China’s Economy Collapses! From Street Stalls to Wall Street, Everyone Fakes a Thriving Business

Global Finance News
11 followers
What's going on here? The owner of this orange stall is faking it, creating the illusion of
lots of customers and a mess on the ground. They want people to think business is booming.
What's going on here? The owner of this snack shop is doing the same thing. Even if there are
no customers, they still want passersby to think business is doing fine. And they'll throw some
napkins on the ground for good measure. What's going on here? The owner of this lottery shop
is doing the same thing, making it look like a lot of people are buying lottery tickets.
But the last thing you want to do is follow that strategy. Once people realize no one is winning,
they'll stop buying. What's going on here? The owner of this liquor stand is doing the same
thing, tossing peanut shells to create the illusion and even putting empty bottles around
to make it look more authentic. What's going on here? The owner of this e-bike repair shop is
doing the same thing, even rubbing some oil on their face and arms to make it seem busier.
What's going on here? The shoe store owner is doing the same thing. If you add some footprints
on the shoe boxes, it'll look even more convincing. As China's economy continues
to struggle and consumer confidence declines, a troubling trend is emerging across industries.
Businesses are inflating their sales and performance to maintain appearances,
a practice that Chinese people called baiting the fish. From small street vendors to large,
well-capitalized companies, many are using various tactics to create the illusion that
their businesses are thriving. The term baiting the fish refers to the practice of using bait to
lure fish into a specific area, creating the appearance of a busy fishing spot. Only when
the fish gather, does the fisherman set the hook. In business, this term is used to describe
companies artificially inflating their sales, performance, or popularity to maintain market
confidence and attract customers or investors. As real demand weakens, this practice is spreading
from small businesses to the capital markets, creating a more dangerous and systemic issue.
E-commerce in particular has become one of the worst hit sectors for data manipulation.
This is no surprise, as e-commerce platforms rely heavily on key performance indicators like
sales volume, rankings, conversion rates, positive reviews, and gross merchandise value.
These numbers directly impact platform traffic allocation, brand financing, marketing,
government subsidies, and even stock evaluations. Of these, GMV, or gross merchandise value,
is the most commonly referenced, and often the most inflated. GMV refers to the total value of
goods sold on a platform, calculated based on product prices during a specific period. In other
words, GMV reflects how much appears to have been sold on paper, not the actual cash paid by
consumers. Since GMV is based on list prices, it typically doesn't account for discounts,
vouchers, or subsidies, which can significantly inflate the figures. Sometimes, even if only a
deposit is paid, or the final amount is pending, the full price is counted in GMV. Therefore,
while GMV might appear high, the actual money consumers spend is often much lower. From a
business standpoint, fake sales on e-commerce are less about the actual transactions, more about
creating the appearance that people are buying. This characteristic makes GMV a hot spot for
sales manipulation. Douyin user frogbro
Regarding the current e-commerce environment, a lot of people probably have the same question.
Why do some live streams generate billions, even tens of billions, in sales? Honestly,
I had my doubts too. Given the current consumer environment, we all have an idea of how much
these products can actually sell for. Then, I realized, the issue isn't about the selling
capability, but about how GMV is calculated. It's way more inflated than we think. For example,
one live streamer was selling a 360 yuan cosmetic set. He said you don't need to pay the full 360
right now, just a 60 yuan deposit, and that counts as a pre-sale. So, consumers are only
paying 1 sixth, and the product hasn't even been sold yet. But in this case, some platforms
calculate the GMV based on the full 360 yuan. For higher priced items, like those over 1000 yuan,
if you only charge a tiny deposit, it creates massive leverage. For example, a 1000 yuan
product with just a 50 yuan deposit equals 20 times the leverage. This means a product that
claims to have a 1 billion yuan GMV could actually only generate 50 million yuan in cash flow.
He also pointed out a new method of inflating sales in Chinese e-commerce, falsely reporting
the number of sales. For example, a 360 yuan cosmetic set contains 5 items, and each item
is counted as a sale. So, while the sales number might show 500 sets sold, only 100 sets were
actually sold. The most significant issue is that the numbers displayed to consumers are
intentionally broken down into the smallest units. For instance, a set, a bottle, or a single item
is often reported as a sale of a certain number of units, though it's the sum of individual items
sold. By combining these two tactics, low deposits, creating leverage, and splitting items into
smaller units, an e-commerce livestream's GMV number can be exaggerated by dozens or even
hundreds of times. Aside from e-commerce, food delivery platforms are also heavily impacted by
this baiting-the-fish practice. A private conversation recorded by a user revealed
the real operations behind this baiting strategy. In the conversation, a food delivery worker
claiming to earn millions annually was asked whether he really made money from food delivery.
His direct response was no. He explained that the most effective way to quickly boost sales
and turnover was by faking orders. However, he emphasized that these weren't fake data,
but real data fake business. The process is straightforward. The operator arranges for
someone to place an order and pays a commission. The order is processed through the platform,
generating real data. Delivery drivers pick up and deliver the food, but the delivery consists
of just an empty box. The food doesn't exist. Afterward, the person who places the order
leaves a brief positive review with a picture provided by the business and uploads it to the
app. On the platform, everything appears legitimate. There's an order, a delivery,
a review, and sales growth, but in reality, there are no actual consumers or purchases.
