The Trouble with Toltecs

X Ancient Americas
1 follower
The eminent archaeologist and anthropologist the late Michael Coe once wrote that there were four
unifying forces in Mesoamerica, the Olmec, Teotihuacan, the Toltecs, and Tenochtitlan.
Today we are focusing on the third of those cultures, the Toltec, but don't let that quote
fool you. Although the Toltec left a palpable influence on Mesoamerica, the Toltec legacy is
baffling and prone to misunderstanding. In writing this episode, I struggled to assemble an easy and
digestible narrative because of the difficulties that come with assessing the Toltecs. Scholars
have championed the notion that the Toltecs were masters of a great Mesoamerican empire at the
same time that others have dismissed them as myth, while others have taken every conceivable position
in between. If this sounds interesting to you, join me as we examine the history of the Toltecs.
The Toltecs occupy an awkward spot in history. We have indigenous accounts and colonial accounts
of the Toltecs, most prominently from the Aztecs. These accounts allow us to see how the Aztecs and
many of their contemporaries understood the Toltecs. Now, a word of warning about these Aztec
sources that will sound very familiar to people who watched our episode on Nezahualcóyotl.
These sources are less than ideal. Nearly all of them were written after the conquest and under
colonial rule, which was already several centuries after the Toltecs had come and gone. No primary
sources survive from the Toltec beyond some images and date glyphs in archaeology. Since these sources
are overwhelmingly colonial, they're also attuned to a Spanish and Catholic audience, so it's safe
to say that there were probably some liberties taken with these accounts. In some cases, for
example, biblical parallels pop up that cast some suspicion on the narrative. Even in cases where
native informants were consulted, the goal of these works was to allow Catholic mendicants to
Not exactly what we would call good ethnography by today's standards. Native tropes also work
their way into the narrative as well. Cycles of rise and fall, glory and tragedy appear in these
accounts as well. Remember, Mesoamericans had a very cyclical view of time, where worlds were
created, destroyed, recreated, and destroyed again. Beyond this, there are other problems.
Before the conquest ever happened, the Mexica, like any other ancient nobility, took very
calculated steps to craft the most impressive pedigree in history for themselves to legitimize
their rule. To this end, they purged histories that did not line up with the new official narrative.
The most visible instance of this was when the Tlatoani Itzcoatl ordered any disagreeing histories
to be burned. On top of that, the Spanish themselves wreaked incredible destruction
during and after the conquest and burned hundreds, perhaps thousands, of native documents.
These destroyed codices could have clarified a lot about the Toltecs had they survived,
but alas, history is seldom kind to history. This is all to say that we are working with
fragments of what must have been a huge corpus of knowledge. So let's see what the Mexica thought
of the Toltecs. The Mexica spoke of the Toltec in the most glowing of praise. The Toltecs
represented the golden age of a bygone era. They were the progenitors of all high culture who also
dominated Mesoamerica in the distant past, much like how the ancient Greeks and Romans were viewed
in Europe during the Renaissance. They were credited as the ones who left later peoples
with the calendar, medicine, and the Nahuatl language itself. They were the greatest,
the strongest, the wisest. At the center of Toltec legend was the culture hero
who founded the great city of Tolan and birthed high civilization.
Just to clarify, this is not the feathered serpent god Quetzalcoatl, but a man with that name.
To the Aztecs and other post-classic cultures, the Toltecs were not just a past people but an ideal
to be emulated. Spanish chronicler Bernardo de Sahagún summed up such memories of the Toltec
The Toltec were wise. Their works were all good, all perfect, all wonderful, all marvelous.
They invented the art of medicine. And these Toltec were very wise. They were thinkers,
for they originated the year count. These Toltec were righteous. They were not deceivers.
Their words were clear words. They were tall. They were larger than the people today.
They were very devout. Indigenous and Spanish chroniclers recorded histories of the Toltec
people, but I use that term very loosely because there's a lot of variation between different
accounts. Remember, we are working with a very fragmented record, much of it produced under
less than ideal circumstances. For a quick example, let's check out these chronologies
for the Toltecs. There are clearly some common elements, but there are huge differences also.
