Nobel Minds 2019

Scientists won the Nobel Prize
12 followers
3 Video Views·Dec 26, 2025
Welcome to the old Stock Exchange building in Stockholm, which now houses the Swedish Academy,
the Nobel Prize Museum and Library. And this is where we have brought together this year's Nobel
Prize laureates for the first time in discussion on TV. We'll be hearing about their groundbreaking
contributions to economics and science, work that has been judged to advance greatly benefits for
humankind. And we're also joined here in the audience by some of their family and friends,
as well as students from Sweden. So Nobel laureates, welcome to you all and congratulations.
Now you've been awarded what is arguably the most prestigious prize in your fields.
You've been thrust center stage in the world. All the eyes are on you. Are you enjoying all
this attention or are you wanting to retreat back into your labs? How are you going to use
this public platform? Professor Kellog. Well, I feel like a rock star. I mean, it's unbelievable,
the level of expectations. It's just massively, I mean, it's just unbelievable. It's just like a flow.
And I guess there are responsibilities that come with that. And what I really would like to do
here, I think I would like to show to everyone that science is fun and it's beautiful. And I
think this is a way to say, I see my work. I'm convinced already. Wish I'd studied science. So
Professor Esther Duflo, you've got a bit of a burden on your shoulders. And if you see it that
way, because you're only the second ever woman to have won the economics prize and you are the
youngest recipient also. Do you see your role now with perhaps inspiring women? I should add,
I'm the only woman besides you on this table. Yes. And I've not won a prize.
Which I like a little bit how broad a problem is that there are relatively few women in sciences,
in economics, even fewer underrepresented minorities. My hope, of course, is that
we can serve as a little bit of a role model for other women and brown people to come into
the field of economics and in science generally. Well, I'm sure you are. And girls and women,
wherever you're watching, listen to what Professor Duflo has just said. So Professor Banerjee,
you are married to Professor Duflo. You've been awarded the Nobel Economics Prize,
along with Michael Cremo, who's sitting next to me. But do you mind your wife perhaps getting
more attention than you because of the fact that she's a woman? No, he doesn't.
This has been true all our lives together. This is not new to me. There's a variety of reasons
for that, including gender. But I think gender is only a small part of it. She's also just fun,
more fun to watch and more fun to listen to. What a lovely husband you have and fellow
collaborator. Okay, well, the other economists, Professor Cremo, how are you going to use your
platform? The spread of mobile phones has just created tremendous opportunities to provide
information to people who need it around the world. And with big data and machine learning,
we can tailor those messages to people. And I'm hoping to work with governments,
and I'm working with governments and private firms to try to help them find ways to deliver
information, for example. Which you always did, but you're going to do it even more then.
All right, let's go to Greg Semenza. How are you going to use your medicine or physiology
prize platform? Well, you know, we, of course, will continue our work. But I guess on a broader
public stage, we need to try to emphasise the importance of science for making decisions in
society. And there's, you know, more recently, a sense that facts don't matter. And I think we
have to emphasise that they do matter, and that science and scientists should play an important
role in important decision making for society. So a wider message, in a sense, from you.
That's gone down well, hasn't it? Stanley Whittingham, you are flying the flag for the
three chemistry laureates, because John Goodenough and Professor Yoshino can't be with us. So what
about you? Are you enjoying being in the public spotlight? Like, are you happy being sitting here
next to me, for instance? Yes, sure. Yes, good. I think now with the lithium battery, that area,
we can now address the issues of energy, sustainability, and particularly global
warming, when all the politicians are saying it doesn't matter. So I think we have to use this
prize now to, you know, transmit to everybody, this is a very important area, and we have to
address it. All right, good. We'll be hearing more about that shortly. Professor William Kalin,
one of the medicine and physiology winners. Yes. Well, I think we're seeing now already some
themes emerging, because I never thought I'd see the day where truth and knowledge and expertise
would come under assault. And this is very dangerous, unless we want to return to the dark
ages. So like many of my other fellow laureates, I want to use the prize to be an advocate
for the importance of science and the importance of generating new knowledge,
and the importance for making decisions based on that knowledge. So just very quickly,
do you think that now in sort of public discourse, we are going more into the realm of fantasy and
fiction and not giving enough respect, paying enough respect to facts? Well, we see this already,
the example of climate change has been brought up where, you know, people think they can just pick
and choose facts and pseudo facts and just, you know, based on what's expedient, decide how they're
going to proceed. And I think we have to get back to making decisions based on data and truth
and knowledge. All right. James Peebles, what about you? I base my career on curiosity.
