Get Surfshark VPN at https://surfshark.deals/wisecrack - Enter promo code WISECRACK for 83% off and 3 extra months for FREE! Thank you to Surfshark for sponsoring this video!
The secret tragedy of Totoro
My Neighbor Totoro has brought joy to the masses since its release in 1986. But surprisingly, it was initially supposed to be screened alongside Studio Ghibli's most depressing film ever: Grave of the Fireflies. Can watching the two films side by side teach us anything, and will doing so change the meaning of Totoro? Let's find out in this Wisecrack Edition: Did We Misunderstand Totoro?
=== Watch More Episodes! === Studio Ghibli & Miyazaki: Why 2D is Better ► • Studio Ghibli & Miyazaki: Why 2D is Better The Philosophy of Miyazaki ► • The Philosophy of Miyazaki – Wisecrack Edi... Hidden Meaning in Spirited Away ► • Hidden Meaning in Spirited Away (Miyazaki)...
Written by Amanda Scherker and Tom Whyman Hosted by Michael Burns Directed by Michael Luxemburg Edited by Kim Su Labby Produced by Olivia Redden and Griffin Davis
Okay, so one of our favorite contributors recently went viral on Twitter when he shared a little
known yet mind-blowing fact about an iconic animated film, My Neighbor Totoro, the deep-cut
nugget of intrigue? Well, when Totoro came out in 1988, it was screened as a double feature alongside
another brand new Studio Ghibli film, Grave of the Fireflies. Now, if you haven't seen Grave of the
Fireflies, know that it's not your typical cheery animated film, not by a long shot. A gut-wrenching
look at the life of two Japanese siblings trying to survive during World War II, the film begins
with the line, and things only get more devastating from there. It doesn't seem
like a natural companion for Totoro, a film about playful sisters befriending a kind,
fluffy forest spirit. So we wanted to explore why these films would ever be billed as a double
feature, and the more we thought about it, the more things started to make sense. In fact, we began
to realize that not only does Totoro's double billing with Fireflies seem pretty fitting, it
actually illuminates the meaning behind the famous film, and even reveals a lot about Studio Ghibli's
On a larger scale, it makes us think about film curation in general, and how considering films in
opposition to each other can help us glean new meanings from them. So, why was a film about a
cuddly forest spirit meant to be watched alongside a harrowing story about siblings suffering from
wartime starvation? We'll explain in this Wisecrack Edition, Is Totoro Secretly a Tragedy?
and spoilers ahead for both films. But before we really get into it, I want to tell you about this
video's sponsor, Surfshark VPN. Surfshark VPN keeps your data secure everywhere you go on the
internet, thanks to their secure protocols and uncrackable encryption. Something I love about
using Surfshark is the way it keeps my location completely private, which is a major advantage
when I'm buying plane tickets, because if a website doesn't know where I am, they can't gouge
the price based on what they think I can afford. All I have to do is connect my secure Surfshark
VPN to other VPNs around the world until I track down the best price. And speaking of the world,
these connections also make it easy to watch all the content that hasn't been released in your
country yet. All of your favorite devices are included in a single subscription, including
your laptop, Android, Amazon Fire Stick, PlayStation, and more. So get started by clicking the link in
the description and using the promo code Wisecrack. When you do, you can get Surfshark VPN for 83%
off, plus three extra months for free. Go to surfshark.deals slash Wisecrack or hit the link
in the description. Protect yourself online and download Surfshark VPN today. And now, back to the
show. As you may know, My Neighbor Totoro was directed by Hayao Miyazaki, the man behind classics
like Spirited Away and Ponyo. While developing the idea for Totoro, Miyazaki was having trouble
securing funding. Meanwhile, Ghibli co-founder Aisao Takada wanted to animate Grave of the
Fireflies, an autobiographical short story by World War II survivor Akiyuki Nozaka. Struggling
to get both into production, they scrounged out a deal by pitching a double villain. Fireflies was
initially intended to be screened first, though theaters were allowed to experiment with the
order. They found that when they led with Totoro, audiences looking to avoid a buzzkill fled the
theater before Fireflies even began. It's wild to imagine a studio working on both films at the
exact same time. Imagine that you're an animator working on Fireflies, a film that stares directly
into hell, while your Totoro colleagues were busy deciding whether or not the cat bus should have
balls. Spoiler, it does. Totoro centers around two sisters moving into a derelict old house and
waiting for their mother to come home from the hospital. The beginning feels melancholy. We
even sense that their mother might die. The sisters struggle to adjust to her absence. Though
they're often quite playful and carefree, they're facing real adult difficulties. They find solace
in the whimsy of their home, which harbors mysterious soot gremlins. Eventually, the
sister, Mei, meets a trio of forest spirits, the fluffiest of which she dubs Totoro.