Rulers are added or are missing, and the dates are sometimes centuries apart.
This is the stuff of historian nightmares, but many have risen to the challenge and done their
best to comb through these accounts to distill the most likely and basic narratives which we'll
explore. Please keep in mind that there is some disagreement between these narratives, but I'll
do my best to present the basic and somewhat abbreviated reconstruction of the Toltec legend.
If you want to dive headfirst into all these accounts, I recommend getting a copy of H.B.
Nicholson's Topiltzin Quetzalcoatl, The Once and Future Lord of the Aztecs. He explores and
compares all of these accounts in spectacular detail. According to the various accounts,
the people who would become the Toltecs were Chichimeca. Chichimeca was the name given to
the diverse populations that were living north of the Valley of Mexico. Oh my, Ancient Americas,
it seems you are up for a wheel ride on this video. After all, the Toltec-Chichimeca dynamic
is one hell of a mess. It sure is, and we'll see that in this video. Actually, can I ask you to
help me here? Why don't you explain the Chichimeca to everyone on your channel? After we finish
talking about the Toltecs over here, of course. It will be my pleasure to do that. Great, I'll see
you over there. Although for now, let's get back to the Toltecs. According to the traditional
narratives, a leader named Mishkowat led the Tolteca into the Valley of Mexico and established
a capital at Ixtapalapa or Cuacan, depending on who's telling the story. Mishkowat had a son
named Topiltzin, born on one reed, who became a virtuous high priest of Quetzalcoatl and even
took his name. His first act was to move the capital to the newly founded city of Tolan.
Topiltzin is presented in many of these accounts as a wise and moral ruler,
as well as a virtuous priest who abhorred human sacrifices. Hmm, sounds suspiciously like our
buddy Nezahwacoyotl. Coincidence? Under the reign of Topiltzin, Tolan prospered.
Unfortunately, things at Tolan got a little crazy when Topiltzin Quetzalcoatl got caught up in a
struggle with another faction, or perhaps a person, with the name of Tezcatlipoca,
who are represented as advocates of blood sacrifice and violence. Now, like Topiltzin
Quetzalcoatl, this is not the god Tezcatlipoca, but a person or faction that shares his name.
In a series of events, Tezcatlipoca deceived and tricked Topiltzin Quetzalcoatl into drinking
polka and violating his priestly vows. Now disgraced, Topiltzin Quetzalcoatl was forced
into exile from Tolan. After leaving the city, he journeyed to the sea, where in one version of the
story, he sets out east on a raft with his followers, or in another version, immolated
himself to become Venus, the morning star in the sky. Incidentally, this is the source of the myth
of the return of Quetzalcoatl that Montezuma II obsessed about and that Cortez exploited during
the Spanish conquest. Back at Tolan, with the Tezcatlipoca faction in power, Tolan became
the seat of a fantastic empire with palaces of jade, gold, turquoise, and quetzal feathers.
The Toltecs themselves were described as talented artists who put their heart into everything,
and who taught the clay to lie, whatever that means. There was nothing that they could not
make. All of this came to a halt with the last ruler of Tolan, Waymoc, who abandoned
Tolan and moved the capital to Chapultepec amidst increasing social and political turmoil.
These accounts mention divine wrath, famine, and warfare as the sources of the turmoil.
Waymoc eventually committed suicide, and the Toltec were dispersed across Mexico
and occupied other sites, most notably Cholula. Later Aztec tradition also claimed that the royal
line of the Toltecs continued through the ruling dynasty of the small city-state of Culucan,
but I couldn't find any information explaining precisely how this came to be.
Now, historians have pored over these stories of Topiltzin Quetzalcoatl and the Toltec to discern
any historical elements in it. There's a lot of fantastic elements baked into these accounts,
and establishing any reliable chronology has been daunting. Some scholars have completely
dismissed this story as nothing more than myth and fabrication, but others believe that there
was a historical Topiltzin who was some type of religious reformer or leader who left a legacy
across Mesoamerica. He may have established a priestly order that played a role in investing
rulers with political power and legitimacy. If you're wondering what I think about this,
I'm sympathetic to the idea that Topiltzin has a historical basis, albeit one that may be very
distorted. The fact that accounts of Topiltzin Quetzalcoatl appear so widely across Mesoamerica
seems to support this, but pinning down the exact history is elusive. This is where archaeology
comes into play. Surely the cold hard facts will elucidate the problem and fill in the gaps,
right? Yeah, about that. Before we dive into the archaeology, let's establish some context.