Where are we? What is our situation in the world? Curiosity drives all of us, I think, and I urge
all of you to keep curious. You, of course, have the drive, I must put food on the table.
But beyond that, try to be curious about what's around you and pay attention to what you observe.
That's your message. Sir Peter Ratcliffe. Yeah, well, it sure is a transformation.
All sorts of people answer my emails that didn't used to.
All sorts of people agree with me who didn't used to. It even includes my family.
Right. Professor Michel Maillot, another of the physicists.
Yes, our society is looking for important challenge. And I'm very sad to see that in
many, many parliament, we have very few scientists being part of the decision, political decision.
OK, let's just hear a little bit more then about what your various prizes were awarded for. And
we're going to kick off with economics. And before we come to each category, we're going to just
show a very short little film which sets out what the prize was actually awarded for.
So let's just see the economics one, please.
Why do some children learn so little in school? Why aren't they all vaccinated?
Michael Creamer, Object Banerjee and Esther Duflo have found a way to answer questions like that
and in doing so have considerably improved our ability to fight global poverty.
Using randomized controlled trials, their method unpacks problems one by one, helping,
for example, to promote remedial tutoring in schools in India and subsidies for preventative
health care. So, Professor Michael Creamer, you were awarded the prize jointly with Professor
Duflo and Banerjee. Their work was in a way separate but related to yours. And you're all
interested in working in poverty. And I just wonder what motivated you into wanting to work
in this field? Well, these are some of the most important problems in the world. And, you know,
one thing that I think discourages many people from working on them is the view that they're
intractable. But one thing that we found in our work is that while there are indeed some things
that some ways of addressing poverty that don't work, there are also many that have a tremendous
impact. And so I think this is an area where we can make a difference and I think we have a moral
obligation to make a difference. But have you got a sort of personal reason why you wanted to go
into this field of economics? You know, I think, you know, my family, my mother taught me that
these were our responsibilities. And I think that's partly why I went into it, a big reason
why I went into it. I'm fortunate enough that the field that I work in is very exciting
intellectually as well. So it's fun at the same time, which is great. Professor Duflo,
what made you want to work in this kind of area? So I'm going to blame my mother as well.
Oh, I like this, the mothers being the influences. Yes. So I grew up in a very
sort of ordinary household in a suburb of Paris with a mathematician for a father and a pediatrician
for a mother. And she, in addition to her regular work, she was also spending time with an NGO
helping kids, victims of wars, going to the Sahara first and then to El Salvador repeatedly.
And every time she was going, she was telling us, you know, this is your part. This is what you're
doing to help the kids in the world. Professor Banerjee, you were born in Mumbai, but raised in
Kolkata and you were from a middle class family. But you say that your home was on the edge of
basically slums in Kolkata. I mean, did that perhaps influence your decision to work in
alleviating poverty? Well, in a sense, I feel like looking back, I don't know how one can work in
economics and not work on alleviating poverty. That to me is more baffling than the other around.