Totoro adds a touch of magic to their lives. At one point, he leads a powerful ritual to help
make their plants grow. The corn that grows becomes a source of pride for them. The girls
eagerly anticipate their mother's scheduled visit, but learn she will be delayed. Distraught, young
Mei marches off to find the hospital, determined to bring their mom an ear of corn. After Mei goes
missing, Totoro helps her sister, Satsuki, find her by summoning his whimsical cat bus. Reunited,
the girls then ride the feline vehicle to the hospital. There, they learn that their mother
will be alright after all, and successfully gift her some corn. In the film's final credits,
the girls joyfully reunite with their mother. Totoro is a lovely film about how seemingly
little things, especially the quiet wonder we might take in nature, can help us through difficult
times in our lives. It presents a world that's a bit like ours, but kinder, luckier, and more
magical. Though the girls experience struggle, in the end, everything works out. It's no surprise
that Totoro's a go-to comfort film for many. Grave of the Fireflies, on the other hand,
couldn't be more different. It opens with the teenage protagonist, Saita, dying as a vagrant
in a Tokyo railway station. He's then treated as just one insignificant corpse among many.
The film then shows us what brought Saita to this point, beginning with the air raid that
destroys his neighborhood and kills his mother. He and his sister, Setsuko, are forced to move
in with their distant aunt because their father is fighting in the war. World War II, I'm sure
you've heard of it. As Saita's letters to his father go unanswered, their situation becomes
desperate. His aunt starts withholding food and his sister begins to suffer from malnutrition.
Eventually, the siblings move to an abandoned air raid shelter to escape their aunt.
They set up a life for themselves there, trading and hunting for food. But when food rationing
hits, Saita is forced to start stealing and still can't fully provide for Setsuko. Her sickness
intensifies as the siblings become scarily thin. As the film draws to a close, Saita discovers that
Japan has lost the war and his father is likely dead. Hope dwindling, he tries to find food to
keep Setsuko alive. We learn that while he's been away, she's been making herself sick by eating
marbles and dirt. She then dies. In short, Fireflies is emotionally devastating. It has an unremittingly
grim plot line and the animation style only adds to the despair we feel, occasionally portraying
the ghost of the children haunting their former surroundings. People often describe Fireflies as
depressing. This is in part because of the way it mixes sadness and joy. There are many beautiful
moments of the siblings just being children, playing on the beach, enjoying candy, and so on.
As with the girls in Totoro, they clearly love each other a lot. They also find solace in nature
by capturing Fireflies. But eventually, the Fireflies die because boy, is this film bleak.