The Toltecs arose in central Mexico after the great hegemony of Teotihuacan began to wither
away. This left a huge power vacuum in Mexico that saw smaller sites rise to prominence,
such as Cacashla, Xochicalco, Cholula, and Tulechico around 700-800 CE. This period in
the literature is referred to as the Terminal Classic or Epic Classic period, and it lines
up with the post-Teotihuacan order. Now that we know when we are, let's establish where we are
by locating the city of Tolan. That may seem easy, but it's not as straightforward as it sounds
because, as it turns out, just like Toltec, the very word Tolan is a can of worms. In Nahuatl,
the word Tolan means place of the reeds, a reference to the fertile agricultural land,
and possibly a reference to reed mats on which Mesoamerican rulers sat.
Tolans were places of gathering as well as sites of authority and investiture.
Royal protocol sometimes required that new lords go to a Tolan to be invested with authority.
In the Cantares Mexicanos, a collection of Nahuatl songs and poems, reeds are sometimes
a metaphor for warriors, so there may be a military connotation as well.
We have a very loaded term on our hands that was used to describe lots of different places.
In fact, ancient accounts apply the term Tolan to many great Mesoamerican cities.
One example of this is the great city of Teotihuacan, the primordial Tolan that birthed
great art and writing, and was believed to even be the birthplace of the gods.
Even Maya records refer to Teotihuacan as a Tolan, or in their language, Tulan.
Other cities referred to as a Tolan include Cholula, Chichen Itza, Tula, Xochicalco,
and even Tenochtitlan. However, there is a specific Tolan that is associated with the
Toltecs in Aztec accounts, Tolan Xicocotitlan. This is the Tolan that the Mexica remembered
as a stopping point before they founded the city of Tenochtitlan. According to memory,
they arrived at this specific Tolan, the former Toltec capital, a full calendar cycle, or 52
years, after leaving their legendary ancestral home of Aztlan. By this point, the city had been
abandoned and all that were left were the remnants of the Toltec. With that said, can we locate this
historical Tolan? Historians and archaeologists spent decades in the late 19th and early 20th
century trying to answer this. Tolan was first ascribed to the great city of Teotihuacan,
and it's not hard to see why given how much the Aztecs talked up the Toltec. However,
Teotihuacan's dates don't match up with the dates ascribed to Tolan by later accounts.
And what's more, Teotihuacan's linguistic toponym, the place name that derives from the geography,
differs from that of the historical Tolan, which is mentioned in colonial documents.
So where was this Tolan? In the 1940s, archaeologist Humberto Jimenez Moreno
really got to work on this. By examining old codices, colonial accounts, and etymologies
of Mexican towns, he was able to deduce that the modern city of Tula was the historic Tolan
Xicocotitlan that had been noted in the Aztec sources as the former Toltec capital. As you
may have guessed, the name Tula itself is a corruption of the word Tolan. Further historical
and archaeological investigations have corroborated this, so archaeologists and historians
are pretty confident that we're looking at the correct spot. Awesome. Unfortunately, time has
not been kind to the site. Tula was not gracefully abandoned, but thoroughly destroyed when it fell,
and then to add insult to injury, it was looted centuries later by the Aztecs in a frenzy of
Toltec mania. Nonetheless, there's still a lot that archaeology can tell us about the site,
so let's take a look. Tula is about 75 kilometers north of Mexico City in the modern state of
Hidalgo. The city was built on a limestone promontory, and there's evidence of settlements
dating back to the pre-classic, but it's not until the epiclassic that Tula begins to rise.
This early stage of Tula is associated with the northeast part of the site called Tula Chico.
This smaller ceremonial center was built in the final days of Teotihuacan's twilight around 650
CE. Tula Chico was a planned city, and was organized along a grid aligned to True North.