In some ways, it's the most starkest economic problem you've ever encountered. But having said
that, again, I'll blame my mother, who would be. My mother has very strong opinions about everything,
including all the things that are wrong in society. So being growing up in a place where
there were just many social problems, very visible, very visible, meaning we lived on the lane
that was the one exit from the slum. So we saw all the children with no clothes and all the
parents who were upset with their lives. And my mother would be running a commentary on all of
that. And so I don't think I had any escape eventually. I think it's wonderful that we've got
these very strong role models amongst the mothers. So just turning to the work that you've done,
Professor Cremer, I mean, we know that millions of children die all over the world every year from
preventable diseases. Now, your work in particular looked at deworming of children in Kenya,
particularly rural Kenya, and also the provision of clean water. And in the case of deworming,
your studies showed that there was a greater take-up of the pills by the parents if these
were made available, free of charge. Right. I have to say to you, is that not stating the blinding
obvious? Isn't it? I'm sorry. It should be completely obvious. It should be completely
obvious. But I think there were, first, there were many organisations, including multilateral
organisations such as the World Bank, but also NGOs that felt it was very important to charge
people something. And what we found was even a very small fee leads to a tremendous reduction
in the percentage of people who take up these preventive health, whether that's clean water,
whether that's deworming medicine. So since that time, there's been a huge change. Many
policymakers, again, from the World Bank to national governments, are now making preventive
health care available for free. And that's led to huge reductions in malaria as mosquito nets
have become free. Many governments have instituted national school-based deworming programs.
Government of Kenya did that. Government of India did that. 150 million children are now being
dewormed as a result of those two governments' decisions every year. And that's, you know,
that's wonderful. Very good, yeah. Professor Diplo. Yeah, I'd like to kind of comment on
something you said. Isn't it obvious? I think every time we think something is obvious,
we should put it to the test. Most of our intuitions are wrong. That's true for
economists' intuition. That's true for policymakers' intuition. That's probably
even true for your intuitions. And I think one of our contributions, if any, is to say,
whenever you think something is obvious, put it to the test, and put it to the test as rigorously
as possible, if possible, with an experiment, which is often possible. And you will often
discover that whatever you thought was obvious happens to be incorrect, either completely or at
least partially. That's interesting, because some of your pioneering work has been using RCTs,
randomized controlled trials, to try to understand the behavior of poorer communities.
And that's precisely what you did in your work, which is quite groundbreaking. Well, I think,
I mean, to take us back to where this started, Michael did an experiment where I think he
started with the presumption that giving textbooks to kids who don't have it was obvious, like you
said, and would certainly make them better at school. And it didn't. And then we did an
experiment together where we said, we're going to halve the class size. We're going to take
one teacher's school and turn it into two teacher's schools. And again, it was blindingly
obvious to us that this was going to do wonderful things, and was very precisely rejected. We got
zero effect of doubling the teachers. And that, I think, was the most educative experience I had
in this whole field. And it sort of made me realize, A, what Esther said, which is that,
you know, the obvious is not the obvious. And second, it made us go back to thinking,
what could be going wrong? Right. And Professor Duflo, I mean, in the realm of education,
you discovered a very novel approach, saying that free textbooks don't work, as we've just heard,
and so on. So just in essence, what was it you discovered that really had a profound impact on
improving levels of education at the primary level? So it's not something I discovered individually,
because another characteristic of our work is that it's really little pieces by little pieces,
and little experiment by little experiment. So we often say that this prize is a prize for
a movement. So think of each experiment as a little dot that progressively helps you emerge
the picture. Very much probably like in medicine, I suppose, that the war of cancer is not like,
let's find like the one magic medicine that is going to cure everything. It's many, many,
many things. So same thing with poverty. So the answer, again, blindingly obvious expose,
is what we call with the organization Pratham in India, teach at the right level, which is go back
to what the kids don't know yet, and teach them at that level. So for a few hours a day, or for a
few days in a year, practice the students, not by their age, but by their current level
of achievement. And then teach them, if they don't know letters, teach them letter. Frequently re-jiggle
them so that they can learn that their progress. Some people make extremely fast progress with the
system. And what we've seen is tremendous improvement in experiment when kids were
subjected, when kids were benefiting from that. You've actually put this, apply this in practice.
Do any of the other laureates want to comment on the economic surprise and poverty alleviation?
