Unearthed Secrets: Ancient Jewish Life in Medieval Europe – Documentary - MDW

Ancient Europe: History, culture and Humans
93 followers
11 Video Views·Dec 27, 2025
Was it you who also had a piece of wood?
Yes, it was.
Number fifty?
Four.
This piece of wood is all black.
The history of the Jewish people is a story of dispersal.
As they gradually settled throughout the ancient world,
Jewish communities left traces of their presence,
which have now been revealed by archaeology.
Since the beginning of our time,
Jewish people have lastingly established themselves
in the societies of the East and West,
both in cities and the countryside.
Thanks to archaeology,
the Jewish presence in Europe during the Middle Ages and earlier
is slowly coming to light through Jewish quarters,
synagogues, ritual baths,
but also cemeteries and funeral steels.
The remains discovered by archaeologists
helps complete the work of historians.
Together, they draw a new portrait of these long-forgotten communities.
The oldest archaeological finds
revealing Jewish presence in the Jordan Valley
date back to the early first millennium BC.
Thanks to a multitude of sites uncovered around the Mediterranean,
we know that Jewish communities existed
and settled in the area for long periods of time.
They were large enough to construct buildings,
the remains of which have stood the test of time.
In Dura-Europos, Syria,
a synagogue with beautiful paintings was discovered,
reflecting a rich and well-established community
along the Euphrates River.
After founding important communities in the eastern Mediterranean,
with Greek as their language of trade,
the Jews settled in the west of the Roman Empire.
In Rome, in the heart of the Eternal City,
a unique site suggests the Jews were able to live in the city peacefully,
as they buried their dead alongside the Christians.
Discovered in the mid-19th century,
the Vigna Randonini catacombs
are a huge network of underground tunnels
used by Christians at the start of the first millennium.
Researcher Elsa Lorenzi
has worked extensively on this exceptional site.
The discovery was a big surprise,
because it was previously believed that
these catacombs were exclusively used by Christians.
In truth, the large painted menorahs and inscriptions
provide immediate proof that this catacomb was Jewish.
The term catacomb comes from the Greek katakombi or Latin kumba,
which means cave or quarry.
It also means near the caves and near the quarries.
These are graves dug into the rock,
but that doesn't mean they were originally meant for burials.
The inscriptions in the Jewish catacombs were in Greek and Latin,
rarely in Hebrew.
And when they were in Hebrew, it was just a few words.
Shalom, for example.
This leads us to believe it was a very integrated community
that practiced the language of the place in which it lived.
But it was also very mobile,
because the world of the Roman Empire was bilingual.
I also think it was a diasporic community that moved and traded.
The Jewish catacombs of the Vigna Randonini,
much like the Christian tombs, are ornately decorated.
The ceilings and walls feature various decorations,
like mythical birds,
bouquets of flowers,
and ornate medallions.
There are even depictions taken from the pagans.
A winged victory,
a cherub in flight,
and fish.
These decorations violate the prohibition for Jews to represent living beings,
demonstrating that Roman Jews were deeply imbued with a Latin culture.
I think they were a very integrated community.
In Rome, the Jewish community dates back to at least the 2nd century BC.
In the 1st century BC,
Jews received special treatment from Caesar,
who granted them a series of privileges.
They benefited from measures aimed at protecting them in one way or another.
We know that Caesar was very loved by the Jews.
When he was assassinated,
historical sources claim the Jews went to the Forum to mourn him.
According to writer Flavius Josephus,
a Romanized Jew from the 1st century AD,
some 30,000 to 40,000 Jews were present in Rome at that time.
They were mainly located in Trastevere,
on the right bank of the Tiber River.
It was a prosperous, well-integrated community
whose worship was perfectly tolerated.
Nearby, in Ostia Antica,
one of Italy's most beautiful and extensive archaeological sites
are the remains of a vast synagogue on the south side of the city.
Excavations show it was active from the 1st to the 4th century AD.
Written records reveal there were many Jews in this port city,
who traded by sea with the rest of the Mediterranean.
The extraordinary expansion of the Roman Empire
lasted until the end of the 5th century,
reaching as far as northern Europe.
Along with Roman armies,
many travelers, merchants, and administrators
moved north along the Roman rivers and roads.