The Coyo-Tlitelco pottery they were making is almost the same as the other pottery being made
in the Valley of Mexico at that time. Archaeology has recovered remains of a small circular temple
that may have been dedicated to the winged god Eakot. Several later Toltec traits are visible
at Tula Chico, such as monument carving, decorated panels for their buildings,
colonnaded halls, and skull racks. At its peak, Tula Chico stretched about five square kilometers
with a population over 10,000 people living in densely packed houses. Unfortunately,
Tula Chico's prosperity came to a halt around 850 CE when the city was burned to the ground,
looted, and abandoned. The exact causes and reasons for this are uncertain.
Surprisingly, that didn't spell the end of Tula. Instead, a new city center began to be constructed
several decades later around 900 CE. With a new vision, the city was reorganized along a new grid
oriented to about 17 degrees east of north, which is very close to the grid orientation of Teotihuacan.
Also like Teotihuacan, the city used apartment compounds to house a large amount of the
population. This new revitalized city is referred to as Tula Grande, and it really took off. By
1000 CE, the city had a population of perhaps 30 to 40,000 people and stretched over 13 square
kilometers, and had begun to dominate the locality around it. Let's examine the ceremonial center of
the city. Tula Grande's main feature is the Palacio Quemado, which also encloses Pyramid B.
To the northeast is one of the ball courts. To the south is the main plaza, which is flanked by
Pyramid C and the second ball court. Within the plaza itself is the central altar and the
skull rack. This design subtly harkens back to Teotihuacan with the placement of its temples.
The larger pyramid, Pyramid C, is oriented west, and the smaller, Pyramid B, is oriented south,
just as the Pyramids of the Sun and the Moon are at Teotihuacan. On the southern end are two
smaller buildings, structures J and K. Although it lacks the grand avenues and sheer scale of Teotihuacan,
Tula Grande evokes its memory in a scaled-down form. Let's look at these features in depth.
The largest monument at the site is Pyramid C, which is sadly in poor shape. At some point,
the structure was destroyed and its decorations removed, leaving only the base, although a small
altar was later erected by the Aztec after the city was re-inhabited. Unfortunately, that means
that the deity this pyramid was dedicated to remains unknown. However, Pyramid B is much better
preserved, so let's devote our attention there. This exquisitely designed but not-so-exquisitely
named structure is the most impressive building left at the site. Built in six successive phases,
this 10-meter-high stepped pyramid is fronted by a colonnaded hall. At the top are the remains of
columns that once held the roof of a two-roomed structure. The largest columns are the famous
atlantes. Just to set the record straight, atlantes does not refer to Atlantis, but rather to the
architectural term Atlas, which is used to describe a sculpted structural support shaped
like a human. I should also mention that these are not unique. There are also other smaller atlantes
from the site used to support altars and smaller structures, like this one. Anyways, these atlantes
depict Toltec warriors. They carry atlatls, darts, war clubs, and tobacco bowls. In front of these
atlantes are two composite columns that depict the feathered serpent. Although there's not much
of them left today, you can get a better idea of what they may have looked like by checking out the
Temple of the Warriors at Chichen Itza. Behind the atlantes are four square columns carved with
warriors and name captions that may depict rulers or legendary figures. One of these figures actually
bears an interesting resemblance to many descriptions of topilts in Quetzalcoatl.
It shows a bearded man in warrior garb with the name sign of Feathered Serpent. By the way, in
several accounts of topilts in Quetzalcoatl, he is described as having a beard, so this is an
interesting detail. Now, whether this is topilts in Quetzalcoatl, or a priest, or a warrior dressed
as him is debated. Although it's not easy to see now, the pyramid would have been decorated in a
Toulouse-Tablero style. On the back of the pyramid, some of this original decoration still survives.
These panels show prowling jaguars, pumas, and eagles devouring human hearts. Another wall behind
the pyramid, called the Coatepantli, has sculptures showing serpents devouring skeletal figures.