When asked how they earned a million a year, their response was surprising.
Through selling the business, not through operations. They explained that a new food
delivery business, from registration to generating impressive data, can cost as little as a few
hundred yuan. But once the sales, ratings, and revenues are boosted, the business can be sold
for hundreds of thousands of yuan. For example, a shop that costs 500 yuan to set up can be sold
for over 300,000 yuan after manipulating the data. The difference in price is the actual profit.
Whether the buyer can continue running the business or whether the platform's risk control
will catch it isn't their concern. This shows that on some platforms, sales, ratings,
and revenue are no longer just results of business operations. There are commodities
that can be fabricated, packaged, and traded. Fake sales have become a widespread method of
survival and profit. It's important to note that such fraudulent practices continue to spread
across industries. On December 20th, Guizhou Bailin Pharmaceutical Group was fined by regulatory
authorities. The company and several executives were penalized for inflating profits and
misrepresenting business performance. The penalty notice revealed that the company's annual reports
from 2019 to 2023 contained false records. From 2019 to 2021, the company inflated profits by
655 million yuan, and in 2023, it understated profits by 459 million yuan. The company was
Chairman Jiang Wei was fined 5 million yuan and banned from the securities market for 10 years.
Other senior executives were fined between 700,000 and 3.5 million yuan. A registered accountant in
Beijing, who was interviewed by Huaxia Times, explained that this is a common method of
financial fraud in listed companies. By reducing sales expenses and adjusting profits, companies
make the inflated sales appear more reasonable. This strategy can temporarily improve financial
reports and stabilize market expectations, but it carries significant risks. This case is not
isolated. On the same day, other companies including ST Yuanzhi, Yongfang, and Baiyi Steel
also disclosed administrative penalties. Yuandao inflated revenue by 123 million yuan in 2019,
66.2 million yuan in 2020, and 138 million yuan in 2021. The company was fined 6 million yuan,
and former chairman Kang Baohua was fined 3 million yuan. Fuendongfang was fined 6.5 million
yuan for false financial reporting, and Baiyi Steel was fined 1.5 million yuan and 2 million
yuan for failing to disclose major non-operating fund transactions with its controlling shareholder,
a significant omission in their reports. The logic behind these cases is clear. It's not
just about improving financial reports, but making sales and performance look good to
appearances. One of the most notable examples of inflating sales is China's EV sector. The
authenticity of sales data from car manufacturers has sparked widespread doubt and criticism.
The authorities can't sit back any longer. Car manufacturers are faking sales figures.
In China, the total annual car sales are about 20 million, yet in just half a year,
several car manufacturers have accumulated nearly 100 million orders. Can you believe
this ridiculous manipulation? Now, at car manufacturers' press conferences, it's not
about boasting for a few minutes and selling a few thousand units. It's about flaunting selling
100,000 cars in a few hours. And these are cars that cost hundreds of thousands. Many people
haven't even seen the car in person, and they're already placing orders? Are we all that rich,
or is it just me, the only poor one here? It turns out that car manufacturers are borrowing
tactics from the mobile phone industry, creating fake data and inflating sales. They hold a press
conference, claim they're selling out, and treat consumers like fools. This has gotten so bad that
even Xinhua News Agency and Economic Daily had to speak out. They directly called for a closer
look at these inflated orders. Another user said,
Many domestic brands, especially in the electric vehicle sector, including some joint ventures,
are doing the same thing, faking sales. I can say with certainty that this has become an
issue. The most direct evidence is the rise in zero mileage used cars, many of which are
registered under the company's name. Zero mileage cars, under personal names, might be cancellations
or display cars. But what about the large volume of used new cars flooding the secondary market?
The answer is simple. The companies are inflating sales. They register the cars, count them as sales,
then resell them on the secondary market, creating the illusion that the cars are selling well,
to confuse consumers. The process isn't complicated. The brand or dealers organize employees,
suppliers, or acquaintances to place orders, complete the entire purchasing process,
and then cancel the orders. In some cases, the deposits aren't even refundable. I've personally
seen this happen, and can confidently say that there's a lot of manipulation involved.
Here's the message for consumers. Don't just rely on the sales figures published by car manufacturers.
If a company is willing to fake sales numbers, how much credibility can you trust with their products,
services, or long-term commitments? Buying a car isn't a small decision. Stay calm.
Check official registration data and real-world visibility, and make an informed judgment.