Professor Kello? Yeah, I was fascinated by the discussion, because you, I mean, you operate with
facts, and you're telling us that I establish facts, and then I draw conclusions from these
facts by having relation between them. And then I build an understanding on this basis, and then I
address a new test and new facts, which is all what we're doing as a scientist. And I'm fascinated
to hear that it seems to be so new, because, I mean, it looks to me like going 500 years back
in time, at the time in Italy, when we had this trial against church, against Galileo Galilei. And
Galileo would say, look at my facts in my telescope. And the church said, no, we don't want to look at
the facts, because we know what it is. So I'm just absolutely fascinated by this discussion.
I guess I would, may I? I think that's slightly, that's slightly maybe unfair to economics, because
I think people have always been dealing with facts. I think the question of what we're trying
to do, which is different, is look at the granularity of the facts. I think what people
don't often know is that, you know, when you talk of education, it's education is good, and that
there's a correlation between higher education and higher GDP. This is a fact. It's not a fact,
but it's hard to interpret that fact, because education doesn't mean one thing. It means a
million things. It means the pedagogy. It means the classroom. It means the teacher training. It
means number of teachers. So when you put each of those pieces together, you get this massive thing
called education. Education is good, but that doesn't necessarily tell us very much about what
to do. And what we're trying to do is take that kind of very general fact and break it into smaller
facts, and the smaller facts are much more informative about a plan to action, and that's
the case we're trying to make. So it's not that economists have not known that facts are important.
Professor Banerjee leaping to the defense of economists against the physicists.
Thank you. Well, if there are clear benefits to the work being done by the economists,
the same can be said of the medicine or physiology laureates. So before we turn to them,
let's just see a brief highlight of what the prize was awarded for.
Oxygen is essential for all animal life because it allows food to be converted into energy,
but how cells adapt to changes in levels of oxygen has been little understood until the research of
William Kalin, Peter Ratcliffe, and Greg Semenza. They identified the molecular machinery which
regulates the activity of genes in response to varying levels of oxygen. Manipulating those
levels paves the way for new strategies to fight anemia, cancer, and many other diseases.
So medicine laureates, you're all doctors working as clinicians. You've worked as clinicians.
To what extent did that inspire you to go into the lab because perhaps you dealt with patients
on a regular basis? Professor Bill Kalin. So imagine you had an internal combustion engine
and you were asked to fix it and you didn't have the parts list and you didn't understand the
principles of an internal combustion engine and then someone handed you a hammer and said start
fixing it and that's what it felt like to me as a cancer physician in the 80s. It was very
frustrating. It was clear we just needed to understand the disease better. So that's what
motivated me to get scientific training and then it turned out it was my clinical knowledge of a
rare hereditary form of cancer called von Hippel-Lindau disease that indicated to me that
the responsible gene had to play an important role in oxygen sensing. And then you ceased to be
practicing doctors didn't you and you all just stayed in the laboratory but that experience
with patients stayed with you and worked as inspiration. So your work, to what extent will
your work pave the way for new strategies to have new drugs in tackling diseases like cancer,
anemia is one of the other ones being mentioned? There's already you know drugs being tested now
for the treatment of anemia that's been approved in several countries and will probably be approved
in the US and Europe in the near future. We studied originally erythropoietin which is produced by the
kidney. Patients who have kidney failure no longer make erythropoietin. Which is a kind of? It's a
hormone that controls red blood cell production so the kidney secretes it into the bloodstream
and then it goes to the bone marrow and stimulates the production of red cells which of course carry
the oxygen to every cell in the body. And at the moment patients with kidney failure require
injections of this of epoprotein that's been made in the lab. These new drugs will simply be pills
that can be taken by mouth and will turn on the system that's already there to allow the body
to make its own epo. Professor Kenney just maybe explain in very simple terms how your work
operates in the body. Yeah so basically the three of us helped to define a molecular pathway or a
molecular circuit that tells the cells and tissues in your body whether they're getting enough
oxygen or not. And once we understood the circuit there were opportunities to intervene with drugs
to either make the circuit more active or less active depending on what the disease was. And so
for example as Greg said there's a pill you can take by mouth that tricks your body into thinking
at high altitude activates the system and you start making more red blood cells.