It's also worth reminding ourselves that this pyramid would have been brightly plastered and
painted. Remember, the ancient world was brightly colored, and not at all like the bleached remains
we see today. To the west of Pyramid B is the Palacio Quemado, the Burned Palace. This gets
its name from the fact that at some point it was burned to the ground, judging from the large
amount of burned debris that was recovered from it. No unintentional human remains have been found
within, so if this was an act of violence, no one was inside when it was destroyed. The palace was
probably never an actual palace, but likely a series of meeting halls and ceremonial spaces.
The building is divided into three colonnaded halls that contain altars, daises, and benches.
One of the most interesting finds in here are what appear to be patoli boards scratched into
the floor. Patoli was a strategy game played all over Mesoamerica that was popular with gambling.
These patios and rooms would have been lavishly decorated with murals and sculptures.
Tula has not one, but two ball courts in its city center. The western ball court measures about 110
meters long, which doesn't sound like much until you realize that those dimensions are identical
to the ball court at the site of Xochicalco, which suggests a connection to the site, but
scholars aren't precisely sure. Besides the northern ball court, three others have been
identified at the site, which brings the total number of courts to five. Scholars have interpreted
this as evidence of a growing emphasis on the ball game and the use of the ball court as a civic
structure. Remember, the Teotihuacan didn't have a formal ball court, or at least if it did, it
hasn't been identified. In front of the western ball court are the remains of the sopantli,
the skull rack. This is a feature that is more commonly associated with Tenochtitlan,
although it also appears in other cities of the post-classic as well. It's a grim reminder that
not everything at Tula was rainbows and unicorns. The Toltecs were also warriors, and they celebrated
that fact. Finally, the central altar in the middle of the plaza may be a dance platform,
but it has one interesting feature. A cache within the platform revealed over 30 ceramic
vessels that are almost identical to the black-on-orange pottery that was being manufactured
at Culhuacan in the Valley of Mexico after the city was abandoned. With them were three female
figurines. This is very interesting because recall that after the fall of Tolan, the Toltec
line was said to continue at Culhuacan. Coincidence? Who knows. At 1000 CE, the city
layout changed. The grid was reoriented dramatically to 17 degrees west, more than 34 degrees from its
original alignment. Those Teotihuacano-style apartment compounds were also abandoned in
favor of house groups. These houses would have been arranged around a central courtyard with
an altar. However, the elites continued to live in grand accommodations. Investigations into these
houses show that the inhabitants were eating local crops, especially maize, but also wild game and
dogs. I do want to point out that Tula itself isn't a marginal agricultural area for farming
due to the amount of rainfall, but agricultural infrastructures such as irrigation canals and
some check dams do remain. Nevertheless, it was never a place of great food surplus.
These houses also contain evidence of craft production and simple workshops,
especially obsidian crafting. Archaeologist Richard Deal, who has worked extensively at the
site, suggests that as many as 40% of the population was involved in the production
of obsidian blades, which came from having access to local obsidian sources.
On the whole, Tula was very well integrated into Mesoamerican trade networks.
Tohio plumbate ware from the Pacific coast and Nicoya polychromes from Nicaragua and Costa Rica
pop up at the site. Imported turquoise from the American Southwest is also present as well.
These areas also furnished salt, peyote, and possibly slaves. Now let's briefly direct our
attention to Toltec art, something that the Toltec were quite famous for among the Aztecs.