Among them were Jewish merchants.
But in Western Europe, and in France in particular,
there are few traces of this ancient presence,
and its existence is largely ignored.
As a result, any object found and identified
as belonging to the Jewish world is a major discovery.
In Paris, at the Museum of Art and History of Judaism,
a beautiful collection of Jewish funerary steels is on display,
along with other objects unearthed by archaeologists.
Museum director Paul Salmona
actively supports research in Judaism archaeology.
Today, he is examining the inscription on a small stone steel
found in Auch, in the south of France.
That's a menorah with seven branches.
It isn't simplified, it actually has seven.
And then there's a palm branch, a lulav,
which was used for the celebration of Sukkot.
Reading the steels always provides valuable information
about the deceased and their ancestry.
The large steels on display at the museum
come from a medieval cemetery on Rue de la Haute in Paris.
Here's a beautiful Hebrew inscription that says,
This is the funeral steel of our Master Rabbi Solomon,
son of our Master Rabbi Judas,
who transitioned to the Garden of Eden
on the Sabbath of the Korah Perikope,
in the Jewish calendar year of 5041.
May his memory live on in the world,
may his soul be bound in the bodies of the living.
What's obviously spectacular is the size of the steel.
Which is typical, as Jewish funeral steels
didn't feature any iconography at that time.
Nevertheless, it's a very sumptuous steel
that was clearly made for prominent personality
of the Parisian Jewish community.
Paul Salmona leads an active community of diverse scientists.
They're interested in the archaeology of Judaism
as a new source of knowledge.
The history of Jewish communities
in the Western world during the Middle Ages
is extremely rich and very well documented.
And yet this history is not well known.
Maybe because the history of the Jews, in France at least,
is not used to feed the national narrative,
or what we call the national myth.
As far as the history of Jews is concerned,
we still pay special attention to the dark moments.
The dramatic, tragic times
that sometimes overshadow the less tragic moments.
This potentially makes Jewish people
harder to understand for the general public.
The history of the Jews on European soil is rich,
complex, and composed of long periods
of peaceful living among the Christians.
At the turn of the year 1000,
European towns and villages
were built around Christian churches,
forming a landscape that's still familiar to us today.
But the Jews played an important role,
and traces of their presence can still be found
in the very center of medieval cities.
Excavation after excavation,
archaeologists have demonstrated that the Jews
settled among the Christians,
with the two communities living side by side
in the same town.
The 1976 discovery of an important medieval monument
under the courtyard of the courthouse
kicked off a new field of research in France,
the archaeology of Judaism.
Claude de McNim works for the National Institute
of Preventative Archaeological Research.
To him, the Rouen building raises many questions.
The functional analysis of this building
really has us puzzled.
Some believe it to have been a synagogue.
Others think it was a Talmudic school,
a place of teaching.
Of course, this stone monument
is embedded with memories.
Stone records everything it undergoes.
When a stone building has been exposed
to something like a fire,
it can be seen,
which is the case here.
When we see that a building used by the Jewish community
suffered a major fire,
it evokes the destruction of the synagogues
and the evictions that took place,
which are reported in certain historical sources.
Maison Sublime, as it's called,
is around 130 square meters,
but only the lower level remains.
The room is lit by four basement windows
on the north face.
There is no trace of a niche on the east wall,
which is typically where a holy arch
housed the scrolls of the Torah.
This certainly represents a turning point
in the archaeology of Judaism,
because this monument is of considerable importance.
It's the oldest preserved Jewish monument
in all of France.
Jacques-Sylvain Klein fought for many years
to open Maison Sublime to the public.
The discovery of this monument was indicative
of a considerable Jewish presence in Normandy.
We've discovered
180 settlement locations throughout the region,
whether in large cities,
small towns, and even in the countryside.
This means that the Jews were not only merchants
and financiers, as commonly believed,
but they were also farmers,
ranchers, and craftsmen.
The Jewish quarter in Rouen,
located in the heart of the city,
was a stone's throw from the town hall,
close to the cathedral,
and fully integrated with the rest of the city.
Presumably, there were even properties
that were jointly occupied
by both Jews and Christians.
This building was quickly identified as Jewish
because of the inscriptions
on the walls.
There were 16 of them.