This year, the methods of inflating sales have evolved. Some car manufacturers have moved beyond
internal manipulation, and now use marketing firms to create campaigns with terms like
small orders over 10,000, or orders hitting the limit. They deliberately inflate refundable orders
to create the illusion of a hot market. This has turned sales manipulation from an individual tactic
to a fully organized ecosystem. The root cause is the intense need among Chinese EV makers for
impressive sales figures. Sales are not just important for market confidence and consumer
decision making. They also affect financing, valuations, and policy support. In addition to
baiting the fish, inflated sales data can serve as leverage when applying for national subsidies
or securing policy resources. With various incentives at play, sales manipulation has become
increasingly professionalized, eventually evolving into a systemic fraud model. In September, NIO
Chairman Li Bing, speaking at the 2025 NIO Day, joked that if all the so-called order numbers from
car manufacturers were added up, the total would likely reach 100 million. However, the actual
annual sales in China's car market are only slightly over 30 million vehicles. This huge gap
exposes the various inflation of industry order data. Li Bing emphasized that many car companies
are eager to show off orders and compete on numbers. This practice serves marketing narratives
rather than genuine demand, and it can mislead the market and disrupt the balance between
production and sales. It may even create long-term risks for the businesses involved. At this point,
a clear pattern has emerged. In the current economic downturn, businesses can't survive
without bending the truth. This is why small vendors create artificial buzz, businesses inflate
sales numbers, companies tell stories to maintain growth, and projects follow processes just to
appear well-regulated. No matter the size, everyone is generating sales and creating an atmosphere of
success. The situation ultimately stems from the Chinese government's long-standing practice of
systemically manipulating data, which has hidden real risks and allowed problems to accumulate.
On December 15th, the National Bureau of Statistics released data that clearly showed one
thing. China's economy is cooling. Let's start with the production side. Industrial added value
grew by only 4.8 percent, the lowest since August. On the consumption side, total retail sales grew
by just 1.3 percent, the worst performance in three years, and it has been slowing for six
consecutive months. Even with a double 11 shopping festival, consumer spending has not improved.
In November, appliance sales dropped by 19 percent year-on-year, the worst performance since 2020.
Investment also weakened, with fixed asset investment down 2.6 percent and real estate
investment falling by 15.9 percent. Housing market and transaction volumes continue to decline.
The real estate risk is accelerating. In November, the year-on-year decline in housing prices
in 70 cities widened to 2.8 percent. Even Vanka, considered a top performer,
is struggling with debt extensions and is facing default risks. The International Monetary Fund
has warned that about 70 percent of Chinese household wealth is tied up in real estate,
and it could cost up to 5 percent of GDP to clean up the mess over the next three years.
As for the auto industry, November should have been the peak season,
but car sales dropped 8.5 percent year-on-year. Reuters and Bloomberg both reported that domestic
demand continues to fall, and the ongoing slump in investment and real estate is directly
undermining consumer confidence. The actual economic situation is even weaker than before
stimulus policies were introduced. The external environment has worsened as well, with France
and Mexico signaling increased tariffs, and the future of U.S.-China trade remains unclear.
If exports are blocked and domestic consumption doesn't pick up, many companies won't be able to
survive. As a result, as the year ends, reports of business closures, foreign withdrawals,
and rising unemployment are becoming more common. Cities like Beijing and Dongguan,
once bustling and representative, are now described by many as visibly bleak. Despite
this, the Central Economic Work Conference continues to emphasize pressing ahead under
pressure and long-term positive prospects. However, to the international community,
the Chinese Communist Party's data manipulation is no secret. In the official narrative,
economic data has long been used as a tool to maintain political legitimacy and advanced
government achievements, rather than reflecting reality. This is a classic example of political
baiting of the fish. The core idea is not that the business is actually doing well,
but that the scene is made to look good. Sales are inflated, hype is created, and data is piled
up to create the illusion of a booming market. Meanwhile, the actual transactions, profits,
and demand are intentionally sidelined. The CCP's data manipulation logic follows the same pattern.
The goal is not to address problems or face reality, but to maintain appearances,
stabilize expectations, and protect the narrative. As long as growth appears to be ongoing and
reports can be submitted, the continued shrinkage of the underlying demand,
large-scale business closures, and the systemic loss of public confidence can be ignored.
The problem, however, is that baiting the fish can deceive people for a period of time,
but it can never deceive reality. When the fake prosperity is prolonged long enough,
real demand is exhausted, and the risks will inevitably accumulate and backfire at some point.
When that happens, no matter how much the data is modified or the narrative adjusted,
the economy will no longer be able to support the performance.
When it comes to maintaining prostate and breast health, you deserve a proactive approach,
one that supports wellness from within. Introducing Best Doctors WBM Rex,
your natural supplement to support prostate and breast health, boost immune function,
and enhance overall wellness. Packed with powerful ingredients like white button mushrooms,
notoginsen, and antioxidants, WBM Rex helps maintain healthy PSA levels,
reduces inflammation, and supports cellular health in the prostate and breast.
With added energy-boosting Panax notoginsen and immune-boosting beta-glucans,
WBM Rex helps you stay active, healthy, and full of vitality. Clinically backed and made
with plant-based ingredients, WBM Rex is your go-to solution for long-term wellness and balance.
Give the joy of health this Christmas with WBM Rex, because the well-being of your loved ones
matters. And don't forget, use our special discount code CO2025 at checkout to get 20%
off your order exclusively for our China Observer viewers.