Most of what survives is Toltec stone sculpture, which makes sense considering that the site was
looted in antiquity. Anything light and portable was taken long ago. Among the most iconic
sculptures from Tula are the reclining chocmules that are spread all over Mesoamerica. You can
find them in Michoacan, Central Mexico, and even the Yucatan. These were kept in front of temples
and were likely where offerings were left to the gods. Several examples of freestanding
sculpture still survive, but the majority of surviving sculpture, as we've previously seen,
is architectural, such as the friezes on Pyramid B and the Atlantes. One of the finest pieces unearthed
from the site is this turquoise jade and pyrite mirror, called a Tezcatlitlapilli, that would have
been worn by a high-ranking warrior. To date, no metal artifacts have been found at Tula, but that
probably has more to do with the fact that no elite burials have been found at the site. By
1100 or 1150 CE, Tula appears to have been abandoned and destroyed by fire. The citizens of
Tula left and migrated from the city. The causes of this destruction have been debated, and there
have been suggestions that the Mexica themselves conquered and destroyed the city, but archaeology
has not borne this out. A century or two later, there does appear to be a brief Aztec occupation
before being seriously reoccupied by the Aztecs around 1400 CE. However, the site's destruction
doesn't line up with the migration of the Mexica, so internal causes or local warfare are likely
better answers. Dr. Shannon Iverson makes an interesting case based on the carbon dates and
ceramic evidence that the city was not destroyed immediately, but abandoned and then later ritually
terminated, but we'll explore that in more detail later. Now, a survey of the Toltecs wouldn't be
complete without a look at another famous Mesoamerican site, one that is actually much
more famous than Tula and one that you're probably very familiar with, and that is Chichen Itza.
But Ancient Americas, you handsome fellow, I hear you all saying. Chichen Itza is a Maya site over a
thousand kilometers away. Surely you must be mistaken. You heard me right. As it turns out,
Chichen Itza has baffling similarities to Tula that cannot be a mere coincidence. Specifically,
much of the later art and architecture bears a striking resemblance to those at Tula.
For some quick examples, check out the Temple of the Warriors at Chichen Itza and compare it to
Pyramid B and the accompanying structures at Tula. Look at the Chocmul statues. Here's the skull
rack at Chichen Itza, a feature hitherto unknown in the Maya world. Here's the feathered serpent in
all of its glory. Although he does have antecedents in Maya culture, his depiction here is in a
distinctly Central Mexican style. Many of these elements are very alien to the Yucatan. Now, we
aren't going to go into great detail on the site because Chichen Itza deserves its own episode,
and we're focused on the told text today. We're just highlighting the similarities, which are
so strong that since the 1800s, most archaeologists have accepted the fact that there is a connection
between the two sites, so much so that they're often referred to as twin tolons. And in fact,
when Pyramid B at Tula was reconstructed by archaeologists, the Temple of the Warriors
was used as a reference, though not without some controversy. Some critics have argued that the
similarities between the buildings are due to this, but others say that this is overstated.
Despite these tantalizing links, teasing out the nature of that connection has been fraught with
controversy. At first, Chichen Itza was thought to be a Toltec conquest, perhaps even a conquest
by Topiltzin Quetzalcoatl himself after his expulsion from Tolan. Making this all the more
strange is that later colonial accounts from the Yucatec Maya, which again are not always the most
reliable sources, recount an invasion by Quetzalcoatl, or K'kulkan to use his Maya name,
and the Itza people. Though just like the Mexica accounts of the Toltec, the historicity and exact
meaning of these accounts is debated. Art at Chichen Itza also shows rulers or figures dressed
in Toltec warrior attire, most notably the stela dated to the end of the 10th century.
This idea dovetailed nicely with the idea of a Toltec empire, and it still has its proponents
today. We also know that there is some precedent for this because recall from our Teotihuacan
episode, Teotihuacan led an expedition to oust the ruling dynasty of the great Maya city of Mutal.
If they could do it, could Tula have done so as well? Maybe. Well, in 1961, George Kubler decided
that he didn't agree with that and theorized that Chichen Itza, in fact, was the founder or
conqueror of Tula rather than the other way around. He and his supporters also argued
controversially that several traits identified as Toltec were actually Maya traits, and that
Chichen Itza's larger size, the exquisite high-quality art, and craftsmanship there dwarfed
those at Tula. This theory still enjoys some support, but since then, others have argued that
these Tolteca-Maya traits were not spread via conquest at all, but consciously adopted by the
later inhabitants of Chichen Itza. After all, Washington, D.C. has a lot of classic-inspired
architecture, but that doesn't mean that it's a classic Greek or Roman city. J. Eric Thompson,
yes, that J. Eric Thompson of Maya decipherment infamy, proposed that the Acalan-Chontal Maya
conquered Chichen Itza and much of the northern Yucatan from the Kempeche region,
and that new trade networks between the Yucatan, Gulf Coast, and Central Mexico
brought these influences to Chichen Itza. So yeah, there's a lot of speculation about this
connection. However, the image of Chichen Itza as a Tula satellite or a Toltec imitator still
persists to this day, but the general consensus appears to be that Chichen Itza began as a Maya
city before a new Central Mexican influence arrived from the outside and began to exert
a strong influence in its development. Now let's pull back the camera and review everything that
we've seen starting with Tula. Looking at the city as a whole, a few things stand out. First,
Tula's small size is underwhelming. As impressive as Tula is, there really isn't too much there.