The most interesting inscription
found in Maison Sublime says,
Let this house be sublime,
with for eternity being implied.
This inscription has led to many discussions
about whether this building was used as a synagogue
or whether it was perhaps a rabbinical academy.
The inscription that gives the building its name
is a quote from the Book of Kings
in the Hebrew Bible.
This would tend to indicate
it was a religious building.
The reopening of Maison Sublime
should allow us to have a much clearer view
of this medieval Judaism
that is completely ignored.
There was a very recent symposium
about a blind spot in the national narrative.
And that's precisely what needs to be filled in.
I think many people will discover
this medieval Judaism in Rouen
with astonishment.
There were periods, especially in the 13th century,
when the Jews went through difficult situations.
There was a rise in persecution
that culminated in the expulsion of 1306
by Philip IV.
These Christians cohabitated
and the city of Rouen is absolutely proof of that.
Our mental construct
depends in large part
on the monuments in our environment.
What we tell ourselves is influenced
by our architectural environment
and it fundamentally helps shape
our mental perspectives.
This is believed by sociologists,
which means that when this building
is reopened to the public,
the people who grew up in the urban setting around it
will have that knowledge and they will assimilate it.
And when we talk to them about contemporary Judaism,
which is generally addressed
through the Nazi genocide most of the time,
they will also have a vision of Jewish communities
that were mixed with Christian communities
in the Middle Ages.
Christians and Jews lived together peacefully
before the royal expulsions.
Ultimately, this building reflects a common,
shared life experience that is fundamentally part
of the discussion of our origins.
Although the heyday of medieval Jewish culture in France
was in the 12th and 13th centuries,
the presence of Jews in Roman Gaul
dates back to the start of the Christian era.
Arriving from the Mediterranean,
along river routes from the Rhône to the Rhine,
archaeology has revealed a few rare traces
of this ancient presence,
which can be counted on one hand.
An oil lamp depicting a seven-branched candlestick
from the 1st century BC,
found in Aragon in the Buche de Rome.
A sarcophagus discovered in Arles in 2009
bearing the inscription of Pompey the Jew in Latin.
A ring in the name of Aster
The funeral steel of three children from the same family
buried in 689 in Norbonne,
which bears the Hebrew inscription,
Peace upon Israel.
And the aforementioned funeral steel of Pelégère
found in Anches, which dates from the 7th century.
Finding traces of the Jewish presence
is painstaking work,
and each discovery is a hard-won victory.
Here in Châteauroux, Philippe Blanchard,
excavates a Jewish cemetery from the Middle Ages.
Is that the first?
I think it's... let's see.
I think it's the right upper facet.
To conduct his analysis,
the archaeologist mainly relies on the absence
of identifiable objects other than bones.
According to Jewish law,
the deceased are buried without any objects or jewels.
In all the graves I've excavated,
except one in 1997,
where we came across a small belt buckle,
we've never found anything.
Generally, in Jewish cemeteries,
it's very rare to find any object or furnishings
that were left there or worn by the deceased.
Similar to the Christians,
there's a certain humility in the idea of meeting the Creator,
so the bodies are usually buried.
Identifying a Jewish cemetery
depends on a set of rather tenuous clues.
It is known, for example,
that graves are almost always facing east,
and that their location is never reused for other burials.
The Jews believe in the resurrection of bodies,
which means the body must remain entirely intact
so that it can be resurrected and revived.
That's very different from Christian beliefs.
For Christians, the body is buried,
and it's just an empty shell.
What's of interest to the Christian is the soul,
which they believe rises to heaven,
leaving behind a body that's nothing but a meaningless shell.
Christians don't hesitate to dig up old tombs
and move the bones, as it doesn't matter to them.
That's a key difference with a Jewish religion.
In Chateauroux,
as in most of France's medieval Jewish cemeteries,
the steels were sold by the crown
after the Jews were expelled from the Kingdom of France
in 1306 and 1394.
The names of the deceased will probably never be known.
To refine our knowledge of these communities,
archaeologists rely on epigraphy,
the science of inscriptions.
Reading engraved texts is an arduous discipline,
as it's rare to find any steels in one piece.
