
So the whole argument for a stable coin from Zuckerberg's point of view disappeared and I think that's one of the reasons why Libra disappeared.
Okay, I am now just going to ask a fundamental question about a stable coin.
Why do you want to buy a stable coin, a dollar stable coin?
Here you are, you're in the US, why do you want to buy one?
Because that is supposed to be fully redeemable against the US dollar.
Whether it always achieves that or whether you can be certain of that is another matter.
It depends on its reserves and I'll come on to that in a few moments.
I just want to make the point that the first step in aiding people who have very little money is to make sure that they do have access to banking for the security of their money
and to make sure that transfers are simple, easy and straightforward for them.
One of the payment services I looked at in the UK, I went to their website, I could see exactly how much the person was going to try to send to another country.
Centrally I could see the exchange rate and then I could see exactly how much the person who was sending money from A to B, how much B would get.
Simple, straightforward, all there, on the website and you could read it and have that assurance.
Because those sort of payment systems are regulated in pretty well every country
and a country without a regulation of a basic bank account needs to introduce it.
So that I think defeated the need and the reason why I pose the question is of course nobody gives you a stablecoin for nothing.
So you've got your dollars but people are going to charge you to change it into a stablecoin,
charge for the transfer and turning your dollar stablecoin back into US dollars or whatever you wanted would have to be paid for at the other end.
And then of course there's the use of blockchain.
Blockchain is becoming, it was already a slowish method because you had to have what were originally called nodes.
Nodes really mean computers.
Bitcoin talked about, the introduction of Bitcoin talked about honest nodes.
I do not know of any honest or dishonest computers.
I know of honest users of computers and dishonest users of computers but I don't actually know any honest computers.
In other words, that moral term does not apply to a computer.
And you would have to wait for the mining so-called to take place, a 51% agreement that this transaction should go ahead.
Nowadays there are more than one blockchain and what happens is that blockchains can get congested
because a lot of exchanges who are transferring stablecoins decide to transfer them in batches
and the large batches simply take longer to be transferred in the manner in which I've described that transference taking place.
So what are we left with and I want to talk specifically about Tether now.
Why am I picking on Tether?
It is a US dominated stablecoin.
It was until a few weeks ago over 70% of the stablecoin market.
Then it dropped to 61% but the latest I checked yesterday is 63%.
So it is still the dominant stablecoin in the market and when it was over 70% and it's creeping up again
it's just got another 7% to go before it hits 70% again.
In effect Tether is the only stablecoin in the market and it has a very interesting history.
Until very recently it was located in the British Virgin Islands.
It was only registered as a company there and tagged to the company registration was always in good standing
which always made me smile or sometimes laugh my head off because in good standing? Who are you kidding?
Never registered. It was supposed to register last year when the virtual asset payment service legislation took effect.
It was supposed to register by July last year. It did not register at all in the British Virgin Islands.
I have to say because it was a British protectorate so I'm sorry to say that that was so corrupt that the government had to be replaced.
It should have been taken under direct rule by the British Parliament but Liz Trust the short-lived Prime Minister
whom you may remember refused to do that and then the matter sort of got lost.
But sadly corruption prevailed in the British Virgin Islands so it's not very surprised that it did not make it
to be registered under the British Virgin Islands Financial Services Commission.
However it has now moved to El Salvador and it falls under El Salvador's adoption of BASP the relevant legislation.
Now some of you might have heard that this young new president of El Salvador wanted to make Bitcoin the currency of the country.
He introduced that. That experiment after four years has just collapsed and of course El Salvador was one of many US dollar dominated countries
and I suppose he wanted to move away from dependence on the US dollar in El Salvador.
But the company has moved and it is now headquartered in El Salvador and falls under El Salvador's financial regulation permission.
Make of that what you will.
Until very recently Tether never issued any audited bank accounts whatsoever.
Instead it had a quarterly attestation which simply said that it had the reserves in US treasuries sufficient to back its US dollar dependence.
Whether or not it had that I do not know.
Its treasuries were managed by Cantor Fitzgerald whose CEO is now Commerce Secretary in the US administration and there's a new CEO of it.
But its audited accounts are with BDO in Milan with the same senior partner who used to verify its attestation that it had sufficient dollar reserves.
He's the chief signatory I noticed.
It would be interesting to read the audited reports and to examine those audits.
Very interesting I suspect.
Why am I going on about Tether?
Partly because of its dominance and partly because of its use.
It uses blockchain in the same way as Bitcoin and others have used blockchain.
In other words you have your private key and your public key.
So A sends money to B.
You know that that transaction has taken place.
But what you don't know is who is A and who is B.
And that is going to be the problem always with a stablecoin.
You're not sure that there's sufficient backing and it's difficult for you to ensure that whether there's sufficient backing in terms of US treasuries if it's a US stablecoin.
You're not sure whether there's sufficient there to ensure that that takes place.
You are not as a user of Tether.
You're not as a user told how you are going to redeem Tethers and how much it's going to cost you.
But it is quite clear that Tether is being used by Russia for example in purchasing weapons.
So once again you don't know who is selling the weapons and who exactly in Russia is benefiting from that purchase.
So the problem with stablecoins is their misuse.
How are we going to deal with the Tethers of this world?
It's changed its blockchain.
It is now using the blockchain called Tron which is headed up by Justin Sun who is the owner of that particular blockchain.
And who apparently resides in Geneva in Switzerland.
So that is the blockchain that's being used.
They change blockchains. There's more than one in existence.
Because some blockchains are speedier than others because they're not going to be so heavily used.
So what can we do about it?
And of course FATFEE does already require under its travel rule that you should know who A is who is sending money to B.
And how much they're sending.
Because of course some companies have limits on transactions of their own currencies to other countries.
So I think that the best way of dealing with these is to actually make sure that they don't only adopt VASP
but you want to see that the travel rule is really really enforced.
And if you enforce that then the value of stablecoins like Tether will diminish.
In my view because the point is anonymity of the transfer.
And if you can undo that anonymity and coupled with what I suggested earlier
proper basic bank accounts in whatever country has those or can reintroduce them
then banks, who of course a basic bank account is not going to bring them any money
it might actually be a loser for them.
But they're properly regulated, they do fail regulations from time to time
but you do give an opportunity for people for safe transfer of goods.
Let me just give you another example from someone who was working for me as a builder
and one day I was setting off with a large handbag.
And he said, why are you taking a large handbag?
I said, why wouldn't I?
El Salvador, if you took a large handbag out with you that meant that you were carrying a lot of cash.
And you would be lucky if you were able to take that cash to wherever you wanted it to be taken.
That's what most people in El Salvador had to resort to, carrying cash around
because no banking system was available to them for safe conduct and security of their supply.
So let's bear that in mind and really go after stable coins with transparency.
Thank you.
Which everyone should be obliged to do.
Thank you Dr. McDonald, well said.
Thank you.