Tula pales in comparison to Teotihuacan, Cholula, or Tenochtitlan. By post-classic standards,
this is one of several similarly sized cities, but certainly not the largest. Its layout and
urban design are ambitious, but the craftsmanship tends to be on the crude side, especially
compared to the sprawling metropolis that is Chichen Itza. It should be mentioned that the
Aztecs looted the site for Toltec art, so this may be why the art there is so limited, and many
people have pointed this out. While it enjoyed some prominence and some extensive trade connections,
these weren't out of the ordinary for cities of that size at that time. Remember, this was
supposed to be the capital of an empire. Does Tula really fit that image? Obviously, reconstructing an
empire from archaeology with very little written records is difficult, and this has prompted a lot
of debate. However, in 2001, Michael Smith and Lisa Montiel took this question on, and argued
that Tula did not meet the criteria for an empire, but rather a small kingdom. To do this,
they reviewed the material culture and archaeological record of Tula using a criteria for
empires, including, but not limited to, a large urban capital, proclamations of an imperial ideology,
political control of provinces, and projection of cultural and economic influence into a larger
international context. They compared this to the archaeological record of other ancient Mesoamerican
empires. All this showed that Tula did not rule an empire as did Tenochtitlan and Teotihuacan.
Rather, it was the capital of a small regional state. To quote the authors,
We believe that scholars have been led to misinterpret the Toltec polity as a large
and powerful empire for three reasons. First, there is a tendency to give too much weight to
the native historical record in central Mexico, in spite of its obviously propagandistic nature.
Thus, many scholars have been tempted to believe Aztec accounts of Toltec greatness,
even when they are contradicted by the archaeological record. Second, there has
been very little intensive archaeological research on early post-classic central Mexico,
outside of Tula, the Bajio, and a few other sites, making it difficult to disprove the
common view of great similarities among the roles of Teotihuacan, Tula, and Tenochtitlan. Third,
there has been a general lack of models in archaeology and anthropology for the large-scale
influence and role of large cities beyond the imperialism model. Now, I do want to point out
that the authors state very clearly that this does not necessarily mean that Tula could not
have wielded great influence, and we quote, A city did not have to rule an empire to be an
important force at the level of Mesoamerica as a whole. We can acknowledge Tula's considerable
cultural, ideological, and economic influence throughout Mesoamerica without having to call
it the capital of an empire. With all that said, there is definitely a Toltec memory that pervades
Mesoamerica that was appropriated by people far and wide. Our best examples come from the Mexica
in the Valley of Mexico. The very word Toltec and its original Nahuatl term, Totecat, was loaded
with meaning. When the Aztecs used the term, it usually referred to a master artisan or craftsman
or to an inhabitant of the city of Tolan, present and historical. Toltec also represented an
important cultural identity that was different to that of the Chichimeca who entered the Valley
of Mexico from the north. Now, the Chichimeca and the Tolteca are often painted in binary terms,
like civilized and barbarian, urban and nomadic, but that's not the case. As Aztlan Historian
points out in his video, the truth is much more complicated. In fact, many ruling dynasties in
Mexico, the Mexica among them, had Chichimeca origins that they were very proud of. Thus,
in the case of the Mexica, they added to their legitimacy by stressing their Toltec heritage,
real or fabricated. As I mentioned earlier, after the fall of Tolan, it was claimed that the
Toltec royal line survived in the city-state of Culhuacan. Women from this line were prized
marriage material by other nobility, and several Mexica-Tlatelani took wives from this Toltec line
so that their sons could claim genuine Toltec descent. Mexica rulers also adopted a distinctive
blue diamond and dot pattern for their royal capes that was associated with Toltec emperors.
