Can You Replant Thinned Radishes?)

My Green Garden
1 follower
Dec 23, 2025
Hey friends, today I want to show you how to thin radishes. This is like one of those tasks that is
so hard. I actually read this quote, I forget who said it, some famous gardener and he said
a gardener should never have to thin their own plants. I think it's just like a moral dilemma,
you know, because you planted them and then you have to pull them out and it's like so sad. So
today I'm going to show you how I resolve the moral dilemma of having to thin my plants
by just replanting them. So it's kind of not necessarily the traditional way to do it,
let's just put it that way. But I'm going to show you what I do in order to make the most
of all the seeds I planted and hopefully get extra radishes out of the deal. So these are
French breakfast radishes that are growing on the edge of my kitchen garden. These are botanical
interests. I absolutely love this brand of seed and I love this kind of radish. They're not too
peppery or bitter and they grow so well and so predictably well, which I think is so important
if you're a new gardener or if you don't have, you know, a ton of time for the fails,
which is my case. So I planted these directly by seed. They have great instructions, by the way,
on the seed packages. So they tell you to space your seeds about one inch apart, which is awesome
that's not that far, right? And then these actually will emerge in five to ten days and
they're usually ready to harvest within a month to 45 days, which for me being impatient, I don't
know if you're like that, but it's just so fabulous to get to harvest something so fast. And the
awesome part about growing your own radishes is you can eat the whole plant. So unlike, you know,
you get radishes from the store, the greens are all like gross and slimy or they're not even there.
Here on the plant, you get to eat the whole thing because you just pull it and then eat it. It's
awesome. So let's talk about how to thin. So I, the little quick story here is I planted seeds
and then I got impatient and things weren't coming up as fast as I wanted them to. There's a weed.
So I came back and planted again and then the ones that I originally planted showed up and
the ones that I planted the second time showed up. So I ended up with double the radishes,
which I'm not complaining, but they might be complaining because they're not getting enough
space to grow. So generally speaking in inches, basically, you know, like thumb to forefinger,
if you just kind of, I think, did y'all learn this in school? Like your eye is like an inch,
something like that. So if you're kind of eyeballing it, then you're going to be, each
needs to be about one inch from each other. That's the minimum. So, or yeah, the minimum,
and then you could go to two inches if you want to have larger radishes. So if I just go along
this line here, you can see these are kind of, I've thinned them a couple of times to be honest,
but you can see if I have this kind of, as my rule, this one inch, I can come in and see,
you know, whether or not each of these radishes has a full inch between them. And most of them
do have that. So these two are pretty properly spaced. These two are okay, but you can see how
it's kind of spindly there, and you can almost see how the radish is forming above the soil line.
So this one I'm going to actually pull and replant because I can tell I'm not going to
get a successful radish out of that. So I'm just going to lightly pull. I try to pull from the stem
if I can, and if it won't come out, I'll pull the whole more from the root. So there's that.
We're going to replant that in a second. I'm going to show you how we do this kind of along
the line. So I'm going to keep going. You can see how these two are too close together.
So I'm going to come in. It's kind of like detangling hair, and any root that's not,
it doesn't look like it's forming under the soil, but it's forming above the soil.
That usually means that there either wasn't good enough soil contact with the seed itself,
or there wasn't enough space. You can see these two, they're definitely too close together.
They're literally sharing the one inch together. So when it comes to these two, I'm going to choose
which one I think looks healthiest. So this one seems to be more into the soil. So I'll pull
this one up instead. And isn't it cool? You can already see the coloration of the radish. You can
almost like, it's like future, right? You can see what that's going to become. So I just pull that
out and basically try to get each one to about one inch between the plants. So I'll literally
go through, and it is painstakingly tough, I'll have to say. So sometimes you'll thin one like
this. That's just too tiny probably to even do anything with. So this could be more like a
microgreen. You can bring that inside and put that on a salad. But I will just kind of come in,
pull each one that I can tell is growing too close to another one, or just isn't getting proper
contact with the soil and isn't deep enough. And then I'll be leaving the ones that seem like they
have good contact with the soil and plenty of space. All right, so I'm just going to go through,
do a handful to show you. And then I try not to let these sit here for too long. And I'm going
tell you why. So at this point, you could put these in the compost pile. You could take the
greens just like a microgreen and eat them right there on the spot if you want to. No harm, no foul.
Or you can do what I try to do, which is to replant. Now replanting is a total gamble.
Most professional gardeners would tell you not to do this. But I love to do it and I usually
have pretty good success. So I usually try to get this in the ground as quickly as possible.