Conversely certain cancers need oxygen and so they use the system in a different way and now
we have drugs that can help block the cancer from hijacking the system. You Sir Peter have talked
about scientists being very competitive. Are you yourself specifically being quite competitive?
Actually I said the three of us were.
Okay I stand corrected. I heard him he did say that.
So I mean we tend to think of scientists as complementing one another's work and sharing
research and so on. Is that not right? Were you three sort of like no this is my research?
We're competitors but the organization of human behavior civilization
and trains human competitiveness to the cooperative advantage. It will be really
interesting to have the economists view on this. I never understand economics but you are really
trying to find rules of society of money of finance of behavior that get what we want out
of this competitiveness. Is it not so? Professor Banerjee.
Economists tend to love the using the word competition but in the way we work we tend to
actually be very collaborative and it's not particularly that I personally I hate being
in a very competitive environment and I would not flourish there. So I think that there's a
sense in which economists use the word competition with more. That's about other people.
And Didier Kello you have said I feel very connected to your fellow laureate professor
Mayur's brain. Well go on. I mean look when you work with someone so intensively for so long
of course you get connected so and any physical experimental setup since a long time is not a
single man endeavor right now. It's big teams and if you look at the size of the experimental
setup right now you talk about 1,000 people working together. So by design it's an absolute
collaborative network that makes science possible otherwise it would not work. Right good. Okay well
we're going to move from medicine. The chemistry prize provides an opportunity to address issues
in global warming and so we turn to that but let's just see a short film about what the
It's carried and used by most of us every day in mobile phones computers and tablets as well as
electric cars. It is the lithium-ion battery. Stanley Whittingham developed the first prototype
having discovered that some superconducting materials hold a very high energy density.
John Goodenough and Akira Yoshino refined the battery making it commercially viable.
This provided stable lightweight renewable energy storage helping to create the right
conditions for a wireless world free of fossil fuels. The world's most powerful battery. So
Professor Stanley Whittingham you're representing all three chemistry laureates your two fellow
laureates couldn't be with us. So the world's most powerful battery but frankly it's not powerful
enough to really do everything we want it to at the moment. No the batteries we've developed are
really a first step. They'll get us the next step. It will help us reduce some of the CO2 we generate.
We can easily convert vehicles over to electric transportation. We can clean up the cities for
example by only allowing electric vehicles in the center of cities like Stockholm, London,
New York and eventually it will help us also get solar energy, wind energy really into the
mainstream. Some countries are doing it but if we have the sunshine particularly I noticed in
Stockholm this week we need to store the energy so we can use it when we want it. You actually
worked in the 70s during the oil crisis with the Exxon oil company trying to find alternatives then
because people were very concerned about you know oil supplies and so on. Why has it taken so long
to get to where you are? I mean the lithium-ion battery wasn't really commercially viable until
perhaps the early 90s, 91. In the end we have private industry it's all economic incentives
that drive it and oil prices went up in the 70s. By the end of the 70s they dropped back down again
so there's no economic driver to do alternative energies until the last maybe 10 years where
solar has come into place, wind is coming into place and there's a huge push on electric transportation
and in the end it's partly people that are going to push it. It's the desire of people so
we scientists have to educate the population that's what the issues really are. Right and so
when people in the developing world are listening to what you have to say and you know you hear a
lot about how they can leapfrog technology and not get rich and dirty as the industrialized world did
I mean how viable is that? Well you can look at the smartphone as an example of that. It is.