Historian Sonia Phelous
is now studying an important set of Hebrew funerary steels,
currently housed in the Ouvre Notre-Dame Museum
in Strasbourg.
I came to Strasbourg to work,
as I have been doing for over a year,
on Hebrew epigraphy.
There's finally been a sort of opening up
of Jewish archaeology in France,
so there's a momentum for research opportunities.
I've come to study these individuals.
Who were the Jews who lived here?
What were their names?
How did they die?
What were the names of the women
and the names of the men?
Using the stones is a textual quest
to learn who the Jews from the Middle Ages were
and what they were about.
We see, for example,
that women had names in the local language,
and that there were specific things
among the Jews of Strasbourg
that differentiated them from the Jews of Paris.
It's proof that there was also
a local micro-culture,
local micro-traditions,
and ways of writing their epitaphs
for the Kingdom of France.
It helps us understand the peculiarities
of these groups,
which were unique because they were Alsatians.
They generated their own traditions
that were specific to their group
as Jews in Alsace,
which proves there was no uniform Jewish culture
across French territory.
Around the 11th century,
there was a revival of Jewish culture,
housing communities influenced by Spanish Judaism
in Provence and Languedoc,
along with Jews closer to German communities in the north.
One of the most important representatives
of Judaism in Europe at that time
was Solomon, son of Isaac the Frenchman.
Called Rashi, he was the most famous rabbi
of the Middle Ages,
and his monumental work was written
in French.
The Talmud, a collection of the teachings
of the great rabbis of antiquity,
is still in use in Jewish communities around the world.
Paradoxically, in France,
his name is absent from the history books.
In Troyes, a Rashi house was reconstructed
in the district where a great master lived
and worked a millennium ago.
The 11th century was a turning point
in Rashi's political-historical role.
Through his immense work, his immense toil,
you could say he made it possible
to spread the Talmud more widely,
to make it known,
to bring it into the lives of Jewish people
and into the practice of Judaism in the West.
Rashi was a mine of knowledge for the Languedoc,
which was the vernacular at the time when Rashi lived.
The literate Jews knew Hebrew,
those who went to school
learned the Hebrew alphabet exclusively,
but obviously in everyday life
they spoke the language of their country.
It is often said that Rashi
was the first French-language author ever,
simply because of how long ago he did his writings.
This period of history was decisive for Judaism
and the evolution of Talmud commentary.
Rashi was at the origin of a renowned school,
that of the Tosafists, or commentators.
His commentary on the Talmud,
written in Hebrew but peppered with thousands of words
in ancient French, is still in use
in Jewish communities around the world,
even though his name is totally ignored in France's history.
Traditionally, Judaism produced thinkers
and led to schools.
Long before the founding of universities in the West,
there were so-called yeshivas,
institutions of higher education,
which men could access starting at a certain age.
One began by studying the Torah,
and then the corpus was generally expanded to the Talmud.
Judaism places great importance on studying,
because Judaism is a religion that becomes
increasingly demanding based on texts
and the knowledge of extremely complicated,
voluminous texts, which are very elaborate and ambiguous.
Practicing Judaism is demanding
and requires a lot of self-sacrifice and much study.
The study of Judaism isn't something one can just improvise.
Texts and archives have provided
a vast amount of knowledge of the history of Jewish thought.
The Jews played an absolutely essential role
in the construction of Western philosophy.
Educated Jews were polyglots
and translated several languages.
In the medieval West, they contributed to knowledge
of the Hebrew Bible and to the spread of Arab culture,
itself an heir to ancient Greek culture.
The mikvah, a Jewish ritual bath from the 12th century,
discovered in the Rue de la Barrerie in the 19th century,
is proof of the cohabitation between Jews and Christians
in the Middle Ages in Montpellier.
Michael Iancu is a doctor of history
and a specialist of the Jews of Provence.
Jews were indeed multilinguists,
translators, philologists, and scholars.
They translated from Arabic and Hebrew,
which are Semitic languages,
into Latin and the vernacular Occitan language.
You had Jews who knew the Semitic languages
and also Occitan,
and you had Christians who knew Occitan and Latin.
That's how many important works
from the Jewish and the Arab Muslim worlds
were translated into the Latin through Occitan.
The mikvah is an essential part of Jewish spiritual life.