I'm going to take a dibber and make a nice generous hole because I don't want to disturb
the roots anymore. I've already kind of disturbed them pretty badly by pulling it up. And then I'm
going to bury this pretty deeply. So I know this is like a jungle in here. It's probably hard to
see. But hopefully you can see how I just replanted that and I pushed it all the way down to the crown
of the plant. So I'm going to do a few of those so you can kind of get an idea. So right here I'll
do another one. See I've got plenty of space. I know I have a full inch away from any other plant.
And then I'm literally just going to stick this right down and support it with some soil.
So the great thing about this is you're taking a chance. You might get a new radish. You might not.
But you know it helps me deal with the drama of thinning plants because for me for years
I wouldn't thin my plants because I literally couldn't deal with the fact that I was pulling
the plants I'd worked so hard to grow that I was pulling them out of the ground.
So worst case scenario which is going to give you a little bit of soil coverage
as your other plants are growing in. But best case scenario you'll end up saving these radishes
and get way more out of your original sowing. So again like I said probably if you follow a lot of
other gardeners this might be you know totally against what they would say. But you know to
each his own. That's the beauty of gardening right? You get to do it your way. So I'm going to plant
all of these in here. So I kind of end up with a second another row. The trick here too is like
minimal root disturbance and getting those radishes replanted ASAP. So you would not want those
to sit around and you know not be planted. Definitely you're going to have to do it like
within seconds of thinning. So I'll do one more to show you and then we're going to harvest
some of our first radishes which is super exciting! Okay let me say I'm going to kind
of dig through here and again see how those are kind of curved? I don't know about y'all but my
first few years of growing radishes that's all I would get. They would like form this bulb.
But it was it was all above ground so it would never turn into anything.
And I realized it was usually because of bad soil contact at planting time or that plant is just
really reaching to get to the sunlight and so it ends up pushing up. Now immediately after you
plant these, replant them, you've got to water them in. So I kind of drowned that one. And when
you water it in you're going to be able to see you know how supported it is. Like you can see
how some of these are sinking. So I know that I need to give them a little bit more soil support.
So I'm just watering in kind of soaking it and then I'll watch these pretty closely
over the next few days to see if they make it. If any of them don't I will just come pull them up or
you know just let them sit here probably and give them a few days. But they do need water.
You want to treat them like literally you know babies. Plants are plants. Plants are I was gonna
say plants are plants for a reason. But as you know if you think about it plants are meant to
be planted. It's in their DNA to go in one place and never leave right. Unlike animals that love
to move, plants love to stay in one place. So anytime you move a plant you know especially
at this young age you gotta know like you're gonna have to really support it because it is
very disturbed by the moving. Okay now let's harvest our first few radishes. This is super
exciting and it's awesome to do. You want to do it quite often mostly because harvesting them means
that you're going to get more. You're making more space. So here's the first radish of this season.
Super exciting. Yay! Look at that beauty. Now French breakfast radishes can get a little bit
bigger than this but I actually really like them at this size because they're not too peppery
and not too starchy. So there's one. Let's see if we can pull another one. All right so let's do this
one. Kind of separate out so you want to be careful you're only pulling that one radish at a
time and perfect. So put this one next to that one and then I think we have room. I saw one more
that looked pretty awesome. So you can see how the greens really kind of give you a clue as to how
close the radish is to being harvested. You're getting good green growth here on these more
mature radishes. See how I've got center growth and exterior growth. All right let's see if I can
make sure you see this. So the way I test it right is I can see the red popping up. That's how I know
it's very close and ready to be harvested. So once your first radishes start to be ready
you really want to be harvesting every few days so that you're making space for new ones to finish
up and grow as well. And then this is a great plant to succession seeds so I can come right in
honestly right after you know harvesting take a few extra seeds and pop them in and I could be
getting radishes. I could make a new row you know every one to two weeks and I could be getting
radishes from now into well into probably July here in the Chicago area. So my friends that is
how to thin your radishes so you get more and you don't have to deal with the moral dilemma
of pulling up the plants that you work so hard to plant. I hope this has encouraged you to
experiment in the garden to not always follow tradition and to make your own way because that's
what makes gardening so much fun. All right and don't forget when you harvest these you can eat
the whole thing so the greens can go in a salad or get sauteed and the radishes can just get eaten
right away. Thanks for watching and if you want to learn more about setting up your own kitchen
garden we have all kinds of resources to help you. I wrote a whole book called Kitchen Garden Revival
you can find out about that below this video and I have an entire course called Kitchen Garden
Academy. It's an online course that teaches you the step-by-step to set up a full kitchen garden
that will grow for you for many years to come. So check out those resources below this video,
subscribe if you want to know every time we drop a new one.
Thanks for watching and I'll see you next time. Bye!