But for a fleeting moment at least, we've experienced something wonderful. It feels
like the movie is reminding us of the power of finding small pockets of joy even in the worst
times imaginable. So, on phase, two very different films and a seemingly odd combination. But before
we get into it, a quick thank you. Thank you to you for doing things like watching our videos,
liking them, subscribing to the channel. It means a lot. But if you want to support the channel even
more, consider checking out our Patreon. We'll have a link in the description. We're doing a lot
of cool stuff there. And when you sign up, you get to join our Discord. You get videos early with
no ads. We also have extra bonus audio and video content. And most importantly, it's the best way
for you to directly support the work we're doing here on the channel. So, check it out if you have
a second. Now, back to the show. Let's consider the double billing in the broader context of film
curation, i.e. the practice of selecting and ordering films to be shown in tandem at a movie
theater, film festival, and so on. We typically think of film curation as a way of showing films
with similar themes or subject matter. Like when, say, the Alamo Drafthouse screens a series of
horror films in the month of October. But as film scholar Peter Bozma argues, one important method
of curation is the dialectic curatorial strategy, i.e. combining contrasting films, resulting in a
new level of understanding. For example, a double feature pairing Beethoven and Jurassic Park might
make no sense on face, but when viewed in tandem, the theme of man's futile ambition to control
nature and exploit it for money is underscored and even intensified. Scholar Laura Mulvey compares
this form of curation, which began with French cinema in the 50s, to montage, i.e. the contrasting
of seemingly unrelated film shots edited together as popularized by early Soviet filmmakers. As
Mulvey notes, when you think of film curation as montage, you can see how pairing films together
creates a dialogue with very unexpected movies which start to talk to each other in an unexpected
way and then also say something unexpected to the spectator. That is to say, the collision of
unexpected films can reveal subtle truths or uncover nuanced meaning in both films. As Bozma
explains, curation is the art of constructing meaning and adding value through creating a
So what happens when we think about the dialectic curatorial relationship between Totoro and Grave
of the Fireflies? The two films become more than they each are on their own, and a lot of interesting
things become apparent. For example, Totoro has very odd pacing, especially for a kid's film.
It starts off slowly, with Totoro making his first appearance around the 40-minute mark. It's almost
as if it's been designed for an audience reeling from a profound emotional shock, i.e. watching the
most depressing movie of all time. This is fitting because the protagonists are similarly reeling
from the hospitalization of their mother. And crucially, Fireflies is set in the war period,
while Totoro is set in the 50s, immediately afterwards, during a time of rapid growth
which eventually led to the economic miracle that defined modern Japan. In this way,
they show a Japan in the throes of trauma, and a Japan that has recovered from and learned to live
with that trauma. Thus, the films form a coherent timeline. But when we read them together,
an interesting mirroring also starts to emerge. See, Fireflies is a film with a lot of joy in it
that is ultimately devastatingly sad. Totoro is a film with a lot of sadness in it that is
ultimately comforting and happy. This is fitting because the whole philosophical point of dialectical
logic, in general, is that a concept often contains both itself and its opposite. In Fireflies,
the world around the siblings is cruel and destructive. It's basically tearing itself
apart. Japan is crumbling, and no one extends the siblings even basic charity or compassion.
Community support is non-existent, as most grimly demonstrated in the opening scene,
where nobody cares that a teenager has starved to death in plain sight. In Totoro, however,
the world around the siblings is fundamentally a good one. Their neighbors are friendly and helpful,
and of course, so are the forest spirits they interact with. When things are going wrong,
there exist forces to help them. It feels like the world, and nature specifically,
is more or less on their side. Now, many Ghibli films share an essentially environmentalist
message. They draw on traditional Japanese folk religion to personify a natural world
that, if you live in harmony with it, will care for you and help you. This is Totoro to a T.
And when watched after experiencing the overwhelming despair of Grave of the Fireflies,
Totoro suggests that healing, as people and as a nation, is possible even after unimaginable
sadness, especially when we seek such healing in the natural world. In watching these films together,
the dialectical relationship between joy and despair, nature and man's devastation of it during
war, human generosity and selfishness, all leave an audience with an awareness of these
irreconcilable contradictions in the human experience. It suggests that devastation can
always be tinged with joy, and vice versa. What's more, when contrasted with Fireflies,
Totoro tells us that if we love and respect nature, there is hope for us,
no matter how difficult things get. If we don't, then even our most profound moments of joy
will be fleeting, we'll be lost when we go, like fireflies dying after the night.
But what do you guys think? Is pairing Grave of the Fireflies and Totoro still one of the
weirdest curatorial choices of all time? Or can viewing these seemingly oppositional films in
tandem reveal unexpected things about both? Let us know what you think in the comments,
and if you watch Fireflies for the first time, make sure you have a box full of tissues ready.
Also, be sure to like and subscribe to this video if you enjoyed it.
Check out our Patreon if you haven't already. I promise, it's fun.
And as always, thank you so much for watching. We'll see you later.