Observant Jews visited regularly
to go from a state of tumah, or impure,
to tahara, or pure.
The men also participate, albeit less frequently,
since they have no monthly cycle.
But on the eve of major celebrations
of the Hebrew lunar calendar,
you would have undressed in this room,
then immersed yourself with seven blessings, and then exited.
It's a rebirth, and during conversion,
you must go through the mikvah.
It's an important part, objectively and subjectively,
and it's one of the oldest religious monuments
along with the crypt of Notre-Dame.
The Jews have been around since the Gallo-Roman era.
There's a lot of talk about Rome, Athens, Jerusalem,
the Euro-Mediterranean heritage.
The Jews are part of the history of France and Europe.
They paid a heavy price
due to medieval Christian anti-Judaism,
but they also contributed a lot.
To the old continent.
Conversely, the fate of the Jewish people
would have been quite different
if they had remained on their original land.
We know a fair amount about the history of the Jews in Europe,
but traces of their presence in the city's landscapes
are rare and undisclosed,
leading to a huge memory gap.
That's why archaeology is so important.
The stone brings back to life memories
and gives us a clearer picture
of how the Jewish and Christian communities
actually lived together,
and not in two separate worlds, as is often believed.
So, Paul, do we agree
that Jewish archaeology in France has a bright future?
Only if there's a real vigilance,
which is the key principle of archaeology
at sites where we presume
there was a significant Jewish presence.
Of all the Jewish streets and their medieval,
Alsatian, or Occitan variants,
there are actually hundreds of them.
So, if we are attentive,
we'll find remnants in almost every city
and large town.
In France, I think we lack a large research program
that would involve archaeologists, historians,
archivists, and all the researchers
who work on topography of medieval cities
to identify the full potential
of this medieval Jewish heritage.
It was obviously anonymized with the evictions,
since any building that was not abandoned
was transformed into something else.
So, we no longer know
which ones were medieval Jewish buildings.
Like the newfound appreciation
of the Mikva in Montpellier,
preserving medieval Jewish heritage in French cities
is of utmost importance for the future
of the archaeology of Judaism.
For the time being, this will depend mainly
on local elected officials and the funding they provide
to preserve the various sites.
Saint-Paul-Trois-Châteaux is one of the few French cities
working to officially designate a medieval Jewish quarter.
The project slowly came together
thanks to the street named Rue Juivry,
the excavation of a Mikva by Claude de McNem,
and the presence of a holy arch,
beautifully carved in stone.
By appropriating and rehabilitating the homes
of the Jewish quarter, the city seeks to create
a unique French destination.
Claude de McNem met with Mylène Lerte,
who's in charge of the development
of Saint-Paul-Trois-Châteaux.
Since you came with your team,
the municipality has bought the last parcel of land
in the area with the intent of rehabilitating
this cultural part of the city.
As you know, we are really in the heart
of the city of Saint-Paul-Trois-Châteaux.
The Jewish quarter was established north
of the ancient city next to a gate,
which is quite important, and in the heart
of the cathedral. So this is genuinely
a perfect example of a Jewish settlement
in medieval times.
All this data really makes it possible
to recreate a classical religious complex
organized around a large courtyard
with distribution systems and the synagogue
being close to the Mikva.
Revealing the Jewish presence in the heart
of French medieval cities is still in the early stages.
But one of the largest Jewish heritage projects
is coming to light.
In downtown Cologne, a truly exceptional
museum project is currently under construction.
In the very heart of the city,
in the town hall square, excavations that
spanned more than 50 years have revealed
one of the largest medieval Jewish quarters
ever discovered in the Western world.
What has reemerged is an entire ancient
synagogue, of which only a few graceful
walls remain.
These last vestiges of an extensive Jewish
quarter were unearthed during a dramatic
moment in the city's history.
Cologne was almost entirely razed by
Allied bombings at the end of World War II.
In the town hall square, the origins
of the city reappeared.
These included a Roman praetorium,
an extensive medieval Jewish quarter,
with the remains of many buildings,
along with a large number of objects.
This major site was excavated in the 1950s
by archaeologist Otto Doppelfeld.
Today, Thomas Oden is leading one of the
most ambitious museum projects in Europe
to honor Jewish heritage, accompanied
by archaeologist Gary White.