The developing world do not have hard lines for telephones anymore. They leapfrog that whole step
and I think in some ways in the energy area they can leapfrog the coal
and the oil and go directly to some of the renewables. If you look at some of the
African countries there's plenty of sun there. Anybody want to come in on what they've heard
Professor Wilkinson? This is one of the more hopeful things I've heard. I mean frankly having
worked on you know studying human disease for 30 years there in my darker days I worry that
trying to alleviate diseases is like you know deck chairs on the Titanic given the problems
that will face us if we don't get this right so I'm heartened to hear some of your views on the
future. I think it's very exciting what as we saw from the chemistry prize how science can make a
in climate change but I think we need two things. We need the institutions and funding to support
the science but we also need as you said economic incentives to adopt that technology and those are
both things that human institutions can help provide and you know part of the challenge we
face as societies is to both keep that science moving and make sure we use it. And going back
to the point about fake news I think you have a huge responsibility. I really think that the
message is so stark and so clear that the fact that there is ambiguity out there I feel like
in a sense media hasn't been as emphatic about how clear the evidence is as it might have been.
I think the overwhelming climate change. Yes I mean the evidence is on both sides on both the
side that it's happening it's it's critical and that it's not impossible to fix. The problem I
have is 2050 or something people are planning for something which is likely to be intrinsically
unstable so you either believe it or you don't if you believe it as as we all do
then it's a matter of immediacy. But I don't think it's not belief it's facts versus lies.
Elaborating. Just expand on that Professor Semenza. It's people lying for their own
self-interest and against humanity and frankly to me it's it's kind of hard to believe
but this is what we're faced with. People with vested interests who do you mean in particular?
Many many people with many different vested interests. Professor Peeble. Let's bear in mind
that this problem is of climate is so difficult. Remember that the prime greenhouse gas is water
vapor. Without water vapor this would be a snowball planet. Water vapor depends on how
the clouds form. That depends on how centers of nucleation set out by salt spray. So many
uncertainties. We should be cautious about overstating the direction we're going other
than that it sounds dangerous. So what you mean there might be a big freeze around the corner?
Well I'm no climatologist but you can see how complicated the problem is. Sweden depends on
the Gulf Stream. The Gulf Stream could start flowing another direction and you would have
a local deep freeze. So what you don't think that these climate scientists who do all their
projections about this is how things go. Belief is always a dangerous thing. You're sounding a bit
skeptical. Well I am because I see the problem is so complex. So I feel nervous about saying
we are headed toward an overheated planet. We're doing a dangerous experiment but I don't think we
know which direction it's going to go. The problem is when by the time we find out it'll be too late.
Oh certainly. Nonetheless you can't be too sure about predicting. Remember the
Yogi Berra predictions are difficult particularly about the future.
Bill Kalin you want to say something to James Peebles directly? So I think it's important for
people to understand that it's almost impossible to get scientists to agree on anything including
things that are clearly true. You know it's like herding cats. I think we had a demonstration of
that when we were doing our sound checks pre-recording. And so they're always going to be
heretics and heretics play a really important role. Is that what you're accusing Professor
Peebles of being? Well that may be the direction he's going but that would be fine with me because
heretics are really important in science because they challenge our ideas, they challenge our
assumptions and they force us to do better experiments. But what heretics should never
be used for is to make policy decisions. And what's happening now in some corners is people
are saying well let's just hope that the heretics are right because wouldn't that all be
convenient? And so if you think back for example to South Africa where the government was convinced
that a virus didn't cause AIDS that led to hundreds of thousands of preventable deaths.
Professor Duflo? I would do my usual job of bringing it to the here and now. Any warming
of the planet is going to start hurting particularly people in the poor world more
than people in the rich world both because it is hotter there and because they have fewer means
to adjust. So the problem we have to face is not 2050 it's like yesterday. All right so your
Nobel laureates are going to be in great demand, you're going to be asked to fly to this place and
that, to speak at this conference and that. So are you going to be mindful about where you go
or in the style of the Swedish environmental activist Greta Thunberg get out your boats and
your sails and go by train? What are you going to do? Professor Beeble? We all flew here I expect
an immense emission of carbon dioxide. So we are I believe as cynical as the rest of
the world in that respect. We find it difficult to make the sacrifices. Actually yes we do have
to stop flying and a lot of other things. So you're going to be quite picky about which
invitations you accept personally? Well I've had 200, it comes to half a million miles.