But the Mexica had deeper connections than that. I mentioned this earlier, but it's worth repeating.
According to their own history, which remember was deliberately manipulated by the Mexica,
they migrated from their legendary ancestral home of Aztlan to central Mexico. Before they reached
Lake Texcoco and founded Tenochtitlan, they stopped at several sites along the way, and
one of them was Tolan, which at this point was a remnant of its former glory. Whether or not
this happened, it was an important part of their collective social memory that linked the Mexica
with Tolan and the Toltecs. Dr. Shannon Iverson argues that early Aztec occupants in Tolan
actually ritually terminated the site by burning it after it was abandoned by the Toltecs,
and that this symbolic rite of passage allowed them to separate their Chichimeca past
and imbue them with the necessary fitness and wisdom needed to rule. All of this combined to
form powerful propaganda for Mexica legitimacy. But the Mexica were not the only people to
appropriate the Toltec legacy. Other cities drank deeply from the Toltec cup. The greatest rivals of
Tenochtitlan, the tenacious city of Tlaxcala, covered one of their deities in a mask that had
been taken from Tolan. There are records of other cities in the basin that had looted statues and
other art from Tolan for their own purposes. Outside the Valley of Mexico, however, many
indigenous groups referenced the Toltecs as well. In Oaxaca, Mixtec genealogies suggest that many
of the ruling dynasties of the leading polities of the Mixteca traced their descent from a figure
referred to as Nine Wind, who bears several of Quetzalcoatl's traits and may possibly be a
reference to Topiltzin Quetzalcoatl or one of his followers. Several Mixtec nobles also claimed
descent from a group of outsiders that ruled over the Mixteca, perhaps another reference to the
Toltec. The Maya of the Guatemalan highlands also claimed descent from Tolteca that arrived in their
territory and even referenced the Toltec city of Tolan. As I mentioned earlier, Yucatec Maya
accounts chronicled an invasion by K'kulkan who came with the Itza and took over Chichen Itza,
although the relationship between the Itza and K'kulkan is not entirely clear.
What we can grasp from this is that Toltec influence spread throughout Mesoamerica
and many different people made attempts to associate themselves with this influence.
Whether this was through the legendary figure of Topiltzin Quetzalcoatl, his followers,
or imitators, we could speculate on all day, but we will never know. All of this makes the
Toltec legacy complicated and difficult to deconstruct. Even today, Toltec continues
to be a very burdened term. If you were to crack open a book or article on Mesoamerica,
the word Toltec could be used to describe a descendant of Teotihuacan, a follower of
Topiltzin Quetzalcoatl, the period between Teotihuacan and the Aztecs, Mexican invaders
of the Yucatan, or their art style, as well as the ancestors of several highland Maya groups.
Toltec has also taken on a new meaning in the past few decades with the work of Miguel Ruiz
and his book The Four Agreements. This New Age self-help book claims to be based off Toltec
wisdom and if you search for books on the Toltec, they'll usually pop up. As popular as the books
are, there's no evidence that any of this wisdom actually dates back to the time of the Toltecs,
but I still find it an interesting example of the weight that the name
Toltec still carries today. Making the Toltec legacy even more frustrating is the archaeology
of Tula, which is impressive but hardly the city of legend that many in Mesoamerica would have us
believe. The Toltecs are an enigma and in writing this episode, I personally found out how difficult
it was to fit them into a clear and concise narrative. What I've come to appreciate is that
the best way to look at the Toltecs isn't about a historical narrative that we can neatly trace
through history and archaeology, but rather as a constructed memory that was shared and revered by
many in Mesoamerica. And that's gonna wrap us up for today. Remember to check out Atzlan Historian's
episode on the Chichimeca and tell him that ancient America sent you. Special thanks to
my patrons listed here, you guys are the best. If you would like to join the ranks of these fine
individuals and support the show, you can do so on Patreon. The link will be in the description
below. Don't forget to like and subscribe and follow us on Facebook. Take care and we'll see
you in our next episode. Transcribed by https://otter.ai