With the help of architects and engineers,
he makes his way through the ruins that
explains and highlights the meticulous
work of the archaeologists.
The innovative concept of the future museum
is to make visitors understand how
archaeology nourishes knowledge of the past
by completely immersing them in the old
Jewish quarter.
From the excavations, we have a very clear
picture of the Jewish quarter, where we
have the synagogue and the mikveh,
and the house, the so-called tanzhaus,
for the community, which laid in the
center of the quarter.
And a little bit aside, other public
buildings and private buildings.
And one of these public buildings is also
the hospital. So we know for this very
first phase of the Jewish quarter that
there was a hospital. And that is also
the end of a huge quarter with good
contacts to other medieval centers in
Germany and also in Europe.
Like many settlements in Europe, the
Jewish quarter is located near the
cathedral, a testament to the long-standing
Jewish presence and the protection that
local authorities offered the community.
The medieval Jewish quarter adjoins even
older ruins that date back to the Roman
period. The Jews probably followed the
Roman armies at the time when Cologne
was founded by Emperor Agrippa in the
first century. Cologne was a very big
city. Already in Roman times, it was a
large city. And that remained throughout
the Middle Ages. It became a center of
trade. The position on the Rhine was
very fortunate for trade. And it
communicated very well through the Roman
period with the land behind the city.
First of all, Doppelfeld excavated the
Praetorium in 1953. And he had the idea
then of building a museum that would be
open to the public, but underneath the
ground, underneath the roads. He then
later, in 1956, excavated the synagogue
and the mikveh. The idea was born then,
or the vision was born, was that the
Jewish quarters with the Roman Praetorium.
And we are now carrying out this vision
from this time and making it reality now.
In Cologne, the remains of the district
are substantial and many buildings are
still present. Here stood a bakery.
Further were a butcher shop and a
leather manufacturer. The museum was
intended to plunge visitors directly into
the daily lives of these communities.
It will also show how reconstruction works,
using a few elements of the remaining
buildings to create an extremely realistic
representation of the size and majesty
of their former version. An image that's
a far cry from the dark and unsanitary
ghettos often associated with Jewish
quarters. We found a lot of interesting
information. One of the major things we
found were the slate tablets, which the
Jewish children and students used to
write on. And we find several examples
of drawings on these tablets. We also
find alphabets. We also find lists of
goods or small sums of money being paid
for something. We don't know what, but
there's a lot of money. We also find
stories written there, translations.
There is some German writing, but most
of it is Hebrew. I don't know of any
other place where there's such a lot of
Hebrew writings been found. Highlighting
the Jewish presence in the heart of
medieval cities helps recall the history
of these communities. Archaeological
discoveries have improved our knowledge
of European Judaism since antiquity and
indicate its very ancient place in the
Middle Ages, up to the expulsions all
across Europe between the 12th and 15th
centuries. In France, throughout the 13th
and 14th centuries, the Jews faced
increasing persecution and restrictions
imposed by the Capetian kings. In 1394,
the last Jews were driven out of the
city, and the crown seized their property.
I believe that in order to understand
the complexity of a minority's existence,
like the Jewish minority in the West,
throughout the centuries, and especially
in the Middle Ages, we should stop trying
to focus on periods of appeasement on one
hand, and periods of disasters, massacres,
and violence on the other. The Christian
West, despite the permanent anti-Judaism
of medieval centuries, allowed the Jews
to endure, to live, to exist. What does it
mean to live among Christians when you're
a Jew? That means being able to practice
the profession you want, being able to
borrow and lend money. It means being
able to buy your own house and your own
land, be a farmer, buy cattle, go to
markets, and also engage in a whole range
of trades, including artisanal trades in
the field of production. All of that
obviously leads to the sharing of daily
life, and more or less friendly relations
with one's neighbors. That's how you
could describe the daily relations between
Jews and Christians in the centuries our
sources have written.
Today, the archaeology of Judaism is still
a budding field of research with limited
means. But the collection of research
findings by a few passionate specialists
has greatly contributed to our knowledge
of the life of these communities on
European territory from antiquity to the
present day. It is their hope that this
knowledge will help transform how Jews
are represented in European history across
the ages and restore their rightful place
in our shared history.