It's completely... So how many tons of carbon would that be? Well I can't, my maths and the
physicists would help me on that one. Good okay well we're going to move from the chemistry prize
and look at an extremely big picture, the whole universe, the cosmos and return to the physics
laureates. But let's see what your prize was awarded for first. 95% of the universe consists
of something we know very little about, dark energy and dark matter. Those terms were defined
by James Peebles and that gave us the science of cosmology, a new understanding of the universe's
structure and history. Michel Mayor and Didier Kello started an astronomy revolution by discovering
a planet outside our solar system, the first exoplanet 51 Pegasi b. More than 4,000 exoplanets
have since been found in the Milky Way, perhaps making the thought of extraterrestrial life
a little bit less fiction-like. Okay physics laureates, straight to the point.
Professor Mayor, is there life somewhere out there? We don't know.
But this is a very important domain for the next generation because what we are sure that we have
plenty of rocky planets at some good distance from the stars to have the possibility to have
the complex chemistry needed for life development. So the problem is not to find new planets at a
good place, the problem is to know what happens when you have the good conditions. And this is no
more a problem of astrophysics, it's a problem, basically it's a problem of biology, chemistry.
Professor Kello, what about you? Is there life possibly somewhere out there in the universe and
if so what kind of life might it be? Well it's a way too difficult question certainly and to
address. It's too big, the questions, but I think we follow a bit the same path. I know
a fellow economist that's saying, well we're going to break this apart in different bits
and then I mean try to understand first, can we say something about the origin of life on Earth?
I mean we have a lot of elements to play with on Earth. We have an amazing knowledge, all life
is working on Earth and we still not know exactly how this whole story started. And then you can
explore life in the solar systems on Mars and Venus and other satellites of giant Jupiter and
then we can push further out to maybe all these other planets. What can we say about life on it?
So it's a very very long process but we're starting. But is it possible that there's some
kind of microorganisms inhabiting a planet out there, Mars perhaps, Venus? Well I think that
would be the topic for another Nobel laureate. Oh I'm so disappointed. Maybe we can address a
different question first. In the solar system we have several places where maybe life could emerge
but not on the surface, maybe in the ocean under the ice shield of Europa, a satellite and so on.
So this is a huge topic and it would be much more fascinating maybe to do some experiments to find
if you have some very simple organism in this ocean and to maybe to have the possibility to
compare what kind of DNA they have compared to the Earth. Professor Peebles, your work looked at the
evolution of the cosmos, the universe and Earth's place in the cosmos. But before I move on to that
just tell us, do you believe that there might be extraterrestrial life in whatever form out there?
I think what is charming is the fact that we can be quite sure that there are thousands of
millions of planets in our galaxy, there are thousands of millions of galaxies.
There will be that many planets on which all sorts of marvellous things are happening
that we the human race will never see. So it's possible?
My lesson is we have a very limited reach. Don't disappoint all those science fiction fans
who are watching this and so on. I think there are better things to worry about.
And okay, fair enough.
We hear people talk quite seriously about you know perhaps in time the human race can colonise
another planet, Mars for instance, you know we often hear is there life on Mars and so on.
Just what is the viability of these kind of ideas?
Well I mean my position on this usually is always the same. I mean we are really
designed as a species to stay on Earth. There's no plan for us to go in space,
it's an extremely dangerous place to go and going to Mars is really an amazingly dangerous
situation because you're not protected anymore like we are on Earth by the atmosphere,
by the magnetic field. So I think being there is really not the place, it is not our place
in a way. There's nothing for us is designed there. Now there is just a practicality I think.
I think just try to take a plane already and to cross the Atlantic and it takes some time.
Well try to go to the Moon, well it will take a bit longer. Try to go to Mars, it's quite a trip.
How long would it take in Earth years?
You know in physics it all depends on your speed.
So talking about is there life possibly out there elsewhere in the universe,
what do the rest of you think?
We'd like to dream about what's up there right? We should all dream. Don't be constrained by
what our peers may think. We need to dream and maybe there's something up there. Let's keep
looking. Well I think you know if you look at life on planet Earth it's changed dramatically. So for
example the first forms of life existed on a planet where there was no oxygen. And so they
required completely different strategies to make energy and to survive. And then somehow an organism
learned how to trap the Sun's light in carbon bonds to make sugar by photosynthesis. And one of
the byproducts of that was to generate oxygen. And oxygen accumulated within the atmosphere
and probably killed most of the organisms that were living at the time because oxygen is very
toxic unless you have ways to protect yourself against it. So there's been I think a tremendous
range of life on Earth and different strategies of life. And so there's no reason to believe that
there wouldn't be other strategies on other planets that would allow life to exist.
Anybody on the, is there life out there? And then we'll move on but yes okay.
Yes I kind of want to, this has been fascinating but I want to jump on that and go back to Earth.
What I take from this conversation is if there is life out there it's not for us. It's too far
anyway and we are not that adapted to it. So and the second thing I took from this conversation is
that the condition could change in a way that are pretty dramatic. And we are as a human species
making sure that to accelerate this process. So I think it is pretty essential that we also think
about the here and now. About getting you know human welfare here and now. Getting food, water
and energy to people now. And we protect the climate now. And we should by all means dream
about these things. But many people should also by all means think about how we are gonna adjust
our behavior as a human species to make sure that they continue to be life on this planet.
Right well I think we've got to the end of our time. I want to just very quickly go around the
table very very quickly. Brief answers please. So Professor Whittingham one of your fellow laureates
for chemistry Professor John Goodenough is 97 years of age. He's from America and he still
goes into the office every day. Laureates does that idea appeal to you or would you like to go
into retirement or does the idea of working as a near centenarian appeal to you? Let's go around
the table. Michael Creamer. I don't know whether I'll be able to do that but I certainly would
aspire to. I mean the problems that we're addressing all of us around here are very
important. And you know it's both fun and very exciting to help try to address these challenges.
And I'm very excited to continue to do so. I have no idea what else I'm good at.
So you would work until I drop. Professor Duplo. So I was so inspired by Professor Goodenough
and I you know I'm exercising all the time to try to keep myself at that level for as long as
possible. Professor Mayor. I'm lucky enough to be in a so exciting domain so I will be very frustrated
to stop right now. DTA Keller. Well I think we're very fortunate to do something with so much
patience and passions. And why would you stop? So I've been retired for 19 years but I keep my
office. I walk in most every day and enjoy what I'm doing. I plan to do that until I can no longer
do it. Fabulous. Well I like to think I've gotten more knowledgeable over the years and maybe
slightly wiser but I don't think I'm actually as smart as I was as a young man. I think that's the
trade-off that comes with aging and perhaps for that reason science is often dominated by the
young people. So I hope I'm engaged in science at that age but I'm not sure it'll be specifically
running a laboratory. We'll see. Oh I'm trying to do so. We're so fortunate you know. People refer
to it as basic science or curiosity driven science or investigator living science. None of those are
very good words for what we do. You're harnessing our passion. Passion for discovery and that's I
think the reason we all want to go, most of us want to go on. It's a passion.
Greg Semenza. I agree it's too much fun to stop. Not too much fun. And Stanley Whittingham. Yeah I'm
excited about what I'm doing and my wife and I have this discussion every February when we're
tired of the snow we say time to retire. 10 minutes later we say but we like doing what we're doing so
we're going to keep doing it and my doctor tells me don't retire. Well thank you May. You all have
wonderful flourishing futures. You're clearly all going from strength to strength to strength.
Thank you all very much indeed Nobel laureates and also here to the audience at the Old Stock
Exchange in Stockholm for me Zainab Badawi and the rest of the Nobel Minds team. Until the next
year. Goodbye.
